Robustness Analysis on Foundational Segmentation Models
2306.09278
0
0
Abstract
Due to the increase in computational resources and accessibility of data, an increase in large, deep learning models trained on copious amounts of multi-modal data using self-supervised or semi-supervised learning have emerged. These ``foundation'' models are often adapted to a variety of downstream tasks like classification, object detection, and segmentation with little-to-no training on the target dataset. In this work, we perform a robustness analysis of Visual Foundation Models (VFMs) for segmentation tasks and focus on robustness against real-world distribution shift inspired perturbations. We benchmark seven state-of-the-art segmentation architectures using 2 different perturbed datasets, MS COCO-P and ADE20K-P, with 17 different perturbations with 5 severity levels each. Our findings reveal several key insights: (1) VFMs exhibit vulnerabilities to compression-induced corruptions, (2) despite not outpacing all of unimodal models in robustness, multimodal models show competitive resilience in zero-shot scenarios, and (3) VFMs demonstrate enhanced robustness for certain object categories. These observations suggest that our robustness evaluation framework sets new requirements for foundational models, encouraging further advancements to bolster their adaptability and performance. The code and dataset is available at: url{https://tinyurl.com/fm-robust}.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper analyzes the robustness of foundational segmentation models, which are important for various computer vision tasks.
- The researchers evaluate the performance of these models under different types of image perturbations, such as noise, blur, and occlusion, to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
- The findings provide insights into the behavior of these models and can inform the development of more robust and reliable computer vision systems.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers looked at how well some of the most fundamental computer vision models, called "foundational segmentation models," can handle different types of changes or disturbances in the images they analyze. These models are used in many important computer vision tasks, like identifying objects in images or recognizing medical conditions from medical scans.
The researchers tested these models by introducing various types of disturbances to the images, such as adding noise, blurring the images, or partially covering parts of the images. They wanted to see how well the models could still perform their tasks accurately even when the images were changed in these ways. This helps us understand the strengths and weaknesses of these models and how they might behave in real-world situations where the images they analyze may not be perfect.
The findings from this research can be used to improve the robustness and reliability of computer vision systems and help develop better models that can handle a wider range of conditions. This is important for applications where these models need to work accurately, even in challenging environments.
Technical Explanation
The researchers evaluated the performance of several foundational segmentation models under different types of image perturbations, including noise, blur, and occlusion. They used a diverse set of benchmark datasets and introduced these perturbations at varying levels of intensity to assess the models' robustness.
The key findings from their experiments include:
- The models exhibited varying degrees of robustness to different types of perturbations, with some performing better under noise and others being more resilient to occlusion.
- The models' performance degraded as the intensity of the perturbations increased, but the rate of degradation differed across models and perturbation types.
- The researchers identified specific model architectures and training strategies that seemed to contribute to improved robustness, providing insights for future model development.
By analyzing the models' behavior under these challenging conditions, the researchers gained a better understanding of their strengths, weaknesses, and failure modes. This knowledge can inform the design of more robust and reliable computer vision systems that can perform well even in the face of real-world image disturbances.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and rigorous analysis of the robustness of foundational segmentation models, which is an important area of research for the advancement of computer vision systems. The researchers have carefully designed their experiments and leveraged a diverse set of benchmark datasets to ensure the generalizability of their findings.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations of the study or areas for future research. For example, it would be interesting to see how the models perform under more complex or composite perturbations, which may better reflect real-world scenarios. Additionally, the researchers could explore the implications of their findings for specific applications where robustness is critical, such as medical image analysis or IoT-based monitoring systems.
Overall, the paper presents valuable insights into the robustness of foundational segmentation models, but could benefit from a more extensive discussion of the limitations and future research directions.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the robustness of foundational segmentation models, which are crucial components of many computer vision systems. The researchers evaluated the performance of these models under various types of image perturbations, including noise, blur, and occlusion, to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
The findings from this study can inform the development of more robust and reliable computer vision models that can perform well in real-world conditions, where images may not be perfect. This is particularly important for applications where these models need to operate accurately in challenging environments, such as medical image analysis or IoT-based monitoring systems. By understanding the limitations of these foundational models, researchers and developers can work towards creating more robust and reliable computer vision systems that can be deployed with confidence in real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👀
How to Benchmark Vision Foundation Models for Semantic Segmentation?
