Studying Differential Mental Health Expressions in India
2402.11477
0
0
🔎
Abstract
Psychosocial stressors and the symptomatology of mental disorders vary across cultures. However, current understandings of mental health expressions on social media are predominantly derived from studies in WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic) contexts. In this paper, we analyze mental health posts on Reddit made by individuals in India, to identify variations in online depression language specific to the Indian context compared to users from the Rest of the World (ROW). Unlike in Western samples, we observe that mental health discussions in India additionally express sadness, use negation, are present-focused, and are related to work and achievement. Illness is uniquely correlated to India, indicating the association between depression and physical health in Indian patients. Two clinical psychologists validated the findings from social media posts and found 95% of the top 20 topics associated with mental health discussions as prevalent in Indians. Significant linguistic variations in online mental health-related language in India compared to ROW, emphasize the importance of developing precision-targeted interventions that are culturally appropriate.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper examines how mental health discussions on social media differ between India and the rest of the world (ROW).
- It analyzes Reddit posts to identify variations in online depression language specific to the Indian context.
- The findings highlight the importance of developing culturally appropriate mental health interventions.
Plain English Explanation
The way people discuss and express mental health issues can vary significantly across different cultures. However, most of our current understanding of mental health on social media comes from studies conducted in Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic (WEIRD) contexts.
In this paper, the researchers analyze mental health-related posts on Reddit made by individuals in India. They aim to identify how the language used in these discussions differs from the language used by people in the rest of the world (ROW).
The researchers found that, unlike in Western samples, mental health discussions in India also express sadness, use negation, are more focused on the present, and are related to work and achievement. Additionally, they observed that illness is uniquely correlated with depression in the Indian context, suggesting a stronger association between mental and physical health.
Two clinical psychologists validated these findings, confirming that 95% of the top 20 topics associated with mental health discussions are prevalent in the Indian context. These significant linguistic variations in online mental health-related language highlight the importance of developing precision-targeted interventions that are tailored to the specific cultural context.
Technical Explanation
The researchers collected mental health-related posts from the India-based and ROW-based subreddits on Reddit. They then used natural language processing techniques to analyze the linguistic differences between the two groups.
Compared to the ROW, the researchers found that mental health discussions in India:
- Express more sadness: Indian users were more likely to use language related to sadness, such as "sad," "sorrow," and "grief."
- Use more negation: Indian users employed more negation words like "no," "not," and "never" when discussing mental health.
- Are more present-focused: Indian users focused more on the present, using words like "now" and "today," rather than discussing the past or future.
- Are more related to work and achievement: Indian users were more likely to discuss mental health in the context of work, success, and academic performance.
Additionally, the researchers found that illness was uniquely correlated with mental health discussions in the Indian context, suggesting a stronger association between depression and physical health in Indian patients.
Two clinical psychologists validated the findings, confirming that 95% of the top 20 topics associated with mental health discussions are prevalent in the Indian context.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into how mental health expressions can vary across different cultural contexts. By analyzing social media data, the researchers were able to identify nuanced differences in the way people from India discuss and express mental health issues compared to the rest of the world.
However, it's important to note that the study is limited to analyzing Reddit posts, which may not be representative of the broader Indian population. Additionally, the study does not delve into the underlying reasons for these cultural differences, which could be influenced by factors such as societal norms, healthcare systems, and socioeconomic conditions.
Further research would be needed to explore the specific cultural and contextual factors that shape mental health expressions in India and other non-Western societies. Incorporating a more diverse range of data sources and engaging with local mental health experts could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the issue.
Conclusion
The findings of this study highlight the importance of considering cultural context when developing mental health interventions and services. By understanding the unique ways in which individuals from different cultural backgrounds express and discuss mental health issues, we can design more effective and culturally appropriate solutions to address mental health challenges.
