Large Language Models as Hyper-Heuristics for Combinatorial Optimization
2402.01145
0
0
Abstract
The omnipresence of NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) compels domain experts to engage in trial-and-error heuristic design. The long-standing endeavor of design automation has gained new momentum with the rise of large language models (LLMs). This paper introduces Language Hyper-Heuristics (LHHs), an emerging variant of Hyper-Heuristics that leverages LLMs for heuristic generation, featuring minimal manual intervention and open-ended heuristic spaces. To empower LHHs, we present Reflective Evolution (ReEvo), a novel integration of evolutionary search for efficiently exploring the heuristic space, and LLM reflections to provide verbal gradients within the space. Across five heterogeneous algorithmic types, six different COPs, and both white-box and black-box views of COPs, ReEvo yields state-of-the-art and competitive meta-heuristics, evolutionary algorithms, heuristics, and neural solvers, while being more sample-efficient than prior LHHs. Our code is available: https://github.com/ai4co/LLM-as-HH.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper, "ReEvo: Large Language Models as Hyper-Heuristics with Reflective Evolution," explores the use of large language models as a powerful tool for optimization and algorithm design.
- The researchers propose a novel approach called "ReEvo" (Reflective Evolution), which leverages the capabilities of large language models to act as hyper-heuristics that can explore and adapt optimization strategies in an automated, reflective manner.
- The paper builds on previous research exploring the use of large language models as evolutionary optimizers and large language model-aided evolutionary search to tackle complex optimization problems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new way to use large language models, which are powerful AI systems trained on vast amounts of text data, to help solve optimization problems. Optimization problems are challenges where the goal is to find the best solution from a set of possible solutions, such as designing the most efficient algorithm or finding the most effective way to allocate resources.
The key idea in this paper is to use the language model as a "hyper-heuristic," which means it can automatically explore and adapt different optimization strategies. Instead of relying on a single, fixed optimization approach, the language model can try out various approaches and learn from the results to improve its performance over time. This "reflective evolution" allows the system to become more efficient and effective at solving the optimization problem.
The researchers show how this approach can outperform traditional optimization methods, particularly on complex problems where the optimal solution is not easily predictable. By leveraging the language model's ability to understand and reason about the problem, the system can explore a wider range of potential solutions and converge on better outcomes.
This research builds on previous work that has explored using large language models to aid in evolutionary optimization [^1] [^2] [^3]. The findings suggest that integrating language models into optimization algorithms can be a powerful way to tackle challenging problems and accelerate the development of more efficient solutions.
[^1]: Evolution, Heuristics and Towards Efficient Automatic Algorithm Design [^2]: Large Language Models as Evolutionary Optimizers [^3]: Large Language Model-Aided Evolutionary Search for Constrained Optimization
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel approach called "ReEvo" (Reflective Evolution), which leverages large language models as hyper-heuristics to automatically explore and adapt optimization strategies. The key components of the ReEvo framework include:
-
Language Model-based Optimization: The researchers use a large language model, specifically GPT-3, as the core optimization engine. The language model is trained to generate optimization strategies, which are then evaluated and refined through an iterative process.
-
Reflective Evolution: The system employs a reflective evolution mechanism, where the language model not only generates optimization strategies but also reflects on the performance of these strategies and uses that feedback to improve its own generation capabilities.
-
Task-Agnostic Optimization: The ReEvo framework is designed to be task-agnostic, meaning it can be applied to a wide range of optimization problems without requiring substantial problem-specific knowledge or feature engineering.
The paper presents experiments on several benchmark optimization problems, including the Traveling Salesman Problem and the Knapsack Problem. The results demonstrate that the ReEvo approach outperforms traditional optimization methods, as well as previous approaches that integrate language models into evolutionary optimization [^1] [^2] [^3].
The researchers attribute the success of ReEvo to the language model's ability to effectively explore and reason about the optimization space, as well as its capacity for reflective learning, which allows the system to continuously improve its optimization strategies.
[^1]: Exploring Improvement in Evolutionary Computation via Large Language Models [^2]: When a Large Language Model Meets Optimization
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to leveraging large language models for optimization tasks, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research:
-
Generalization Capabilities: While the ReEvo framework demonstrates strong performance on the benchmark problems, the researchers note that further investigation is needed to assess its generalization capabilities to a wider range of optimization problems, especially those with unique characteristics or constraints.
-
Computational Efficiency: The use of large language models can be computationally intensive, which may limit the practical applicability of the ReEvo approach, particularly for time-sensitive or resource-constrained optimization problems. Improvements in computational efficiency or the development of more lightweight language models could help address this challenge.
-
Interpretability and Transparency: As with many deep learning-based systems, the inner workings of the ReEvo framework can be opaque, making it challenging to understand and explain the reasoning behind the optimization strategies generated by the language model. Enhancing the interpretability of the system could improve its acceptance and adoption in real-world applications.
-
Ethical Considerations: The use of large language models in optimization tasks raises potential ethical concerns, such as the risk of biased or unintended consequences. Careful consideration of these issues and the development of appropriate safeguards and guidelines will be essential as this technology continues to evolve.
Despite these limitations, the ReEvo approach represents an exciting step forward in the integration of large language models and optimization, suggesting new possibilities for addressing complex problems in a more automated and adaptive manner. As the field continues to progress, addressing these challenges and further exploring the capabilities of language model-based optimization will be crucial.
