Grokking as the Transition from Lazy to Rich Training Dynamics
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the phenomenon of "grokking" in deep learning, where models can unexpectedly learn to generalize well after a period of poor performance.
- It investigates the dynamics of training and how they transition from a "lazy" regime to a "rich" regime, leading to grokking.
- The paper challenges common explanations for grokking, such as parameter norm decrease and weight decay, and proposes an alternative view.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a fascinating phenomenon in deep learning called "grokking." This refers to the unexpected ability of deep neural networks to suddenly start generalizing well, after an initial period of poor performance.
The researchers investigate the dynamics of the training process and how they transition from a "lazy" regime to a "rich" regime, which leads to this grokking behavior. They challenge some common explanations for grokking, such as the decrease in the overall magnitude of the model parameters or the effects of weight decay.
Instead, the paper proposes an alternative view on what's happening during this grokking transition. It dives into the nuances of how the training dynamics evolve over time, and how this shift from lazy to rich behavior allows the model to discover more meaningful patterns in the data.
The findings in this paper provide valuable insights into the inner workings of deep neural networks and how they learn to generalize. Understanding the grokking phenomenon could lead to important advancements in machine learning, helping us build more robust and capable models.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the concept of "grokking" in deep learning, which refers to the unexpected ability of deep neural networks to suddenly start generalizing well after an initial period of poor performance.
The researchers analyze the training dynamics of deep models, examining how they transition from a "lazy" regime, where the model makes limited progress, to a "rich" regime, where the model starts to discover more meaningful patterns in the data and generalize better.
One common explanation for grokking is the decrease in the overall magnitude of the model parameters, or the effects of weight decay. However, the paper challenges these explanations, showing that parameter norm decrease and weight decay alone cannot fully account for the grokking phenomenon.
Instead, the researchers propose an alternative view, focusing on the nuances of how the training dynamics evolve over time. They explore the complex interplay between different aspects of the training process, such as the loss landscape, the optimization trajectory, and the model's ability to discover relevant features.
The paper provides a detailed technical analysis of the grokking transition, shedding light on the underlying mechanisms that enable deep neural networks to suddenly start generalizing well. This understanding could lead to important advancements in machine learning, helping researchers and engineers build more robust and capable models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling analysis of the grokking phenomenon, challenging common explanations and proposing an alternative view that considers the complex evolution of training dynamics. However, the research does have some limitations and areas that could benefit from further exploration.
One potential limitation is the specific model architectures and tasks used in the experiments. While the findings may hold true for the tested scenarios, it would be valuable to see how the insights scale to a wider range of model types and problem domains. Extending the analysis to different deep learning architectures and tasks could help validate the generalizability of the proposed explanations.
Additionally, the paper primarily focuses on the theoretical and empirical analysis of the grokking transition, without delving deeply into the practical implications or potential applications of this knowledge. Exploring how the insights from this research could be leveraged to improve model training, design, or even architectural choices could further strengthen the impact of this work.
Despite these potential areas for further research, the paper makes a significant contribution to the understanding of grokking in deep learning. By challenging existing explanations and proposing a more nuanced view of the training dynamics, the authors have expanded our knowledge of how deep neural networks learn and generalize. This work serves as a valuable foundation for future studies on the inner workings of deep learning models.
Conclusion
The paper offers a thought-provoking exploration of the grokking phenomenon in deep learning, where models unexpectedly start to generalize well after a period of poor performance. By investigating the transition from "lazy" to "rich" training dynamics, the researchers challenge common explanations and propose an alternative view that considers the complex evolution of the training process.
The findings in this paper provide valuable insights into the inner workings of deep neural networks and how they learn to discover meaningful patterns in data. Understanding the grokking phenomenon could lead to important advancements in machine learning, helping researchers and engineers build more robust and capable models.
