Can We Understand Plasticity Through Neural Collapse?
2404.02719
0
0
Abstract
This paper explores the connection between two recently identified phenomena in deep learning: plasticity loss and neural collapse. We analyze their correlation in different scenarios, revealing a significant association during the initial training phase on the first task. Additionally, we introduce a regularization approach to mitigate neural collapse, demonstrating its effectiveness in alleviating plasticity loss in this specific setting.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the connection between neural collapse and plasticity in deep learning models.
- Neural collapse refers to the phenomenon where neural network representations become highly clustered and separable during training.
- The researchers investigate whether understanding neural collapse can provide insights into the plasticity of deep learning models, which is their ability to adapt and learn new tasks.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models, such as those used for image recognition or natural language processing, are powerful tools that can learn complex patterns in data. A key aspect of these models is their plasticity - their ability to adapt and learn new tasks over time.
The researchers in this paper explore whether the phenomenon of "neural collapse" can help us understand this plasticity. Neural collapse describes how the internal representations within a deep learning model become highly organized and structured as the model trains on data. Specifically, the neural representations cluster into distinct groups that are easily separable.
The researchers investigate this connection between neural collapse and plasticity through a series of experiments. They train deep learning models on the permuted MNIST dataset, where the pixels in handwritten digit images are randomly rearranged. This tests the model's ability to adapt and learn new spatial structures, a key aspect of plasticity.
By analyzing the internal representations of the trained models, the researchers find that the degree of neural collapse is correlated with the model's ability to learn the permuted MNIST task. Models that exhibit stronger neural collapse tend to be more plastic and adaptable to the new spatial structure of the data.
This suggests that studying neural collapse could provide important insights into understanding and potentially enhancing the plasticity of deep learning models. If we can better understand the mechanisms behind neural collapse, it may allow us to design more adaptable and flexible AI systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper explores the relationship between neural collapse and plasticity in deep learning models. Neural collapse refers to the phenomenon where the representations learned by a neural network become highly clustered and separable during training.
To investigate this connection, the researchers conduct experiments using the permuted MNIST dataset. In this dataset, the pixels of the handwritten digit images are randomly rearranged, requiring the model to learn a new spatial structure compared to standard MNIST.
The researchers train deep neural networks on the permuted MNIST task and analyze the internal representations of the models as they learn. They find that the degree of neural collapse, measured by various metrics, is correlated with the model's ability to adapt and learn the permuted task.
Specifically, models that exhibit stronger neural collapse, with more distinct and separable representation clusters, tend to be more plastic and better able to learn the new spatial structure of the permuted MNIST data. In contrast, models with weaker neural collapse struggle more with the permuted task.
These findings suggest that understanding the mechanisms underlying neural collapse could provide important insights into the plasticity of deep learning models. If we can harness the factors that drive neural collapse, it may allow us to design more adaptable and flexible AI systems capable of learning new tasks and environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents an intriguing connection between neural collapse and plasticity, but there are some limitations and areas for further research that could be explored.
One key limitation is the focus on a single, relatively simple dataset (permuted MNIST). While this provides a controlled setting to study the relationship, it remains to be seen whether the findings extend to more complex, real-world tasks and datasets. Further experiments on a wider range of benchmarks would help validate the generalizability of the insights.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific mechanisms and underlying factors that drive the observed correlation between neural collapse and plasticity. A more detailed analysis of the internal representations and optimization dynamics could provide further explanatory power and guide the development of models with enhanced plasticity.
Another potential avenue for exploration is the role of architectural choices and training procedures in shaping neural collapse and plasticity. The paper uses standard deep neural network architectures, but investigating the impact of novel model designs or specialized training regimes could uncover additional ways to leverage neural collapse for improved adaptability.
Overall, this work offers an intriguing starting point for understanding the connections between neural collapse and the plasticity of deep learning models. Continued research in this direction, with a focus on expanding the scope of experiments and deepening the mechanistic understanding, could yield valuable insights for the development of more flexible and adaptable AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the relationship between neural collapse and the plasticity of deep learning models. The researchers find that the degree of neural collapse, where the internal representations become highly clustered and separable, is correlated with the model's ability to adapt and learn new tasks, as demonstrated by their experiments on the permuted MNIST dataset.
