Beyond Regular Grids: Fourier-Based Neural Operators on Arbitrary Domains
2305.19663
0
0
🧠
Abstract
The computational efficiency of many neural operators, widely used for learning solutions of PDEs, relies on the fast Fourier transform (FFT) for performing spectral computations. As the FFT is limited to equispaced (rectangular) grids, this limits the efficiency of such neural operators when applied to problems where the input and output functions need to be processed on general non-equispaced point distributions. Leveraging the observation that a limited set of Fourier (Spectral) modes suffice to provide the required expressivity of a neural operator, we propose a simple method, based on the efficient direct evaluation of the underlying spectral transformation, to extend neural operators to arbitrary domains. An efficient implementation* of such direct spectral evaluations is coupled with existing neural operator models to allow the processing of data on arbitrary non-equispaced distributions of points. With extensive empirical evaluation, we demonstrate that the proposed method allows us to extend neural operators to arbitrary point distributions with significant gains in training speed over baselines while retaining or improving the accuracy of Fourier neural operators (FNOs) and related neural operators.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a method to extend neural operators, which are widely used for learning solutions to partial differential equations (PDEs), to handle arbitrary non-equispaced point distributions.
- Neural operators often rely on the fast Fourier transform (FFT) for efficient spectral computations, but the FFT is limited to equispaced (rectangular) grids.
- The authors leverage the observation that a limited set of Fourier (spectral) modes can provide the required expressivity of a neural operator, and they propose a method based on the efficient direct evaluation of the underlying spectral transformation to process data on arbitrary non-equispaced distributions of points.
Plain English Explanation
Neural operators are a powerful tool for learning solutions to partial differential equations (PDEs), which are mathematical equations that describe how different quantities in a system change over time and space. These neural operators often use the fast Fourier transform (FFT) to perform the necessary computations efficiently.
However, the FFT is limited to working with data that is evenly spaced, like a grid. This can be a problem when the input and output functions need to be processed on more general, non-evenly spaced point distributions.
The authors of this paper have come up with a clever solution to this problem. They realized that a neural operator doesn't need a full, detailed Fourier representation of the data - a limited set of Fourier (or spectral) modes is often enough to capture the required information.
Using this insight, the researchers developed a method that can directly evaluate the underlying spectral transformation, without relying on the FFT. This allows their neural operators to work with data on arbitrary, non-evenly spaced point distributions.
The authors show that their approach can significantly speed up the training of these neural operators compared to existing methods, while still maintaining or even improving the accuracy of the results. This is an important advancement, as it makes neural operators more flexible and useful for a wider range of real-world problems involving PDEs.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the authors' method for extending Fourier neural operators (FNOs) and related neural operators to handle arbitrary non-equispaced point distributions.
The authors observe that the computational efficiency of many neural operators relies on the fast Fourier transform (FFT) for performing spectral computations. However, the FFT is limited to equispaced (rectangular) grids, which can limit the efficiency of such neural operators when applied to problems where the input and output functions need to be processed on general non-equispaced point distributions.
To address this, the authors leverage the observation that a limited set of Fourier (Spectral) modes can provide the required expressivity of a neural operator. They propose a simple method, based on the efficient direct evaluation of the underlying spectral transformation, to extend neural operators to arbitrary domains.
This efficient implementation of direct spectral evaluations is coupled with existing neural operator models, allowing the processing of data on arbitrary non-equispaced distributions of points. The authors demonstrate, through extensive empirical evaluation, that their proposed method can extend neural operators to arbitrary point distributions with significant gains in training speed over baselines, while retaining or improving the accuracy of FNOs and related neural operators.
Critical Analysis
The authors' approach to extending neural operators to arbitrary non-equispaced point distributions is a clever and practical solution to an important limitation of existing methods. By leveraging the insight that a limited set of Fourier modes can provide the necessary expressivity, they are able to develop a more flexible and efficient technique.
One potential limitation of the proposed method is that it may not be as computationally efficient as the FFT-based approach for certain types of equispaced grids, where the FFT can be highly optimized. However, the authors' results suggest that the gains in flexibility and training speed for non-equispaced domains outweigh this potential drawback.
Additionally, the authors do not explore the theoretical properties of their direct spectral evaluation method, such as its convergence rate or any guarantees on the quality of the approximation. Further research in this direction could provide a deeper understanding of the method's strengths and limitations.
Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of neural operators and PDE solving, making these powerful techniques more accessible and applicable to a wider range of real-world problems. Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate the research and consider how it might impact their own work or the broader scientific community.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an innovative method to extend neural operators, which are widely used for learning solutions to partial differential equations (PDEs), to handle arbitrary non-equispaced point distributions. By leveraging the insight that a limited set of Fourier modes can provide the required expressivity, the authors develop an efficient direct spectral evaluation technique that can be coupled with existing neural operator models.
The authors demonstrate that their proposed method can significantly improve the training speed of neural operators on non-equispaced domains, while maintaining or even enhancing the accuracy of Fourier neural operators (FNOs) and related models. This is an important advancement that makes neural operators more flexible and applicable to a broader range of real-world problems involving PDEs.