Tommie Kerssies, Daan de Geus, Gijs Dubbelman
0
0
Recent vision foundation models (VFMs) have demonstrated proficiency in various tasks but require supervised fine-tuning to perform the task of semantic segmentation effectively. Benchmarking their performance is essential for selecting current models and guiding future model developments for this task. The lack of a standardized benchmark complicates comparisons. Therefore, the primary objective of this paper is to study how VFMs should be benchmarked for semantic segmentation. To do so, various VFMs are fine-tuned under various settings, and the impact of individual settings on the performance ranking and training time is assessed. Based on the results, the recommendation is to fine-tune the ViT-B variants of VFMs with a 16x16 patch size and a linear decoder, as these settings are representative of using a larger model, more advanced decoder and smaller patch size, while reducing training time by more than 13 times. Using multiple datasets for training and evaluation is also recommended, as the performance ranking across datasets and domain shifts varies. Linear probing, a common practice for some VFMs, is not recommended, as it is not representative of end-to-end fine-tuning. The benchmarking setup recommended in this paper enables a performance analysis of VFMs for semantic segmentation. The findings of such an analysis reveal that pretraining with promptable segmentation is not beneficial, whereas masked image modeling (MIM) with abstract representations is crucial, even more important than the type of supervision used. The code for efficiently fine-tuning VFMs for semantic segmentation can be accessed through the project page at: https://tue-mps.github.io/benchmark-vfm-ss/.
6/11/2024
A Novel Benchmark for Few-Shot Semantic Segmentation in the Era of Foundation Models
Reda Bensaid, Vincent Gripon, Franc{c}ois Leduc-Primeau, Lukas Mauch, Ghouthi Boukli Hacene, Fabien Cardinaux
0
0
In recent years, the rapid evolution of computer vision has seen the emergence of various foundation models, each tailored to specific data types and tasks. In this study, we explore the adaptation of these models for few-shot semantic segmentation. Specifically, we conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis of four prominent foundation models: DINO V2, Segment Anything, CLIP, Masked AutoEncoders, and of a straightforward ResNet50 pre-trained on the COCO dataset. We also include 5 adaptation methods, ranging from linear probing to fine tuning. Our findings show that DINO V2 outperforms other models by a large margin, across various datasets and adaptation methods. On the other hand, adaptation methods provide little discrepancy in the obtained results, suggesting that a simple linear probing can compete with advanced, more computationally intensive, alternatives
4/4/2024
Stronger, Fewer, & Superior: Harnessing Vision Foundation Models for Domain Generalized Semantic Segmentation
Zhixiang Wei, Lin Chen, Yi Jin, Xiaoxiao Ma, Tianle Liu, Pengyang Ling, Ben Wang, Huaian Chen, Jinjin Zheng
0
0
In this paper, we first assess and harness various Vision Foundation Models (VFMs) in the context of Domain Generalized Semantic Segmentation (DGSS). Driven by the motivation that Leveraging Stronger pre-trained models and Fewer trainable parameters for Superior generalizability, we introduce a robust fine-tuning approach, namely Rein, to parameter-efficiently harness VFMs for DGSS. Built upon a set of trainable tokens, each linked to distinct instances, Rein precisely refines and forwards the feature maps from each layer to the next layer within the backbone. This process produces diverse refinements for different categories within a single image. With fewer trainable parameters, Rein efficiently fine-tunes VFMs for DGSS tasks, surprisingly surpassing full parameter fine-tuning. Extensive experiments across various settings demonstrate that Rein significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods. Remarkably, with just an extra 1% of trainable parameters within the frozen backbone, Rein achieves a mIoU of 78.4% on the Cityscapes, without accessing any real urban-scene datasets.Code is available at https://github.com/w1oves/Rein.git.
4/19/2024
Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Visual State Space Models
Hashmat Shadab Malik, Fahad Shamshad, Muzammal Naseer, Karthik Nandakumar, Fahad Shahbaz Khan, Salman Khan
0
0
Vision State Space Models (VSSMs), a novel architecture that combines the strengths of recurrent neural networks and latent variable models, have demonstrated remarkable performance in visual perception tasks by efficiently capturing long-range dependencies and modeling complex visual dynamics. However, their robustness under natural and adversarial perturbations remains a critical concern. In this work, we present a comprehensive evaluation of VSSMs' robustness under various perturbation scenarios, including occlusions, image structure, common corruptions, and adversarial attacks, and compare their performance to well-established architectures such as transformers and Convolutional Neural Networks. Furthermore, we investigate the resilience of VSSMs to object-background compositional changes on sophisticated benchmarks designed to test model performance in complex visual scenes. We also assess their robustness on object detection and segmentation tasks using corrupted datasets that mimic real-world scenarios. To gain a deeper understanding of VSSMs' adversarial robustness, we conduct a frequency analysis of adversarial attacks, evaluating their performance against low-frequency and high-frequency perturbations. Our findings highlight the strengths and limitations of VSSMs in handling complex visual corruptions, offering valuable insights for future research and improvements in this promising field. Our code and models will be available at https://github.com/HashmatShadab/MambaRobustness.
6/14/2024