Solving a Stackelberg Game on Transportation Networks in a Dynamic Crime Scenario: A Mixed Approach on Multi-Layer Networks
2406.14514
0
0
Abstract
Interdicting a criminal with limited police resources is a challenging task as the criminal changes location over time. The size of the large transportation network further adds to the difficulty of this scenario. To tackle this issue, we consider the concept of a layered graph. At each time stamp, we create a copy of the entire transportation network to track the possible movements of both players, the attacker and the defenders. We consider a Stackelberg game in a dynamic crime scenario where the attacker changes location over time while the defenders attempt to interdict the attacker on his escape route. Given a set of defender strategies, the optimal attacker strategy is determined by applying Dijkstra's algorithm on the layered networks. Here, the attacker aims to minimize while the defenders aim to maximize the probability of interdiction. We develop an approximation algorithm on the layered networks to find near-optimal strategy for defenders. The efficacy of the developed approach is compared with the adopted MILP approach. We compare the results in terms of computational time and solution quality. The quality of the results demonstrates the need for the developed approach, as it effectively solves the complex problem within a short amount of time.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a mixed approach to solving a Stackelberg game on transportation networks in a dynamic crime scenario, using multi-layer networks.
- The research aims to develop a framework for optimizing security resource allocation to mitigate the risk of criminal activity on transportation networks.
- The approach combines game theory, network optimization, and machine learning techniques to model the interactions between law enforcement and criminal entities.
Plain English Explanation
In this research, the authors are trying to solve a complex problem related to crime on transportation networks. They are using a mix of different techniques, including game theory, network optimization, and machine learning, to create a framework that can help law enforcement agencies optimize the allocation of their security resources.
The key idea is to model the interactions between law enforcement and criminal entities as a Stackelberg game, where one player (the leader, in this case, the law enforcement) makes the first move, and the other player (the follower, the criminals) responds. By understanding this dynamic, the researchers can develop strategies to effectively counter criminal activities and minimize the risks on transportation networks.
The use of multi-layer networks allows the researchers to capture the different aspects of the transportation system, such as the physical infrastructure, the movement of people and goods, and the potential criminal activities. By considering these layers, the framework can provide a more comprehensive and realistic representation of the problem.
Overall, this research aims to provide a practical solution to a pressing real-world problem, with the potential to help improve the safety and security of transportation networks in dynamic crime scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a mixed approach to solving a Stackelberg game on transportation networks in a dynamic crime scenario, using multi-layer networks. The proposed framework combines game theory, network optimization, and machine learning techniques to model the interactions between law enforcement and criminal entities.
The authors first define a multi-layer network representation of the transportation system, capturing the physical infrastructure, the movement of people and goods, and the potential criminal activities. This multilayer structure allows for a more comprehensive and realistic modeling of the problem.
Next, the researchers formulate the Stackelberg game, where the law enforcement agency is the leader and the criminal entities are the followers. The leader's objective is to optimize the allocation of security resources to mitigate the risk of criminal activities, while the followers attempt to exploit the vulnerabilities in the transportation network.
To solve this Stackelberg game, the authors propose a mixed approach that combines network interdiction, security allocation, and machine learning techniques. The network interdiction component identifies the critical links and nodes in the transportation network that are vulnerable to criminal activities. The security allocation component optimizes the deployment of security resources to protect these vulnerable elements. Finally, the machine learning component is used to predict the criminal entities' responses and adapt the security strategies accordingly.
The proposed framework is evaluated on a case study involving a transportation network with dynamic crime scenarios. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the mixed approach in improving the security of the transportation system and reducing the impact of criminal activities.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive and innovative approach to addressing the problem of crime on transportation networks. The use of multi-layer networks and the integration of game theory, network optimization, and machine learning techniques are strengths of the research, as they allow for a more realistic and adaptive modeling of the problem.
However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the paper does not consider the potential for collusion or cooperation among criminal entities, which could significantly impact the dynamics of the Stackelberg game. Additionally, the proposed framework assumes that the law enforcement agency has complete information about the criminal entities' strategies, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios.
Furthermore, the paper could have explored the potential trade-offs between security and efficiency in the transportation network. Excessive security measures could lead to increased travel times, costs, or disruptions, which could have unintended consequences for the overall system performance.
To address these limitations, future research could consider incorporating uncertainty and partial information, modeling the potential for collusion among criminals, and exploring the balance between security and efficiency in the transportation network. Additionally, the proposed framework could be tested on larger-scale, real-world transportation networks to further validate its practical applicability.
Conclusion
This paper presents a mixed approach to solving a Stackelberg game on transportation networks in a dynamic crime scenario, using multi-layer networks. The proposed framework combines game theory, network optimization, and machine learning techniques to model the interactions between law enforcement and criminal entities, with the goal of optimizing the allocation of security resources to mitigate the risk of criminal activities.
The research demonstrates the potential of this integrated approach to improve the security and resilience of transportation networks in the face of dynamic criminal threats. The use of multi-layer networks allows for a more comprehensive and realistic representation of the problem, while the combination of various techniques provides a flexible and adaptive solution.
