Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Medical Image Analysis: The Missed Opportunity
2305.08252
0
0
š¼ļø
Abstract
Foundation models have significantly advanced medical image analysis through the pre-train fine-tune paradigm. Among various fine-tuning algorithms, Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) is increasingly utilized for knowledge transfer across diverse tasks, including vision-language and text-to-image generation. However, its application in medical image analysis is relatively unexplored due to the lack of a structured benchmark for evaluating PEFT methods. This study fills this gap by evaluating 17 distinct PEFT algorithms across convolutional and transformer-based networks on image classification and text-to-image generation tasks using six medical datasets of varying size, modality, and complexity. Through a battery of over 700 controlled experiments, our findings demonstrate PEFT's effectiveness, particularly in low data regimes common in medical imaging, with performance gains of up to 22% in discriminative and generative tasks. These recommendations can assist the community in incorporating PEFT into their workflows and facilitate fair comparisons of future PEFT methods, ensuring alignment with advancements in other areas of machine learning and AI.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This study evaluates 17 different Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) algorithms across both convolutional and transformer-based neural networks.
- The evaluation is performed on image classification and text-to-image generation tasks using six medical datasets of varying size, modality, and complexity.
- The study aims to fill the gap in the literature regarding the application of PEFT methods in medical image analysis, which has been relatively unexplored.
Plain English Explanation
Foundation models have significantly advanced the field of medical image analysis through a technique called pre-train fine-tune. This means that the models are first trained on a large, general dataset, and then "fine-tuned" on a smaller, more specific dataset.
One type of fine-tuning algorithm is called Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT). PEFT is becoming increasingly popular for transferring knowledge across different tasks, like vision-language and text-to-image generation. However, its use in medical image analysis has not been well-studied.
This study aims to change that. The researchers evaluated 17 different PEFT algorithms on medical image classification and text-to-image generation tasks, using six medical datasets of varying size, type, and complexity. They ran over 700 experiments to see how well these PEFT methods perform, especially in situations where there is limited data, which is common in medical imaging.
The results show that PEFT can be very effective in medical image analysis, with performance gains of up to 22% in both discriminative (classification) and generative (text-to-image) tasks. These findings can help researchers and practitioners incorporate PEFT into their workflows and ensure fair comparisons of future PEFT methods as the field continues to advance.
Technical Explanation
The researchers evaluated 17 distinct PEFT algorithms across both convolutional and transformer-based neural network architectures. They tested these algorithms on image classification and text-to-image generation tasks using six medical datasets of varying size, modality, and complexity.
For the image classification tasks, the researchers used four medical imaging datasets: CheXpert, [SIIM-ISIC Melanoma Classification], [RSNA Pneumonia Detection], and [PatchCamelyon]. For the text-to-image generation tasks, they used two medical datasets: [ROCO] and [PEIR GROSS].
Through a battery of over 700 controlled experiments, the study demonstrates the effectiveness of PEFT, particularly in low data regimes common in medical imaging. The researchers report performance gains of up to 22% in both discriminative and generative tasks when using PEFT methods compared to traditional fine-tuning approaches.
The study also introduces novel PEFT approaches, such as Sparsity and Hybridity Inspired Visual PEFT and Unlocking PEFT for Low-Resource Settings, which demonstrate promising results in the medical imaging domain.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations of the study, including the need for further investigation into the generalization of PEFT methods across a wider range of medical imaging tasks and datasets. Additionally, the study does not explore the computational and memory efficiency of the PEFT algorithms, which are important factors in real-world medical applications.
While the study provides a comprehensive evaluation of PEFT methods in medical imaging, there may be other factors, such as data quality, preprocessing, and model architectures, that could significantly impact the performance of these algorithms. Further research is needed to understand the interplay between PEFT and these other important considerations.
Overall, the study represents a valuable contribution to the field of medical image analysis by establishing a structured benchmark for evaluating PEFT methods and demonstrating their potential benefits. However, as with any research, it is important for readers to think critically about the findings and their implications, and to consider the limitations and areas for further exploration.
Conclusion
This study provides a comprehensive evaluation of 17 Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) algorithms across convolutional and transformer-based networks for medical image classification and text-to-image generation tasks. The findings demonstrate the effectiveness of PEFT, particularly in low-data regimes common in medical imaging, with performance gains of up to 22%.
These results can assist the research community in incorporating PEFT into their workflows and facilitate fair comparisons of future PEFT methods, ensuring alignment with advancements in other areas of machine learning and AI. The study also introduces novel PEFT approaches that show promise for medical imaging applications.
