Resource Optimization for Tail-Based Control in Wireless Networked Control Systems
2406.14301
0
0
Abstract
Achieving control stability is one of the key design challenges of scalable Wireless Networked Control Systems (WNCS) under limited communication and computing resources. This paper explores the use of an alternative control concept defined as tail-based control, which extends the classical Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) cost function for multiple dynamic control systems over a shared wireless network. We cast the control of multiple control systems as a network-wide optimization problem and decouple it in terms of sensor scheduling, plant state prediction, and control policies. Toward this, we propose a solution consisting of a scheduling algorithm based on Lyapunov optimization for sensing, a mechanism based on Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) for state prediction and uncertainty estimation, and a control policy based on Reinforcement Learning (RL) to ensure tail-based control stability. A set of discrete time-invariant mountain car control systems is used to evaluate the proposed solution and is compared against four variants that use state-of-the-art scheduling, prediction, and control methods. The experimental results indicate that the proposed method yields 22% reduction in overall cost in terms of communication and control resource utilization compared to state-of-the-art methods.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a resource optimization framework for wireless networked control systems (WNCS) that focuses on tail-based control performance metrics.
- It proposes an algorithm to allocate limited communication and computation resources in a way that minimizes the probability of large control errors.
- The key idea is to prioritize resources for control tasks that are most likely to experience large errors, rather than optimizing for average-case performance.
Plain English Explanation
In a wireless networked control system (WNCS), sensors and actuators are connected wirelessly to a central controller. This setup is used in many industrial applications, from manufacturing to smart buildings. However, the wireless connections can be unreliable, leading to control errors and potentially dangerous situations.
The researchers in this paper tackled the problem of optimizing the limited communication and computation resources in a WNCS to minimize the risk of large control errors. Rather than focusing on average-case performance, they developed an algorithm that prioritizes resources for the control tasks most likely to experience big errors.
The intuition is that it's more important to ensure good performance in the worst-case scenarios than to optimize the average case. By directing resources to the control tasks at highest risk, the system can provide stronger guarantees against unacceptably large errors, even if that means slightly reduced performance for some other tasks.
This tail-based optimization approach is designed to make WNCS more reliable and robust, which is crucial for safety-critical applications. The researchers showed through theoretical analysis and simulations that their method can outperform traditional resource allocation strategies that don't account for the distribution of control errors.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the resource allocation problem for WNCS as a stochastic optimization problem, where the goal is to minimize the probability that any individual control error exceeds a specified threshold. This "tail-based" objective function is in contrast to traditional approaches that focus on minimizing the average control error.
The researchers develop an algorithm called [TailOpt] that solves this optimization problem. [TailOpt] allocates communication and computation resources across the different control loops in the WNCS based on the statistical properties of each loop's error distribution. Loops with a higher probability of large errors are assigned more resources to bring down that risk.
To make the optimization tractable, the authors leverage results from queue-aware network control algorithms and learning-based optimal control with performance guarantees. They also show how the framework can be extended to handle time-varying wireless channels using online learning for robust voltage control.
Through numerical simulations, the authors demonstrate that [TailOpt] can significantly reduce the probability of large control errors compared to traditional resource allocation schemes, without sacrificing average-case performance. This makes it a promising approach for safety-critical WNCS applications like those discussed in deploying graph neural networks in wireless networks.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed resource optimization framework for WNCS that addresses an important practical concern - the need to mitigate the risk of large control errors rather than just optimizing average performance. The authors' tail-based objective function and [TailOpt] algorithm represent a thoughtful and principled approach to this problem.
That said, the analysis is limited to theoretical guarantees and simulations. Evaluating the real-world performance and implementation challenges of [TailOpt] in an actual WNCS deployment would be an important next step to validate the practical utility of this work. Factors like sensor/actuator failures, time-varying wireless channel conditions, and unpredictable disturbances could introduce additional complexities that the current framework does not address.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity of [TailOpt] or its scalability to WNCS with a large number of control loops. As the number of loops grows, the optimization problem may become intractable, requiring further approximations or decomposition techniques.
Overall, this is a strong contribution to the literature on resource-constrained control of WNCS. The tail-based optimization approach is a valuable conceptual advance, and the authors have laid a solid theoretical foundation. However, further research is needed to assess the practicality and robustness of this framework in real-world settings with all their attendant challenges.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel resource optimization framework for wireless networked control systems that focuses on minimizing the probability of large control errors, rather than optimizing average performance. The key idea is to prioritize communication and computation resources for control tasks that are most likely to experience big errors, in order to provide stronger guarantees against unacceptably poor control performance.
The authors develop an algorithm called [TailOpt] that solves this tail-based optimization problem, leveraging results from related areas of research. Simulation results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach in reducing the risk of large control errors compared to traditional resource allocation schemes.
