Does Knowledge Graph Really Matter for Recommender Systems?
2404.03164
0
0
Abstract
Recommender systems (RSs) are designed to provide personalized recommendations to users. Recently, knowledge graphs (KGs) have been widely introduced in RSs to improve recommendation accuracy. In this study, however, we demonstrate that RSs do not necessarily perform worse even if the KG is downgraded to the user-item interaction graph only (or removed). We propose an evaluation framework KG4RecEval to systematically evaluate how much a KG contributes to the recommendation accuracy of a KG-based RS, using our defined metric KGER (KG utilization efficiency in recommendation). We consider the scenarios where knowledge in a KG gets completely removed, randomly distorted and decreased, and also where recommendations are for cold-start users. Our extensive experiments on four commonly used datasets and a number of state-of-the-art KG-based RSs reveal that: to remove, randomly distort or decrease knowledge does not necessarily decrease recommendation accuracy, even for cold-start users. These findings inspire us to rethink how to better utilize knowledge from existing KGs, whereby we discuss and provide insights into what characteristics of datasets and KG-based RSs may help improve KG utilization efficiency.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the role of knowledge graphs in recommender systems, exploring whether they truly matter for improving recommendation performance.
- The researchers conduct experiments to compare the effectiveness of knowledge graph-based and non-knowledge graph-based recommender systems across several datasets.
- The results provide insights into the conditions under which knowledge graphs can be beneficial for recommendation tasks.
Plain English Explanation
Recommender systems are algorithms that suggest products, services, or content to users based on their past preferences and behaviors. These systems play a crucial role in many online platforms, helping users discover new and relevant items.
One approach to building recommender systems is to incorporate knowledge graphs - structured representations of entities (like products, people, or concepts) and the relationships between them. The idea is that this additional information about the underlying items and their connections can lead to more accurate and personalized recommendations.
However, the value of knowledge graphs for recommender systems has been debated. This paper sets out to empirically investigate whether knowledge graphs really do matter for improving recommendation performance. The researchers compare the performance of knowledge graph-based and non-knowledge graph-based recommender models across several real-world datasets.
Their findings suggest that the benefits of using knowledge graphs depend on the specific characteristics of the dataset and recommendation task. In some cases, incorporating knowledge graphs can indeed boost recommendation accuracy. But in other scenarios, simpler models that don't use knowledge graphs can perform just as well, or even better.
The key insight is that the usefulness of knowledge graphs is context-dependent. Factors like the sparsity of the user-item interaction data, the availability and quality of the knowledge graph, and the specific recommendation algorithms used all play a role in determining whether knowledge graphs will be helpful.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a systematic empirical study to understand the impact of knowledge graphs on the performance of recommender systems. The researchers conducted experiments on several real-world datasets, including e-commerce, movie, and book recommendation scenarios.
They compared the performance of two types of recommender models: those that leverage knowledge graphs (knowledge graph-based models) and those that do not (non-knowledge graph-based models). The knowledge graph-based models incorporated entity and relationship information from the knowledge graphs, while the non-knowledge graph-based models relied solely on user-item interaction data.
To ensure a fair comparison, the researchers used the same underlying recommendation algorithms (e.g., matrix factorization, graph neural networks) for both model types. They evaluated the models on standard recommendation metrics such as Recall, Normalized Discounted Cumulative Gain (NDCG), and Hit Ratio.
The results show that the effectiveness of knowledge graphs varies across different datasets and recommendation tasks. In some cases, the knowledge graph-based models outperformed the non-knowledge graph-based models, demonstrating the potential value of incorporating structured knowledge. However, in other scenarios, the non-knowledge graph-based models performed equally well or even better.
The authors provide insights into the factors that influence the usefulness of knowledge graphs, including the sparsity of the user-item interaction data, the completeness and quality of the knowledge graph, and the specific recommendation algorithms employed. They also discuss the trade-offs between the increased model complexity and potential performance gains when using knowledge graphs.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thoughtful study that contributes to our understanding of the role of knowledge graphs in recommender systems. The researchers have carefully controlled for various factors and used appropriate evaluation metrics to ensure a fair comparison between the different model types.
One potential limitation is the scope of the datasets used. While the authors have examined several real-world scenarios, it would be valuable to further explore the performance of knowledge graph-based recommenders across a wider range of domains and data characteristics. Assessing the impact of different knowledge graph properties, such as size, coverage, and noise, could also provide additional insights.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the overall recommendation performance, but does not delve into the specific reasons why knowledge graphs may or may not be beneficial in certain cases. Investigating the underlying mechanisms and the types of recommendations where knowledge graphs excel could lead to more nuanced guidelines for when and how to effectively incorporate knowledge graphs into recommender systems.
Overall, this study serves as an important step in understanding the practical implications of using knowledge graphs in recommender systems. The findings highlight the need for a context-aware approach, where the decision to use knowledge graphs should be based on a careful analysis of the specific recommendation problem and dataset characteristics.
Conclusion
This paper presents a thorough investigation into the role of knowledge graphs in recommender systems. The results demonstrate that the usefulness of knowledge graphs is not a foregone conclusion and depends on the specific characteristics of the recommendation task and the available data.
