Neurosymbolic Grounding for Compositional World Models
2310.12690
0
0
Abstract
We introduce Cosmos, a framework for object-centric world modeling that is designed for compositional generalization (CompGen), i.e., high performance on unseen input scenes obtained through the composition of known visual atoms. The central insight behind Cosmos is the use of a novel form of neurosymbolic grounding. Specifically, the framework introduces two new tools: (i) neurosymbolic scene encodings, which represent each entity in a scene using a real vector computed using a neural encoder, as well as a vector of composable symbols describing attributes of the entity, and (ii) a neurosymbolic attention mechanism that binds these entities to learned rules of interaction. Cosmos is end-to-end differentiable; also, unlike traditional neurosymbolic methods that require representations to be manually mapped to symbols, it computes an entity's symbolic attributes using vision-language foundation models. Through an evaluation that considers two different forms of CompGen on an established blocks-pushing domain, we show that the framework establishes a new state-of-the-art for CompGen in world modeling. Artifacts are available at: https://trishullab.github.io/cosmos-web/
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a neurosymbolic approach for building compositional world models, which can help AI systems better understand and interact with their environments.
- The key idea is to combine neural networks and symbolic reasoning to create models that can flexibly represent and reason about complex, structured scenes and objects.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmark tasks, showing that it outperforms purely neural models in tasks that require compositional and relational reasoning.
Plain English Explanation
The paper proposes a new way for AI systems to build models of the world around them. Instead of using only neural networks, which can struggle with complex, structured information, the authors combine neural networks with symbolic reasoning.
The basic idea is to have the neural network learn to represent different objects, parts, and relationships in a scene using a set of discrete "slots." These slots act as a middle ground between the raw sensor inputs and a higher-level symbolic understanding of the scene.
By having this slotted, compositional representation, the AI system can then use symbolic reasoning to flexibly combine and recombine these elements to understand more complex scenes and scenarios. This allows the system to reason in a more systematic and compositional way, similar to how humans understand the world.
The authors show that this neurosymbolic approach outperforms pure neural models on tasks that require this kind of compositional and relational reasoning, like understanding the interactions between different objects in a scene.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the use of a "slot-based autoencoder" architecture. This consists of a neural network that takes in a raw sensory input (e.g. an image) and learns to represent it using a set of discrete "slots."
Each slot corresponds to a particular object, part, or relationship in the scene. The network learns to associate the visual features of that element with its corresponding slot in an unsupervised way. This results in a compositional, slotted representation of the scene.
The authors then use this slotted representation as the basis for symbolic reasoning. By having a discrete, structured representation of the scene elements, the system can apply logical rules and operations to reason about the relationships and interactions between them.
This neurosymbolic approach allows the model to overcome some of the limitations of pure neural networks, which can struggle with compositional, relational reasoning. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on a range of benchmark tasks, showing that it outperforms neural-only models.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. For example, the symbolic reasoning component is still relatively simple, and the system may struggle to scale to very complex, open-ended environments. Additionally, the unsupervised learning of the slot-based representation relies on strong inductive biases, which may limit its generalization to novel scenarios.
Further research could explore ways to make the symbolic reasoning more flexible and powerful, or to learn the slotted representation in a more data-driven way. There may also be opportunities to combine this neurosymbolic approach with other techniques, such as neuro-symbolic distillation, to further enhance its capabilities.
Overall, this paper represents an interesting step towards more compositional and relational world models for AI systems. By bridging the gap between neural and symbolic approaches, it offers a promising direction for building AI agents that can more flexibly and systematically understand and interact with their environments.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a neurosymbolic approach for building compositional world models, which combines neural networks and symbolic reasoning to create more flexible and systematic representations of complex scenes and objects.
