Neural Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms for Solving Vehicle Routing Problems: A Comprehensive Survey with Perspectives
2406.00415
0
0
Abstract
Although several surveys on Neural Combinatorial Optimization (NCO) solvers specifically designed to solve Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs) have been conducted. These existing surveys did not cover the state-of-the-art (SOTA) NCO solvers emerged recently. More importantly, to provide a comprehensive taxonomy of NCO solvers with up-to-date coverage, based on our thorough review of relevant publications and preprints, we divide all NCO solvers into four distinct categories, namely Learning to Construct, Learning to Improve, Learning to Predict-Once, and Learning to Predict-Multiplicity solvers. Subsequently, we present the inadequacies of the SOTA solvers, including poor generalization, incapability to solve large-scale VRPs, inability to address most types of VRP variants simultaneously, and difficulty in comparing these NCO solvers with the conventional Operations Research algorithms. Simultaneously, we propose promising and viable directions to overcome these inadequacies. In addition, we compare the performance of representative NCO solvers from the Reinforcement, Supervised, and Unsupervised Learning paradigms across both small- and large-scale VRPs. Finally, following the proposed taxonomy, we provide an accompanying web page as a live repository for NCO solvers. Through this survey and the live repository, we hope to make the research community of NCO solvers for VRPs more thriving.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a comprehensive survey of neural combinatorial optimization algorithms for solving vehicle routing problems (VRPs).
- VRPs are a class of optimization problems that involve finding the optimal routes for a fleet of vehicles to service a set of geographically dispersed customers.
- The paper examines various neural network-based approaches that have been developed to tackle VRPs, including multi-task learning for routing problems, prompt learning for generalized vehicle routing, genetic algorithms with neural cost predictors for hierarchical VRPs, instance-conditioned adaptation for large-scale generalization, and towards generalizable neural solvers for VRPs.
Plain English Explanation
Vehicle routing problems are a type of optimization challenge that involve determining the best routes for a fleet of vehicles to service a group of customers located in different places. This paper provides a comprehensive review of various neural network-based approaches that have been developed to tackle these types of problems.
Neural networks are a type of machine learning model that are inspired by the structure and function of the human brain. Researchers have been exploring how neural networks can be used to solve complex optimization problems like vehicle routing, which traditionally have been addressed using more classical optimization techniques.
The paper examines several key neural network-based approaches that have been proposed, including using multi-task learning to leverage insights from related routing problems, employing prompt learning to enable generalization to new problem instances, combining genetic algorithms with neural cost predictors for hierarchical routing problems, using instance-conditioned adaptation to scale up to large-scale problems, and working towards the development of generalizable neural solvers that can handle a wide variety of vehicle routing scenarios.
Each of these approaches has its own unique strengths and limitations, and the paper provides a detailed analysis of the tradeoffs involved. The goal is to help researchers and practitioners better understand the current state of the art in neural combinatorial optimization for vehicle routing and identify promising directions for future work.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing an overview of vehicle routing problems (VRPs) and their importance in logistics and transportation. VRPs involve finding optimal routes for a fleet of vehicles to service a set of geographically dispersed customers, subject to various constraints such as vehicle capacity, time windows, and precedence requirements.
The authors then dive into an extensive review of recent neural combinatorial optimization approaches that have been proposed for solving VRPs. These include:
-
Multi-task learning for routing problems: Leveraging shared representations and knowledge across related routing problems to improve model performance.
-
Prompt learning for generalized vehicle routing: Using language model-based prompts to enable neural networks to adapt to new VRP instances and problem settings.
-
Genetic algorithms with neural cost predictors for hierarchical VRPs: Combining the strengths of genetic algorithms and neural networks to solve complex, hierarchical VRP variants.
-
Instance-conditioned adaptation for large-scale generalization: Developing neural architectures that can quickly adapt to solve new VRP instances, enabling scalability to large-scale problems.
-
Towards generalizable neural solvers for VRPs: Exploring strategies to build neural networks that can handle a wide variety of VRP settings and constraints without requiring extensive retraining.
For each approach, the paper provides a detailed technical description of the underlying algorithms and architectures, as well as an analysis of the experimental results and insights gained from the research.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough and well-researched survey of the state-of-the-art in neural combinatorial optimization for vehicle routing problems. The authors have done an excellent job of covering a diverse range of approaches and highlighting their respective strengths and limitations.
One potential limitation of the survey is that it does not delve deeply into the specific details of the neural network architectures and training procedures used in the reviewed studies. While the high-level descriptions are informative, readers with a strong technical background may wish for more in-depth discussion of the model design choices and hyperparameter tuning.
Additionally, the paper does not fully address the issue of the computational complexity and runtime performance of the neural-based VRP solvers. As these are important practical considerations for real-world deployment, further analysis of the scalability and efficiency of the proposed methods would be valuable.
Finally, the paper could benefit from a more critical examination of the potential biases and limitations of the neural network-based approaches. For instance, the reliance on data-driven learning may make these methods susceptible to biases inherent in the training data, and their performance may degrade in cases where the problem constraints or customer distributions deviate significantly from the training scenarios.
Despite these minor criticisms, the paper remains an excellent resource for researchers and practitioners interested in the application of neural combinatorial optimization to vehicle routing problems. The comprehensive coverage and insightful analysis provide a solid foundation for further exploration and development in this important field.
Conclusion
This survey paper provides a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art in neural combinatorial optimization algorithms for solving vehicle routing problems. The authors have done an excellent job of highlighting the diverse range of approaches that have been proposed, including multi-task learning, prompt learning, genetic algorithms with neural cost predictors, instance-conditioned adaptation, and efforts towards generalizable neural solvers.