Overall, this work represents an important step in advancing the application of foundation models and PEFT techniques in the medical imaging domain, paving the way for more efficient and effective use of these powerful tools in clinical settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning: A Comprehensive Analysis Across Applications
Charith Chandra Sai Balne, Sreyoshi Bhaduri, Tamoghna Roy, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
0
0
The rise of deep learning has marked significant progress in fields such as computer vision, natural language processing, and medical imaging, primarily through the adaptation of pre-trained models for specific tasks. Traditional fine-tuning methods, involving adjustments to all parameters, face challenges due to high computational and memory demands. This has led to the development of Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques, which selectively update parameters to balance computational efficiency with performance. This review examines PEFT approaches, offering a detailed comparison of various strategies highlighting applications across different domains, including text generation, medical imaging, protein modeling, and speech synthesis. By assessing the effectiveness of PEFT methods in reducing computational load, speeding up training, and lowering memory usage, this paper contributes to making deep learning more accessible and adaptable, facilitating its wider application and encouraging innovation in model optimization. Ultimately, the paper aims to contribute towards insights into PEFT's evolving landscape, guiding researchers and practitioners in overcoming the limitations of conventional fine-tuning approaches.
4/23/2024
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Models: A Comprehensive Survey
Zeyu Han, Chao Gao, Jinyang Liu, Jeff Zhang, Sai Qian Zhang
0
0
Large models represent a groundbreaking advancement in multiple application fields, enabling remarkable achievements across various tasks. However, their unprecedented scale comes with significant computational costs. These models, often consisting of billions of parameters, require vast amounts of computational resources for execution. Especially, the expansive scale and computational demands pose considerable challenges when customizing them for particular downstream tasks, particularly over the hardware platforms constrained by computational capabilities. Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) provides a practical solution by efficiently adapt the large models over the various downstream tasks. In particular, PEFT refers to the process of adjusting the parameters of a pre-trained large models to adapt it to a specific task while minimizing the number of additional parameters introduced or computational resources required. This approach is particularly important when dealing with large language models with high parameter counts, as fine-tuning these models from scratch can be computationally expensive and resource-intensive, posing considerable challenges in the supporting system platform design. In this survey, we present comprehensive studies of various PEFT algorithms, examining their performance and computational overhead. Moreover, we provide an overview of applications developed using different PEFT algorithms and discuss common techniques employed to mitigate computation costs for PEFT. In addition to the algorithmic perspective, we overview various real-world system designs to investigate the implementation costs associated with different PEFT algorithms. This survey serves as an indispensable resource for researchers aiming to understand both the PEFT algorithm and its system implementation, offering detailed insights into recent advancements and practical applications.
4/30/2024
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of LLaMA for the Clinical Domain
Aryo Pradipta Gema, Pasquale Minervini, Luke Daines, Tom Hope, Beatrice Alex
0
0
Adapting pretrained language models to novel domains, such as clinical applications, traditionally involves retraining their entire set of parameters. Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques for fine-tuning language models significantly reduce computational requirements by selectively fine-tuning small subsets of parameters. In this study, we propose a two-step PEFT framework and evaluate it in the clinical domain. Our approach combines a specialised PEFT adapter layer designed for clinical domain adaptation with another adapter specialised for downstream tasks. We evaluate the framework on multiple clinical outcome prediction datasets, comparing it to clinically trained language models. Our framework achieves a better AUROC score averaged across all clinical downstream tasks compared to clinical language models. In particular, we observe large improvements of 4-5% AUROC in large-scale multilabel classification tasks, such as diagnoses and procedures classification. To our knowledge, this study is the first to provide an extensive empirical analysis of the interplay between PEFT techniques and domain adaptation in an important real-world domain of clinical applications.
6/11/2024
Sparsity- and Hybridity-Inspired Visual Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Medical Diagnosis
Mingyuan Liu, Lu Xu, Shengnan Liu, Jicong Zhang
0
0
The success of Large Vision Models (LVMs) is accompanied by vast data volumes, which are prohibitively expensive in medical diagnosis.To address this, recent efforts exploit Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT), which trains a small number of weights while freezing the rest.However, they typically assign trainable weights to the same positions in LVMs in a heuristic manner, regardless of task differences, making them suboptimal for professional applications like medical diagnosis.To address this, we statistically reveal the nature of sparsity and hybridity during diagnostic-targeted fine-tuning, i.e., a small portion of key weights significantly impacts performance, and these key weights are hybrid, including both task-specific and task-agnostic parts.Based on this, we propose a novel Sparsity- and Hybridity-inspired Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (SH-PEFT).It selects and trains a small portion of weights based on their importance, which is innovatively estimated by hybridizing both task-specific and task-agnostic strategies.Validated on six medical datasets of different modalities, we demonstrate that SH-PEFT achieves state-of-the-art performance in transferring LVMs to medical diagnosis in terms of accuracy. By tuning around 0.01% number of weights, it outperforms full model fine-tuning.Moreover, SH-PEFT also achieves comparable performance to other models deliberately optimized for specific medical tasks.Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of each design and reveal that large model transfer holds great potential in medical diagnosis.
5/29/2024