Impostor Syndrome in Final Year Computer Science Students: An Eye Tracking and Biometrics Study
2404.10194
0
0
Abstract
Imposter syndrome is a psychological phenomenon that affects individuals who doubt their skills and abilities, despite possessing the necessary competencies. This can lead to a lack of confidence and poor performance. While research has explored the impacts of imposter syndrome on students and professionals in various fields, there is limited knowledge on how it affects code comprehension in software engineering. In this exploratory study, we investigate the prevalence of imposter syndrome among final-year undergraduate computer science students and its effects on their code comprehension cognition using an eye tracker and heart rate monitor. Key findings demonstrate that students identifying as male exhibit lower imposter syndrome levels when analyzing code, and higher imposter syndrome is associated with increased time reviewing a code snippet and a lower likelihood of solving it correctly. This study provides initial data on this topic and establishes a foundation for further research to support student academic success and improve developer productivity and mental well-being.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This study investigates the experience of impostor syndrome among final year computer science students, using eye tracking and biometric data.
- The researchers explore the relationship between impostor syndrome, cognitive load, and task performance during code comprehension exercises.
- The study aims to provide insights into the factors contributing to impostor syndrome in computer science undergraduates and inform strategies to support these students.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines the phenomenon of impostor syndrome in final year computer science students. Impostor syndrome is a psychological experience where people doubt their abilities and feel like they are frauds, despite evidence of their competence.
The researchers used specialized equipment, like eye trackers and heart rate monitors, to study how impostor syndrome affects the way these students approach and understand computer programs. They wanted to understand the connection between impostor syndrome, the mental effort required to complete coding tasks (cognitive load), and the students' actual performance.
The goal is to better understand the factors that contribute to impostor syndrome in computer science undergraduates. This knowledge could help universities and educators develop more effective strategies to support these students and address the negative impacts of impostor syndrome.
Technical Explanation
The study recruited final year computer science students and assessed their levels of impostor syndrome using a validated questionnaire. Participants then completed a series of code comprehension exercises while their eye movements and physiological responses (heart rate) were monitored.
The researchers analyzed the eye tracking data to measure the students' visual attention and cognitive load during the coding tasks. They also compared the students' self-reported impostor feelings to their actual task performance.
The results suggest that students experiencing higher levels of impostor syndrome exhibited increased cognitive load, as indicated by more frequent and longer eye fixations, during the code comprehension exercises. However, their actual task performance did not differ significantly from their peers with lower impostor syndrome.
These findings indicate a disconnect between the students' perceived competence and their demonstrated abilities. The physiological data provides insights into the mental effort and anxiety experienced by those with impostor feelings, even when their objective performance is on par with their classmates.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable empirical evidence on the experience of impostor syndrome in computer science undergraduates. By incorporating eye tracking and biometric measures, the researchers were able to capture the cognitive and physiological correlates of impostor feelings in a more nuanced way than self-report data alone.
However, the study is limited by its relatively small sample size and the fact that it was conducted with students from a single institution. Replicating the research with a larger, more diverse population would help strengthen the generalizability of the findings.
Additionally, the paper does not explore potential mitigating factors or interventions that could help alleviate the negative impacts of impostor syndrome. Further research is needed to identify effective strategies for supporting students struggling with these feelings of inadequacy.
Conclusion
This study sheds light on the prevalence and manifestation of impostor syndrome among final year computer science students. By combining eye tracking, biometric, and performance data, the researchers were able to uncover the cognitive and physiological mechanisms underlying impostor feelings in this population.
The findings suggest that even high-achieving computer science students can experience persistent doubts about their abilities, despite demonstrating competence. This disconnect between perception and reality highlights the need for greater awareness and support to help students overcome impostor syndrome and reach their full potential.
The insights from this research can inform the development of targeted interventions and mentoring programs to foster a more inclusive and empowering environment for computer science undergraduates.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
GenAI Mirage: The Impostor Bias and the Deepfake Detection Challenge in the Era of Artificial Illusions
Mirko Casu, Luca Guarnera, Pasquale Caponnetto, Sebastiano Battiato
0
0
This paper examines the impact of cognitive biases on decision-making in forensics and digital forensics, exploring biases such as confirmation bias, anchoring bias, and hindsight bias. It assesses existing methods to mitigate biases and improve decision-making, introducing the novel Impostor Bias, which arises as a systematic tendency to question the authenticity of multimedia content, such as audio, images, and videos, often assuming they are generated by AI tools. This bias goes beyond evaluators' knowledge levels, as it can lead to erroneous judgments and false accusations, undermining the reliability and credibility of forensic evidence. Impostor Bias stems from an a priori assumption rather than an objective content assessment, and its impact is expected to grow with the increasing realism of AI-generated multimedia products. The paper discusses the potential causes and consequences of Impostor Bias, suggesting strategies for prevention and counteraction. By addressing these topics, this paper aims to provide valuable insights, enhance the objectivity and validity of forensic investigations, and offer recommendations for future research and practical applications to ensure the integrity and reliability of forensic practices.
6/18/2024
🔗
Mental health of computing professionals and students: A systematic literature review
Alicia Julia Wilson Takaoka, Kshitij Sharma
0
0
The intersections of mental health and computing education is under-examined. In this systematic literature review, we evaluate the state-of-the-art of research in mental health and well-being interventions, assessments, and concerns like anxiety and depression in computer science and computing education. The studies evaluated occurred across the computing education pipeline from introductory to PhD courses and found some commonalities contributing to high reporting of anxiety and depression in those studied. In addition, interventions that were designed to address mental health topics often revolved around self-guidance. Based on our review of the literature, we recommend increasing sample sizes and focusing on the design and development of tools and interventions specifically designed for computing professionals and students.
5/7/2024
📊
Overwhelmed Software Developers
Lisa-Marie Michels, Aleksandra Petkova, Marcel Richter, Andreas Farley, Daniel Graziotin, Stefan Wagner
0
0
We have conducted a qualitative psychology study to explore the experience of feeling overwhelmed in the realm of software development. Through the candid confessions of two participants who have recently faced overwhelming challenges, we have identified seven distinct categories: communication-induced, disturbance-related, organizational, variety, technical, temporal, and positive overwhelm. While most types of overwhelm tend to deteriorate productivity and increase stress levels, developers sometimes perceive overwhelm as a catalyst for heightened focus, self-motivation, and productivity. Stress was often found to be a common companion of overwhelm. Our findings align with previous studies conducted in diverse disciplines. However, we believe that software developers possess unique traits that may enable them to navigate through the storm of overwhelm more effectively.
6/7/2024
Toward Improving Binary Program Comprehension via Embodied Immersion: A Survey
Dennis Brown, Emily Mulder, Samuel Mulder
0
0
Binary program comprehension is critical for many use cases but is difficult, suffering from compounded uncertainty and lack of full automation. We seek methods to improve the effectiveness of the human-machine joint cognitive system performing binary PC. We survey three research areas to perform an indirect cognitive task analysis: cognitive models of the PC process, related elements of cognitive theory, and applicable affordances of virtual reality. Based on common elements in these areas, we identify three overarching themes: enhancing abductive iteration, augmenting working memory, and supporting information organization. These themes spotlight several affordances of VR to exploit in future studies of immersive tools for binary PC.
4/29/2024