The technical explanations of these various methods are detailed and informative, and the critical analysis raises important considerations around computational complexity, scalability, and the potential biases of data-driven approaches. While the paper does not address every aspect of these complex challenges, it serves as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working to advance the field of neural combinatorial optimization for vehicle routing and related optimization problems.
By synthesizing the latest research and providing insightful perspectives, this survey paper helps to chart the path forward for developing more robust, efficient, and generalizable neural-based solvers for real-world vehicle routing scenarios. As the demand for optimization solutions in logistics and transportation continues to grow, the continued progress in this area will be crucial for driving innovation and improving the way goods and services are delivered.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Multi-Task Learning for Routing Problem with Cross-Problem Zero-Shot Generalization
Fei Liu, Xi Lin, Zhenkun Wang, Qingfu Zhang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan
0
0
Vehicle routing problems (VRPs), which can be found in numerous real-world applications, have been an important research topic for several decades. Recently, the neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) approach that leverages a learning-based model to solve VRPs without manual algorithm design has gained substantial attention. However, current NCO methods typically require building one model for each routing problem, which significantly hinders their practical application for real-world industry problems with diverse attributes. In this work, we make the first attempt to tackle the crucial challenge of cross-problem generalization. In particular, we formulate VRPs as different combinations of a set of shared underlying attributes and solve them simultaneously via a single model through attribute composition. In this way, our proposed model can successfully solve VRPs with unseen attribute combinations in a zero-shot generalization manner. Extensive experiments are conducted on eleven VRP variants, benchmark datasets, and industry logistic scenarios. The results show that the unified model demonstrates superior performance in the eleven VRPs, reducing the average gap to around 5% from over 20% in the existing approach and achieving a significant performance boost on benchmark datasets as well as a real-world logistics application. The source code is included in https://github.com/FeiLiu36/MTNCO.
4/15/2024
🌿
Prompt Learning for Generalized Vehicle Routing
Fei Liu, Xi Lin, Weiduo Liao, Zhenkun Wang, Qingfu Zhang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan
0
0
Neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) is a promising learning-based approach to solving various vehicle routing problems without much manual algorithm design. However, the current NCO methods mainly focus on the in-distribution performance, while the real-world problem instances usually come from different distributions. A costly fine-tuning approach or generalized model retraining from scratch could be needed to tackle the out-of-distribution instances. Unlike the existing methods, this work investigates an efficient prompt learning approach in NCO for cross-distribution adaptation. To be concrete, we propose a novel prompt learning method to facilitate fast zero-shot adaptation of a pre-trained model to solve routing problem instances from different distributions. The proposed model learns a set of prompts among various distributions and then selects the best-matched one to prompt a pre-trained attention model for each problem instance. Extensive experiments show that the proposed prompt learning approach facilitates the fast adaptation of pre-trained routing models. It also outperforms existing generalized models on both in-distribution prediction and zero-shot generalization to a diverse set of new tasks. Our code implementation is available online https://github.com/FeiLiu36/PromptVRP.
5/22/2024
🧠
Genetic Algorithms with Neural Cost Predictor for Solving Hierarchical Vehicle Routing Problems
Abhay Sobhanan, Junyoung Park, Jinkyoo Park, Changhyun Kwon
0
0
When vehicle routing decisions are intertwined with higher-level decisions, the resulting optimization problems pose significant challenges for computation. Examples are the multi-depot vehicle routing problem (MDVRP), where customers are assigned to depots before delivery, and the capacitated location routing problem (CLRP), where the locations of depots should be determined first. A simple and straightforward approach for such hierarchical problems would be to separate the higher-level decisions from the complicated vehicle routing decisions. For each higher-level decision candidate, we may evaluate the underlying vehicle routing problems to assess the candidate. As this approach requires solving vehicle routing problems multiple times, it has been regarded as impractical in most cases. We propose a novel deep-learning-based approach called Genetic Algorithm with Neural Cost Predictor (GANCP) to tackle the challenge and simplify algorithm developments. For each higher-level decision candidate, we predict the objective function values of the underlying vehicle routing problems using a pre-trained graph neural network without actually solving the routing problems. In particular, our proposed neural network learns the objective values of the HGS-CVRP open-source package that solves capacitated vehicle routing problems. Our numerical experiments show that this simplified approach is effective and efficient in generating high-quality solutions for both MDVRP and CLRP and has the potential to expedite algorithm developments for complicated hierarchical problems. We provide computational results evaluated in the standard benchmark instances used in the literature.
5/7/2024
Instance-Conditioned Adaptation for Large-scale Generalization of Neural Combinatorial Optimization
Changliang Zhou, Xi Lin, Zhenkun Wang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan, Qingfu Zhang
0
0
The neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) approach has shown great potential for solving routing problems without the requirement of expert knowledge. However, existing constructive NCO methods cannot directly solve large-scale instances, which significantly limits their application prospects. To address these crucial shortcomings, this work proposes a novel Instance-Conditioned Adaptation Model (ICAM) for better large-scale generalization of neural combinatorial optimization. In particular, we design a powerful yet lightweight instance-conditioned adaptation module for the NCO model to generate better solutions for instances across different scales. In addition, we develop an efficient three-stage reinforcement learning-based training scheme that enables the model to learn cross-scale features without any labeled optimal solution. Experimental results show that our proposed method is capable of obtaining excellent results with a very fast inference time in solving Traveling Salesman Problems (TSPs) and Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problems (CVRPs) across different scales. To the best of our knowledge, our model achieves state-of-the-art performance among all RL-based constructive methods for TSP and CVRP with up to 1,000 nodes.
5/6/2024