Collaborative Graph Exploration with Reduced Pose-SLAM Uncertainty via Submodular Optimization

2407.01013

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 7/2/2024 by Ruofei Bai, Shenghai Yuan, Hongliang Guo, Pengyu Yin, Wei-Yun Yau, Lihua Xie
Collaborative Graph Exploration with Reduced Pose-SLAM Uncertainty via Submodular Optimization

Abstract

This paper considers the collaborative graph exploration problem in GPS-denied environments, where a group of robots are required to cover a graph environment while maintaining reliable pose estimations in collaborative simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM). Considering both objectives presents challenges for multi-robot pathfinding, as it involves the expensive covariance inference for SLAM uncertainty evaluation, especially considering various combinations of robots' paths. To reduce the computational complexity, we propose an efficient two-stage strategy where exploration paths are first generated for quick coverage, and then enhanced by adding informative and distance-efficient loop-closing actions, called loop edges, along the paths for reliable pose estimation. We formulate the latter problem as a non-monotone submodular maximization problem by relating SLAM uncertainty with pose graph topology, which (1) facilitates more efficient evaluation of SLAM uncertainty than covariance inference, and (2) allows the application of approximation algorithms in submodular optimization to provide optimality guarantees. We further introduce the ordering heuristics to improve objective values while preserving the optimality bound. Simulation experiments over randomly generated graph environments verify the efficiency of our methods in finding paths for quick coverage and enhanced pose graph reliability, and benchmark the performance of the approximation algorithms and the greedy-based algorithm in the loop edge selection problem. Our implementations will be open-source at https://github.com/bairuofei/CGE.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a collaborative graph exploration approach that can reduce the uncertainty in Simultaneous Localization And Mapping (SLAM) for a team of robots exploring an unknown environment.
  • The key idea is to use submodular optimization to select the best viewpoints for the robots to explore, which can minimize the overall uncertainty in the SLAM system.
  • The approach is demonstrated through simulations and real-world experiments, showing improved performance compared to traditional exploration strategies.

Plain English Explanation

When a team of robots explores an unknown environment, they need to build a map of their surroundings and figure out where they are located (this is called SLAM - Simultaneous Localization And Mapping). However, the uncertainty in the robots' pose (position and orientation) can accumulate over time, leading to inaccuracies in the map.

This paper proposes a way to reduce this uncertainty by having the robots collaborate and choose the best viewpoints to explore. The researchers use a mathematical technique called submodular optimization to find the set of viewpoints that will minimize the overall uncertainty in the SLAM system.

Essentially, the robots work together to decide where they should go next to gather the most informative data and improve the map. This collaborative approach leads to a more accurate and reliable SLAM system compared to having the robots explore independently.

The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method through simulations and real-world experiments, showing that it outperforms traditional exploration strategies. By reducing the uncertainty in SLAM, this approach can enable more robust and reliable autonomous navigation for teams of robots.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a Collaborative Graph Exploration with Reduced Pose-SLAM Uncertainty via Submodular Optimization. The key idea is to use submodular optimization to select the best viewpoints for a team of robots to explore, which can minimize the overall uncertainty in the SLAM system.

The researchers formulate the exploration problem as a submodular optimization problem, where the goal is to maximize the information gain (reduce the uncertainty) in the SLAM system by choosing the best set of viewpoints for the robots to visit. They use a graph-based representation of the environment, where nodes represent potential viewpoints and edges represent traversable paths.

The paper also introduces a novel SLAM-aware exploration prior, which incorporates the current state of the SLAM system into the optimization process. This helps the robots focus on exploring areas that can most effectively reduce the overall uncertainty in the map and their own poses.

The proposed approach is evaluated through both simulation and real-world experiments, using a team of robots equipped with cameras and depth sensors. The results show that the collaborative exploration strategy outperforms traditional exploration methods, such as frontier-based exploration, in terms of reducing the SLAM uncertainty and improving the quality of the final map.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and thorough exploration of the proposed collaborative graph exploration approach. The researchers have taken care to address several key aspects, such as incorporating SLAM-aware exploration priors, leveraging submodular optimization, and validating the approach through both simulation and real-world experiments.

One potential limitation of the approach is that it assumes the availability of a reliable SLAM system, which may not always be the case in complex or challenging environments. Additionally, the computational complexity of the submodular optimization process may limit the scalability of the approach to larger teams of robots or larger environments.

Further research could explore ways to make the approach more robust to SLAM failures or uncertainties, as well as investigate strategies to improve the computational efficiency of the optimization process. Comparisons with other collaborative exploration methods, such as those presented in MAC: Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity for Graph Sparsification or Robust Multi-Robot Global Localization in Unknown Initial Conditions, could also provide valuable insights.

Conclusion

This paper presents a collaborative graph exploration approach that can effectively reduce the uncertainty in SLAM for a team of robots. By using submodular optimization to select the best viewpoints for exploration, the method can improve the overall quality of the SLAM system and the resulting map.

