SCAFFLSA: Taming Heterogeneity in Federated Linear Stochastic Approximation and TD Learning
2402.04114
0
0
Abstract
In this paper, we analyze the sample and communication complexity of the federated linear stochastic approximation (FedLSA) algorithm. We explicitly quantify the effects of local training with agent heterogeneity. We show that the communication complexity of FedLSA scales polynomially with the inverse of the desired accuracy $epsilon$. To overcome this, we propose SCAFFLSA a new variant of FedLSA that uses control variates to correct for client drift, and establish its sample and communication complexities. We show that for statistically heterogeneous agents, its communication complexity scales logarithmically with the desired accuracy, similar to Scaffnew. An important finding is that, compared to the existing results for Scaffnew, the sample complexity scales with the inverse of the number of agents, a property referred to as linear speed-up. Achieving this linear speed-up requires completely new theoretical arguments. We apply the proposed method to federated temporal difference learning with linear function approximation and analyze the corresponding complexity improvements.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new algorithm called SCAFFLSA (Stochastic Coordinate Ascent Federated Federated Linear Stochastic Approximation) to address the problem of heterogeneity bias in federated linear stochastic approximation and temporal difference learning.
- Heterogeneity bias can arise when the data distributions or learning tasks across different client devices in a federated learning setting are not identical, leading to suboptimal performance.
- SCAFFLSA aims to quantify and eliminate this bias to improve the convergence and optimization properties of federated learning algorithms.
Plain English Explanation
Federated learning is a machine learning technique where multiple devices or clients collaborate to train a shared model, without directly sharing their local data. This is useful when the data is distributed across many devices and cannot be easily centralized.
However, a challenge in federated learning is that the data or learning tasks on different devices may not be exactly the same. This "heterogeneity" can introduce biases that prevent the model from converging to the optimal solution.
The paper proposes a new algorithm called SCAFFLSA that aims to address this heterogeneity bias. SCAFFLSA works by quantifying the impact of the heterogeneity and then adjusting the learning process to compensate for it. This helps the federated learning algorithm converge faster and achieve better performance, even when the client devices have quite different data or learning objectives.
By overcoming the challenge of heterogeneity, SCAFFLSA can make federated learning more practical and effective in real-world applications where data is naturally distributed across many devices with varying characteristics.
Technical Explanation
The paper first provides a theoretical analysis of the heterogeneity bias in federated linear stochastic approximation (LSA) and temporal difference (TD) learning. It shows that this bias can significantly degrade the convergence rate and final solution quality of these algorithms.
To address this, the authors propose the SCAFFLSA algorithm, which builds upon the SCAFFOLD algorithm for federated optimization [link]. SCAFFLSA uses control variates to estimate and compensate for the heterogeneity bias, leading to improved convergence guarantees.
The paper then provides a finite-time analysis of SCAFFLSA, deriving bounds on the optimization error and demonstrating that it can achieve a faster convergence rate compared to previous federated LSA and TD learning algorithms, even in the presence of heterogeneity.
The authors also conduct experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets, validating the theoretical findings and showing that SCAFFLSA outperforms existing methods in terms of optimization performance and robustness to heterogeneity.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical and empirical analysis of the SCAFFLSA algorithm, addressing an important challenge in federated learning. The authors' approach of quantifying and compensating for heterogeneity bias is a novel contribution to the field.
However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or caveats of the SCAFFLSA algorithm. For example, it is unclear how the algorithm would perform in scenarios with extreme levels of heterogeneity, or how sensitive it is to the quality of the control variate estimates.
Additionally, the paper focuses on linear and temporal difference learning problems, but does not consider more complex federated learning settings, such as those involving nonlinear models or reinforcement learning. Exploring the applicability of SCAFFLSA to a wider range of federated learning problems would be a valuable direction for future research.
Conclusion
The SCAFFLSA algorithm proposed in this paper represents an important step forward in addressing the challenge of heterogeneity bias in federated learning. By quantifying and compensating for this bias, the algorithm can improve the convergence and optimization performance of federated linear stochastic approximation and temporal difference learning, making these techniques more practical and robust in real-world applications.
The theoretical analysis and experimental results presented in the paper demonstrate the effectiveness of the SCAFFLSA approach, and suggest that it could have a significant impact on the field of federated learning. Further research to extend the algorithm's capabilities and explore its broader applicability would be a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to develop efficient and reliable distributed machine learning systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Finite-Time Analysis of On-Policy Heterogeneous Federated Reinforcement Learning
Chenyu Zhang, Han Wang, Aritra Mitra, James Anderson
0
0
Federated reinforcement learning (FRL) has emerged as a promising paradigm for reducing the sample complexity of reinforcement learning tasks by exploiting information from different agents. However, when each agent interacts with a potentially different environment, little to nothing is known theoretically about the non-asymptotic performance of FRL algorithms. The lack of such results can be attributed to various technical challenges and their intricate interplay: Markovian sampling, linear function approximation, multiple local updates to save communication, heterogeneity in the reward functions and transition kernels of the agents' MDPs, and continuous state-action spaces. Moreover, in the on-policy setting, the behavior policies vary with time, further complicating the analysis. In response, we introduce FedSARSA, a novel federated on-policy reinforcement learning scheme, equipped with linear function approximation, to address these challenges and provide a comprehensive finite-time error analysis. Notably, we establish that FedSARSA converges to a policy that is near-optimal for all agents, with the extent of near-optimality proportional to the level of heterogeneity. Furthermore, we prove that FedSARSA leverages agent collaboration to enable linear speedups as the number of agents increases, which holds for both fixed and adaptive step-size configurations.
