Unifying Graph Convolution and Contrastive Learning in Collaborative Filtering
2406.13996
0
0
Abstract
Graph-based models and contrastive learning have emerged as prominent methods in Collaborative Filtering (CF). While many existing models in CF incorporate these methods in their design, there seems to be a limited depth of analysis regarding the foundational principles behind them. This paper bridges graph convolution, a pivotal element of graph-based models, with contrastive learning through a theoretical framework. By examining the learning dynamics and equilibrium of the contrastive loss, we offer a fresh lens to understand contrastive learning via graph theory, emphasizing its capability to capture high-order connectivity. Building on this analysis, we further show that the graph convolutional layers often used in graph-based models are not essential for high-order connectivity modeling and might contribute to the risk of oversmoothing. Stemming from our findings, we introduce Simple Contrastive Collaborative Filtering (SCCF), a simple and effective algorithm based on a naive embedding model and a modified contrastive loss. The efficacy of the algorithm is demonstrated through extensive experiments across four public datasets. The experiment code is available at url{https://github.com/wu1hong/SCCF}. end{abstract}
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new model that combines graph convolution and contrastive learning for collaborative filtering in recommendation systems.
- The model aims to capture both local graph structure and global data distribution to improve recommendation performance.
- The authors conduct experiments on several datasets to demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach compared to existing methods.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about a new way to build recommendation systems, which are algorithms that suggest products or content you might like based on your past behavior and preferences. Recommendation systems are commonly used by online platforms like e-commerce websites and streaming services.
The key idea is to combine two powerful machine learning techniques - graph convolution and contrastive learning - to build a more effective recommendation model. Graph convolution is a way to learn from the connections between items, like how products are related to each other. Contrastive learning is a method for learning useful features by comparing similar and dissimilar data points.
By uniting these approaches, the model can capture both the local structure of the data (how items are connected) and the global distribution of the data (what patterns emerge across all the data). This allows the model to make more informed and personalized recommendations.
The authors test their model on several real-world datasets and show that it outperforms existing recommendation techniques. This suggests their approach is a promising step forward in building better recommendation systems that can provide more relevant and useful suggestions to users.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new model called Unified Graph Contrastive Collaborative Filtering (UGCCF) that combines graph convolution and contrastive learning for collaborative filtering.
The graph convolution component learns representations of users and items by aggregating information from their neighborhoods in the user-item interaction graph. This allows the model to capture the local structure of the data.
The contrastive learning component trains the model to learn representations that maximize the agreement between positive (interacted) user-item pairs and minimize the agreement between negative (non-interacted) pairs. This helps the model learn a global understanding of the data distribution.
The authors design a unified framework that integrates these two components, enabling the model to simultaneously leverage local graph structure and global data distribution for improved recommendation performance.
They evaluate UGCCF on several public datasets and show that it outperforms state-of-the-art collaborative filtering methods, including cluster-based graph collaborative filtering, mixed supervised graph contrastive learning, and neural causal graph collaborative filtering. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of their unified approach.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough study, with a clear explanation of the proposed model and rigorous experimental evaluation. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The paper focuses on static user-item interaction graphs, but in many real-world scenarios, these graphs are dynamic and evolving over time. Extending the model to handle temporal dynamics could be an interesting direction for future work.
-
The authors only consider implicit feedback (e.g., purchases, clicks) in their experiments. Incorporating explicit feedback (e.g., ratings, reviews) could potentially further improve recommendation performance, and this could be explored in future research.
-
While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach, they do not provide much insight into the learned representations or the specific mechanisms by which the model achieves its performance gains. Providing more interpretability and understanding of the model's inner workings could strengthen the contribution.
-
The experiments are conducted on relatively small-scale datasets. Evaluating the scalability of the approach on larger, real-world datasets would be an important next step to assess its practical applicability.
Overall, the paper presents a novel and promising approach to collaborative filtering that combines graph convolution and contrastive learning. The results are compelling, and the proposed model could serve as a useful starting point for further research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new recommendation model called Unified Graph Contrastive Collaborative Filtering (UGCCF) that integrates graph convolution and contrastive learning to capture both local graph structure and global data distribution for improved collaborative filtering performance.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach, which outperforms several state-of-the-art methods on various datasets. While the paper presents a well-designed and thorough study, there are a few potential limitations and areas for future research, such as handling dynamic user-item graphs, incorporating explicit feedback, providing more interpretability, and evaluating scalability on larger datasets.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of recommendation systems by proposing a novel and effective technique that leverages the complementary strengths of graph convolution and contrastive learning. The ideas presented in this work could inspire further advancements in building more accurate and personalized recommendation systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Cluster-based Graph Collaborative Filtering
Fan Liu, Shuai Zhao, Zhiyong Cheng, Liqiang Nie, Mohan Kankanhalli
0
0
Graph Convolution Networks (GCNs) have significantly succeeded in learning user and item representations for recommendation systems. The core of their efficacy is the ability to explicitly exploit the collaborative signals from both the first- and high-order neighboring nodes. However, most existing GCN-based methods overlook the multiple interests of users while performing high-order graph convolution. Thus, the noisy information from unreliable neighbor nodes (e.g., users with dissimilar interests) negatively impacts the representation learning of the target node. Additionally, conducting graph convolution operations without differentiating high-order neighbors suffers the over-smoothing issue when stacking more layers, resulting in performance degradation. In this paper, we aim to capture more valuable information from high-order neighboring nodes while avoiding noise for better representation learning of the target node. To achieve this goal, we propose a novel GCN-based recommendation model, termed Cluster-based Graph Collaborative Filtering (ClusterGCF). This model performs high-order graph convolution on cluster-specific graphs, which are constructed by capturing the multiple interests of users and identifying the common interests among them. Specifically, we design an unsupervised and optimizable soft node clustering approach to classify user and item nodes into multiple clusters. Based on the soft node clustering results and the topology of the user-item interaction graph, we assign the nodes with probabilities for different clusters to construct the cluster-specific graphs. To evaluate the effectiveness of ClusterGCF, we conducted extensive experiments on four publicly available datasets. Experimental results demonstrate that our model can significantly improve recommendation performance.