These findings suggest that studying the mechanisms underlying neural collapse could provide important insights into enhancing the plasticity of deep learning models. If we can better understand the factors that drive neural collapse, it may allow us to design more adaptable AI systems capable of learning new environments and tasks.
While this work offers an interesting starting point, further research is needed to validate the generalizability of these insights and deepen the understanding of the connection between neural collapse and plasticity. Expanding the scope of experiments and investigating the specific mechanisms involved could yield valuable advancements in the development of flexible and versatile deep learning models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Linguistic Collapse: Neural Collapse in (Large) Language Models
Robert Wu, Vardan Papyan
0
0
Neural collapse ($mathcal{NC}$) is a phenomenon observed in classification tasks where top-layer representations collapse into their class means, which become equinorm, equiangular and aligned with the classifiers. These behaviors -- associated with generalization and robustness -- would manifest under specific conditions: models are trained towards zero loss, with noise-free labels belonging to balanced classes, which do not outnumber the model's hidden dimension. Recent studies have explored $mathcal{NC}$ in the absence of one or more of these conditions to extend and capitalize on the associated benefits of ideal geometries. Language modeling presents a curious frontier, as textit{training by token prediction} constitutes a classification task where none of the conditions exist: the vocabulary is imbalanced and exceeds the embedding dimension; different tokens might correspond to similar contextual embeddings; and large language models (LLMs) in particular are typically only trained for a few epochs. This paper empirically investigates the impact of scaling the architectures and training of causal language models (CLMs) on their progression towards $mathcal{NC}$. We find that $mathcal{NC}$ properties that develop with scaling are linked to generalization. Moreover, there is evidence of some relationship between $mathcal{NC}$ and generalization independent of scale. Our work therefore underscores the generality of $mathcal{NC}$ as it extends to the novel and more challenging setting of language modeling. Downstream, we seek to inspire further research on the phenomenon to deepen our understanding of LLMs -- and neural networks at large -- and improve existing architectures based on $mathcal{NC}$-related properties.
5/29/2024
The Impact of Geometric Complexity on Neural Collapse in Transfer Learning
Michael Munn, Benoit Dherin, Javier Gonzalvo
0
0
Many of the recent remarkable advances in computer vision and language models can be attributed to the success of transfer learning via the pre-training of large foundation models. However, a theoretical framework which explains this empirical success is incomplete and remains an active area of research. Flatness of the loss surface and neural collapse have recently emerged as useful pre-training metrics which shed light on the implicit biases underlying pre-training. In this paper, we explore the geometric complexity of a model's learned representations as a fundamental mechanism that relates these two concepts. We show through experiments and theory that mechanisms which affect the geometric complexity of the pre-trained network also influence the neural collapse. Furthermore, we show how this effect of the geometric complexity generalizes to the neural collapse of new classes as well, thus encouraging better performance on downstream tasks, particularly in the few-shot setting.
5/29/2024
Collapse of Self-trained Language Models
David Herel, Tomas Mikolov
0
0
In various fields of knowledge creation, including science, new ideas often build on pre-existing information. In this work, we explore this concept within the context of language models. Specifically, we explore the potential of self-training models on their own outputs, akin to how humans learn and build on their previous thoughts and actions. While this approach is intuitively appealing, our research reveals its practical limitations. We find that extended self-training of the GPT-2 model leads to a significant degradation in performance, resulting in repetitive and collapsed token output.
4/4/2024
A Study of Plasticity Loss in On-Policy Deep Reinforcement Learning
Arthur Juliani, Jordan T. Ash
0
0
Continual learning with deep neural networks presents challenges distinct from both the fixed-dataset and convex continual learning regimes. One such challenge is plasticity loss, wherein a neural network trained in an online fashion displays a degraded ability to fit new tasks. This problem has been extensively studied in both supervised learning and off-policy reinforcement learning (RL), where a number of remedies have been proposed. Still, plasticity loss has received less attention in the on-policy deep RL setting. Here we perform an extensive set of experiments examining plasticity loss and a variety of mitigation methods in on-policy deep RL. We demonstrate that plasticity loss is pervasive under domain shift in this regime, and that a number of methods developed to resolve it in other settings fail, sometimes even resulting in performance that is worse than performing no intervention at all. In contrast, we find that a class of ``regenerative'' methods are able to consistently mitigate plasticity loss in a variety of contexts, including in gridworld tasks and more challenging environments like Montezuma's Revenge and ProcGen.
5/30/2024