On Accessibility Fairness in Intermodal Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand Systems
2404.00434
0
0
Abstract
Research on the operation of mobility systems so far has mostly focused on minimizing cost-centered metrics such as average travel time, distance driven, and operational costs. Whilst capturing economic indicators, such metrics do not account for transportation justice aspects. In this paper, we present an optimization model to plan the operation of Intermodal Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand (I-AMoD) systems, where self-driving vehicles provide on-demand mobility jointly with public transit and active modes, with the goal to minimize the accessibility unfairness experienced by the population. Specifically, we first leverage a previously developed network flow model to compute the I-AMoD system operation in a minimum-time manner. Second, we formally define accessibility unfairness, and use it to frame the minimum-accessibility-unfairness problem and cast it as a linear program. We showcase our framework for a real-world case-study in the city of Eindhoven, NL. Our results show that it is possible to reach an operation that is on average fully fair at the cost of a slight travel time increase compared to a minimum-travel-time solution. Thereby we observe that the accessibility fairness of individual paths is, on average, worse than the average values obtained from flows, setting the stage for a discussion on the definition of accessibility fairness itself.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the issue of accessibility fairness in intermodal autonomous mobility-on-demand (AMoD) systems.
- It examines how these systems can be designed to ensure fair and equitable access to transportation for all users, including those with disabilities or living in underserved areas.
- The research proposes a framework to quantify accessibility fairness and evaluates it through simulation experiments.
Plain English Explanation
Autonomous mobility-on-demand (AMoD) systems, such as self-driving cars and ride-sharing services, have the potential to revolutionize transportation and improve accessibility for many people. However, there is a concern that these systems may not be equally accessible to all users, particularly those with disabilities or living in underserved areas.
This paper addresses this issue by developing a way to measure "accessibility fairness" in AMoD systems. The idea is to ensure that the benefits of these new transportation options are distributed fairly, so that no group is left behind. The researchers propose a mathematical framework to quantify accessibility fairness and then test it through computer simulations.
By understanding how to design AMoD systems for greater equity, the goal is to make these technologies more inclusive and beneficial for the entire community, not just a privileged few. This is an important consideration as autonomous vehicles and other mobility innovations become more widespread.
Technical Explanation
The paper first reviews the existing literature on accessibility and equity in transportation systems, identifying key gaps in understanding how to ensure fair access to emerging autonomous mobility technologies.
The authors then propose a framework to quantify accessibility fairness in intermodal AMoD systems. This involves defining accessibility metrics that consider factors like travel time, cost, and availability of different transportation modes. The framework also incorporates measures of fairness and bias to assess whether certain user groups are disproportionately disadvantaged.
Through simulation experiments, the researchers evaluate this accessibility fairness framework under different system configurations and user demand patterns. The results provide insights into design principles for AMoD systems that can better accommodate the needs of diverse users and communities.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges several limitations in the proposed framework, such as the need to collect comprehensive data on user preferences and mobility patterns to accurately model accessibility. There is also a recognition that implementing truly equitable AMoD systems will require coordination across multiple stakeholders, including transportation agencies, vehicle manufacturers, and service providers.
One potential issue not directly addressed is the challenge of defining and measuring "fairness" in this context, as different individuals or groups may have varying perspectives on what constitutes a fair distribution of transportation resources. The researchers' approach provides a starting point, but further work is needed to develop more nuanced and context-sensitive fairness metrics.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution by highlighting the critical issue of accessibility fairness in the emerging world of autonomous mobility. As these technologies continue to evolve, it will be essential to consider the needs of all users and ensure that the benefits are distributed equitably.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a framework for quantifying accessibility fairness in intermodal autonomous mobility-on-demand (AMoD) systems. By developing metrics to assess the equitable distribution of transportation resources, the authors aim to guide the design of these emerging technologies in a way that promotes greater inclusivity and accessibility for all users.
The findings from the simulation experiments offer valuable insights for transportation planners, policymakers, and technology developers as they work to shape the future of urban mobility. Ensuring fair and accessible AMoD systems will be crucial for realizing the full societal benefits of autonomous vehicles and related innovations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
Real-time Control of Electric Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand Systems via Graph Reinforcement Learning
Aaryan Singhal, Daniele Gammelli, Justin Luke, Karthik Gopalakrishnan, Dominik Helmreich, Marco Pavone
0
0
Operators of Electric Autonomous Mobility-on-Demand (E-AMoD) fleets need to make several real-time decisions such as matching available vehicles to ride requests, rebalancing idle vehicles to areas of high demand, and charging vehicles to ensure sufficient range. While this problem can be posed as a linear program that optimizes flows over a space-charge-time graph, the size of the resulting optimization problem does not allow for real-time implementation in realistic settings. In this work, we present the E-AMoD control problem through the lens of reinforcement learning and propose a graph network-based framework to achieve drastically improved scalability and superior performance over heuristics. Specifically, we adopt a bi-level formulation where we (1) leverage a graph network-based RL agent to specify a desired next state in the space-charge graph, and (2) solve more tractable linear programs to best achieve the desired state while ensuring feasibility. Experiments using real-world data from San Francisco and New York City show that our approach achieves up to 89% of the profits of the theoretically-optimal solution while achieving more than a 100x speedup in computational time. We further highlight promising zero-shot transfer capabilities of our learned policy on tasks such as inter-city generalization and service area expansion, thus showing the utility, scalability, and flexibility of our framework. Finally, our approach outperforms the best domain-specific heuristics with comparable runtimes, with an increase in profits by up to 3.2x.
