Learning The Likelihood Test With One-Class Classifiers

Overview

• Considers a problem of deciding which of two probability density functions (PDFs) generated a randomly observed data point
• Assumes knowledge of one PDF (P0) but complete lack of knowledge about the other PDF (P1)
• Explores using one-class classification (OCC) models to mimic the behavior of the likelihood test (LT), which is the optimal decision technique when P0 is known
• Presents a modified stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm for OCC to operate as the LT without needing an artificial negative class dataset
• Analyzes the performance of the one-class least-squares support vector machine (OCLSSVM) and the autoencoder (AE) classifier in this context

Plain English Explanation

Imagine you have two mysterious black boxes, and you want to figure out which one a randomly selected object came from. In one black box, you know exactly how the objects are distributed (the P0 PDF), but in the other, the distribution (the P1 PDF) is completely unknown to you.

The researchers in this paper explore a technique called one-class classification (OCC) as a way to solve this problem. With OCC, you train a model using only the objects from the known black box. This model then tries to mimic the optimal decision technique, called the likelihood test (LT), which would be used if you knew the distribution in the other black box.

The key insight is that by training the OCC model in a specific way, using an "artificial" dataset for the unknown black box, it can learn to behave like the LT. The researchers also develop a new algorithm that allows the OCC model to mimic the LT without needing this artificial dataset.

Additionally, the paper analyzes how well different OCC models, like the one-class least-squares support vector machine and the autoencoder classifier, can perform this task. The findings provide guidance on which models are most suitable for this type of problem, which could be useful in security applications where the attacker's behavior is unknown.

Technical Explanation

The paper considers a problem where an observation is randomly generated from one of two probability density functions (PDFs), P0 or P1. The goal is to design a decision technique to determine which PDF generated the observation.

When the P0 PDF is known, the optimal decision technique is the likelihood test (LT). However, in the scenario explored in this paper, the P1 PDF is completely unknown, while the P0 PDF is either known or a set of samples from it is available.

To address this challenge, the researchers explore using one-class classification (OCC) models to mimic the behavior of the LT. They show that this can be achieved for the multilayer perceptron neural network (NN) and the one-class least-squares support vector machine (OCLSSVM) models when they are trained as two-class classifiers using an artificial dataset for the negative class. This artificial dataset is generated by sampling uniformly over the domain of the positive class dataset and is used only during training.

The researchers also derive a modified stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm that allows the OCC model to operate as the LT without the need for the artificial dataset. Furthermore, they demonstrate that the OCLSSVM with suitable kernels operates as the LT at convergence.

Finally, the paper analyzes the autoencoder (AE) classifier and shows that it generally does not provide the LT behavior, in contrast to the other OCC models explored.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel approach to using one-class classification (OCC) models to mimic the behavior of the likelihood test (LT) when the distribution of one of the two PDFs is completely unknown. This is a practical scenario that could arise in security contexts, where the attacker's behavior is unknown to the legitimate users.

One potential limitation of the research is that it relies on the availability of a set of samples from the known PDF (P0) or the ability to generate them. In real-world scenarios, this assumption may not always hold, and the researchers could explore methods to relax this requirement.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the performance and robustness of the proposed approaches across different types of PDFs and noise levels. Further empirical evaluation in more diverse settings could help establish the broader applicability and limitations of the techniques.

While the paper demonstrates the behavior of the OCLSSVM and the autoencoder classifier, it would be valuable to explore the performance of other OCC models, such as one-class neural networks or isolation forests, to determine the most suitable approaches for this problem.

Finally, the researchers could investigate the practical implications of their findings, particularly in security-related applications, and provide guidance on how the proposed techniques could be deployed and evaluated in real-world scenarios.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative approach to using one-class classification (OCC) models to solve a problem of deciding which of two probability density functions (PDFs) generated a randomly observed data point, when the distribution of one of the PDFs (P1) is completely unknown. The key insight is that by training the OCC models in a specific way, they can be made to mimic the behavior of the optimal likelihood test (LT) decision technique, which is available when the P0 PDF is known.

The researchers demonstrate that the multilayer perceptron neural network and the one-class least-squares support vector machine can be trained to operate as the LT, and they also develop a modified stochastic gradient descent algorithm to achieve this without the need for an artificial negative class dataset. Additionally, the analysis of the autoencoder classifier provides valuable insights into the limitations of certain OCC models in this context.

The findings of this paper could have important implications for security applications, where the attacker's behavior is often unknown to the legitimate users. The techniques presented here offer a promising approach to making optimal decisions in such scenarios, and further research in this direction could lead to more robust and practical solutions.