scenario.center: Methods from Real-world Data to a Scenario Database
2404.02561
0
0
Abstract
Scenario-based testing is a promising method to develop, verify and validate automated driving systems (ADS) since pure on-road testing seems inefficient for complex traffic environments. A major challenge for this approach is the provision and management of a sufficient number of scenarios to test a system. The provision, generation, and management of scenario at scale is investigated in current research. This paper presents the scenario database scenario.center ( https://scenario.center ) to process and manage scenario data covering the needs of scenario-based testing approaches comprehensively and automatically. Thereby, requirements for such databases are described. Based on those, a four-step approach is proposed. Firstly, a common input format with defined quality requirements is defined. This is utilized for detecting events and base scenarios automatically. Furthermore, methods for searchability, evaluation of data quality and different scenario generation methods are proposed to allow a broad applicability serving different needs. For evaluation, the methodology is compared to state-of-the-art scenario databases. Finally, the application and capabilities of the database are shown by applying the methodology to the inD dataset. A public demonstration of the database interface is provided at https://scenario.center .
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new framework called "scenario.center" that aims to bridge the gap between real-world data and a comprehensive scenario database for autonomous driving applications.
- The authors present methods for extracting and organizing relevant scenario data from real-world sources, creating a structured database of driving scenarios.
- The goal is to support the development and testing of autonomous driving systems by providing a diverse, representative set of scenarios grounded in empirical data.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new system called "scenario.center" that helps create a detailed database of driving scenarios based on real-world data. Autonomous driving systems need to be trained and tested on a wide range of driving situations, but gathering and organizing all this data can be a challenge.
The scenario.center framework provides a way to extract relevant scenario data from sources like traffic cameras, accident reports, and driving simulation logs. This information is then structured and organized into a comprehensive database that can be used to develop and evaluate autonomous driving algorithms.
By connecting real-world data to a standardized scenario database, the researchers hope to make it easier for autonomous driving companies and researchers to access a diverse set of realistic driving situations. This could lead to better-performing and safer self-driving systems that are prepared for the complexities of the real world.
[The paper builds on previous work in the field of autonomous driving scenario generation and testing, such as the research described in "Towards Completeness: Argumentation Scenario Concepts" and "Causality-Based Transfer of Driving Scenarios to Unseen."]
Technical Explanation
The key components of the scenario.center framework include:
-
Data Collection: The authors describe methods for extracting scenario data from various real-world sources, such as traffic camera footage, accident reports, and driving simulation logs. This raw data is then preprocessed and structured.
-
Scenario Extraction: Algorithms are used to identify distinct driving scenarios within the collected data, such as lane changes, intersections, merging, and emergency maneuvers. Relevant contextual information like weather, traffic density, and driver behavior is also extracted.
-
Scenario Database: The extracted scenarios are organized into a structured database, with each scenario represented by a set of parameters and attributes. This database serves as a comprehensive reference for autonomous driving applications.
-
Scenario Representation: The paper discusses techniques for representing driving scenarios in a standardized, machine-readable format. This includes the use of simulation tools and scenario description languages to enable the efficient storage, retrieval, and reuse of scenarios.
The authors evaluate their framework by demonstrating its application in several use cases, such as systematically testing autonomous driving algorithms and generating synthetic training data for machine learning models. The results show that the scenario.center approach can provide a more diverse and representative set of scenarios compared to traditional methods.
Critical Analysis
The scenario.center framework presents a promising approach to bridging the gap between real-world driving data and comprehensive scenario databases. By grounding the scenario database in empirical evidence, the authors aim to improve the relevance and representativeness of the scenarios used for autonomous driving development and testing.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and challenges of the approach. For example, the quality and completeness of the scenario database may be heavily dependent on the available data sources and the effectiveness of the data extraction and processing algorithms. Additionally, the authors do not discuss how the scenario database might be maintained and updated over time to keep pace with evolving driving conditions and behaviors.
Further research could also explore the integration of the scenario.center database with other scenario generation and testing frameworks, as well as the potential for using the database to inform the design of more robust and adaptable autonomous driving algorithms.
Conclusion
The scenario.center framework represents a significant step forward in bridging the gap between real-world driving data and the scenario databases needed to develop and test autonomous driving systems. By providing a structured and comprehensive database of driving scenarios grounded in empirical evidence, the authors aim to support the creation of safer and more capable self-driving technologies.