This research underscores the need for a global, cross-cultural approach to mental health research and practice, moving beyond the predominant focus on WEIRD contexts. By embracing diversity and incorporating local perspectives, we can work towards building a more inclusive and responsive mental health ecosystem that better serves the needs of people around the world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
Exploring Social Media Posts for Depression Identification: A Study on Reddit Dataset
Nandigramam Sai Harshit, Nilesh Kumar Sahu, Haroon R. Lone
0
0
Depression is one of the most common mental disorders affecting an individual's personal and professional life. In this work, we investigated the possibility of utilizing social media posts to identify depression in individuals. To achieve this goal, we conducted a preliminary study where we extracted and analyzed the top Reddit posts made in 2022 from depression-related forums. The collected data were labeled as depressive and non-depressive using UMLS Metathesaurus. Further, the pre-processed data were fed to classical machine learning models, where we achieved an accuracy of 92.28% in predicting the depressive and non-depressive posts.
5/14/2024
🔎
Diverse Perspectives, Divergent Models: Cross-Cultural Evaluation of Depression Detection on Twitter
Nuredin Ali, Charles Chuankai Zhang, Ned Mayo, Stevie Chancellor
0
0
Social media data has been used for detecting users with mental disorders, such as depression. Despite the global significance of cross-cultural representation and its potential impact on model performance, publicly available datasets often lack crucial metadata related to this aspect. In this work, we evaluate the generalization of benchmark datasets to build AI models on cross-cultural Twitter data. We gather a custom geo-located Twitter dataset of depressed users from seven countries as a test dataset. Our results show that depression detection models do not generalize globally. The models perform worse on Global South users compared to Global North. Pre-trained language models achieve the best generalization compared to Logistic Regression, though still show significant gaps in performance on depressed and non-Western users. We quantify our findings and provide several actionable suggestions to mitigate this issue.
6/26/2024
Context is Important in Depressive Language: A Study of the Interaction Between the Sentiments and Linguistic Markers in Reddit Discussions
Neha Sharma, Kairit Sirts
0
0
Research exploring linguistic markers in individuals with depression has demonstrated that language usage can serve as an indicator of mental health. This study investigates the impact of discussion topic as context on linguistic markers and emotional expression in depression, using a Reddit dataset to explore interaction effects. Contrary to common findings, our sentiment analysis revealed a broader range of emotional intensity in depressed individuals, with both higher negative and positive sentiments than controls. This pattern was driven by posts containing no emotion words, revealing the limitations of the lexicon based approaches in capturing the full emotional context. We observed several interesting results demonstrating the importance of contextual analyses. For instance, the use of 1st person singular pronouns and words related to anger and sadness correlated with increased positive sentiments, whereas a higher rate of present-focused words was associated with more negative sentiments. Our findings highlight the importance of discussion contexts while interpreting the language used in depression, revealing that the emotional intensity and meaning of linguistic markers can vary based on the topic of discussion.
5/29/2024
Mental Disorder Classification via Temporal Representation of Text
Raja Kumar, Kishan Maharaj, Ashita Saxena, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
0
0
Mental disorders pose a global challenge, aggravated by the shortage of qualified mental health professionals. Mental disorder prediction from social media posts by current LLMs is challenging due to the complexities of sequential text data and the limited context length of language models. Current language model-based approaches split a single data instance into multiple chunks to compensate for limited context size. The predictive model is then applied to each chunk individually, and the most voted output is selected as the final prediction. This results in the loss of inter-post dependencies and important time variant information, leading to poor performance. We propose a novel framework which first compresses the large sequence of chronologically ordered social media posts into a series of numbers. We then use this time variant representation for mental disorder classification. We demonstrate the generalization capabilities of our framework by outperforming the current SOTA in three different mental conditions: depression, self-harm, and anorexia, with an absolute improvement of 5% in the F1 score. We investigate the situation where current data instances fall within the context length of language models and present empirical results highlighting the importance of temporal properties of textual data. Furthermore, we utilize the proposed framework for a cross-domain study, exploring commonalities across disorders and the possibility of inter-domain data usage.
6/26/2024