Structured Prediction in Online Learning
2406.12366
0
0
🔮
Abstract
We study a theoretical and algorithmic framework for structured prediction in the online learning setting. The problem of structured prediction, i.e. estimating function where the output space lacks a vectorial structure, is well studied in the literature of supervised statistical learning. We show that our algorithm is a generalisation of optimal algorithms from the supervised learning setting, and achieves the same excess risk upper bound also when data are not i.i.d. Moreover, we consider a second algorithm designed especially for non-stationary data distributions, including adversarial data. We bound its stochastic regret in function of the variation of the data distributions.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Discusses a framework for structured prediction in online learning
- Proposes two algorithms: one that generalizes from supervised learning, and another for non-stationary/adversarial data
- Claims the algorithms achieve strong performance guarantees even when data are not i.i.d.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a framework for structured prediction in the context of online learning. Structured prediction is the task of estimating a complex function where the output space lacks a vector structure, such as predicting the parse tree of a sentence or the layout of a web page.
The researchers propose two main algorithms. The first is a generalization of optimal algorithms from the supervised learning setting, and it achieves the same strong performance guarantees even when the data are not independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.).
The second algorithm is designed specifically for handling non-stationary or adversarial data distributions. The paper provides bounds on the algorithm's stochastic regret as a function of how much the data distribution varies over time.
Overall, the work provides a principled online learning framework for structured prediction problems, with strong theoretical guarantees that hold even in challenging, non-i.i.d. settings.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a theoretical and algorithmic framework for structured prediction in the online learning setting. Structured prediction is the problem of estimating a complex function where the output space lacks a vector structure, such as predicting the parse tree of a sentence or the layout of a web page.
The researchers develop two main algorithms. The first is a generalization of optimal algorithms from the supervised learning setting, and it achieves the same excess risk upper bound as those algorithms, even when the data are not i.i.d. The second algorithm is designed specifically for handling non-stationary or adversarial data distributions, and the paper provides bounds on its stochastic regret as a function of the variation in the data distributions over time.
The paper analyzes the algorithms theoretically and also presents experimental results demonstrating their effectiveness.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes valuable contributions to the field of online structured prediction, providing a principled framework with strong theoretical guarantees. However, the analysis and experiments are limited to synthetic or relatively simple real-world datasets. It would be helpful to see the algorithms evaluated on more complex, real-world structured prediction tasks to better understand their practical performance and limitations.
Additionally, the paper does not address the computational efficiency of the proposed algorithms. In many real-world structured prediction problems, the output space can be extremely large, making the algorithms' runtime and memory requirements an important practical consideration.
Future research could explore ways to make the algorithms more scalable and efficient, as well as investigate their performance on a wider range of structured prediction tasks, including those with adversarial or non-stationary data distributions.
Conclusion
This paper presents a theoretical and algorithmic framework for structured prediction in the online learning setting. The researchers develop two main algorithms: one that generalizes from supervised learning, and another designed for non-stationary or adversarial data distributions.
The work provides strong theoretical guarantees for the algorithms' performance, even when the data are not i.i.d. This is an important advance, as many real-world structured prediction problems involve complex, interdependent outputs and non-stationary data.
While the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed framework on synthetic and simple real-world datasets, further research is needed to evaluate the algorithms' scalability and performance on more challenging, real-world structured prediction tasks. Nonetheless, this work represents a valuable contribution to the field of online structured prediction.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
Online Classification with Predictions
Vinod Raman, Ambuj Tewari
0
0
We study online classification when the learner has access to predictions about future examples. We design an online learner whose expected regret is never worse than the worst-case regret, gracefully improves with the quality of the predictions, and can be significantly better than the worst-case regret when the predictions of future examples are accurate. As a corollary, we show that if the learner is always guaranteed to observe data where future examples are easily predictable, then online learning can be as easy as transductive online learning. Our results complement recent work in online algorithms with predictions and smoothed online classification, which go beyond a worse-case analysis by using machine-learned predictions and distributional assumptions respectively.
5/24/2024
Deep Sketched Output Kernel Regression for Structured Prediction
Tamim El Ahmad, Junjie Yang, Pierre Laforgue, Florence d'Alch'e-Buc
0
0
By leveraging the kernel trick in the output space, kernel-induced losses provide a principled way to define structured output prediction tasks for a wide variety of output modalities. In particular, they have been successfully used in the context of surrogate non-parametric regression, where the kernel trick is typically exploited in the input space as well. However, when inputs are images or texts, more expressive models such as deep neural networks seem more suited than non-parametric methods. In this work, we tackle the question of how to train neural networks to solve structured output prediction tasks, while still benefiting from the versatility and relevance of kernel-induced losses. We design a novel family of deep neural architectures, whose last layer predicts in a data-dependent finite-dimensional subspace of the infinite-dimensional output feature space deriving from the kernel-induced loss. This subspace is chosen as the span of the eigenfunctions of a randomly-approximated version of the empirical kernel covariance operator. Interestingly, this approach unlocks the use of gradient descent algorithms (and consequently of any neural architecture) for structured prediction. Experiments on synthetic tasks as well as real-world supervised graph prediction problems show the relevance of our method.
6/14/2024
🔄
An adaptive transfer learning perspective on classification in non-stationary environments
Henry W J Reeve
0
0
We consider a semi-supervised classification problem with non-stationary label-shift in which we observe a labelled data set followed by a sequence of unlabelled covariate vectors in which the marginal probabilities of the class labels may change over time. Our objective is to predict the corresponding class-label for each covariate vector, without ever observing the ground-truth labels, beyond the initial labelled data set. Previous work has demonstrated the potential of sophisticated variants of online gradient descent to perform competitively with the optimal dynamic strategy (Bai et al. 2022). In this work we explore an alternative approach grounded in statistical methods for adaptive transfer learning. We demonstrate the merits of this alternative methodology by establishing a high-probability regret bound on the test error at any given individual test-time, which adapt automatically to the unknown dynamics of the marginal label probabilities. Further more, we give bounds on the average dynamic regret which match the average guarantees of the online learning perspective for any given time interval.
5/29/2024
🔮
Online Structured Prediction with Fenchel--Young Losses and Improved Surrogate Regret for Online Multiclass Classification with Logistic Loss
Shinsaku Sakaue, Han Bao, Taira Tsuchiya, Taihei Oki
0
0
This paper studies online structured prediction with full-information feedback. For online multiclass classification, Van der Hoeven (2020) established emph{finite} surrogate regret bounds, which are independent of the time horizon, by introducing an elegant emph{exploit-the-surrogate-gap} framework. However, this framework has been limited to multiclass classification primarily because it relies on a classification-specific procedure for converting estimated scores to outputs. We extend the exploit-the-surrogate-gap framework to online structured prediction with emph{Fenchel--Young losses}, a large family of surrogate losses that includes the logistic loss for multiclass classification as a special case, obtaining finite surrogate regret bounds in various structured prediction problems. To this end, we propose and analyze emph{randomized decoding}, which converts estimated scores to general structured outputs. Moreover, by applying our decoding to online multiclass classification with the logistic loss, we obtain a surrogate regret bound of $O(| mathbf{U} |_mathrm{F}^2)$, where $mathbf{U}$ is the best offline linear estimator and $| cdot |_mathrm{F}$ denotes the Frobenius norm. This bound is tight up to logarithmic factors and improves the previous bound of $O(d| mathbf{U} |_mathrm{F}^2)$ due to Van der Hoeven (2020) by a factor of $d$, the number of classes.
6/12/2024