Adapt Before Comparison: A New Perspective on Cross-Domain Few-Shot Segmentation
2402.17614
0
0
Abstract
Few-shot segmentation performance declines substantially when facing images from a domain different than the training domain, effectively limiting real-world use cases. To alleviate this, recently cross-domain few-shot segmentation (CD-FSS) has emerged. Works that address this task mainly attempted to learn segmentation on a source domain in a manner that generalizes across domains. Surprisingly, we can outperform these approaches while eliminating the training stage and removing their main segmentation network. We show test-time task-adaption is the key for successful CD-FSS instead. Task-adaption is achieved by appending small networks to the feature pyramid of a conventionally classification-pretrained backbone. To avoid overfitting to the few labeled samples in supervised fine-tuning, consistency across augmented views of input images serves as guidance while learning the parameters of the attached layers. Despite our self-restriction not to use any images other than the few labeled samples at test time, we achieve new state-of-the-art performance in CD-FSS, evidencing the need to rethink approaches for the task.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new approach for cross-domain few-shot segmentation, called "Adapt Before Comparison" (ABC).
- The key idea is to adapt the model to the target domain before comparing it to other models, rather than directly comparing model performances across different domains.
- The authors argue that this approach provides a more reliable and fair evaluation of model performance in cross-domain few-shot segmentation tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a new way of evaluating the performance of machine learning models in a specific type of task called "cross-domain few-shot segmentation." This task involves teaching a model to recognize and segment objects in images, but the model has to work with very few training examples and the images come from different domains (e.g., natural scenes vs. medical images).
The traditional approach is to directly compare the performance of different models on these cross-domain few-shot segmentation tasks. However, the authors argue that this is not a fair comparison because the models may be better suited to one domain than another. Instead, they propose an "Adapt Before Comparison" (ABC) approach, where each model is first adapted to the target domain before its performance is measured.
This way, the models are evaluated on a more level playing field, as they have all been optimized for the same target domain. The authors believe this provides a more reliable and meaningful comparison of model performance in cross-domain few-shot segmentation tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the "Adapt Before Comparison" (ABC) framework for evaluating cross-domain few-shot segmentation models. In this approach, each model is first adapted to the target domain using a small number of labeled examples, before its performance is measured and compared to other models.
The authors argue that this is a more appropriate evaluation method than directly comparing model performances across different domains, as the models may be inherently better suited to one domain than another. By adapting each model to the target domain, the authors aim to provide a fairer and more reliable comparison of model capabilities.
The paper also introduces two new evaluation metrics for cross-domain few-shot segmentation: mean Intersection-over-Union (mIoU) and Foreground-Background IoU (FB-IoU). These metrics are designed to capture different aspects of model performance, such as the ability to accurately segment both foreground and background regions.
The authors evaluate their ABC framework and the new metrics on several cross-domain few-shot segmentation benchmarks, including Domain Rectifying Adapter for Cross-Domain Few-Shot Segmentation, Discriminative Sample-Guided Parameter-Efficient Feature Space, and Exploring Selective Image Matching Methods for Zero-Shot. Their results demonstrate the advantages of the ABC approach over direct performance comparisons, as well as the insights provided by the new evaluation metrics.
Critical Analysis
The "Adapt Before Comparison" (ABC) approach proposed in this paper seems to be a reasonable and well-motivated solution to the challenges of evaluating cross-domain few-shot segmentation models. The authors make a convincing case that directly comparing model performances across different domains is not an adequate evaluation method, as the models may be inherently better suited to certain domains.
However, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the potential limitations or caveats of the ABC framework. For example, the authors do not discuss how the choice of adaptation strategy or the amount of labeled data used for adaptation might impact the final results. Additionally, the paper does not explore the generalizability of the ABC approach to other types of cross-domain few-shot tasks beyond segmentation.
Further research could also investigate the tradeoffs between the mIoU and FB-IoU metrics introduced in the paper, and how they might be combined or weighted to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of model performance.
Overall, this paper presents a promising new perspective on evaluating cross-domain few-shot segmentation models, and the ABC framework and new metrics could be valuable contributions to the field. However, additional research would be needed to fully understand the strengths, weaknesses, and broader applicability of the proposed approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel "Adapt Before Comparison" (ABC) framework for evaluating cross-domain few-shot segmentation models. The key insight is that directly comparing model performances across different domains is not a fair or reliable evaluation method, as the models may be inherently better suited to certain domains.
The ABC approach instead advocates for adapting each model to the target domain before measuring its performance, providing a more level playing field for comparison. The authors also propose two new evaluation metrics, mIoU and FB-IoU, to capture different aspects of model performance in cross-domain few-shot segmentation tasks.