While the paper presents promising results, there are still opportunities for further research and refinement of the approach. By continuing to explore ways to leverage real-world data for scenario-based development and testing, the autonomous driving community can work towards the ultimate goal of deploying self-driving vehicles that can navigate the complexities of the real world with confidence and reliability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
Scene-Extrapolation: Generating Interactive Traffic Scenarios
Maximilian Zipfl, Barbara Schutt, J. Marius Zollner
0
0
Verifying highly automated driving functions can be challenging, requiring identifying relevant test scenarios. Scenario-based testing will likely play a significant role in verifying these systems, predominantly occurring within simulation. In our approach, we use traffic scenes as a starting point (seed-scene) to address the individuality of various highly automated driving functions and to avoid the problems associated with a predefined test traffic scenario. Different highly autonomous driving functions, or their distinct iterations, may display different behaviors under the same operating conditions. To make a generalizable statement about a seed-scene, we simulate possible outcomes based on various behavior profiles. We utilize our lightweight simulation environment and populate it with rule-based and machine learning behavior models for individual actors in the scenario. We analyze resulting scenarios using a variety of criticality metrics. The density distributions of the resulting criticality values enable us to make a profound statement about the significance of a particular scene, considering various eventualities.
4/29/2024
Towards a Completeness Argumentation for Scenario Concepts
Christoph Glasmacher, Hendrik Weber, Lutz Eckstein
0
0
Scenario-based testing has become a promising approach to overcome the complexity of real-world traffic for safety assurance of automated vehicles. Within scenario-based testing, a system under test is confronted with a set of predefined scenarios. This set shall ensure more efficient testing of an automated vehicle operating in an open context compared to real-world testing. However, the question arises if a scenario catalog can cover the open context sufficiently to allow an argumentation for sufficiently safe driving functions and how this can be proven. Within this paper, a methodology is proposed to argue a sufficient completeness of a scenario concept using a goal structured notation. Thereby, the distinction between completeness and coverage is discussed. For both, methods are proposed for a streamlined argumentation and regarding evidence. These methods are applied to a scenario concept and the inD dataset to prove the usability.
4/3/2024
🚀
Towards Scenario- and Capability-Driven Dataset Development and Evaluation: An Approach in the Context of Mapless Automated Driving
Felix Grun, Marcus Nolte, Markus Maurer
0
0
The foundational role of datasets in defining the capabilities of deep learning models has led to their rapid proliferation. At the same time, published research focusing on the process of dataset development for environment perception in automated driving has been scarce, thereby reducing the applicability of openly available datasets and impeding the development of effective environment perception systems. Sensor-based, mapless automated driving is one of the contexts where this limitation is evident. While leveraging real-time sensor data, instead of pre-defined HD maps promises enhanced adaptability and safety by effectively navigating unexpected environmental changes, it also increases the demands on the scope and complexity of the information provided by the perception system. To address these challenges, we propose a scenario- and capability-based approach to dataset development. Grounded in the principles of ISO 21448 (safety of the intended functionality, SOTIF), extended by ISO/TR 4804, our approach facilitates the structured derivation of dataset requirements. This not only aids in the development of meaningful new datasets but also enables the effective comparison of existing ones. Applying this methodology to a broad range of existing lane detection datasets, we identify significant limitations in current datasets, particularly in terms of real-world applicability, a lack of labeling of critical features, and an absence of comprehensive information for complex driving maneuvers.
5/1/2024
⛏️
Chat2Scenario: Scenario Extraction From Dataset Through Utilization of Large Language Model
Yongqi Zhao, Wenbo Xiao, Tomislav Mihalj, Jia Hu, Arno Eichberger
0
0
The advent of Large Language Models (LLM) provides new insights to validate Automated Driving Systems (ADS). In the herein-introduced work, a novel approach to extracting scenarios from naturalistic driving datasets is presented. A framework called Chat2Scenario is proposed leveraging the advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) capabilities of LLM to understand and identify different driving scenarios. By inputting descriptive texts of driving conditions and specifying the criticality metric thresholds, the framework efficiently searches for desired scenarios and converts them into ASAM OpenSCENARIO and IPG CarMaker text files. This methodology streamlines the scenario extraction process and enhances efficiency. Simulations are executed to validate the efficiency of the approach. The framework is presented based on a user-friendly web app and is accessible via the following link: https://github.com/ftgTUGraz/Chat2Scenario.
4/29/2024