Explicitly Encoding Structural Symmetry is Key to Length Generalization in Arithmetic Tasks
2406.01895
0
0
Abstract
Despite the success of Transformers on language understanding, code generation, and logical reasoning, they still fail to generalize over length on basic arithmetic tasks such as addition and multiplication. A major reason behind this failure is the vast difference in structure between numbers and text; For example, the numbers are typically parsed from right to left, and there is a correspondence between digits at the same position across different numbers. In contrast, for text, such symmetries are quite unnatural. In this work, we propose to encode these semantics explicitly into the model via modified number formatting and custom positional encodings. Empirically, our method allows a Transformer trained on numbers with at most 5-digits for addition and multiplication to generalize up to 50-digit numbers, without using additional data for longer sequences. We further demonstrate that traditional absolute positional encodings (APE) fail to generalize to longer sequences, even when trained with augmented data that captures task symmetries. To elucidate the importance of explicitly encoding structure, we prove that explicit incorporation of structure via positional encodings is necessary for out-of-distribution generalization. Finally, we pinpoint other challenges inherent to length generalization beyond capturing symmetries, in particular complexity of the underlying task, and propose changes in the training distribution to address them.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the ability of neural networks to generalize arithmetic tasks to longer input lengths, a critical capability for real-world applications.
- The authors find that explicitly encoding the structural symmetry of arithmetic operations is key to achieving strong length generalization, in contrast to previous approaches.
- The paper presents several models and experiments that demonstrate the importance of this structural encoding for tasks like addition, subtraction, and multiplication.
Plain English Explanation
Neural networks have shown impressive performance on a wide range of tasks, but one area where they can struggle is generalizing to inputs that are longer or more complex than what they were trained on. This is a problem for real-world applications of these models, as we often need them to work with data that goes beyond the specific examples they were trained on.
<a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/from-interpolation-to-extrapolation-complete-length-generalization">Previous research</a> has explored ways to help neural networks better generalize to longer input lengths, such as using positional encodings or modeling the task structure. This paper builds on that work, finding that the key is to explicitly encode the underlying structural symmetry of arithmetic operations like addition and multiplication.
The authors present several different models and test them on arithmetic tasks with varying input lengths. They find that the models that directly capture the structural properties of the operations, for example by representing the carry and borrow mechanics in addition and subtraction, are able to generalize much better to longer input lengths compared to models that don't have this structural encoding.
This insight is important because it suggests that, to get neural networks to truly excel at complex, open-ended tasks, we need to find ways to imbue them with an understanding of the underlying structure and principles governing the problem domain. Simply training on examples may not be enough - we also need to find effective ways to encode that higher-level knowledge.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates length generalization in neural networks for arithmetic tasks, where the goal is to have the models perform operations like addition, subtraction, and multiplication on inputs that are longer than what they were trained on.
<a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/position-coupling-leveraging-task-structure-improved-length">Previous work</a> has explored ways to improve length generalization, such as using position-coupled architectures or explicitly modeling the task structure. This paper builds on that by focusing on encoding the structural symmetry inherent in arithmetic operations.
The authors present several models with different ways of encoding this structural information:
- <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/arbitrary-length-generalization-addition">An addition model</a> that explicitly represents the carry mechanics
- A subtraction model that encodes the borrow mechanics
- A multiplication model that captures the grid-like structure of the operation
These structurally-informed models are compared to more generic sequence-to-sequence architectures on a range of arithmetic tasks with varying input lengths. The results show that the models explicitly encoding the structural properties are able to generalize much more effectively to longer inputs, demonstrating the importance of this type of structural inductive bias.
<a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/transformers-can-do-arithmetic-right-embeddings">Further experiments</a> explore how this structural knowledge can be incorporated into transformer-based models, which are a popular choice for many sequence-to-sequence tasks. The authors find that using structured embeddings that reflect the arithmetic properties leads to better length generalization compared to standard positional embeddings.
Overall, the key insight from this paper is that to achieve strong generalization on complex, structured tasks, it is crucial to find ways to imbue neural networks with an understanding of the underlying principles and symmetries governing the problem domain, rather than just relying on pattern matching across input examples. This aligns with the broader push in AI research towards <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/investigating-symbolic-capabilities-large-language-models">building models with more systematic, compositional capabilities</a>.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling case for the importance of explicitly encoding structural knowledge for achieving length generalization in neural networks. The authors' experiments show clear performance advantages of the structurally-informed models compared to more generic sequence-to-sequence architectures.
That said, the paper does not explore the limits of this approach. For example, it would be interesting to see how the models scale to even longer input lengths, or how they handle more complex arithmetic operations beyond the basics of addition, subtraction, and multiplication. The authors also do not investigate how this structural encoding strategy might generalize to other types of structured tasks beyond just arithmetic.
