Collaborative Safety-Critical Control for Networked Dynamic Systems
2310.03289
0
0
🛸
Abstract
As modern systems become ever more connected with complex dynamic coupling relationships, the development of safe control methods for such networked systems becomes paramount. In this paper, we define a general networked model with coupled dynamics and local control and discuss the relationship of node-level safety definitions for individual agents with local neighborhood dynamics. We define a node-level barrier function (NBF), node-level control barrier function (NCBF), and collaborative node-level barrier function (cNCBF) and provide conditions under which sets defined by these functions will be forward invariant. We use collaborative node-level barrier functions to construct a novel distributed algorithm for the safe control of collaborating network agents and provide conditions under which the algorithm is guaranteed to converge to a viable set of safe control actions for all agents or a terminally infeasible state for at least one agent. We introduce the notion of non-compliance of network neighbors as a metric of robustness for collaborative safety for a given network state and chosen barrier function hyper-parameters. We illustrate these results on a networked susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) model.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Defines a general networked model with coupled dynamics and local control
- Discusses the relationship between node-level safety definitions for individual agents and local neighborhood dynamics
- Introduces node-level barrier functions (NBF), node-level control barrier functions (NCBF), and collaborative node-level barrier functions (cNCBF)
- Provides conditions for forward invariance of sets defined by these functions
- Presents a distributed algorithm for safe control of collaborating network agents
- Introduces the concept of "non-compliance" as a metric of robustness for collaborative safety
Plain English Explanation
As modern systems become increasingly interconnected, with complex relationships between different components, it is crucial to develop safe control methods for these networked systems. This paper proposes a general model for networked systems with coupled dynamics and local control, and explores the relationship between the safety of individual agents and the dynamics of their local neighborhoods.
The researchers define several types of barrier functions, including node-level barrier functions (NBF), node-level control barrier functions (NCBF), and collaborative node-level barrier functions (cNCBF). These functions help ensure that the system stays within a "safe" set of states, and the paper provides conditions under which these sets will remain forward invariant, meaning the system will not leave them over time.
Using the collaborative node-level barrier functions, the researchers develop a novel distributed algorithm for the safe control of collaborating network agents. This algorithm is designed to converge to a set of safe control actions for all agents, or to a state where at least one agent is unable to act safely.
The paper also introduces the concept of "non-compliance" of network neighbors as a way to measure the robustness of the collaborative safety for a given network state and choice of barrier function parameters. This metric can help identify potential weak points in the system.
The researchers illustrate these concepts using a networked susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) model, which represents the spread of a disease or information through a network of interconnected agents.
Technical Explanation
The paper defines a general networked model with coupled dynamics and local control, where the state of each agent (node) is affected by the states of its neighbors. The researchers introduce the concept of node-level barrier functions (NBF), which describe safe sets for individual agents, and node-level control barrier functions (NCBF), which incorporate the agent's control input.
Building on this, the paper defines collaborative node-level barrier functions (cNCBF), which capture the safety of an agent's neighborhood. The researchers provide conditions under which sets defined by these functions will be forward invariant, ensuring the system remains in a safe state.
To enable safe control of collaborating network agents, the paper presents a distributed algorithm that uses the cNCBF to find a set of safe control actions for all agents. This algorithm is guaranteed to either converge to a viable set of safe controls or reach a state where at least one agent is unable to act safely.
The notion of "non-compliance" is introduced as a metric to assess the robustness of the collaborative safety for a given network state and barrier function parameters. This metric can help identify situations where the safety of the overall system may be vulnerable to the actions of individual agents.
The researchers illustrate these concepts using a networked susceptible-infected-susceptible (SIS) model, which represents the spread of a disease or information through a network of interconnected agents.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive framework for ensuring the safe control of networked systems with coupled dynamics, which is an important problem as modern systems become increasingly interconnected. The introduction of collaborative node-level barrier functions and the distributed algorithm for finding safe control actions are significant contributions.
One potential limitation of the research is the reliance on the availability of accurate models of the system dynamics and coupling relationships. In real-world scenarios, these models may be subject to uncertainty or incomplete information, which could impact the effectiveness of the proposed methods.
Additionally, the paper does not address the computational complexity of the proposed algorithms, which could be a concern for large-scale or time-critical applications. Further research may be needed to optimize the implementation and scalability of the methods.