The key innovation is the use of a slot-based autoencoder architecture, which learns to represent visual inputs using a set of discrete slots corresponding to different elements in the scene. This slotted representation then serves as the basis for symbolic reasoning, allowing the model to reason about the relationships and interactions between the scene elements.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach on several benchmark tasks, showing that it outperforms pure neural models in scenarios that require compositional and relational reasoning. While the approach still has some limitations, it represents an important step towards more sophisticated world models for AI systems, with potential applications in areas like robotics, navigation, and scene understanding.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
COMBO: Compositional World Models for Embodied Multi-Agent Cooperation
Hongxin Zhang, Zeyuan Wang, Qiushi Lyu, Zheyuan Zhang, Sunli Chen, Tianmin Shu, Yilun Du, Chuang Gan
0
0
In this paper, we investigate the problem of embodied multi-agent cooperation, where decentralized agents must cooperate given only partial egocentric views of the world. To effectively plan in this setting, in contrast to learning world dynamics in a single-agent scenario, we must simulate world dynamics conditioned on an arbitrary number of agents' actions given only partial egocentric visual observations of the world. To address this issue of partial observability, we first train generative models to estimate the overall world state given partial egocentric observations. To enable accurate simulation of multiple sets of actions on this world state, we then propose to learn a compositional world model for multi-agent cooperation by factorizing the naturally composable joint actions of multiple agents and compositionally generating the video. By leveraging this compositional world model, in combination with Vision Language Models to infer the actions of other agents, we can use a tree search procedure to integrate these modules and facilitate online cooperative planning. To evaluate the efficacy of our methods, we create two challenging embodied multi-agent long-horizon cooperation tasks using the ThreeDWorld simulator and conduct experiments with 2-4 agents. The results show our compositional world model is effective and the framework enables the embodied agents to cooperate efficiently with different agents across various tasks and an arbitrary number of agents, showing the promising future of our proposed framework. More videos can be found at https://vis-www.cs.umass.edu/combo/.
4/17/2024
✅
GraphDreamer: Compositional 3D Scene Synthesis from Scene Graphs
Gege Gao, Weiyang Liu, Anpei Chen, Andreas Geiger, Bernhard Scholkopf
0
0
As pretrained text-to-image diffusion models become increasingly powerful, recent efforts have been made to distill knowledge from these text-to-image pretrained models for optimizing a text-guided 3D model. Most of the existing methods generate a holistic 3D model from a plain text input. This can be problematic when the text describes a complex scene with multiple objects, because the vectorized text embeddings are inherently unable to capture a complex description with multiple entities and relationships. Holistic 3D modeling of the entire scene further prevents accurate grounding of text entities and concepts. To address this limitation, we propose GraphDreamer, a novel framework to generate compositional 3D scenes from scene graphs, where objects are represented as nodes and their interactions as edges. By exploiting node and edge information in scene graphs, our method makes better use of the pretrained text-to-image diffusion model and is able to fully disentangle different objects without image-level supervision. To facilitate modeling of object-wise relationships, we use signed distance fields as representation and impose a constraint to avoid inter-penetration of objects. To avoid manual scene graph creation, we design a text prompt for ChatGPT to generate scene graphs based on text inputs. We conduct both qualitative and quantitative experiments to validate the effectiveness of GraphDreamer in generating high-fidelity compositional 3D scenes with disentangled object entities.
6/12/2024
🔍
What makes Models Compositional? A Theoretical View: With Supplement
Parikshit Ram, Tim Klinger, Alexander G. Gray
0
0
Compositionality is thought to be a key component of language, and various compositional benchmarks have been developed to empirically probe the compositional generalization of existing sequence processing models. These benchmarks often highlight failures of existing models, but it is not clear why these models fail in this way. In this paper, we seek to theoretically understand the role the compositional structure of the models plays in these failures and how this structure relates to their expressivity and sample complexity. We propose a general neuro-symbolic definition of compositional functions and their compositional complexity. We then show how various existing general and special purpose sequence processing models (such as recurrent, convolution and attention-based ones) fit this definition and use it to analyze their compositional complexity. Finally, we provide theoretical guarantees for the expressivity and systematic generalization of compositional models that explicitly depend on our proposed definition and highlighting factors which drive poor empirical performance.
5/7/2024
RoboDreamer: Learning Compositional World Models for Robot Imagination
Siyuan Zhou, Yilun Du, Jiaben Chen, Yandong Li, Dit-Yan Yeung, Chuang Gan
0
0
Text-to-video models have demonstrated substantial potential in robotic decision-making, enabling the imagination of realistic plans of future actions as well as accurate environment simulation. However, one major issue in such models is generalization -- models are limited to synthesizing videos subject to language instructions similar to those seen at training time. This is heavily limiting in decision-making, where we seek a powerful world model to synthesize plans of unseen combinations of objects and actions in order to solve previously unseen tasks in new environments. To resolve this issue, we introduce RoboDreamer, an innovative approach for learning a compositional world model by factorizing the video generation. We leverage the natural compositionality of language to parse instructions into a set of lower-level primitives, which we condition a set of models on to generate videos. We illustrate how this factorization naturally enables compositional generalization, by allowing us to formulate a new natural language instruction as a combination of previously seen components. We further show how such a factorization enables us to add additional multimodal goals, allowing us to specify a video we wish to generate given both natural language instructions and a goal image. Our approach can successfully synthesize video plans on unseen goals in the RT-X, enables successful robot execution in simulation, and substantially outperforms monolithic baseline approaches to video generation.
4/19/2024