The critical analysis suggests that while the authors' approach may not be as computationally efficient as FFT-based methods for certain equispaced grids, the gains in flexibility and training speed for non-equispaced domains are substantial and outweigh this potential drawback. Further research into the theoretical properties of the direct spectral evaluation method could provide additional insights and guidelines for its application.
Overall, this paper represents a significant contribution to the field of neural operators and PDE solving, paving the way for more widespread adoption and application of these powerful techniques in various scientific and engineering domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
Fourier Neural Operator with Learned Deformations for PDEs on General Geometries
Zongyi Li, Daniel Zhengyu Huang, Burigede Liu, Anima Anandkumar
0
0
Deep learning surrogate models have shown promise in solving partial differential equations (PDEs). Among them, the Fourier neural operator (FNO) achieves good accuracy, and is significantly faster compared to numerical solvers, on a variety of PDEs, such as fluid flows. However, the FNO uses the Fast Fourier transform (FFT), which is limited to rectangular domains with uniform grids. In this work, we propose a new framework, viz., geo-FNO, to solve PDEs on arbitrary geometries. Geo-FNO learns to deform the input (physical) domain, which may be irregular, into a latent space with a uniform grid. The FNO model with the FFT is applied in the latent space. The resulting geo-FNO model has both the computation efficiency of FFT and the flexibility of handling arbitrary geometries. Our geo-FNO is also flexible in terms of its input formats, viz., point clouds, meshes, and design parameters are all valid inputs. We consider a variety of PDEs such as the Elasticity, Plasticity, Euler's, and Navier-Stokes equations, and both forward modeling and inverse design problems. Geo-FNO is $10^5$ times faster than the standard numerical solvers and twice more accurate compared to direct interpolation on existing ML-based PDE solvers such as the standard FNO.
5/3/2024
Toward a Better Understanding of Fourier Neural Operators: Analysis and Improvement from a Spectral Perspective
Shaoxiang Qin, Fuyuan Lyu, Wenhui Peng, Dingyang Geng, Ju Wang, Naiping Gao, Xue Liu, Liangzhu Leon Wang
0
0
In solving partial differential equations (PDEs), Fourier Neural Operators (FNOs) have exhibited notable effectiveness compared to Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). This paper presents clear empirical evidence through spectral analysis to elucidate the superiority of FNO over CNNs: FNO is significantly more capable of learning low-frequencies. This empirical evidence also unveils FNO's distinct low-frequency bias, which limits FNO's effectiveness in learning high-frequency information from PDE data. To tackle this challenge, we introduce SpecBoost, an ensemble learning framework that employs multiple FNOs to better capture high-frequency information. Specifically, a secondary FNO is utilized to learn the overlooked high-frequency information from the prediction residual of the initial FNO. Experiments demonstrate that SpecBoost noticeably enhances FNO's prediction accuracy on diverse PDE applications, achieving an up to 71% improvement.
4/11/2024
🧠
Discretization Error of Fourier Neural Operators
Samuel Lanthaler, Andrew M. Stuart, Margaret Trautner
0
0
Operator learning is a variant of machine learning that is designed to approximate maps between function spaces from data. The Fourier Neural Operator (FNO) is a common model architecture used for operator learning. The FNO combines pointwise linear and nonlinear operations in physical space with pointwise linear operations in Fourier space, leading to a parameterized map acting between function spaces. Although FNOs formally involve convolutions of functions on a continuum, in practice the computations are performed on a discretized grid, allowing efficient implementation via the FFT. In this paper, the aliasing error that results from such a discretization is quantified and algebraic rates of convergence in terms of the grid resolution are obtained as a function of the regularity of the input. Numerical experiments that validate the theory and describe model stability are performed.
5/6/2024
Spectral-Refiner: Fine-Tuning of Accurate Spatiotemporal Neural Operator for Turbulent Flows
Shuhao Cao, Francesco Brarda, Ruipeng Li, Yuanzhe Xi
0
0
Recent advancements in operator-type neural networks have shown promising results in approximating the solutions of spatiotemporal Partial Differential Equations (PDEs). However, these neural networks often entail considerable training expenses, and may not always achieve the desired accuracy required in many scientific and engineering disciplines. In this paper, we propose a new Spatiotemporal Fourier Neural Operator (SFNO) that learns maps between Bochner spaces, and a new learning framework to address these issues. This new paradigm leverages wisdom from traditional numerical PDE theory and techniques to refine the pipeline of commonly adopted end-to-end neural operator training and evaluations. Specifically, in the learning problems for the turbulent flow modeling by the Navier-Stokes Equations (NSE), the proposed architecture initiates the training with a few epochs for SFNO, concluding with the freezing of most model parameters. Then, the last linear spectral convolution layer is fine-tuned without the frequency truncation. The optimization uses a negative Sobolev norm for the first time as the loss in operator learning, defined through a reliable functional-type emph{a posteriori} error estimator whose evaluation is almost exact thanks to the Parseval identity. This design allows the neural operators to effectively tackle low-frequency errors while the relief of the de-aliasing filter addresses high-frequency errors. Numerical experiments on commonly used benchmarks for the 2D NSE demonstrate significant improvements in both computational efficiency and accuracy, compared to end-to-end evaluation and traditional numerical PDE solvers.
5/28/2024