The notion of "non-compliance" as a robustness metric is interesting, but its practical implementation and interpretation may require further investigation, particularly in complex, real-world scenarios.
Overall, this paper provides a valuable foundation for the development of safe control methods for networked systems, and the ideas presented here could inspire further research in this important area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a comprehensive framework for ensuring the safe control of networked systems with coupled dynamics. By defining node-level barrier functions, node-level control barrier functions, and collaborative node-level barrier functions, the researchers provide a way to capture the safety of individual agents and their neighborhoods.
The distributed algorithm presented in the paper allows for the safe control of collaborating network agents, with guarantees of either converging to a viable set of safe controls or reaching a state where at least one agent is unable to act safely. The concept of "non-compliance" as a robustness metric is also a valuable contribution, as it can help identify potential vulnerabilities in the system.
While the paper relies on accurate models of the system dynamics and coupling relationships, which may be challenging in real-world scenarios, the ideas presented here represent an important step forward in the development of safe control methods for complex, interconnected systems. Further research may focus on addressing the computational complexity of the algorithms and exploring the practical implementation of the "non-compliance" metric in diverse application domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔎
Collaborative Safe Formation Control for Coupled Multi-Agent Systems
Brooks A. Butler, Chi Ho Leung, Philip E. Par'e
0
0
The safe control of multi-robot swarms is a challenging and active field of research, where common goals include maintaining group cohesion while simultaneously avoiding obstacles and inter-agent collision. Building off our previously developed theory for distributed collaborative safety-critical control for networked dynamic systems, we propose a distributed algorithm for the formation control of robot swarms given individual agent dynamics, induced formation dynamics, and local neighborhood position and velocity information within a defined sensing radius for each agent. Individual safety guarantees for each agent are obtained using rounds of communication between neighbors to restrict unsafe control actions among cooperating agents through safety conditions derived from high-order control barrier functions. We provide conditions under which a swarm is guaranteed to achieve collective safety with respect to multiple obstacles using a modified collaborative safety algorithm. We demonstrate the performance of our distributed algorithm via simulation in a simplified physics-based environment.
4/3/2024
🌀
Safe Distributed Control of Multi-Robot Systems with Communication Delays
Luca Ballotta, Rajat Talak
0
0
Safe operation of multi-robot systems is critical, especially in communication-degraded environments such as underwater for seabed mapping, underground caves for navigation, and in extraterrestrial missions for assembly and construction. We address safety of networked autonomous systems where the information exchanged between robots incurs communication delays. We formalize a notion of distributed control barrier function (CBF) for multi-robot systems, a safety certificate amenable to a distributed implementation, which provides formal ground to using graph neural networks to learn safe distributed controllers. Further, we observe that learning a distributed controller ignoring delays can severely degrade safety. Our main contribution is a predictor-based framework to train a safe distributed controller under communication delays, where the current state of nearby robots is predicted from received data and age-of-information. Numerical experiments on multi-robot collision avoidance show that our predictor-based approach can significantly improve the safety of a learned distributed controller under communication delays
5/28/2024
Constructive Safety-Critical Control: Synthesizing Control Barrier Functions for Partially Feedback Linearizable Systems
Max H. Cohen, Ryan K. Cosner, Aaron D. Ames
0
0
Certifying the safety of nonlinear systems, through the lens of set invariance and control barrier functions (CBFs), offers a powerful method for controller synthesis, provided a CBF can be constructed. This paper draws connections between partial feedback linearization and CBF synthesis. We illustrate that when a control affine system is input-output linearizable with respect to a smooth output function, then, under mild regularity conditions, one may extend any safety constraint defined on the output to a CBF for the full-order dynamics. These more general results are specialized to robotic systems where the conditions required to synthesize CBFs simplify. The CBFs constructed from our approach are applied and verified in simulation and hardware experiments on a quadrotor.
6/6/2024
Using Dynamic Safety Margins as Control Barrier Functions
Victor Freire, Marco M. Nicotra
0
0
This paper provides an approach to design control barrier functions (CBFs) using the notion of dynamic safety margins (DSMs). In particular, it is shown that DSMs are CBFs for an augmented system. The proposed approach can handle multiple state and input constraints using the control-sharing property of CBFs. Moreover, it makes no assumption on the relative degree of the constraints. Numerical simulations show that the method outperforms existing DSM-based approaches, while also guaranteeing safety and recursive feasibility.
4/3/2024