A Comprehensive Evaluation of Generative Models in Calorimeter Shower Simulation
2406.12898
0
0
Abstract
The pursuit of understanding fundamental particle interactions has reached unparalleled precision levels. Particle physics detectors play a crucial role in generating low-level object signatures that encode collision physics. However, simulating these particle collisions is a demanding task in terms of memory and computation which will be exasperated with larger data volumes, more complex detectors, and a higher pileup environment in the High-Luminosity LHC. The introduction of Fast Simulation has been pivotal in overcoming computational bottlenecks. The use of deep-generative models has sparked a surge of interest in surrogate modeling for detector simulations, generating particle showers that closely resemble the observed data. Nonetheless, there is a pressing need for a comprehensive evaluation of their performance using a standardized set of metrics. In this study, we conducted a rigorous evaluation of three generative models using standard datasets and a diverse set of metrics derived from physics, computer vision, and statistics. Furthermore, we explored the impact of using full versus mixed precision modes during inference. Our evaluation revealed that the CaloDiffusion and CaloScore generative models demonstrate the most accurate simulation of particle showers, yet there remains substantial room for improvement. Our findings identified areas where the evaluated models fell short in accurately replicating Geant4 data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of various generative models for simulating calorimeter shower data in particle physics experiments.
- The authors compare the performance of several deep learning-based approaches, including generative diffusion models, conditional variational autoencoders, and super-resolution models, in generating realistic calorimeter shower images.
- The evaluation is conducted on multiple datasets, including a new dataset introduced in this work, to assess the models' ability to capture the complex spatial and energy distributions observed in particle physics experiments.
Plain English Explanation
Particle physics experiments often require simulating the behavior of particles as they interact with specialized detectors called calorimeters. These simulations are crucial for understanding the underlying physics and designing more effective experiments. However, traditional simulation methods can be computationally expensive and time-consuming.
This paper explores the use of advanced deep learning models, known as generative models, to generate realistic calorimeter shower data more efficiently. Generative models are a class of machine learning algorithms that can learn to generate new data that resembles the original training data.
The researchers in this study compared the performance of several types of generative models, including generative diffusion models, conditional variational autoencoders, and super-resolution models, in generating calorimeter shower images. They tested these models on multiple datasets, including a new dataset introduced in this work, to evaluate their ability to capture the complex spatial and energy distributions observed in particle physics experiments.
The findings of this study could have significant implications for the field of particle physics, as they demonstrate the potential of deep learning-based generative models to accelerate the simulation of calorimeter showers, enabling more efficient and cost-effective experiments.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of various generative models for simulating calorimeter shower data in particle physics experiments. The authors compare the performance of several deep learning-based approaches, including generative diffusion models, conditional variational autoencoders, and super-resolution models.
The evaluation is conducted on multiple datasets, including a new dataset introduced in this work, to assess the models' ability to capture the complex spatial and energy distributions observed in particle physics experiments. The new dataset, which includes realistic calorimeter shower images, allows the researchers to evaluate the models' performance on a more representative set of data.
The authors use a range of quantitative and qualitative metrics to assess the generated calorimeter shower images, including measures of image quality, energy deposition patterns, and other physics-inspired characteristics. They also analyze the models' ability to generate diverse and realistic samples, as well as their computational efficiency.
The results of the study suggest that the deep learning-based generative models can effectively simulate calorimeter shower data, outperforming traditional simulation methods in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency. The findings have the potential to significantly impact the field of particle physics, as they demonstrate the viability of using deep learning for accelerating the simulation of calorimeter showers, which is a crucial step in the design and analysis of particle physics experiments.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough and well-designed evaluation of various generative models for calorimeter shower simulation, addressing an important problem in the field of particle physics. The authors have carefully selected and compared multiple state-of-the-art deep learning approaches, providing valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each model.
One potential limitation of the study is the reliance on a single new dataset, which may not fully capture the diversity of calorimeter shower data observed in different particle physics experiments. It would be interesting to see the models evaluated on additional datasets, potentially from different experimental setups or particle interactions, to assess their robustness and generalization capabilities.
Furthermore, the paper could have delved deeper into the interpretability and explainability of the generative models, shedding light on the underlying mechanisms and physical insights that these models can provide. Particle physics DL simulation with control over generated is an example of a paper that explores this aspect in more detail.
Despite these minor limitations, the comprehensive evaluation and the promising results presented in the paper make it a valuable contribution to the field of particle physics simulation. The findings could pave the way for the widespread adoption of deep learning-based approaches in accelerating calorimeter shower simulations and improving the efficiency of particle physics experiments.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of various generative models for simulating calorimeter shower data in particle physics experiments. The authors compare the performance of several deep learning-based approaches, including generative diffusion models, conditional variational autoencoders, and super-resolution models, on multiple datasets, including a new dataset introduced in this work.