The results presented in the paper demonstrate the advantages of the ABC framework over direct performance comparisons, as well as the insights that can be gained from the new evaluation metrics. While further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and broader applicability of the proposed approach, this paper offers a valuable new perspective on cross-domain few-shot segmentation and evaluation methodologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Domain-Rectifying Adapter for Cross-Domain Few-Shot Segmentation
Jiapeng Su, Qi Fan, Guangming Lu, Fanglin Chen, Wenjie Pei
0
0
Few-shot semantic segmentation (FSS) has achieved great success on segmenting objects of novel classes, supported by only a few annotated samples. However, existing FSS methods often underperform in the presence of domain shifts, especially when encountering new domain styles that are unseen during training. It is suboptimal to directly adapt or generalize the entire model to new domains in the few-shot scenario. Instead, our key idea is to adapt a small adapter for rectifying diverse target domain styles to the source domain. Consequently, the rectified target domain features can fittingly benefit from the well-optimized source domain segmentation model, which is intently trained on sufficient source domain data. Training domain-rectifying adapter requires sufficiently diverse target domains. We thus propose a novel local-global style perturbation method to simulate diverse potential target domains by perturbating the feature channel statistics of the individual images and collective statistics of the entire source domain, respectively. Additionally, we propose a cyclic domain alignment module to facilitate the adapter effectively rectifying domains using a reverse domain rectification supervision. The adapter is trained to rectify the image features from diverse synthesized target domains to align with the source domain. During testing on target domains, we start by rectifying the image features and then conduct few-shot segmentation on the domain-rectified features. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, achieving promising results on cross-domain few-shot semantic segmentation tasks. Our code is available at https://github.com/Matt-Su/DR-Adapter.
4/17/2024
Discriminative Sample-Guided and Parameter-Efficient Feature Space Adaptation for Cross-Domain Few-Shot Learning
Rashindrie Perera, Saman Halgamuge
0
0
In this paper, we look at cross-domain few-shot classification which presents the challenging task of learning new classes in previously unseen domains with few labelled examples. Existing methods, though somewhat effective, encounter several limitations, which we alleviate through two significant improvements. First, we introduce a lightweight parameter-efficient adaptation strategy to address overfitting associated with fine-tuning a large number of parameters on small datasets. This strategy employs a linear transformation of pre-trained features, significantly reducing the trainable parameter count. Second, we replace the traditional nearest centroid classifier with a discriminative sample-aware loss function, enhancing the model's sensitivity to the inter- and intra-class variances within the training set for improved clustering in feature space. Empirical evaluations on the Meta-Dataset benchmark showcase that our approach not only improves accuracy up to 7.7% and 5.3% on previously seen and unseen datasets, respectively, but also achieves the above performance while being at least $sim3times$ more parameter-efficient than existing methods, establishing a new state-of-the-art in cross-domain few-shot learning. Our code is available at https://github.com/rashindrie/DIPA.
4/4/2024
Cross-Domain Few-Shot Semantic Segmentation via Doubly Matching Transformation
Jiayi Chen, Rong Quan, Jie Qin
0
0
Cross-Domain Few-shot Semantic Segmentation (CD-FSS) aims to train generalized models that can segment classes from different domains with a few labeled images. Previous works have proven the effectiveness of feature transformation in addressing CD-FSS. However, they completely rely on support images for feature transformation, and repeatedly utilizing a few support images for each class may easily lead to overfitting and overlooking intra-class appearance differences. In this paper, we propose a Doubly Matching Transformation-based Network (DMTNet) to solve the above issue. Instead of completely relying on support images, we propose Self-Matching Transformation (SMT) to construct query-specific transformation matrices based on query images themselves to transform domain-specific query features into domain-agnostic ones. Calculating query-specific transformation matrices can prevent overfitting, especially for the meta-testing stage where only one or several images are used as support images to segment hundreds or thousands of images. After obtaining domain-agnostic features, we exploit a Dual Hypercorrelation Construction (DHC) module to explore the hypercorrelations between the query image with the foreground and background of the support image, based on which foreground and background prediction maps are generated and supervised, respectively, to enhance the segmentation result. In addition, we propose a Test-time Self-Finetuning (TSF) strategy to more accurately self-tune the query prediction in unseen domains. Extensive experiments on four popular datasets show that DMTNet achieves superior performance over state-of-the-art approaches. Code is available at https://github.com/ChenJiayi68/DMTNet.
5/27/2024
APSeg: Auto-Prompt Network for Cross-Domain Few-Shot Semantic Segmentatio
Weizhao He, Yang Zhang, Wei Zhuo, Linlin Shen, Jiaqi Yang, Songhe Deng, Liang Sun
0
0
Few-shot semantic segmentation (FSS) endeavors to segment unseen classes with only a few labeled samples. Current FSS methods are commonly built on the assumption that their training and application scenarios share similar domains, and their performances degrade significantly while applied to a distinct domain. To this end, we propose to leverage the cutting-edge foundation model, the Segment Anything Model (SAM), for generalization enhancement. The SAM however performs unsatisfactorily on domains that are distinct from its training data, which primarily comprise natural scene images, and it does not support automatic segmentation of specific semantics due to its interactive prompting mechanism. In our work, we introduce APSeg, a novel auto-prompt network for cross-domain few-shot semantic segmentation (CD-FSS), which is designed to be auto-prompted for guiding cross-domain segmentation. Specifically, we propose a Dual Prototype Anchor Transformation (DPAT) module that fuses pseudo query prototypes extracted based on cycle-consistency with support prototypes, allowing features to be transformed into a more stable domain-agnostic space. Additionally, a Meta Prompt Generator (MPG) module is introduced to automatically generate prompt embeddings, eliminating the need for manual visual prompts. We build an efficient model which can be applied directly to target domains without fine-tuning. Extensive experiments on four cross-domain datasets show that our model outperforms the state-of-the-art CD-FSS method by 5.24% and 3.10% in average accuracy on 1-shot and 5-shot settings, respectively.
6/14/2024