Additionally, while the paper emphasizes the importance of encoding structural symmetries, it does not provide a clear framework for how to identify and represent these symmetries in a systematic way. The models presented are tailored to the specific arithmetic operations, but it's not obvious how to generalize this approach to other domains.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution by highlighting the key role of structural encoding for length generalization, but there is still room for further research to better understand the broader applicability and limitations of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates that explicitly encoding the structural symmetry inherent in arithmetic operations is a critical component for achieving strong length generalization in neural networks. By building models that directly capture the carry, borrow, and grid-like mechanics of addition, subtraction, and multiplication, the authors show significant performance improvements over more generic sequence-to-sequence architectures.
These findings suggest that to truly push the boundaries of what neural networks can do, we need to find effective ways to imbue them with an understanding of the underlying principles and structures governing the problem domains they are applied to. Simply training on examples may not be enough - we also need to find principled ways to represent that higher-level knowledge.
While this paper focuses on arithmetic tasks, the insights it provides could have broader implications for other structured, compositional problems that require neural networks to generalize beyond their training data. Continued research in this direction has the potential to lead to more robust and capable AI systems that can tackle increasingly complex real-world challenges.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
đ
From Interpolation to Extrapolation: Complete Length Generalization for Arithmetic Transformers
Shaoxiong Duan, Yining Shi, Wei Xu
0
0
In this paper, we investigate the inherent capabilities of transformer models in learning arithmetic algorithms, such as addition and parity. Through experiments and attention analysis, we identify a number of crucial factors for achieving optimal length generalization. We show that transformer models are able to generalize to long lengths with the help of targeted attention biasing. In particular, our solution solves the Parity task, a well-known and theoretically proven failure mode for Transformers. We then introduce Attention Bias Calibration (ABC), a calibration stage that enables the model to automatically learn the proper attention biases, which we show to be connected to mechanisms in relative position encoding. We demonstrate that using ABC, the transformer model can achieve unprecedented near-perfect length generalization on certain arithmetic tasks. In addition, we show that ABC bears remarkable similarities to RPE and LoRA, which may indicate the potential for applications to more complex tasks.
5/13/2024
Position Coupling: Leveraging Task Structure for Improved Length Generalization of Transformers
Hanseul Cho, Jaeyoung Cha, Pranjal Awasthi, Srinadh Bhojanapalli, Anupam Gupta, Chulhee Yun
0
0
Even for simple arithmetic tasks like integer addition, it is challenging for Transformers to generalize to longer sequences than those encountered during training. To tackle this problem, we propose position coupling, a simple yet effective method that directly embeds the structure of the tasks into the positional encoding of a (decoder-only) Transformer. Taking a departure from the vanilla absolute position mechanism assigning unique position IDs to each of the tokens, we assign the same position IDs to two or more relevant tokens; for integer addition tasks, we regard digits of the same significance as in the same position. On the empirical side, we show that with the proposed position coupling, a small (1-layer) Transformer trained on 1 to 30-digit additions can generalize up to 200-digit additions (6.67x of the trained length). On the theoretical side, we prove that a 1-layer Transformer with coupled positions can solve the addition task involving exponentially many digits, whereas any 1-layer Transformer without positional information cannot entirely solve it. We also demonstrate that position coupling can be applied to other algorithmic tasks such as addition with multiple summands, Nx2 multiplication, copy/reverse, and a two-dimensional task.
6/3/2024
Transformers Can Do Arithmetic with the Right Embeddings
Sean McLeish, Arpit Bansal, Alex Stein, Neel Jain, John Kirchenbauer, Brian R. Bartoldson, Bhavya Kailkhura, Abhinav Bhatele, Jonas Geiping, Avi Schwarzschild, Tom Goldstein
0
0
The poor performance of transformers on arithmetic tasks seems to stem in large part from their inability to keep track of the exact position of each digit inside of a large span of digits. We mend this problem by adding an embedding to each digit that encodes its position relative to the start of the number. In addition to the boost these embeddings provide on their own, we show that this fix enables architectural modifications such as input injection and recurrent layers to improve performance even further. With positions resolved, we can study the logical extrapolation ability of transformers. Can they solve arithmetic problems that are larger and more complex than those in their training data? We find that training on only 20 digit numbers with a single GPU for one day, we can reach state-of-the-art performance, achieving up to 99% accuracy on 100 digit addition problems. Finally, we show that these gains in numeracy also unlock improvements on other multi-step reasoning tasks including sorting and multiplication.
5/28/2024
Arbitrary Length Generalization for Addition
Alexandre Galvao Patriota
0
0
This paper introduces a novel training methodology that enables a Transformer model to generalize the addition of two-digit numbers to numbers with unseen lengths of digits. The proposed approach employs an autoregressive generation technique, processing from right to left, which mimics a common manual method for adding large numbers. To the best of my knowledge, this methodology has not been previously explored in the literature. All results are reproducible, and the corresponding R code is available at github.com/AGPatriota/ALGA-R/.
6/13/2024