Finite element approximation of time-dependent mean field games with nondifferentiable Hamiltonians
2306.13174
0
0
👨🏫
Abstract
The standard formulation of the PDE system of Mean Field Games (MFG) requires the differentiability of the Hamiltonian. However in many cases, the structure of the underlying optimal problem leads to a convex but nondifferentiable Hamiltonian. For time-dependent MFG systems, we introduce a generalization of the problem as a Partial Differential Inclusion (PDI) by interpreting the derivative of the Hamiltonian in terms of the subdifferential set. In particular, we prove the existence and uniqueness of weak solutions to the resulting MFG PDI system under standard assumptions in the literature. We propose a monotone stabilized finite element discretization of the problem, using conforming affine elements in space and an implicit Euler discretization in time with mass-lumping. We prove the strong convergence in $L^2(H^1)$ of the value function approximations, and strong convergence in $L^p(L^2)$ of the density function approximations, together with strong $L^2$-convergence of the value function approximations at the initial time.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a finite element approximation method for solving time-dependent Mean Field Games (MFGs) with non-differentiable Hamiltonians.
- MFGs are a framework for modeling the collective behavior of a large number of rational, strategic agents in dynamic environments.
- The authors focus on scenarios where the Hamiltonians (the functions that describe the agents' optimization problems) are non-differentiable, which can occur in real-world applications.
- They develop a numerical scheme using finite elements to approximate the solutions to these time-dependent MFG problems.
Plain English Explanation
Mean Field Games are a way to model situations where many individuals are making strategic decisions that affect each other. Imagine a crowd of people in a busy city, each trying to get to their destination as quickly as possible. The decisions of one person, like taking a shortcut, can impact the experiences of everyone else.
In this paper, the researchers looked at a specific type of Mean Field Game where the mathematical functions describing the individuals' decision-making (called Hamiltonians) are not smooth or differentiable. This can happen in real-world scenarios, like when people have to deal with non-continuous factors like traffic lights or obstacles.
The researchers developed a numerical method using finite elements to approximate the solutions to these complex, time-dependent Mean Field Game problems. Finite elements involve breaking down a problem into small, manageable pieces that can be solved individually and then combined to get the overall solution.
By tackling these non-differentiable Hamiltonians, the researchers have expanded the applicability of Mean Field Game theory to a wider range of real-world situations. Their numerical approach provides a way to compute solutions to these challenging problems, which could help improve our understanding of collective decision-making in dynamic environments.
Technical Explanation
The authors consider time-dependent Mean Field Game (MFG) problems with non-differentiable Hamiltonians. In MFGs, a large number of rational, strategic agents interact in a dynamic environment, and their collective behavior is described by a coupled system of a Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation and a Fokker-Planck (FP) equation.
The key challenge addressed in this paper is the case where the Hamiltonians are non-differentiable, which can occur in practical applications. The authors develop a finite element approximation scheme to numerically solve these time-dependent MFG problems.
The main steps of their approach are:
- Formulate the time-dependent MFG problem with non-differentiable Hamiltonians
- Introduce a variational formulation of the coupled HJB-FP system
- Discretize the problem in time using a semi-implicit scheme and in space using finite elements
- Prove the well-posedness and convergence of the finite element approximation
The authors establish theoretical results on the existence, uniqueness, and convergence of the finite element approximation. They also present numerical experiments to demonstrate the performance of their method on examples with non-differentiable Hamiltonians.
Critical Analysis
The authors thoroughly address the challenge of non-differentiable Hamiltonians in time-dependent Mean Field Game problems, which is an important consideration for practical applications. Their finite element approximation scheme provides a robust numerical method for computing solutions to these complex problems.
One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the assumption of uniform ellipticity of the diffusion terms in the HJB and FP equations. This may restrict the applicability of the method to certain problem settings. Additionally, the authors note that the convergence analysis relies on strong regularity assumptions on the solution, which may not always be satisfied in practice.
Further research could explore relaxing some of these assumptions or investigating alternative numerical approaches, such as finite difference or spectral methods, for solving time-dependent MFG problems with non-differentiable Hamiltonians. Incorporating more realistic features, like state constraints or uncertainty, could also be an interesting direction for future work.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of Mean Field Game theory by addressing an important practical consideration and providing a robust numerical scheme for approximating solutions to these challenging problems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a finite element approximation method for solving time-dependent Mean Field Game problems with non-differentiable Hamiltonians. The authors develop a numerical scheme that can handle these complex scenarios, which are relevant for real-world applications where agents' decision-making functions may not be smooth.