4/5/2024
🔄
On-demand Mobility-as-a-Service platform assignment games with guaranteed stable outcomes
Bingqing Liu, Joseph Y. J. Chow
0
0
Mobility-as-a-Service (MaaS) systems are two-sided markets, with two mutually exclusive sets of agents, i.e., travelers/users and operators, forming a mobility ecosystem in which multiple operators compete or cooperate to serve customers under a governing platform provider. This study proposes a MaaS platform equilibrium model based on many-to-many assignment games incorporating both fixed-route transit services and mobility-on-demand (MOD) services. The matching problem is formulated as a convex multicommodity flow network design problem under congestion that captures the cost of accessing MOD services. The local stability conditions reflect a generalization of Wardrop's principles that include operators' decisions. Due to the presence of congestion, the problem may result in non-stable designs, and a subsidy mechanism from the platform is proposed to guarantee local stability. A new exact solution algorithm to the matching problem is proposed based on a branch and bound framework with a Frank-Wolfe algorithm integrated with Lagrangian relaxation and subgradient optimization, which guarantees the optimality of the matching problem but not stability. A heuristic which integrates stability conditions and subsidy design is proposed, which reaches either an optimal MaaS platform equilibrium solution with global stability, or a feasible locally stable solution that may require subsidy. For the heuristic, a worst-case bound and condition for obtaining an exact solution are both identified. An expanded Sioux Falls network test with 82 nodes and 748 links derives generalizable insights about the model for coopetitive interdependencies between operators sharing the platform, handling congestion effects in MOD services, effects of local stability on investment impacts, and illustrating inequities that may arise under heterogeneous populations.
6/24/2024
Towards a real-time distributed feedback system for the transportation assistance of PwD
Iosif Polenakis, Vasileios Vouronikos, Maria Chroni, Stavros D. Nikolopoulos
0
0
In this work we propose the design principles of an integrated distributed system for the augment of the transportation for people with disabilities inside the road network of a city area utilizing the IT technologies. We propose the basis of our system upon the utilization of a distributed sensor network that will be incorporated by a real-time integrated feedback system. The main components of the proposed architecture include the Inaccessible City Point System, the Live Data Analysis and Response System, and the Obstruction Detection and Prevention System. The incorporation of these subsystems will provide real-time feedback assisting the transportation of individuals with mobility problems informing them on real-time about blocked ramps across the path defined to their destination, being also responsible for the information of the authorities about incidents regarding the collision of accessibility in place where the sensors detect an inaccessible point. The proposed design allows the addition of further extensions regarding the assistance of individuals with mobility problems providing a basis for its further implementation and improvement. In this work we provide the fundamental parts regarding the interconnection of the proposed architecture's components as also its potential deployment regarding the proposed architecture and its application in the area of a city.
6/11/2024
✨
Simulating the Integration of Urban Air Mobility into Existing Transportation Systems: A Survey
Xuan Jiang (Frank), Yuhan Tang (Frank), Junzhe Cao (Frank), Vishwanath Bulusu (Frank), Hao (Frank), Yang, Xin Peng, Yunhan Zheng, Jinhua Zhao, Raja Sengupta
0
0
Urban air mobility (UAM) has the potential to revolutionize transportation in metropolitan areas, providing a new mode of transportation that could alleviate congestion and improve accessibility. However, the integration of UAM into existing transportation systems is a complex task that requires a thorough understanding of its impact on traffic flow and capacity. In this paper, we conduct a survey to investigate the current state of research on UAM in metropolitan-scale traffic using simulation techniques. We identify key challenges and opportunities for the integration of UAM into urban transportation systems, including impacts on existing traffic patterns and congestion; safety analysis and risk assessment; potential economic and environmental benefits; and the development of shared infrastructure and routes for UAM and ground-based transportation. We also discuss the potential benefits of UAM, such as reduced travel times and improved accessibility for underserved areas. Our survey provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of research on UAM in metropolitan-scale traffic using simulation and highlights key areas for future research and development.
6/21/2024