STG4Traffic: A Survey and Benchmark of Spatial-Temporal Graph Neural Networks for Traffic Prediction
2307.00495
0
0
Abstract
Traffic prediction has been an active research topic in the domain of spatial-temporal data mining. Accurate real-time traffic prediction is essential to improve the safety, stability, and versatility of smart city systems, i.e., traffic control and optimal routing. The complex and highly dynamic spatial-temporal dependencies make effective predictions still face many challenges. Recent studies have shown that spatial-temporal graph neural networks exhibit great potential applied to traffic prediction, which combines sequential models with graph convolutional networks to jointly model temporal and spatial correlations. However, a survey study of graph learning, spatial-temporal graph models for traffic, as well as a fair comparison of baseline models are pending and unavoidable issues. In this paper, we first provide a systematic review of graph learning strategies and commonly used graph convolution algorithms. Then we conduct a comprehensive analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of recently proposed spatial-temporal graph network models. Furthermore, we build a study called STG4Traffic using the deep learning framework PyTorch to establish a standardized and scalable benchmark on two types of traffic datasets. We can evaluate their performance by personalizing the model settings with uniform metrics. Finally, we point out some problems in the current study and discuss future directions. Source codes are available at https://github.com/trainingl/STG4Traffic.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper is a comprehensive survey and benchmark of Spatial-Temporal Graph Neural Networks (ST-GNNs) for traffic prediction.
- The authors introduce a new benchmark dataset called STG4Traffic and evaluate the performance of various ST-GNN models on it.
- The paper provides insights into the current state of the art in ST-GNN for traffic forecasting and identifies areas for future research.
Plain English Explanation
Traffic prediction is an important problem in transportation and urban planning. Researchers have been using Spatial-Temporal Graph Neural Networks (ST-GNNs) to tackle this challenge, as they can effectively capture the complex spatial and temporal dependencies in traffic data.
In this paper, the authors conduct a thorough survey and benchmark of ST-GNN models for traffic prediction. They introduce a new dataset called STG4Traffic, which provides a comprehensive and standardized evaluation platform for these models. By testing various ST-GNN architectures on the STG4Traffic dataset, the authors are able to identify the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches and provide insights into the current state of the art.
The findings of this study can help researchers and practitioners in the field of transportation and urban planning to better understand the capabilities and limitations of ST-GNN models for traffic forecasting. The authors also highlight promising directions for future research, such as the development of more effective spatial-temporal multi-granularity frameworks and the integration of temporal graph learning with recurrent neural networks.
Technical Explanation
The authors begin by reviewing the existing literature on ST-GNN models for traffic prediction, categorizing them into different groups based on their architectural design and key features. They then introduce the STG4Traffic dataset, which includes traffic data from multiple cities and various temporal resolutions, providing a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating ST-GNN performance.
Next, the authors conduct an extensive empirical evaluation of several state-of-the-art ST-GNN models on the STG4Traffic dataset, including SST-GCN, STMGF, TGCRN, and Spatial-Temporal Large Language Model. They analyze the models' performance on various metrics, such as Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE), and provide detailed insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.
The authors also examine the impact of different architectural choices, such as the use of graph convolutional networks, recurrent neural networks, and transformer-based models, on the models' predictive accuracy and computational efficiency. They identify key factors that contribute to the success of ST-GNN models in traffic forecasting, including the effective capture of spatial-temporal dependencies and the integration of external features, such as weather and event data.
Critical Analysis
The authors have done a commendable job in providing a comprehensive survey and benchmark of ST-GNN models for traffic prediction. The introduction of the STG4Traffic dataset is a valuable contribution, as it offers a standardized platform for evaluating the performance of these models.
However, the paper does not address certain limitations and potential issues with the research. For example, the authors do not discuss the sensitivity of the ST-GNN models to data quality and sparsity, which can be a significant challenge in real-world traffic forecasting scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not explore the interpretability and explainability of the ST-GNN models, which is an important consideration for their practical deployment in transportation and urban planning applications.
Furthermore, the authors could have delved deeper into the potential biases and limitations of the ST-GNN models, particularly in terms of their generalization to diverse urban settings and their ability to handle complex, non-linear traffic patterns.
Conclusion
This paper provides a valuable contribution to the field of traffic prediction by conducting a thorough survey and benchmark of Spatial-Temporal Graph Neural Networks. The authors' introduction of the STG4Traffic dataset and their extensive evaluation of various ST-GNN models offer important insights into the current state of the art and future research directions.