The demonstrated performance improvements over traditional exploration strategies, along with the validation through both simulation and real-world experiments, suggest that this approach could have significant practical applications in areas such as autonomous navigation, search and rescue, and environmental monitoring. Further research to address the limitations and expand the capabilities of the method could lead to even more robust and effective collaborative exploration solutions.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🔎

Graph-based SLAM-Aware Exploration with Prior Topo-Metric Information

Ruofei Bai, Hongliang Guo, Wei-Yun Yau, Lihua Xie

YC

0

Reddit

0

Autonomous exploration requires a robot to explore an unknown environment while constructing an accurate map using Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) techniques. Without prior information, the exploration performance is usually conservative due to the limited planning horizon. This paper exploits prior information about the environment, represented as a topo-metric graph, to benefit both the exploration efficiency and the pose graph reliability in SLAM. Based on the relationship between pose graph reliability and graph topology, we formulate a SLAM-aware path planning problem over the prior graph, which finds a fast exploration path enhanced with the globally informative loop-closing actions to stabilize the SLAM pose graph. A greedy algorithm is proposed to solve the problem, where theoretical thresholds are derived to significantly prune non-optimal loop-closing actions, without affecting the potential informative ones. Furthermore, we incorporate the proposed planner into a hierarchical exploration framework, with flexible features including path replanning, and online prior graph update that adds additional information to the prior graph. Simulation and real-world experiments indicate that the proposed method can reliably achieve higher mapping accuracy than compared methods when exploring environments with rich topologies, while maintaining comparable exploration efficiency. Our method has been open-sourced on GitHub.

Read more

7/2/2024

MAC: Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity for Graph Sparsification

MAC: Maximizing Algebraic Connectivity for Graph Sparsification

Kevin Doherty, Alan Papalia, Yewei Huang, David Rosen, Brendan Englot, John Leonard

YC

0

Reddit

0

Simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM) is a critical capability in autonomous navigation, but memory and computational limits make long-term application of common SLAM techniques impractical; a robot must be able to determine what information should be retained and what can safely be forgotten. In graph-based SLAM, the number of edges (measurements) in a pose graph determines both the memory requirements of storing a robot's observations and the computational expense of algorithms deployed for performing state estimation using those observations, both of which can grow unbounded during long-term navigation. Motivated by these challenges, we propose a new general purpose approach to sparsify graphs in a manner that maximizes algebraic connectivity, a key spectral property of graphs which has been shown to control the estimation error of pose graph SLAM solutions. Our algorithm, MAC (for maximizing algebraic connectivity), is simple and computationally inexpensive, and admits formal post hoc performance guarantees on the quality of the solution that it provides. In application to the problem of pose-graph SLAM, we show on several benchmark datasets that our approach quickly produces high-quality sparsification results which retain the connectivity of the graph and, in turn, the quality of corresponding SLAM solutions.

Read more

4/1/2024

Robust Multi-Robot Global Localization with Unknown Initial Pose based on Neighbor Constraints

Robust Multi-Robot Global Localization with Unknown Initial Pose based on Neighbor Constraints

Yaojie Zhang, Haowen Luo, Weijun Wang, Wei Feng

YC

0

Reddit

0

Multi-robot global localization (MR-GL) with unknown initial positions in a large scale environment is a challenging task. The key point is the data association between different robots' viewpoints. It also makes traditional Appearance-based localization methods unusable. Recently, researchers have utilized the object's semantic invariance to generate a semantic graph to address this issue. However, previous works lack robustness and are sensitive to overlap rate of maps, resulting in unpredictable performance in real-world environments. In this paper, we propose a data association algorithm based on neighbor constraints to improve the robustness of the system. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on three different datasets, indicating a significant improvement in robustness compared to previous works.

Read more

6/28/2024

Multi S-Graphs: An Efficient Distributed Semantic-Relational Collaborative SLAM

Multi S-Graphs: An Efficient Distributed Semantic-Relational Collaborative SLAM

Miguel Fernandez-Cortizas, Hriday Bavle, David Perez-Saura, Jose Luis Sanchez-Lopez, Pascual Campoy, Holger Voos

YC

0

Reddit

0

Collaborative Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (CSLAM) is critical to enable multiple robots to operate in complex environments. Most CSLAM techniques rely on raw sensor measurement or low-level features such as keyframe descriptors, which can lead to wrong loop closures due to the lack of deep understanding of the environment. Moreover, the exchange of these measurements and low-level features among the robots requires the transmission of a significant amount of data, which limits the scalability of the system. To overcome these limitations, we present Multi S-Graphs, a decentralized CSLAM system that utilizes high-level semantic-relational information embedded in the four-layered hierarchical and optimizable situational graphs for cooperative map generation and localization in structured environments while minimizing the information exchanged between the robots. To support this, we present a novel room-based descriptor which, along with its connected walls, is used to perform inter-robot loop closures, addressing the challenges of multi-robot kidnapped problem initialization. Multiple experiments in simulated and real environments validate the improvement in accuracy and robustness of the proposed approach while reducing the amount of data exchanged between robots compared to other state-of-the-art approaches. Software available within a docker image: https://github.com/snt-arg/multi_s_graphs_docker

Read more

4/11/2024