Online Resource Allocation with Non-Stationary Customers
2401.16945
0
0
📈
Abstract
We propose a novel algorithm for online resource allocation with non-stationary customer arrivals and unknown click-through rates. We assume multiple types of customers arrive in a nonstationary stochastic fashion, with unknown arrival rates in each period, and that customers' click-through rates are unknown and can only be learned online. By leveraging results from the stochastic contextual bandit with knapsack and online matching with adversarial arrivals, we develop an online scheme to allocate the resources to nonstationary customers. We prove that under mild conditions, our scheme achieves a ``best-of-both-world'' result: the scheme has a sublinear regret when the customer arrivals are near-stationary, and enjoys an optimal competitive ratio under general (non-stationary) customer arrival distributions. Finally, we conduct extensive numerical experiments to show our approach generates near-optimal revenues for all different customer scenarios.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a novel algorithm for online resource allocation with non-stationary customer arrivals and unknown click-through rates
- Assumes multiple types of customers arrive in a non-stationary stochastic fashion, with unknown arrival rates and click-through rates
- Leverages results from the stochastic contextual bandit with knapsack and online matching with adversarial arrivals to develop an online scheme for allocating resources
- Achieves sublinear regret when customer arrivals are near-stationary and optimal competitive ratio under general non-stationary distributions
- Extensive numerical experiments show near-optimal revenues for different customer scenarios
Plain English Explanation
This research proposes a new way to allocate resources, like ad space or product inventory, to customers in an online setting. The key challenges are that customer arrivals are unpredictable and changing over time, and the customers' likelihood of engaging with the resources (click-through rates) is unknown.
To address this, the researchers developed an algorithm that leverages insights from related problems, like the stochastic contextual bandit with knapsack and online matching with adversarial arrivals. This allows them to adaptively allocate resources to customers, learning their click-through rates over time.
The algorithm has two key properties. First, it performs well when customer arrivals are relatively stable over time, achieving a sublinear regret (i.e., the difference between the algorithm's performance and the optimal offline solution shrinks over time). Second, it performs optimally even when customer arrivals are highly unpredictable, maintaining a competitive ratio (the ratio between the algorithm's performance and the optimal offline solution) that is as good as possible.
Through extensive numerical experiments, the researchers show that their approach can generate near-optimal revenues for a variety of customer scenarios, making it a promising technique for real-world resource allocation problems with uncertain and changing demand.
Technical Explanation
The core challenge addressed in this paper is online resource allocation with non-stationary customer arrivals and unknown click-through rates. Specifically, the researchers assume that multiple types of customers arrive in a non-stationary stochastic fashion, with unknown arrival rates in each period, and that customers' click-through rates are also unknown and can only be learned over time.
To tackle this problem, the researchers leverage insights from the stochastic contextual bandit with knapsack and online matching with adversarial arrivals problems. They develop an online scheme that adaptively allocates resources to customers, learning their click-through rates over time.
The key theoretical results are as follows:
-
Sublinear Regret for Near-Stationary Arrivals: When customer arrivals are relatively stable over time, the proposed algorithm achieves a sublinear regret, meaning the difference between the algorithm's performance and the optimal offline solution shrinks over time.
-
Optimal Competitive Ratio for General Arrivals: Even when customer arrivals are highly unpredictable, the algorithm maintains an optimal competitive ratio, ensuring its performance is as good as possible compared to the optimal offline solution.
The researchers also conduct extensive numerical experiments, demonstrating that their approach can generate near-optimal revenues for a variety of customer scenarios, including both near-stationary and highly non-stationary arrivals.
Critical Analysis
The researchers have addressed an important problem in online resource allocation, where customer arrivals are uncertain and their engagement with the resources is unknown. The proposed algorithm is theoretically well-founded, drawing on insights from related problems, and the empirical results are promising.
However, the paper does not address several potential limitations and areas for further research. For example, the assumption of known customer types may not hold in real-world scenarios, and the algorithm's performance in the face of unknown or changing customer types is not explored. Additionally, the researchers do not consider the potential impact of strategic customer behavior, where customers may adapt their arrival patterns or click-through rates in response to the allocation algorithm.
Furthermore, the paper could have provided a more in-depth discussion of the practical implications and challenges of implementing the proposed algorithm in real-world settings, such as the computational complexity, the need for accurate arrival rate and click-through rate estimation, and the potential trade-offs between exploration and exploitation.
Despite these limitations, the research represents an important step forward in the field of online resource allocation, and the proposed algorithm could be a valuable tool for companies and organizations facing similar challenges. By encouraging readers to think critically about the research and its potential applications, the authors can help drive further advancements in this area.
Conclusion
This paper proposes a novel algorithm for online resource allocation in the face of non-stationary customer arrivals and unknown click-through rates. By leveraging insights from related problems, the researchers have developed an adaptive scheme that can achieve sublinear regret when customer arrivals are near-stationary and an optimal competitive ratio under more general non-stationary conditions.