4/16/2024
📈
Robust Model Aggregation for Heterogeneous Federated Learning: Analysis and Optimizations
Yumeng Shao, Jun Li, Long Shi, Kang Wei, Ming Ding, Qianmu Li, Zengxiang Li, Wen Chen, Shi Jin
0
0
Conventional synchronous federated learning (SFL) frameworks suffer from performance degradation in heterogeneous systems due to imbalanced local data size and diverse computing power on the client side. To address this problem, asynchronous FL (AFL) and semi-asynchronous FL have been proposed to recover the performance loss by allowing asynchronous aggregation. However, asynchronous aggregation incurs a new problem of inconsistency between local updates and global updates. Motivated by the issues of conventional SFL and AFL, we first propose a time-driven SFL (T-SFL) framework for heterogeneous systems. The core idea of T-SFL is that the server aggregates the models from different clients, each with varying numbers of iterations, at regular time intervals. To evaluate the learning performance of T-SFL, we provide an upper bound on the global loss function. Further, we optimize the aggregation weights to minimize the developed upper bound. Then, we develop a discriminative model selection (DMS) algorithm that removes local models from clients whose number of iterations falls below a predetermined threshold. In particular, this algorithm ensures that each client's aggregation weight accurately reflects its true contribution to the global model update, thereby improving the efficiency and robustness of the system. To validate the effectiveness of T-SFL with the DMS algorithm, we conduct extensive experiments using several popular datasets including MNIST, Cifar-10, Fashion-MNIST, and SVHN. The experimental results demonstrate that T-SFL with the DMS algorithm can reduce the latency of conventional SFL by 50%, while achieving an average 3% improvement in learning accuracy over state-of-the-art AFL algorithms.
5/14/2024
Federated Control in Markov Decision Processes
Hao Jin, Yang Peng, Liangyu Zhang, Zhihua Zhang
0
0
We study problems of federated control in Markov Decision Processes. To solve an MDP with large state space, multiple learning agents are introduced to collaboratively learn its optimal policy without communication of locally collected experience. In our settings, these agents have limited capabilities, which means they are restricted within different regions of the overall state space during the training process. In face of the difference among restricted regions, we firstly introduce concepts of leakage probabilities to understand how such heterogeneity affects the learning process, and then propose a novel communication protocol that we call Federated-Q protocol (FedQ), which periodically aggregates agents' knowledge of their restricted regions and accordingly modifies their learning problems for further training. In terms of theoretical analysis, we justify the correctness of FedQ as a communication protocol, then give a general result on sample complexity of derived algorithms FedQ-X with the RL oracle , and finally conduct a thorough study on the sample complexity of FedQ-SynQ. Specifically, FedQ-X has been shown to enjoy linear speedup in terms of sample complexity when workload is uniformly distributed among agents. Moreover, we carry out experiments in various environments to justify the efficiency of our methods.
5/8/2024
Asynchronous Federated Stochastic Optimization with Exact Averaging for Heterogeneous Local Objectives
Charikleia Iakovidou, Kibaek Kim
0
0
Federated learning (FL) was recently proposed to securely train models with data held over multiple locations (clients) under the coordination of a central server. Two major challenges hindering the performance of FL algorithms are long training times caused by straggling clients, and a decline in model accuracy under non-iid local data distributions (client drift). In this work, we propose and analyze Asynchronous Exact Averaging (AREA), a new stochastic (sub)gradient algorithm that utilizes asynchronous communication to speed up convergence and enhance scalability, and employs client memory to correct the client drift caused by variations in client update frequencies. Moreover, AREA is, to the best of our knowledge, the first method that is guaranteed to converge under arbitrarily long delays, without the use of delay-adaptive stepsizes, and (i) for strongly convex, smooth functions, asymptotically converges to an error neighborhood whose size depends only on the variance of the stochastic gradients used with respect to the number of iterations, and (ii) for convex, non-smooth functions, matches the convergence rate of the centralized stochastic subgradient method up to a constant factor, which depends on the average of the individual client update frequencies instead of their minimum (or maximum). Our numerical results validate our theoretical analysis and indicate AREA outperforms state-of-the-art methods when local data are highly non-iid, especially as the number of clients grows.
5/30/2024