Non-ergodicity in reinforcement learning: robustness via ergodicity transformations
2310.11335
0
0
🏅
Abstract
Envisioned application areas for reinforcement learning (RL) include autonomous driving, precision agriculture, and finance, which all require RL agents to make decisions in the real world. A significant challenge hindering the adoption of RL methods in these domains is the non-robustness of conventional algorithms. In this paper, we argue that a fundamental issue contributing to this lack of robustness lies in the focus on the expected value of the return as the sole ``correct'' optimization objective. The expected value is the average over the statistical ensemble of infinitely many trajectories. For non-ergodic returns, this average differs from the average over a single but infinitely long trajectory. Consequently, optimizing the expected value can lead to policies that yield exceptionally high returns with probability zero but almost surely result in catastrophic outcomes. This problem can be circumvented by transforming the time series of collected returns into one with ergodic increments. This transformation enables learning robust policies by optimizing the long-term return for individual agents rather than the average across infinitely many trajectories. We propose an algorithm for learning ergodicity transformations from data and demonstrate its effectiveness in an instructive, non-ergodic environment and on standard RL benchmarks.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper argues that the traditional focus on optimizing the expected value of returns in reinforcement learning (RL) can lead to non-robust policies that risk catastrophic outcomes.
- The authors propose transforming the collected returns into a time series with ergodic increments, which enables learning robust policies by optimizing the long-term return for individual agents rather than the average across many trajectories.
- The proposed algorithm learns the ergodicity transformation from data and demonstrates its effectiveness in a non-ergodic environment and on standard RL benchmarks.
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement learning (RL) is a type of machine learning that enables agents to make decisions in dynamic environments by learning from the consequences of their actions. Envisioned application areas for RL include autonomous driving, precision agriculture, and finance, which all require RL agents to make decisions in the real world.
A significant challenge hindering the adoption of RL methods in these domains is the non-robustness of conventional algorithms. The authors argue that a fundamental issue contributing to this lack of robustness lies in the focus on the expected value of the return as the sole "correct" optimization objective.
The expected value is the average over the statistical ensemble of infinitely many trajectories. For non-ergodic returns, this average differs from the average over a single but infinitely long trajectory. Consequently, optimizing the expected value can lead to policies that yield exceptionally high returns with probability zero but almost surely result in catastrophic outcomes.
To address this problem, the authors propose transforming the time series of collected returns into one with ergodic increments. This transformation enables learning robust policies by optimizing the long-term return for individual agents rather than the average across infinitely many trajectories. The authors' algorithm learns the ergodicity transformation from data and demonstrates its effectiveness in an instructive, non-ergodic environment and on standard RL benchmarks.
Technical Explanation
The authors argue that a fundamental issue contributing to the non-robustness of conventional RL algorithms is the focus on optimizing the expected value of the return as the sole objective. The expected value is the average over the statistical ensemble of infinitely many trajectories. However, for non-ergodic returns, this average differs from the average over a single but infinitely long trajectory.
Consequently, optimizing the expected value can lead to policies that yield exceptionally high returns with probability zero but almost surely result in catastrophic outcomes. This problem can be circumvented by transforming the time series of collected returns into one with ergodic increments, which enables learning robust policies by optimizing the long-term return for individual agents rather than the average across infinitely many trajectories.
The authors propose an algorithm for learning the ergodicity transformation from data. This algorithm is evaluated in an instructive, non-ergodic environment and on standard RL benchmarks, demonstrating its effectiveness in learning robust policies.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge that their proposed approach assumes the existence of an ergodicity transformation and that finding such a transformation may be challenging in practice. They suggest that further research is needed to address this limitation, potentially by developing methods for directly optimizing the long-term return without the need for an explicit transformation.
Additionally, the authors focus on the non-robustness of conventional RL algorithms due to the expected value optimization objective, but they do not address other potential sources of non-robustness, such as the sensitivity to environmental stochasticity or the influence of function approximation errors. Further research may be needed to develop a more comprehensive understanding of the factors contributing to the non-robustness of RL systems in real-world applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to addressing the non-robustness of conventional reinforcement learning algorithms by transforming the collected returns into a time series with ergodic increments. This transformation enables learning robust policies that optimize the long-term return for individual agents, rather than the average across infinitely many trajectories.
