TransGNN: Harnessing the Collaborative Power of Transformers and Graph Neural Networks for Recommender Systems
2308.14355
0
0
🧠
Abstract
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have emerged as promising solutions for collaborative filtering (CF) through the modeling of user-item interaction graphs. The nucleus of existing GNN-based recommender systems involves recursive message passing along user-item interaction edges to refine encoded embeddings. Despite their demonstrated effectiveness, current GNN-based methods encounter challenges of limited receptive fields and the presence of noisy interest-irrelevant connections. In contrast, Transformer-based methods excel in aggregating information adaptively and globally. Nevertheless, their application to large-scale interaction graphs is hindered by inherent complexities and challenges in capturing intricate, entangled structural information. In this paper, we propose TransGNN, a novel model that integrates Transformer and GNN layers in an alternating fashion to mutually enhance their capabilities. Specifically, TransGNN leverages Transformer layers to broaden the receptive field and disentangle information aggregation from edges, which aggregates information from more relevant nodes, thereby enhancing the message passing of GNNs. Additionally, to capture graph structure information effectively, positional encoding is meticulously designed and integrated into GNN layers to encode such structural knowledge into node attributes, thus enhancing the Transformer's performance on graphs. Efficiency considerations are also alleviated by proposing the sampling of the most relevant nodes for the Transformer, along with two efficient sample update strategies to reduce complexity. Furthermore, theoretical analysis demonstrates that TransGNN offers increased expressiveness compared to GNNs, with only a marginal increase in linear complexity. Extensive experiments on five public datasets validate the effectiveness and efficiency of TransGNN.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- GNNs (Graph Neural Networks) have shown promise for collaborative filtering by modeling user-item interaction graphs
- Current GNN-based recommender systems use message passing along user-item edges to refine embeddings
- However, they face challenges like limited receptive fields and noisy connections
- Transformer-based methods excel at adaptive, global information aggregation but struggle with large-scale graph data
Plain English Explanation
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are a type of machine learning model that can work well for collaborative filtering - that is, making recommendations to users based on their past interactions with items. The key idea is to represent the user-item interactions as a graph, and then use a neural network to learn patterns in how users and items are connected.
The way current GNN-based recommender systems work is by passing "messages" back and forth along the edges of the user-item graph. This helps to refine the encoded representations (embeddings) of the users and items. However, these systems can struggle with a couple of issues:
- Limited receptive field: The information a GNN can access is limited to the immediate neighbors of a node, so it may miss important signals from farther away in the graph.
- Noisy connections: The graph may contain connections that don't actually reflect a user's true interests, which can distort the message passing.
In contrast, Transformer-based models are great at aggregating information adaptively and globally. But they have a hard time handling the complex structural information present in large-scale graph data.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new model called TransGNN that combines the strengths of Transformers and GNNs. TransGNN alternates between Transformer layers and GNN layers, where the Transformer layers help to:
- Broaden the receptive field: By aggregating information from more relevant nodes, not just immediate neighbors.
- Disentangle information aggregation from edges: The Transformer can learn to focus on the most important connections, rather than being constrained by the graph structure.
To help the Transformer work effectively on graphs, TransGNN also integrates a carefully designed positional encoding scheme into the GNN layers. This encodes structural information about the graph into the node attributes, which the Transformer can then leverage.
Additionally, the authors propose efficient techniques to reduce the computational complexity of the Transformer, such as node sampling and update strategies. Theoretical analysis shows that TransGNN has greater expressive power than standalone GNNs, with only a modest increase in complexity.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to combining the strengths of Transformers and GNNs for recommender systems. The authors thoughtfully address key limitations of existing GNN-based methods, such as their restricted receptive fields and sensitivity to noisy connections.
However, the paper does not deeply explore the potential downsides or failure modes of the TransGNN model. For example, it would be helpful to understand how the model might perform in the presence of very large or sparse graphs, or if there are particular types of user-item interactions where the Transformer component may not be as effective.
Additionally, while the theoretical analysis is promising, it would be valuable to see more empirical comparisons to state-of-the-art Transformer-based and GNN-based recommenders, such as those discussed in the survey paper on graph neural networks for social recommender systems.
Overall, TransGNN appears to be a promising direction, but further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and potential applications beyond the specific datasets examined in this paper.
Conclusion
The TransGNN model presented in this paper demonstrates a creative approach to leveraging the complementary strengths of Transformers and Graph Neural Networks for collaborative filtering tasks. By integrating Transformer layers to broaden the receptive field and disentangle information aggregation, while using carefully designed positional encoding in the GNN layers, the authors have developed a hybrid architecture that shows improved performance over standalone GNN models.
