A Preliminary Empirical Study on Prompt-based Unsupervised Keyphrase Extraction
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper presents a preliminary empirical study on using prompts to extract keywords (known as keyphrases) from documents in an unsupervised manner.
• The researchers explore the effectiveness of prompt-based techniques for keyphrase extraction, which could have applications in summarization, indexing, and other areas.
• The study evaluates several prompt-based models on benchmark datasets and compares their performance to traditional unsupervised keyphrase extraction methods.
Plain English Explanation
Keyphrases are important words or phrases that summarize the main topics in a document. Traditionally, extracting these keyphrases has required training machine learning models on large datasets of labeled examples. However, this can be time-consuming and expensive.
The researchers in this paper looked at a new approach using language model prompt-based techniques. The idea is to provide a short "prompt" to a language model, which then generates relevant keyphrases without needing extensive training data. This could make keyphrase extraction more accessible and scalable.
The paper explores different ways of constructing these prompts and evaluates how well the resulting keyphrases match those chosen by human experts. The results suggest that prompt-based methods can be competitive with traditional unsupervised techniques, opening up new possibilities for prompt-based applications in text analysis.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a series of experiments to assess the performance of prompt-based keyphrase extraction. They evaluated several prompt templates, including ones that provided the model with instructions, examples, or contextual information about the target document.
These prompts were used to generate keyphrases from a set of benchmark documents, which were then compared to gold-standard keyphrases assigned by human experts. The researchers measured metrics like precision, recall, and F1-score to quantify the accuracy of the automatically generated keyphrases.
The results showed that prompt-based approaches can achieve comparable or even better performance than traditional unsupervised keyphrase extraction methods. Certain prompt templates, such as those providing examples or context, tended to yield higher-quality keyphrases.
The authors also note that prompt-based techniques have advantages in terms of flexibility and scalability compared to supervised machine learning models. This suggests that prompt-based keyphrase extraction could be a promising direction for further research and application development.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a solid initial exploration of prompt-based keyphrase extraction, but there are some limitations and areas for future work:
-
The study was conducted on a relatively small set of benchmark datasets, so more extensive evaluation on diverse document types would be helpful to assess the generalizability of the findings.
-
The paper does not delve deeply into the prompt design process or provide guidance on how to construct effective prompts for keyphrase extraction. This is an important area that deserves further investigation.
-
While the prompt-based approaches showed promise, the authors note that traditional unsupervised methods still have certain advantages, such as being more interpretable. Combining prompt-based techniques with other approaches could lead to further performance improvements.
Overall, this paper lays the groundwork for exploring prompt-based keyphrase extraction and highlights its potential, but there is still much more to be explored in this emerging area of research.
Conclusion
This preliminary study demonstrates that prompt-based techniques can be a viable approach for unsupervised keyphrase extraction, with the potential to be more flexible and scalable than traditional methods. The results suggest that carefully designed prompts can guide language models to generate high-quality keyphrases that align well with human judgments.
While further research is needed, this work opens up new possibilities for applying prompt-based techniques to text analysis tasks, potentially reducing the need for large labeled datasets. As the field of prompt engineering continues to advance, the insights from this paper could inform the development of more effective and efficient keyphrase extraction systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Preliminary Empirical Study on Prompt-based Unsupervised Keyphrase Extraction
Mingyang Song, Yi Feng, Liping Jing
Pre-trained large language models can perform natural language processing downstream tasks by conditioning on human-designed prompts. However, a prompt-based approach often requires prompt engineering to design different prompts, primarily hand-crafted through laborious trial and error, requiring human intervention and expertise. It is a challenging problem when constructing a prompt-based keyphrase extraction method. Therefore, we investigate and study the effectiveness of different prompts on the keyphrase extraction task to verify the impact of the cherry-picked prompts on the performance of extracting keyphrases. Extensive experimental results on six benchmark keyphrase extraction datasets and different pre-trained large language models demonstrate that (1) designing complex prompts may not necessarily be more effective than designing simple prompts; (2) individual keyword changes in the designed prompts can affect the overall performance; (3) designing complex prompts achieve better performance than designing simple prompts when facing long documents.
Read more5/28/2024
💬
0
A Survey of Prompt Engineering Methods in Large Language Models for Different NLP Tasks
Shubham Vatsal, Harsh Dubey
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on many different Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Prompt engineering plays a key role in adding more to the already existing abilities of LLMs to achieve significant performance gains on various NLP tasks. Prompt engineering requires composing natural language instructions called prompts to elicit knowledge from LLMs in a structured way. Unlike previous state-of-the-art (SoTA) models, prompt engineering does not require extensive parameter re-training or fine-tuning based on the given NLP task and thus solely operates on the embedded knowledge of LLMs. Additionally, LLM enthusiasts can intelligently extract LLMs' knowledge through a basic natural language conversational exchange or prompt engineering, allowing more and more people even without deep mathematical machine learning background to experiment with LLMs. With prompt engineering gaining popularity in the last two years, researchers have come up with numerous engineering techniques around designing prompts to improve accuracy of information extraction from the LLMs. In this paper, we summarize different prompting techniques and club them together based on different NLP tasks that they have been used for. We further granularly highlight the performance of these prompting strategies on various datasets belonging to that NLP task, talk about the corresponding LLMs used, present a taxonomy diagram and discuss the possible SoTA for specific datasets. In total, we read and present a survey of 44 research papers which talk about 39 different prompting methods on 29 different NLP tasks of which most of them have been published in the last two years.
Read more7/25/2024
💬
1
Prompt Engineering a Prompt Engineer
Qinyuan Ye, Maxamed Axmed, Reid Pryzant, Fereshte Khani
Prompt engineering is a challenging yet crucial task for optimizing the performance of large language models on customized tasks. It requires complex reasoning to examine the model's errors, hypothesize what is missing or misleading in the current prompt, and communicate the task with clarity. While recent works indicate that large language models can be meta-prompted to perform automatic prompt engineering, we argue that their potential is limited due to insufficient guidance for complex reasoning in the meta-prompt. We fill this gap by infusing into the meta-prompt three key components: detailed descriptions, context specification, and a step-by-step reasoning template. The resulting method, named PE2, exhibits remarkable versatility across diverse language tasks. It finds prompts that outperform let's think step by step by 6.3% on MultiArith and 3.1% on GSM8K, and outperforms competitive baselines on counterfactual tasks by 6.9%. Further, we show that PE2 can make targeted and highly specific prompt edits, rectify erroneous prompts, and induce multi-step plans for complex tasks.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Language Model Prompt Selection via Simulation Optimization
Haoting Zhang, Jinghai He, Rhonda Righter, Zeyu Zheng
With the advancement in generative language models, the selection of prompts has gained significant attention in recent years. A prompt is an instruction or description provided by the user, serving as a guide for the generative language model in content generation. Despite existing methods for prompt selection that are based on human labor, we consider facilitating this selection through simulation optimization, aiming to maximize a pre-defined score for the selected prompt. Specifically, we propose a two-stage framework. In the first stage, we determine a feasible set of prompts in sufficient numbers, where each prompt is represented by a moderate-dimensional vector. In the subsequent stage for evaluation and selection, we construct a surrogate model of the score regarding the moderate-dimensional vectors that represent the prompts. We propose sequentially selecting the prompt for evaluation based on this constructed surrogate model. We prove the consistency of the sequential evaluation procedure in our framework. We also conduct numerical experiments to demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed framework, providing practical instructions for implementation.
Read more5/21/2024