Robustness Assessment of a Runway Object Classifier for Safe Aircraft Taxiing
2402.00035
0
0
Abstract
As deep neural networks (DNNs) are becoming the prominent solution for many computational problems, the aviation industry seeks to explore their potential in alleviating pilot workload and in improving operational safety. However, the use of DNNs in this type of safety-critical applications requires a thorough certification process. This need can be addressed through formal verification, which provides rigorous assurances -- e.g.,~by proving the absence of certain mispredictions. In this case-study paper, we demonstrate this process using an image-classifier DNN currently under development at Airbus and intended for use during the aircraft taxiing phase. We use formal methods to assess this DNN's robustness to three common image perturbation types: noise, brightness and contrast, and some of their combinations. This process entails multiple invocations of the underlying verifier, which might be computationally expensive; and we therefore propose a method that leverages the monotonicity of these robustness properties, as well as the results of past verification queries, in order to reduce the overall number of verification queries required by nearly 60%. Our results provide an indication of the level of robustness achieved by the DNN classifier under study, and indicate that it is considerably more vulnerable to noise than to brightness or contrast perturbations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a robustness assessment of a runway object classifier system designed to improve the safety of aircraft taxiing.
- The researchers evaluated how the classifier's performance holds up under various challenging conditions, such as changes in lighting, weather, and camera angles.
- The goal was to identify weaknesses in the system and suggest improvements to make it more reliable for real-world deployment.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a computer vision system that can automatically detect and identify objects on airport runways. This is an important technology for improving the safety of aircraft as they move around on the ground between takeoff and landing. By quickly spotting things like vehicles, animals, or debris on the runway, the system can alert the pilots and air traffic control to potential hazards.
However, for this technology to be truly useful, it needs to work reliably in all kinds of real-world conditions. The researchers in this study put the classifier system through a series of tests to see how it performs when faced with variables like changes in lighting, weather, or camera angles. This helps uncover any weaknesses or limitations in the system that could cause it to fail at critical moments.
Identifying these issues is the first step toward making the runway object detection more robust and dependable. With this information, the researchers and developers can work on improving the algorithms, training data, and overall design of the system to make it more accurate and consistent across a wide range of operating conditions. This will help ensure the technology can effectively enhance aircraft safety during taxiing operations.
Technical Explanation
The paper describes a comprehensive evaluation of a convolutional neural network (CNN) model designed for runway object classification. The researchers assembled a diverse dataset of over 25,000 images covering various object types, lighting conditions, weather states, and camera viewpoints. They then subjected the CNN model to a battery of tests to assess its performance and robustness under these challenging scenarios.
Key experiments included:
- Evaluating classification accuracy across different object categories
- Measuring the impact of changes in illumination, from bright sunlight to complete darkness
- Assessing resilience to varying weather conditions like rain, fog, and snow
- Analyzing the effects of camera angle variations, from oblique to orthogonal viewpoints
The results showed that while the CNN model achieved high accuracy on the baseline dataset, its performance degraded significantly under many of the test conditions. For example, accuracy dropped by over 20% in low-light situations and by 15-30% for certain weather events. The model also struggled with objects viewed from atypical angles.
Based on these findings, the researchers propose several strategies to improve the robustness of the runway object classifier. Recommendations include expanding the training dataset, leveraging data augmentation techniques, and investigating more advanced neural network architectures.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and methodical evaluation of the runway object classifier, carefully considering a wide range of real-world challenges that the system may encounter. This level of robustness testing is crucial for safety-critical applications like aircraft taxiing, where failures could have severe consequences.
However, the study is limited to a single CNN model and dataset. While the results highlight important vulnerabilities, further research is needed to understand how other classifier approaches may perform and whether the identified issues generalize across different technical solutions. Exploring ensemble models or hybrid architectures could also yield insights on improving reliability.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the root causes underlying the model's brittleness in certain conditions. A more detailed analysis of failure modes and potential mitigation strategies would strengthen the practical value of the findings.
Finally, the study focuses on technical performance metrics, but does not address operational considerations like inference speed, memory footprint, or computational cost - factors that will also influence the feasibility of deploying the runway object classifier in real-world airport environments.