While the paper does not explore all the potential limitations and failure modes of TransGNN, the core idea of combining these two powerful machine learning techniques is an exciting development that could have broad implications for large-scale recommendation systems and graph-based collaborative filtering more generally. As research in this area continues to evolve, TransGNN serves as a valuable contribution to the growing body of work on using graph neural networks for social recommender systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Neural Causal Graph Collaborative Filtering
Xiangmeng Wang, Qian Li, Dianer Yu, Wei Huang, Guandong Xu
0
0
Graph collaborative filtering (GCF) has gained considerable attention in recommendation systems by leveraging graph learning techniques to enhance collaborative filtering (CF). One classical approach in GCF is to learn user and item embeddings with Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) and utilize these embeddings for CF models. However, existing GCN-based methods are insufficient in generating satisfactory embeddings for CF models. This is because they fail to model complex node dependencies and variable relation dependencies from a given graph, making the learned embeddings fragile to uncover the root causes of user interests. In this work, we propose to integrate causal modeling with the learning process of GCN-based GCF models, leveraging causality-aware graph embeddings to capture complex causal relations in recommendations. We complete the task by 1) Causal Graph conceptualization, 2) Neural Causal Model parameterization and 3) Variational inference for Neural Causal Model. Our Neural Causal Model, called Neural Causal Graph Collaborative Filtering (NCGCF), enables causal modeling for GCN-based GCF to facilitate accurate recommendations. Extensive experiments show that NCGCF provides precise recommendations that align with user preferences. We release our code and processed datasets at https://github.com/Chrystalii/CNGCF.
4/9/2024
🛸
Gransformer: Transformer-based Graph Generation
Ahmad Khajenezhad, Seyed Ali Osia, Mahmood Karimian, Hamid Beigy
0
0
Transformers have become widely used in various tasks, such as natural language processing and machine vision. This paper proposes Gransformer, an algorithm based on Transformer for generating graphs. We modify the Transformer encoder to exploit the structural information of the given graph. The attention mechanism is adapted to consider the presence or absence of edges between each pair of nodes. We also introduce a graph-based familiarity measure between node pairs that applies to both the attention and the positional encoding. This measure of familiarity is based on message-passing algorithms and contains structural information about the graph. Also, this measure is autoregressive, which allows our model to acquire the necessary conditional probabilities in a single forward pass. In the output layer, we also use a masked autoencoder for density estimation to efficiently model the sequential generation of dependent edges connected to each node. In addition, we propose a technique to prevent the model from generating isolated nodes without connection to preceding nodes by using BFS node orderings. We evaluate this method using synthetic and real-world datasets and compare it with related ones, including recurrent models and graph convolutional networks. Experimental results show that the proposed method performs comparatively to these methods.
6/3/2024
🌐
IA-GCN: Interactive Graph Convolutional Network for Recommendation
Yinan Zhang, Pei Wang, Congcong Liu, Xiwei Zhao, Hao Qi, Jie He, Junsheng Jin, Changping Peng, Zhangang Lin, Jingping Shao
0
0
Recently, Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) has become a novel state-of-art for Collaborative Filtering (CF) based Recommender Systems (RS). It is a common practice to learn informative user and item representations by performing embedding propagation on a user-item bipartite graph, and then provide the users with personalized item suggestions based on the representations. Despite effectiveness, existing algorithms neglect precious interactive features between user-item pairs in the embedding process. When predicting a user's preference for different items, they still aggregate the user tree in the same way, without emphasizing target-related information in the user neighborhood. Such a uniform aggregation scheme easily leads to suboptimal user and item representations, limiting the model expressiveness to some extent. In this work, we address this problem by building bilateral interactive guidance between each user-item pair and proposing a new model named IA-GCN (short for InterActive GCN). Specifically, when learning the user representation from its neighborhood, we assign higher attention weights to those neighbors similar to the target item. Correspondingly, when learning the item representation, we pay more attention to those neighbors resembling the target user. This leads to interactive and interpretable features, effectively distilling target-specific information through each graph convolutional operation. Our model is built on top of LightGCN, a state-of-the-art GCN model for CF, and can be combined with various GCN-based CF architectures in an end-to-end fashion. Extensive experiments on three benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of IA-GCN.
5/8/2024
Cluster-based Graph Collaborative Filtering
Fan Liu, Shuai Zhao, Zhiyong Cheng, Liqiang Nie, Mohan Kankanhalli
0
0
Graph Convolution Networks (GCNs) have significantly succeeded in learning user and item representations for recommendation systems. The core of their efficacy is the ability to explicitly exploit the collaborative signals from both the first- and high-order neighboring nodes. However, most existing GCN-based methods overlook the multiple interests of users while performing high-order graph convolution. Thus, the noisy information from unreliable neighbor nodes (e.g., users with dissimilar interests) negatively impacts the representation learning of the target node. Additionally, conducting graph convolution operations without differentiating high-order neighbors suffers the over-smoothing issue when stacking more layers, resulting in performance degradation. In this paper, we aim to capture more valuable information from high-order neighboring nodes while avoiding noise for better representation learning of the target node. To achieve this goal, we propose a novel GCN-based recommendation model, termed Cluster-based Graph Collaborative Filtering (ClusterGCF). This model performs high-order graph convolution on cluster-specific graphs, which are constructed by capturing the multiple interests of users and identifying the common interests among them. Specifically, we design an unsupervised and optimizable soft node clustering approach to classify user and item nodes into multiple clusters. Based on the soft node clustering results and the topology of the user-item interaction graph, we assign the nodes with probabilities for different clusters to construct the cluster-specific graphs. To evaluate the effectiveness of ClusterGCF, we conducted extensive experiments on four publicly available datasets. Experimental results demonstrate that our model can significantly improve recommendation performance.
4/17/2024