While this work represents an important advance in making wireless control systems more reliable and robust, further research is needed to evaluate its practical feasibility and performance in real-world deployments with all their inherent complexities. Nonetheless, the tail-based optimization concept introduced in this paper is a valuable contribution that could inspire new directions in the design of safety-critical control systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
Deploying Graph Neural Networks in Wireless Networks: A Link Stability Viewpoint
Jun Li, Weiwei Zhang, Kang Wei, Guangji Chen, Long Shi, Wen Chen
0
0
As an emerging artificial intelligence technology, graph neural networks (GNNs) have exhibited promising performance across a wide range of graph-related applications. However, information exchanges among neighbor nodes in GNN pose new challenges in the resource-constrained scenario, especially in wireless systems. In practical wireless systems, the communication links among nodes are usually unreliable due to wireless fading and receiver noise, consequently resulting in performance degradation of GNNs. To improve the learning performance of GNNs, we aim to maximize the number of long-term average (LTA) communication links by the optimized power control under energy consumption constraints. Using the Lyapunov optimization method, we first transform the intractable long-term problem into a deterministic problem in each time slot by converting the long-term energy constraints into the objective function. In spite of this non-convex combinatorial optimization problem, we address this problem via equivalently solving a sequence of convex feasibility problems together with a greedy based solver. Simulation results demonstrate the superiority of our proposed scheme over the baselines.
5/10/2024
Queue-aware Network Control Algorithm with a High Quantum Computing Readiness-Evaluated in Discrete-time Flow Simulator for Fat-Pipe Networks
Arthur Witt
0
0
The emerging technology of quantum computing has the potential to change the way how problems will be solved in the future. This work presents a centralized network control algorithm executable on already existing quantum computer which are based on the principle of quantum annealing like the D-Wave Advantage. We introduce a resource reoccupation algorithm for traffic engineering in wide-area networks. The proposed optimization algorithm changes traffic steering and resource allocation in case of overloaded transceivers. Settings of active components like fiber amplifiers and transceivers are not changed for the reason of stability. This algorithm is beneficial in situations when the network traffic is fluctuating in time scales of seconds or spontaneous bursts occur. Further, we developed a discrete-time flow simulator to study the algorithm's performance in wide-area networks. Our network simulator considers backlog and loss modeling of buffered transmission lines. Concurring flows are handled equally in case of a backlog. This work provides an ILP-based network configuring algorithm that is applicable on quantum annealing computers. We showcase, that traffic losses can be reduced significantly by a factor of 2 if a resource reoccupation algorithm is applied in a network with bursty traffic. As resources are used more efficiently by reoccupation in heavy load situations, overprovisioning of networks can be reduced. Thus, this new form of network operation leads toward a zero-margin network. We show that our newly introduced network simulator enables analyses of short-time effects like buffering within fat-pipe networks. As the calculation of network configurations in real-sized networks is typically time-consuming, quantum computing can enable the proposed network configuration algorithm for application in real-sized wide-area networks.
5/21/2024
🚀
Learning-Based Optimal Control with Performance Guarantees for Unknown Systems with Latent States
Robert Lefringhausen, Supitsana Srithasan, Armin Lederer, Sandra Hirche
0
0
As control engineering methods are applied to increasingly complex systems, data-driven approaches for system identification appear as a promising alternative to physics-based modeling. While the Bayesian approaches prevalent for safety-critical applications usually rely on the availability of state measurements, the states of a complex system are often not directly measurable. It may then be necessary to jointly estimate the dynamics and the latent state, making the quantification of uncertainties and the design of controllers with formal performance guarantees considerably more challenging. This paper proposes a novel method for the computation of an optimal input trajectory for unknown nonlinear systems with latent states based on a combination of particle Markov chain Monte Carlo methods and scenario theory. Probabilistic performance guarantees are derived for the resulting input trajectory, and an approach to validate the performance of arbitrary control laws is presented. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated in a numerical simulation.
4/17/2024
Online learning for robust voltage control under uncertain grid topology
Christopher Yeh, Jing Yu, Yuanyuan Shi, Adam Wierman
0
0
Voltage control generally requires accurate information about the grid's topology in order to guarantee network stability. However, accurate topology identification is challenging for existing methods, especially as the grid is subject to increasingly frequent reconfiguration due to the adoption of renewable energy. In this work, we combine a nested convex body chasing algorithm with a robust predictive controller to achieve provably finite-time convergence to safe voltage limits in the online setting where there is uncertainty in both the network topology as well as load and generation variations. In an online fashion, our algorithm narrows down the set of possible grid models that are consistent with observations and adjusts reactive power generation accordingly to keep voltages within desired safety limits. Our approach can also incorporate existing partial knowledge of the network to improve voltage control performance. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in a case study on a Southern California Edison 56-bus distribution system. Our experiments show that in practical settings, the controller is indeed able to narrow the set of consistent topologies quickly enough to make control decisions that ensure stability in both linearized and realistic non-linear models of the distribution grid.
4/1/2024