While the paper has some limitations, it serves as a solid foundation for further exploration and research in this area. By continuing to unravel the mysteries of deep learning, we can unlock new possibilities for building intelligent systems that can generalize and adapt in ways that truly impress and benefit humanity.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Grokking as the Transition from Lazy to Rich Training Dynamics
Tanishq Kumar, Blake Bordelon, Samuel J. Gershman, Cengiz Pehlevan
We propose that the grokking phenomenon, where the train loss of a neural network decreases much earlier than its test loss, can arise due to a neural network transitioning from lazy training dynamics to a rich, feature learning regime. To illustrate this mechanism, we study the simple setting of vanilla gradient descent on a polynomial regression problem with a two layer neural network which exhibits grokking without regularization in a way that cannot be explained by existing theories. We identify sufficient statistics for the test loss of such a network, and tracking these over training reveals that grokking arises in this setting when the network first attempts to fit a kernel regression solution with its initial features, followed by late-time feature learning where a generalizing solution is identified after train loss is already low. We find that the key determinants of grokking are the rate of feature learning -- which can be controlled precisely by parameters that scale the network output -- and the alignment of the initial features with the target function $y(x)$. We argue this delayed generalization arises when (1) the top eigenvectors of the initial neural tangent kernel and the task labels $y(x)$ are misaligned, but (2) the dataset size is large enough so that it is possible for the network to generalize eventually, but not so large that train loss perfectly tracks test loss at all epochs, and (3) the network begins training in the lazy regime so does not learn features immediately. We conclude with evidence that this transition from lazy (linear model) to rich training (feature learning) can control grokking in more general settings, like on MNIST, one-layer Transformers, and student-teacher networks.
Read more4/12/2024
0
Grokking as a First Order Phase Transition in Two Layer Networks
Noa Rubin, Inbar Seroussi, Zohar Ringel
A key property of deep neural networks (DNNs) is their ability to learn new features during training. This intriguing aspect of deep learning stands out most clearly in recently reported Grokking phenomena. While mainly reflected as a sudden increase in test accuracy, Grokking is also believed to be a beyond lazy-learning/Gaussian Process (GP) phenomenon involving feature learning. Here we apply a recent development in the theory of feature learning, the adaptive kernel approach, to two teacher-student models with cubic-polynomial and modular addition teachers. We provide analytical predictions on feature learning and Grokking properties of these models and demonstrate a mapping between Grokking and the theory of phase transitions. We show that after Grokking, the state of the DNN is analogous to the mixed phase following a first-order phase transition. In this mixed phase, the DNN generates useful internal representations of the teacher that are sharply distinct from those before the transition.
Read more5/7/2024
0
Deep Grokking: Would Deep Neural Networks Generalize Better?
Simin Fan, Razvan Pascanu, Martin Jaggi
Recent research on the grokking phenomenon has illuminated the intricacies of neural networks' training dynamics and their generalization behaviors. Grokking refers to a sharp rise of the network's generalization accuracy on the test set, which occurs long after an extended overfitting phase, during which the network perfectly fits the training set. While the existing research primarily focus on shallow networks such as 2-layer MLP and 1-layer Transformer, we explore grokking on deep networks (e.g. 12-layer MLP). We empirically replicate the phenomenon and find that deep neural networks can be more susceptible to grokking than its shallower counterparts. Meanwhile, we observe an intriguing multi-stage generalization phenomenon when increase the depth of the MLP model where the test accuracy exhibits a secondary surge, which is scarcely seen on shallow models. We further uncover compelling correspondences between the decreasing of feature ranks and the phase transition from overfitting to the generalization stage during grokking. Additionally, we find that the multi-stage generalization phenomenon often aligns with a double-descent pattern in feature ranks. These observations suggest that internal feature rank could serve as a more promising indicator of the model's generalization behavior compared to the weight-norm. We believe our work is the first one to dive into grokking in deep neural networks, and investigate the relationship of feature rank and generalization performance.
Read more5/31/2024
0
Deep Networks Always Grok and Here is Why
Ahmed Imtiaz Humayun, Randall Balestriero, Richard Baraniuk
Grokking, or delayed generalization, is a phenomenon where generalization in a deep neural network (DNN) occurs long after achieving near zero training error. Previous studies have reported the occurrence of grokking in specific controlled settings, such as DNNs initialized with large-norm parameters or transformers trained on algorithmic datasets. We demonstrate that grokking is actually much more widespread and materializes in a wide range of practical settings, such as training of a convolutional neural network (CNN) on CIFAR10 or a Resnet on Imagenette. We introduce the new concept of delayed robustness, whereby a DNN groks adversarial examples and becomes robust, long after interpolation and/or generalization. We develop an analytical explanation for the emergence of both delayed generalization and delayed robustness based on the local complexity of a DNN's input-output mapping. Our local complexity measures the density of so-called linear regions (aka, spline partition regions) that tile the DNN input space and serves as a utile progress measure for training. We provide the first evidence that, for classification problems, the linear regions undergo a phase transition during training whereafter they migrate away from the training samples (making the DNN mapping smoother there) and towards the decision boundary (making the DNN mapping less smooth there). Grokking occurs post phase transition as a robust partition of the input space thanks to the linearization of the DNN mapping around the training points. Website: https://bit.ly/grok-adversarial
Read more6/10/2024