The findings of this study suggest that deep learning-based generative models can effectively simulate calorimeter shower data, outperforming traditional simulation methods in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency. These results have the potential to significantly impact the field of particle physics, as they demonstrate the viability of using deep learning for accelerating the simulation of calorimeter showers, a crucial step in the design and analysis of particle physics experiments.
The comprehensive evaluation and the promising results presented in this paper make it a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts in the particle physics community to leverage advanced machine learning techniques for more efficient and cost-effective experimentation.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Deep Generative Models for Proton Zero Degree Calorimeter Simulations in ALICE, CERN
Patryk Bk{e}dkowski, Jan Dubi'nski, Kamil Deja, Przemys{l}aw Rokita
0
0
Simulating detector responses is a crucial part of understanding the inner-workings of particle collisions in the Large Hadron Collider at CERN. The current reliance on statistical Monte-Carlo simulations strains CERN's computational grid, underscoring the urgency for more efficient alternatives. Addressing these challenges, recent proposals advocate for generative machine learning methods. In this study, we present an innovative deep learning simulation approach tailored for the proton Zero Degree Calorimeter in the ALICE experiment. Leveraging a Generative Adversarial Network model with Selective Diversity Increase loss, we directly simulate calorimeter responses. To enhance its capabilities in modeling a broad range of calorimeter response intensities, we expand the SDI-GAN architecture with additional regularization. Moreover, to improve the spatial fidelity of the generated data, we introduce an auxiliary regressor network. Our method offers a significant speedup when comparing to the traditional Monte-Carlo based approaches.
6/6/2024
CaloQVAE : Simulating high-energy particle-calorimeter interactions using hybrid quantum-classical generative models
Sehmimul Hoque (Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics), Hao Jia (Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of British Columbia), Abhishek Abhishek (TRIUMF), Mojde Fadaie (Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics), J. Quetzalcoatl Toledo-Mar'in (TRIUMF), Tiago Vale (Department of Physics, Simon Fraser University), Roger G. Melko (Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics), Maximilian Swiatlowski (TRIUMF), Wojciech T. Fedorko (TRIUMF)
0
0
The Large Hadron Collider's high luminosity era presents major computational challenges in the analysis of collision events. Large amounts of Monte Carlo (MC) simulation will be required to constrain the statistical uncertainties of the simulated datasets below these of the experimental data. Modelling of high-energy particles propagating through the calorimeter section of the detector is the most computationally intensive MC simulation task. We introduce a technique combining recent advancements in generative models and quantum annealing for fast and efficient simulation of high-energy particle-calorimeter interactions.
5/13/2024
🗣️
Calorimeter shower superresolution
Ian Pang, John Andrew Raine, David Shih
0
0
Calorimeter shower simulation is a major bottleneck in the Large Hadron Collider computational pipeline. There have been recent efforts to employ deep-generative surrogate models to overcome this challenge. However, many of best performing models have training and generation times that do not scale well to high-dimensional calorimeter showers. In this work, we introduce SuperCalo, a flow-based superresolution model, and demonstrate that high-dimensional fine-grained calorimeter showers can be quickly upsampled from coarse-grained showers. This novel approach presents a way to reduce computational cost, memory requirements and generation time associated with fast calorimeter simulation models. Additionally, we show that the showers upsampled by SuperCalo possess a high degree of variation. This allows a large number of high-dimensional calorimeter showers to be upsampled from much fewer coarse showers with high-fidelity, which results in additional reduction in generation time.
5/17/2024
Generative Diffusion Models for Fast Simulations of Particle Collisions at CERN
Miko{l}aj Kita, Jan Dubi'nski, Przemys{l}aw Rokita, Kamil Deja
0
0
In High Energy Physics simulations play a crucial role in unraveling the complexities of particle collision experiments within CERN's Large Hadron Collider. Machine learning simulation methods have garnered attention as promising alternatives to traditional approaches. While existing methods mainly employ Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) or Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), recent advancements highlight the efficacy of diffusion models as state-of-the-art generative machine learning methods. We present the first simulation for Zero Degree Calorimeter (ZDC) at the ALICE experiment based on diffusion models, achieving the highest fidelity compared to existing baselines. We perform an analysis of trade-offs between generation times and the simulation quality. The results indicate a significant potential of latent diffusion model due to its rapid generation time.
6/6/2024