The extensive numerical experiments demonstrate the algorithm's ability to generate near-optimal revenues across a variety of customer scenarios, highlighting its potential for real-world applications. While the paper does not address all the potential limitations and challenges, it represents an important contribution to the field of online resource allocation and could inspire further research and development in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Online Optimization for Randomized Network Resource Allocation with Long-Term Constraints
Ahmed Sid-Ali, Ioannis Lambadaris, Yiqiang Q. Zhao, Gennady Shaikhet, Shima Kheradmand
0
0
In this paper, we study an optimal online resource reservation problem in a simple communication network. The network is composed of two compute nodes linked by a local communication link. The system operates in discrete time; at each time slot, the administrator reserves resources for servers before the actual job requests are known. A cost is incurred for the reservations made. Then, after the client requests are observed, jobs may be transferred from one server to the other to best accommodate the demands by incurring an additional transport cost. If certain job requests cannot be satisfied, there is a violation that engenders a cost to pay for each of the blocked jobs. The goal is to minimize the overall reservation cost over finite horizons while maintaining the cumulative violation and transport costs under a certain budget limit. To study this problem, we first formalize it as a repeated game against nature where the reservations are drawn randomly according to a sequence of probability distributions that are derived from an online optimization problem over the space of allowable reservations. We then propose an online saddle-point algorithm for which we present an upper bound for the associated K-benchmark regret together with an upper bound for the cumulative constraint violations. Finally, we present numerical experiments where we compare the performance of our algorithm with those of simple deterministic resource allocation policies.
4/4/2024
Best of Many in Both Worlds: Online Resource Allocation with Predictions under Unknown Arrival Model
Lin An, Andrew A. Li, Benjamin Moseley, Gabriel Visotsky
0
0
Online decision-makers often obtain predictions on future variables, such as arrivals, demands, inventories, and so on. These predictions can be generated from simple forecasting algorithms for univariate time-series, all the way to state-of-the-art machine learning models that leverage multiple time-series and additional feature information. However, the prediction accuracy is unknown to decision-makers a priori, hence blindly following the predictions can be harmful. In this paper, we address this problem by developing algorithms that utilize predictions in a manner that is robust to the unknown prediction accuracy. We consider the Online Resource Allocation Problem, a generic model for online decision-making, in which a limited amount of resources may be used to satisfy a sequence of arriving requests. Prior work has characterized the best achievable performances when the arrivals are either generated stochastically (i.i.d.) or completely adversarially, and shown that algorithms exist which match these bounds under both arrival models, without ``knowing'' the underlying model. To this backdrop, we introduce predictions in the form of shadow prices on each type of resource. Prediction accuracy is naturally defined to be the distance between the predictions and the actual shadow prices. We tightly characterize, via a formal lower bound, the extent to which any algorithm can optimally leverage predictions (that is, to ``follow'' the predictions when accurate, and ``ignore'' them when inaccurate) without knowing the prediction accuracy or the underlying arrival model. Our main contribution is then an algorithm which achieves this lower bound. Finally, we empirically validate our algorithm with a large-scale experiment on real data from the retailer H&M.
6/26/2024
Exponentially Weighted Algorithm for Online Network Resource Allocation with Long-Term Constraints
Ahmed Sid-Ali, Ioannis Lambadaris, Yiqiang Q. Zhao, Gennady Shaikhet, Amirhossein Asgharnia
0
0
This paper studies an online optimal resource reservation problem in communication networks with job transfers where the goal is to minimize the reservation cost while maintaining the blocking cost under a certain budget limit. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel algorithm based on a randomized exponentially weighted method that encompasses long-term constraints. We then analyze the performance of our algorithm by establishing an upper bound for the associated regret and the cumulative constraint violations. Finally, we present numerical experiments where we compare the performance of our algorithm with those of reinforcement learning where we show that our algorithm surpasses it.
5/7/2024
Online Local False Discovery Rate Control: A Resource Allocation Approach
Ruicheng Ao, Hongyu Chen, David Simchi-Levi, Feng Zhu
0
0
We consider the problem of sequentially conducting multiple experiments where each experiment corresponds to a hypothesis testing task. At each time point, the experimenter must make an irrevocable decision of whether to reject the null hypothesis (or equivalently claim a discovery) before the next experimental result arrives. The goal is to maximize the number of discoveries while maintaining a low error rate at all time points measured by local False Discovery Rate (FDR). We formulate the problem as an online knapsack problem with exogenous random budget replenishment. We start with general arrival distributions and show that a simple policy achieves a $O(sqrt{T})$ regret. We complement the result by showing that such regret rate is in general not improvable. We then shift our focus to discrete arrival distributions. We find that many existing re-solving heuristics in the online resource allocation literature, albeit achieve bounded loss in canonical settings, may incur a $Omega(sqrt{T})$ or even a $Omega(T)$ regret. With the observation that canonical policies tend to be too optimistic and over claim discoveries, we propose a novel policy that incorporates budget safety buffers. It turns out that a little more safety can greatly enhance efficiency -- small additional logarithmic buffers suffice to reduce the regret from $Omega(sqrt{T})$ or even $Omega(T)$ to $O(ln^2 T)$. From a practical perspective, we extend the policy to the scenario with continuous arrival distributions as well as time-dependent information structures. We conduct both synthetic experiments and empirical applications on a time series data from New York City taxi passengers to validate the performance of our proposed policies. Our results emphasize how effective policies should be designed in online resource allocation problems with exogenous budget replenishment.
4/3/2024