By tackling non-differentiable Hamiltonians, the researchers have expanded the applicability of Mean Field Game theory to a wider range of dynamic, interactive environments. Their finite element approach provides a robust way to compute solutions to these challenging problems, which could lead to improved understanding and modeling of collective decision-making in various fields, such as economics, transportation, and social networks.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌀
Analysis and Numerical Approximation of Stationary Second-Order Mean Field Game Partial Differential Inclusions
Yohance A. P. Osborne, Iain Smears
0
0
The formulation of Mean Field Games (MFG) typically requires continuous differentiability of the Hamiltonian in order to determine the advective term in the Kolmogorov--Fokker--Planck equation for the density of players. However, in many cases of practical interest, the underlying optimal control problem may exhibit bang-bang controls, which typically lead to nondifferentiable Hamiltonians. We develop the analysis and numerical analysis of stationary MFG for the general case of convex, Lipschitz, but possibly nondifferentiable Hamiltonians. In particular, we propose a generalization of the MFG system as a Partial Differential Inclusion (PDI) based on interpreting the derivative of the Hamiltonian in terms of subdifferentials of convex functions. We establish existence of a weak solution to the MFG PDI system, and we further prove uniqueness under a similar monotonicity condition to the one considered by Lasry and Lions. We then propose a monotone finite element discretization of the problem, and we prove strong $H^1$-norm convergence of the approximations to the value function and strong $L^q$-norm convergence of the approximations of the density function. We illustrate the performance of the numerical method in numerical experiments featuring nonsmooth solutions.
4/3/2024
📊
Monotone inclusion methods for a class of second-order non-potential mean-field games
Levon Nurbekyan, Siting Liu, Yat Tin Chow
0
0
We propose a monotone splitting algorithm for solving a class of second-order non-potential mean-field games. Following [Achdou, Capuzzo-Dolcetta, Mean Field Games: Numerical Methods, SINUM (2010)], we introduce a finite-difference scheme and observe that the scheme represents first-order optimality conditions for a primal-dual pair of monotone inclusions. Based on this observation, we prove that the finite-difference system obtains a solution that can be provably recovered by an extension of the celebrated primal-dual hybrid gradient (PDHG) algorithm.
4/1/2024
🧠
Improved Particle Approximation Error for Mean Field Neural Networks
Atsushi Nitanda
0
0
Mean-field Langevin dynamics (MFLD) minimizes an entropy-regularized nonlinear convex functional defined over the space of probability distributions. MFLD has gained attention due to its connection with noisy gradient descent for mean-field two-layer neural networks. Unlike standard Langevin dynamics, the nonlinearity of the objective functional induces particle interactions, necessitating multiple particles to approximate the dynamics in a finite-particle setting. Recent works (Chen et al., 2022; Suzuki et al., 2023b) have demonstrated the uniform-in-time propagation of chaos for MFLD, showing that the gap between the particle system and its mean-field limit uniformly shrinks over time as the number of particles increases. In this work, we improve the dependence on logarithmic Sobolev inequality (LSI) constants in their particle approximation errors, which can exponentially deteriorate with the regularization coefficient. Specifically, we establish an LSI-constant-free particle approximation error concerning the objective gap by leveraging the problem structure in risk minimization. As the application, we demonstrate improved convergence of MFLD, sampling guarantee for the mean-field stationary distribution, and uniform-in-time Wasserstein propagation of chaos in terms of particle complexity.
6/17/2024
🌿
Leveraging Hamilton-Jacobi PDEs with time-dependent Hamiltonians for continual scientific machine learning
Paula Chen, Tingwei Meng, Zongren Zou, J'er^ome Darbon, George Em Karniadakis
0
0
We address two major challenges in scientific machine learning (SciML): interpretability and computational efficiency. We increase the interpretability of certain learning processes by establishing a new theoretical connection between optimization problems arising from SciML and a generalized Hopf formula, which represents the viscosity solution to a Hamilton-Jacobi partial differential equation (HJ PDE) with time-dependent Hamiltonian. Namely, we show that when we solve certain regularized learning problems with integral-type losses, we actually solve an optimal control problem and its associated HJ PDE with time-dependent Hamiltonian. This connection allows us to reinterpret incremental updates to learned models as the evolution of an associated HJ PDE and optimal control problem in time, where all of the previous information is intrinsically encoded in the solution to the HJ PDE. As a result, existing HJ PDE solvers and optimal control algorithms can be reused to design new efficient training approaches for SciML that naturally coincide with the continual learning framework, while avoiding catastrophic forgetting. As a first exploration of this connection, we consider the special case of linear regression and leverage our connection to develop a new Riccati-based methodology for solving these learning problems that is amenable to continual learning applications. We also provide some corresponding numerical examples that demonstrate the potential computational and memory advantages our Riccati-based approach can provide.
5/8/2024