The proposed algorithm demonstrates promising results in an instructive, non-ergodic environment and on standard RL benchmarks. While the authors acknowledge the limitations of their approach, this research represents an important step towards developing more reliable and robust reinforcement learning systems for real-world applications, such as autonomous driving, precision agriculture, and finance.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Sample-Efficient Robust Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning in the Face of Environmental Uncertainty
Laixi Shi, Eric Mazumdar, Yuejie Chi, Adam Wierman
0
0
To overcome the sim-to-real gap in reinforcement learning (RL), learned policies must maintain robustness against environmental uncertainties. While robust RL has been widely studied in single-agent regimes, in multi-agent environments, the problem remains understudied -- despite the fact that the problems posed by environmental uncertainties are often exacerbated by strategic interactions. This work focuses on learning in distributionally robust Markov games (RMGs), a robust variant of standard Markov games, wherein each agent aims to learn a policy that maximizes its own worst-case performance when the deployed environment deviates within its own prescribed uncertainty set. This results in a set of robust equilibrium strategies for all agents that align with classic notions of game-theoretic equilibria. Assuming a non-adaptive sampling mechanism from a generative model, we propose a sample-efficient model-based algorithm (DRNVI) with finite-sample complexity guarantees for learning robust variants of various notions of game-theoretic equilibria. We also establish an information-theoretic lower bound for solving RMGs, which confirms the near-optimal sample complexity of DRNVI with respect to problem-dependent factors such as the size of the state space, the target accuracy, and the horizon length.
5/10/2024
🏅
Offline Reinforcement Learning from Datasets with Structured Non-Stationarity
Johannes Ackermann, Takayuki Osa, Masashi Sugiyama
0
0
Current Reinforcement Learning (RL) is often limited by the large amount of data needed to learn a successful policy. Offline RL aims to solve this issue by using transitions collected by a different behavior policy. We address a novel Offline RL problem setting in which, while collecting the dataset, the transition and reward functions gradually change between episodes but stay constant within each episode. We propose a method based on Contrastive Predictive Coding that identifies this non-stationarity in the offline dataset, accounts for it when training a policy, and predicts it during evaluation. We analyze our proposed method and show that it performs well in simple continuous control tasks and challenging, high-dimensional locomotion tasks. We show that our method often achieves the oracle performance and performs better than baselines.
5/29/2024
Stein Variational Ergodic Search
Darrick Lee, Cameron Lerch, Fabio Ramos, Ian Abraham
0
0
Exploration requires that robots reason about numerous ways to cover a space in response to dynamically changing conditions. However, in continuous domains there are potentially infinitely many options for robots to explore which can prove computationally challenging. How then should a robot efficiently optimize and choose exploration strategies to adopt? In this work, we explore this question through the use of variational inference to efficiently solve for distributions of coverage trajectories. Our approach leverages ergodic search methods to optimize coverage trajectories in continuous time and space. In order to reason about distributions of trajectories, we formulate ergodic search as a probabilistic inference problem. We propose to leverage Stein variational methods to approximate a posterior distribution over ergodic trajectories through parallel computation. As a result, it becomes possible to efficiently optimize distributions of feasible coverage trajectories for which robots can adapt exploration. We demonstrate that the proposed Stein variational ergodic search approach facilitates efficient identification of multiple coverage strategies and show online adaptation in a model-predictive control formulation. Simulated and physical experiments demonstrate adaptability and diversity in exploration strategies online.
6/18/2024
🔍
NeoRL: Efficient Exploration for Nonepisodic RL
Bhavya Sukhija, Lenart Treven, Florian Dorfler, Stelian Coros, Andreas Krause
0
0
We study the problem of nonepisodic reinforcement learning (RL) for nonlinear dynamical systems, where the system dynamics are unknown and the RL agent has to learn from a single trajectory, i.e., without resets. We propose Nonepisodic Optimistic RL (NeoRL), an approach based on the principle of optimism in the face of uncertainty. NeoRL uses well-calibrated probabilistic models and plans optimistically w.r.t. the epistemic uncertainty about the unknown dynamics. Under continuity and bounded energy assumptions on the system, we provide a first-of-its-kind regret bound of $setO(beta_T sqrt{T Gamma_T})$ for general nonlinear systems with Gaussian process dynamics. We compare NeoRL to other baselines on several deep RL environments and empirically demonstrate that NeoRL achieves the optimal average cost while incurring the least regret.
6/5/2024