Conclusion
The paper "ReEvo: Large Language Models as Hyper-Heuristics with Reflective Evolution" presents a novel and promising approach to leveraging the power of large language models for optimization tasks. By using the language model as a hyper-heuristic that can automatically explore and adapt optimization strategies, the ReEvo framework demonstrates the potential for language models to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of optimization processes.
The research builds on previous work in the field of evolutionary optimization with language models and language model-aided evolutionary search, further advancing the integration of these two powerful techniques.
While the paper identifies several areas for improvement and further research, the findings suggest that the integration of large language models into optimization algorithms can be a transformative development, enabling more efficient and adaptable solutions to complex problems. As the field continues to evolve, the insights and approaches presented in this paper could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from engineering and logistics to scientific discovery and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Metaheuristics and Large Language Models Join Forces: Towards an Integrated Optimization Approach
Camilo Chac'on Sartori, Christian Blum, Filippo Bistaffa, Guillem Rodr'iguez Corominas
0
0
Since the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) a couple of years ago, researchers in metaheuristics (MHs) have wondered how to use their power in a beneficial way within their algorithms. This paper introduces a novel approach that leverages LLMs as pattern recognition tools to improve MHs. The resulting hybrid method, tested in the context of a social network-based combinatorial optimization problem, outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches that combine machine learning with MHs regarding the obtained solution quality. By carefully designing prompts, we demonstrate that the output obtained from LLMs can be used as problem knowledge, leading to improved results. Lastly, we acknowledge LLMs' potential drawbacks and limitations and consider it essential to examine them to advance this type of research further.
5/29/2024
Evolution of Heuristics: Towards Efficient Automatic Algorithm Design Using Large Language Mode
Fei Liu, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan, Xi Lin, Fu Luo, Zhenkun Wang, Zhichao Lu, Qingfu Zhang
0
0
Heuristics are widely used for dealing with complex search and optimization problems. However, manual design of heuristics can be often very labour extensive and requires rich working experience and knowledge. This paper proposes Evolution of Heuristic (EoH), a novel evolutionary paradigm that leverages both Large Language Models (LLMs) and Evolutionary Computation (EC) methods for Automatic Heuristic Design (AHD). EoH represents the ideas of heuristics in natural language, termed thoughts. They are then translated into executable codes by LLMs. The evolution of both thoughts and codes in an evolutionary search framework makes it very effective and efficient for generating high-performance heuristics. Experiments on three widely studied combinatorial optimization benchmark problems demonstrate that EoH outperforms commonly used handcrafted heuristics and other recent AHD methods including FunSearch. Particularly, the heuristic produced by EoH with a low computational budget (in terms of the number of queries to LLMs) significantly outperforms widely-used human hand-crafted baseline algorithms for the online bin packing problem.
6/4/2024
💬
Large Language Models as Evolutionary Optimizers
Shengcai Liu, Caishun Chen, Xinghua Qu, Ke Tang, Yew-Soon Ong
0
0
Evolutionary algorithms (EAs) have achieved remarkable success in tackling complex combinatorial optimization problems. However, EAs often demand carefully-designed operators with the aid of domain expertise to achieve satisfactory performance. In this work, we present the first study on large language models (LLMs) as evolutionary combinatorial optimizers. The main advantage is that it requires minimal domain knowledge and human efforts, as well as no additional training of the model. This approach is referred to as LLM-driven EA (LMEA). Specifically, in each generation of the evolutionary search, LMEA instructs the LLM to select parent solutions from current population, and perform crossover and mutation to generate offspring solutions. Then, LMEA evaluates these new solutions and include them into the population for the next generation. LMEA is equipped with a self-adaptation mechanism that controls the temperature of the LLM. This enables it to balance between exploration and exploitation and prevents the search from getting stuck in local optima. We investigate the power of LMEA on the classical traveling salesman problems (TSPs) widely used in combinatorial optimization research. Notably, the results show that LMEA performs competitively to traditional heuristics in finding high-quality solutions on TSP instances with up to 20 nodes. Additionally, we also study the effectiveness of LLM-driven crossover/mutation and the self-adaptation mechanism in evolutionary search. In summary, our results reveal the great potentials of LLMs as evolutionary optimizers for solving combinatorial problems. We hope our research shall inspire future explorations on LLM-driven EAs for complex optimization challenges.
4/29/2024
Towards Next Era of Multi-objective Optimization: Large Language Models as Architects of Evolutionary Operators
Yuxiao Huang, Shenghao Wu, Wenjie Zhang, Jibin Wu, Liang Feng, Kay Chen Tan
0
0
Multi-objective optimization problems (MOPs) are prevalent in various real-world applications, necessitating sophisticated solutions that balance conflicting objectives. Traditional evolutionary algorithms (EAs), while effective, often rely on domain-specific expert knowledge and iterative tuning, which can impede innovation when encountering novel MOPs. Very recently, the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized software engineering by enabling the autonomous development and refinement of programs. Capitalizing on this advancement, we propose a new LLM-based framework for evolving EA operators, designed to address a wide array of MOPs. This framework facilitates the production of EA operators without the extensive demands for expert intervention, thereby streamlining the design process. To validate the efficacy of our approach, we have conducted extensive empirical studies across various categories of MOPs. The results demonstrate the robustness and superior performance of our LLM-evolved operators.
6/14/2024