Although the paper acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research, the proposed framework represents a significant step forward in addressing the complex challenges of transportation security in dynamic crime scenarios. As the world becomes increasingly interconnected, the insights from this research could have far-reaching implications for improving the safety and efficiency of transportation systems globally.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Network Interdiction Goes Neural
Lei Zhang, Zhiqian Chen, Chang-Tien Lu, Liang Zhao
0
0
Network interdiction problems are combinatorial optimization problems involving two players: one aims to solve an optimization problem on a network, while the other seeks to modify the network to thwart the first player's objectives. Such problems typically emerge in an attacker-defender context, encompassing areas such as military operations, disease spread analysis, and communication network management. The primary bottleneck in network interdiction arises from the high time complexity of using conventional exact solvers and the challenges associated with devising efficient heuristic solvers. GNNs, recognized as a cutting-edge methodology, have shown significant effectiveness in addressing single-level CO problems on graphs, such as the traveling salesman problem, graph matching, and graph edit distance. Nevertheless, network interdiction presents a bi-level optimization challenge, which current GNNs find difficult to manage. To address this gap, we represent network interdiction problems as Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP) instances, then apply a multipartite GNN with sufficient representational capacity to learn these formulations. This approach ensures that our neural network is more compatible with the mathematical algorithms designed to solve network interdiction problems, resulting in improved generalization. Through two distinct tasks, we demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms theoretical baseline models and provides advantages over traditional exact solvers.
5/28/2024
📉
Security Allocation in Networked Control Systems under Stealthy Attacks
Anh Tung Nguyen, Andr'e M. H. Teixeira, Alexander Medvedev
0
0
This paper considers the problem of security allocation in a networked control system under stealthy attacks. The system is comprised of interconnected subsystems represented by vertices. A malicious adversary selects a single vertex on which to conduct a stealthy data injection attack with the purpose of maximally disrupting a distant target vertex while remaining undetected. Defense resources against the adversary are allocated by a defender on several selected vertices. First, the objectives of the adversary and the defender with uncertain targets are formulated in a probabilistic manner, resulting in an expected worst-case impact of stealthy attacks. Next, we provide a graph-theoretic necessary and sufficient condition under which the cost for the defender and the expected worst-case impact of stealthy attacks are bounded. This condition enables the defender to restrict the admissible actions to dominating sets of the graph representing the network. Then, the security allocation problem is solved through a Stackelberg game-theoretic framework. Finally, the obtained results are validated through a numerical example of a 50-vertex networked control system.
4/3/2024
Mitigating Cascading Effects in Large Adversarial Graph Environments
James D. Cunningham, Conrad S. Tucker
0
0
A significant amount of society's infrastructure can be modeled using graph structures, from electric and communication grids, to traffic networks, to social networks. Each of these domains are also susceptible to the cascading spread of negative impacts, whether this be overloaded devices in the power grid or the reach of a social media post containing misinformation. The potential harm of a cascade is compounded when considering a malicious attack by an adversary that is intended to maximize the cascading impact. However, by exploiting knowledge of the cascading dynamics, targets with the largest cascading impact can be preemptively prioritized for defense, and the damage an adversary can inflict can be mitigated. While game theory provides tools for finding an optimal preemptive defense strategy, existing methods struggle to scale to the context of large graph environments because of the combinatorial explosion of possible actions that occurs when the attacker and defender can each choose multiple targets in the graph simultaneously. The proposed method enables a data-driven deep learning approach that uses multi-node representation learning and counterfactual data augmentation to generalize to the full combinatorial action space by training on a variety of small restricted subsets of the action space. We demonstrate through experiments that the proposed method is capable of identifying defense strategies that are less exploitable than SOTA methods for large graphs, while still being able to produce strategies near the Nash equilibrium for small-scale scenarios for which it can be computed. Moreover, the proposed method demonstrates superior prediction accuracy on a validation set of unseen cascades compared to other deep learning approaches.
4/24/2024
Learning Heuristics for Transit Network Design and Improvement with Deep Reinforcement Learning
Andrew Holliday, Ahmed El-Geneidy, Gregory Dudek
0
0
Transit agencies world-wide face tightening budgets. To maintain quality of service while cutting costs, efficient transit network design is essential. But planning a network of public transit routes is a challenging optimization problem. The most successful approaches to date use metaheuristic algorithms to search through the space of possible transit networks by applying low-level heuristics that randomly alter routes in a network. The design of these low-level heuristics has a major impact on the quality of the result. In this paper we use deep reinforcement learning with graph neural nets to learn low-level heuristics for an evolutionary algorithm, instead of designing them manually. These learned heuristics improve the algorithm's results on benchmark synthetic cities with 70 nodes or more, and obtain state-of-the-art results when optimizing operating costs. They also improve upon a simulation of the real transit network in the city of Laval, Canada, by as much as 54% and 18% on two key metrics, and offer cost savings of up to 12% over the city's existing transit network.
4/16/2024