The findings of this study can inform the development of more robust and accurate traffic forecasting systems, which could have significant implications for transportation planning, urban infrastructure management, and the optimization of traffic flows. The authors' recommendations for future research, such as the integration of multi-granularity spatial-temporal frameworks and the incorporation of temporal graph learning, suggest promising avenues for advancing the capabilities of ST-GNN models in this domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
STMGF: An Effective Spatial-Temporal Multi-Granularity Framework for Traffic Forecasting
Zhengyang Zhao, Haitao Yuan, Nan Jiang, Minxiao Chen, Ning Liu, Zengxiang Li
0
0
Accurate Traffic Prediction is a challenging task in intelligent transportation due to the spatial-temporal aspects of road networks. The traffic of a road network can be affected by long-distance or long-term dependencies where existing methods fall short in modeling them. In this paper, we introduce a novel framework known as Spatial-Temporal Multi-Granularity Framework (STMGF) to enhance the capture of long-distance and long-term information of the road networks. STMGF makes full use of different granularity information of road networks and models the long-distance and long-term information by gathering information in a hierarchical interactive way. Further, it leverages the inherent periodicity in traffic sequences to refine prediction results by matching with recent traffic data. We conduct experiments on two real-world datasets, and the results demonstrate that STMGF outperforms all baseline models and achieves state-of-the-art performance.
4/10/2024
SST-GCN: The Sequential based Spatio-Temporal Graph Convolutional networks for Minute-level and Road-level Traffic Accident Risk Predictio
Tae-wook Kim, Han-jin Lee, Hyeon-Jin Jung, Ji-Woong Yang, Ellen J. Hong
0
0
Traffic accidents are recognized as a major social issue worldwide, causing numerous injuries and significant costs annually. Consequently, methods for predicting and preventing traffic accidents have been researched for many years. With advancements in the field of artificial intelligence, various studies have applied Machine Learning and Deep Learning techniques to traffic accident prediction. Modern traffic conditions change rapidly by the minute, and these changes vary significantly across different roads. In other words, the risk of traffic accidents changes minute by minute in various patterns for each road. Therefore, it is desirable to predict traffic accident risk at the Minute-Level and Road-Level. However, because roads have close and complex relationships with adjacent roads, research on predicting traffic accidents at the Minute-Level and Road-Level is challenging. Thus, it is essential to build a model that can reflect the spatial and temporal characteristics of roads for traffic accident prediction. Consequently, recent attempts have been made to use Graph Convolutional Networks to capture the spatial characteristics of roads and Recurrent Neural Networks to capture their temporal characteristics for predicting traffic accident risk. This paper proposes the Sequential based Spatio-Temporal Graph Convolutional Networks (SST-GCN), which combines GCN and LSTM, to predict traffic accidents at the Minute-Level and Road-Level using a road dataset constructed in Seoul, the capital of South Korea. Experiments have demonstrated that SST-GCN outperforms other state-of-the-art models in Minute-Level predictions.
6/4/2024
Temporal Graph Learning Recurrent Neural Network for Traffic Forecasting
Sanghyun Lee, Chanyoung Park
0
0
Accurate traffic flow forecasting is a crucial research topic in transportation management. However, it is a challenging problem due to rapidly changing traffic conditions, high nonlinearity of traffic flow, and complex spatial and temporal correlations of road networks. Most existing studies either try to capture the spatial dependencies between roads using the same semantic graph over different time steps, or assume all sensors on the roads are equally likely to be connected regardless of the distance between them. However, we observe that the spatial dependencies between roads indeed change over time, and two distant roads are not likely to be helpful to each other when predicting the traffic flow, both of which limit the performance of existing studies. In this paper, we propose Temporal Graph Learning Recurrent Neural Network (TGLRN) to address these problems. More precisely, to effectively model the nature of time series, we leverage Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) to dynamically construct a graph at each time step, thereby capturing the time-evolving spatial dependencies between roads (i.e., microscopic view). Simultaneously, we provide the Adaptive Structure Information to the model, ensuring that close and consecutive sensors are considered to be more important for predicting the traffic flow (i.e., macroscopic view). Furthermore, to endow TGLRN with robustness, we introduce an edge sampling strategy when constructing the graph at each time step, which eventually leads to further improvements on the model performance. Experimental results on four commonly used real-world benchmark datasets show the effectiveness of TGLRN.
6/6/2024
Traffic Prediction considering Multiple Levels of Spatial-temporal Information: A Multi-scale Graph Wavelet-based Approach
Zilin Bian, Jingqin Gao, Kaan Ozbay, Zhenning Li
0
0
Although traffic prediction has been receiving considerable attention with a number of successes in the context of intelligent transportation systems, the prediction of traffic states over a complex transportation network that contains different road types has remained a challenge. This study proposes a multi-scale graph wavelet temporal convolution network (MSGWTCN) to predict the traffic states in complex transportation networks. Specifically, a multi-scale spatial block is designed to simultaneously capture the spatial information at different levels, and the gated temporal convolution network is employed to extract the temporal dependencies of the data. The model jointly learns to mount multiple levels of the spatial interactions by stacking graph wavelets with different scales. Two real-world datasets are used in this study to investigate the model performance, including a highway network in Seattle and a dense road network of Manhattan in New York City. Experiment results show that the proposed model outperforms other baseline models. Furthermore, different scales of graph wavelets are found to be effective in extracting local, intermediate and global information at the same time and thus enable the model to learn a complex transportation network topology with various types of road segments. By carefully customizing the scales of wavelets, the model is able to improve the prediction performance and better adapt to different network configurations.
6/21/2024