The key takeaway is that the decision to incorporate knowledge graphs into a recommender system should be driven by a careful analysis of the problem at hand. In some cases, knowledge graphs can provide valuable additional information and lead to performance improvements. But in other scenarios, simpler models that rely solely on user-item interaction data may be equally or more effective.
This research underscores the importance of understanding the limitations and trade-offs associated with knowledge graph-based recommender systems. As the field of recommender systems continues to evolve, these insights can help guide practitioners in making more informed decisions about the appropriate use of knowledge graphs and other advanced techniques to deliver personalized and accurate recommendations to users.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Knowledge Graph Pruning for Recommendation
Fake Lin, Xi Zhu, Ziwei Zhao, Deqiang Huang, Yu Yu, Xueying Li, Tong Xu, Enhong Chen
0
0
Recent years have witnessed the prosperity of knowledge graph based recommendation system (KGRS), which enriches the representation of users, items, and entities by structural knowledge with striking improvement. Nevertheless, its unaffordable computational cost still limits researchers from exploring more sophisticated models. We observe that the bottleneck for training efficiency arises from the knowledge graph, which is plagued by the well-known issue of knowledge explosion. Recently, some works have attempted to slim the inflated KG via summarization techniques. However, these summarized nodes may ignore the collaborative signals and deviate from the facts that nodes in knowledge graph represent symbolic abstractions of entities from the real-world. To this end, in this paper, we propose a novel approach called KGTrimmer for knowledge graph pruning tailored for recommendation, to remove the unessential nodes while minimizing performance degradation. Specifically, we design an importance evaluator from a dual-view perspective. For the collective view, we embrace the idea of collective intelligence by extracting community consensus based on abundant collaborative signals, i.e. nodes are considered important if they attract attention of numerous users. For the holistic view, we learn a global mask to identify the valueless nodes from their inherent properties or overall popularity. Next, we build an end-to-end importance-aware graph neural network, which injects filtered knowledge to enhance the distillation of valuable user-item collaborative signals. Ultimately, we generate a pruned knowledge graph with lightweight, stable, and robust properties to facilitate the following-up recommendation task. Extensive experiments are conducted on three publicly available datasets to prove the effectiveness and generalization ability of KGTrimmer.
5/21/2024
How to Surprisingly Consider Recommendations? A Knowledge-Graph-based Approach Relying on Complex Network Metrics
Oliver Baumann, Durgesh Nandini, Anderson Rossanez, Mirco Schoenfeld, Julio Cesar dos Reis
0
0
Traditional recommendation proposals, including content-based and collaborative filtering, usually focus on similarity between items or users. Existing approaches lack ways of introducing unexpectedness into recommendations, prioritizing globally popular items over exposing users to unforeseen items. This investigation aims to design and evaluate a novel layer on top of recommender systems suited to incorporate relational information and suggest items with a user-defined degree of surprise. We propose a Knowledge Graph (KG) based recommender system by encoding user interactions on item catalogs. Our study explores whether network-level metrics on KGs can influence the degree of surprise in recommendations. We hypothesize that surprisingness correlates with certain network metrics, treating user profiles as subgraphs within a larger catalog KG. The achieved solution reranks recommendations based on their impact on structural graph metrics. Our research contributes to optimizing recommendations to reflect the metrics. We experimentally evaluate our approach on two datasets of LastFM listening histories and synthetic Netflix viewing profiles. We find that reranking items based on complex network metrics leads to a more unexpected and surprising composition of recommendation lists.
5/15/2024
🏋️
Ripple Knowledge Graph Convolutional Networks For Recommendation Systems
Chen Li, Yang Cao, Ye Zhu, Debo Cheng, Chengyuan Li, Yasuhiko Morimoto
0
0
Using knowledge graphs to assist deep learning models in making recommendation decisions has recently been proven to effectively improve the model's interpretability and accuracy. This paper introduces an end-to-end deep learning model, named RKGCN, which dynamically analyses each user's preferences and makes a recommendation of suitable items. It combines knowledge graphs on both the item side and user side to enrich their representations to maximize the utilization of the abundant information in knowledge graphs. RKGCN is able to offer more personalized and relevant recommendations in three different scenarios. The experimental results show the superior effectiveness of our model over 5 baseline models on three real-world datasets including movies, books, and music.
4/11/2024
A review of feature selection strategies utilizing graph data structures and knowledge graphs
Sisi Shao, Pedro Henrique Ribeiro, Christina Ramirez, Jason H. Moore
0
0
Feature selection in Knowledge Graphs (KGs) are increasingly utilized in diverse domains, including biomedical research, Natural Language Processing (NLP), and personalized recommendation systems. This paper delves into the methodologies for feature selection within KGs, emphasizing their roles in enhancing machine learning (ML) model efficacy, hypothesis generation, and interpretability. Through this comprehensive review, we aim to catalyze further innovation in feature selection for KGs, paving the way for more insightful, efficient, and interpretable analytical models across various domains. Our exploration reveals the critical importance of scalability, accuracy, and interpretability in feature selection techniques, advocating for the integration of domain knowledge to refine the selection process. We highlight the burgeoning potential of multi-objective optimization and interdisciplinary collaboration in advancing KG feature selection, underscoring the transformative impact of such methodologies on precision medicine, among other fields. The paper concludes by charting future directions, including the development of scalable, dynamic feature selection algorithms and the integration of explainable AI principles to foster transparency and trust in KG-driven models.
6/24/2024