4/17/2024
👨🏫
Mixed Supervised Graph Contrastive Learning for Recommendation
Weizhi Zhang, Liangwei Yang, Zihe Song, Henry Peng Zou, Ke Xu, Yuanjie Zhu, Philip S. Yu
0
0
Recommender systems (RecSys) play a vital role in online platforms, offering users personalized suggestions amidst vast information. Graph contrastive learning aims to learn from high-order collaborative filtering signals with unsupervised augmentation on the user-item bipartite graph, which predominantly relies on the multi-task learning framework involving both the pair-wise recommendation loss and the contrastive loss. This decoupled design can cause inconsistent optimization direction from different losses, which leads to longer convergence time and even sub-optimal performance. Besides, the self-supervised contrastive loss falls short in alleviating the data sparsity issue in RecSys as it learns to differentiate users/items from different views without providing extra supervised collaborative filtering signals during augmentations. In this paper, we propose Mixed Supervised Graph Contrastive Learning for Recommendation (MixSGCL) to address these concerns. MixSGCL originally integrates the training of recommendation and unsupervised contrastive losses into a supervised contrastive learning loss to align the two tasks within one optimization direction. To cope with the data sparsity issue, instead unsupervised augmentation, we further propose node-wise and edge-wise mixup to mine more direct supervised collaborative filtering signals based on existing user-item interactions. Extensive experiments on three real-world datasets demonstrate that MixSGCL surpasses state-of-the-art methods, achieving top performance on both accuracy and efficiency. It validates the effectiveness of MixSGCL with our coupled design on supervised graph contrastive learning.
4/29/2024
Neural Causal Graph Collaborative Filtering
Xiangmeng Wang, Qian Li, Dianer Yu, Wei Huang, Guandong Xu
0
0
Graph collaborative filtering (GCF) has gained considerable attention in recommendation systems by leveraging graph learning techniques to enhance collaborative filtering (CF). One classical approach in GCF is to learn user and item embeddings with Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) and utilize these embeddings for CF models. However, existing GCN-based methods are insufficient in generating satisfactory embeddings for CF models. This is because they fail to model complex node dependencies and variable relation dependencies from a given graph, making the learned embeddings fragile to uncover the root causes of user interests. In this work, we propose to integrate causal modeling with the learning process of GCN-based GCF models, leveraging causality-aware graph embeddings to capture complex causal relations in recommendations. We complete the task by 1) Causal Graph conceptualization, 2) Neural Causal Model parameterization and 3) Variational inference for Neural Causal Model. Our Neural Causal Model, called Neural Causal Graph Collaborative Filtering (NCGCF), enables causal modeling for GCN-based GCF to facilitate accurate recommendations. Extensive experiments show that NCGCF provides precise recommendations that align with user preferences. We release our code and processed datasets at https://github.com/Chrystalii/CNGCF.
4/9/2024
Collaborative Filtering Based on Diffusion Models: Unveiling the Potential of High-Order Connectivity
Yu Hou, Jin-Duk Park, Won-Yong Shin
0
0
A recent study has shown that diffusion models are well-suited for modeling the generative process of user-item interactions in recommender systems due to their denoising nature. However, existing diffusion model-based recommender systems do not explicitly leverage high-order connectivities that contain crucial collaborative signals for accurate recommendations. Addressing this gap, we propose CF-Diff, a new diffusion model-based collaborative filtering (CF) method, which is capable of making full use of collaborative signals along with multi-hop neighbors. Specifically, the forward-diffusion process adds random noise to user-item interactions, while the reverse-denoising process accommodates our own learning model, named cross-attention-guided multi-hop autoencoder (CAM-AE), to gradually recover the original user-item interactions. CAM-AE consists of two core modules: 1) the attention-aided AE module, responsible for precisely learning latent representations of user-item interactions while preserving the model's complexity at manageable levels, and 2) the multi-hop cross-attention module, which judiciously harnesses high-order connectivity information to capture enhanced collaborative signals. Through comprehensive experiments on three real-world datasets, we demonstrate that CF-Diff is (a) Superior: outperforming benchmark recommendation methods, achieving remarkable gains up to 7.29% compared to the best competitor, (b) Theoretically-validated: reducing computations while ensuring that the embeddings generated by our model closely approximate those from the original cross-attention, and (c) Scalable: proving the computational efficiency that scales linearly with the number of users or items.
4/23/2024