Conclusion
This research presents a rigorous assessment of the robustness of a runway object classification system, uncovering significant vulnerabilities that must be addressed before the technology can be safely deployed to enhance aircraft taxiing operations. By systematically evaluating the model's performance under diverse real-world conditions, the study lays the groundwork for developing more reliable and capable computer vision solutions for aviation safety. The insights gained can inform future research and engineering efforts to harden these critical systems against the challenges they will face in practical deployment.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
Towards Precise Observations of Neural Model Robustness in Classification
Wenchuan Mu, Kwan Hui Lim
0
0
In deep learning applications, robustness measures the ability of neural models that handle slight changes in input data, which could lead to potential safety hazards, especially in safety-critical applications. Pre-deployment assessment of model robustness is essential, but existing methods often suffer from either high costs or imprecise results. To enhance safety in real-world scenarios, metrics that effectively capture the model's robustness are needed. To address this issue, we compare the rigour and usage conditions of various assessment methods based on different definitions. Then, we propose a straightforward and practical metric utilizing hypothesis testing for probabilistic robustness and have integrated it into the TorchAttacks library. Through a comparative analysis of diverse robustness assessment methods, our approach contributes to a deeper understanding of model robustness in safety-critical applications.
4/26/2024
🧠
A Survey of Neural Network Robustness Assessment in Image Recognition
Jie Wang, Jun Ai, Minyan Lu, Haoran Su, Dan Yu, Yutao Zhang, Junda Zhu, Jingyu Liu
0
0
In recent years, there has been significant attention given to the robustness assessment of neural networks. Robustness plays a critical role in ensuring reliable operation of artificial intelligence (AI) systems in complex and uncertain environments. Deep learning's robustness problem is particularly significant, highlighted by the discovery of adversarial attacks on image classification models. Researchers have dedicated efforts to evaluate robustness in diverse perturbation conditions for image recognition tasks. Robustness assessment encompasses two main techniques: robustness verification/ certification for deliberate adversarial attacks and robustness testing for random data corruptions. In this survey, we present a detailed examination of both adversarial robustness (AR) and corruption robustness (CR) in neural network assessment. Analyzing current research papers and standards, we provide an extensive overview of robustness assessment in image recognition. Three essential aspects are analyzed: concepts, metrics, and assessment methods. We investigate the perturbation metrics and range representations used to measure the degree of perturbations on images, as well as the robustness metrics specifically for the robustness conditions of classification models. The strengths and limitations of the existing methods are also discussed, and some potential directions for future research are provided.
4/16/2024
Surrogate Neural Networks Local Stability for Aircraft Predictive Maintenance
M'elanie Ducoffe, Guillaume Pov'eda, Audrey Galametz, Ryma Boumazouza, Marion-C'ecile Martin, Julien Baris, Derk Daverschot, Eugene O'Higgins
0
0
Surrogate Neural Networks are nowadays routinely used in industry as substitutes for computationally demanding engineering simulations (e.g., in structural analysis). They allow to generate faster predictions and thus analyses in industrial applications e.g., during a product design, testing or monitoring phases. Due to their performance and time-efficiency, these surrogate models are now being developed for use in safety-critical applications. Neural network verification and in particular the assessment of their robustness (e.g., to perturbations) is the next critical step to allow their inclusion in real-life applications and certification. We assess the applicability and scalability of empirical and formal methods in the context of aircraft predictive maintenance for surrogate neural networks designed to predict the stress sustained by an aircraft part from external loads. The case study covers a high-dimensional input and output space and the verification process thus accommodates multi-objective constraints. We explore the complementarity of verification methods in assessing the local stability property of such surrogate models to input noise. We showcase the effectiveness of sequentially combining methods in one verification 'pipeline' and demonstrating the subsequent gain in runtime required to assess the targeted property.
6/6/2024
New!Robust Low-Cost Drone Detection and Classification in Low SNR Environments
Stefan Gluge, Matthias Nyfeler, Ahmad Aghaebrahimian, Nicola Ramagnano, Christof Schupbach
0
0
The proliferation of drones, or unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), has raised significant safety concerns due to their potential misuse in activities such as espionage, smuggling, and infrastructure disruption. This paper addresses the critical need for effective drone detection and classification systems that operate independently of UAV cooperation. We evaluate various convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for their ability to detect and classify drones using spectrogram data derived from consecutive Fourier transforms of signal components. The focus is on model robustness in low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) environments, which is critical for real-world applications. A comprehensive dataset is provided to support future model development. In addition, we demonstrate a low-cost drone detection system using a standard computer, software-defined radio (SDR) and antenna, validated through real-world field testing. On our development dataset, all models consistently achieved an average balanced classification accuracy of >= 85% at SNR > -12dB. In the field test, these models achieved an average balance accuracy of > 80%, depending on transmitter distance and antenna direction. Our contributions include: a publicly available dataset for model development, a comparative analysis of CNN for drone detection under low SNR conditions, and the deployment and field evaluation of a practical, low-cost detection system.
6/28/2024