Acquiring Better Load Estimates by Combining Anomaly and Change-point Detection in Power Grid Time-series Measurements
2405.16164
0
0
Abstract
In this paper we present novel methodology for automatic anomaly and switch event filtering to improve load estimation in power grid systems. By leveraging unsupervised methods with supervised optimization, our approach prioritizes interpretability while ensuring robust and generalizable performance on unseen data. Through experimentation, a combination of binary segmentation for change point detection and statistical process control for anomaly detection emerges as the most effective strategy, specifically when ensembled in a novel sequential manner. Results indicate the clear wasted potential when filtering is not applied. The automatic load estimation is also fairly accurate, with approximately 90% of estimates falling within a 10% error margin, with only a single significant failure in both the minimum and maximum load estimates across 60 measurements in the test set. Our methodology's interpretability makes it particularly suitable for critical infrastructure planning, thereby enhancing decision-making processes.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a method for acquiring better load estimates in power grid time-series measurements by combining anomaly and change-point detection.
- The approach integrates anomaly detection and change-point detection techniques to identify significant events that impact power load.
- By detecting these events, the method aims to improve the accuracy of load forecasting and management in power grid systems.
Plain English Explanation
Power grids are complex systems that experience fluctuations in electricity demand over time. Accurately estimating and predicting these power loads is crucial for efficiently managing the grid and avoiding blackouts or other disruptions. However, power load data can be noisy and subject to various anomalies or unexpected changes.
This research proposes a new approach that combines two complementary techniques to better identify and understand these anomalies and changes in power load data. The first technique is anomaly detection, which identifies data points that deviate significantly from the normal patterns in the time series. The second technique is change-point detection, which identifies the specific points in time where the underlying data-generating process seems to change.
By applying both of these techniques to power grid data, the researchers can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the factors influencing power loads. This information can then be used to improve load forecasting models, allowing grid operators to better anticipate and respond to fluctuations in demand. Ultimately, this approach aims to help power grid systems run more efficiently and reliably, reducing the risk of blackouts or other disruptions.
Technical Explanation
The key elements of the paper's approach are as follows:
-
Anomaly Detection: The researchers use a data-driven anomaly detection method to identify unusual data points in the power load time series that deviate significantly from the normal patterns.
-
Change-point Detection: They also apply a context-agnostic change-point detection algorithm to identify the specific points in time where the underlying data-generating process seems to change, indicating significant events that impact power load.
-
Integration: By combining the insights from both the anomaly detection and change-point detection methods, the researchers can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the factors influencing power loads, such as weather events, equipment failures, or changes in consumer behavior.
-
Improved Load Forecasting: The researchers hypothesize that this integrated approach will lead to more accurate load forecasting models, as the identified anomalies and change-points can be used to adjust the models and better anticipate fluctuations in power demand.
The researchers evaluate their approach using real-world power grid data and demonstrate its effectiveness in improving load estimation accuracy compared to traditional methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and promising approach for enhancing power load estimation by leveraging both anomaly and change-point detection techniques. However, some potential limitations and areas for further research are worth noting:
-
Generalizability: The researchers tested their approach on a specific power grid dataset, and it remains to be seen how well it would perform on data from other grid systems with different characteristics or in different geographical regions. Further research may be needed to assess the broader applicability of the method.
-
Computational Complexity: The integration of two separate detection algorithms may increase the computational complexity of the overall approach, potentially impacting its real-time performance or scalability for large-scale power grid systems. Optimizing the implementation or exploring more efficient algorithms could be an area for future investigation.
-
Interpretability: While the combined approach provides more comprehensive insights into power load dynamics, the complexity of the methods may make it challenging to fully interpret the underlying causes of the identified anomalies and change-points. Developing more explainable or transparent techniques could enhance the usability and trust in the system's outputs.
Overall, the researchers have presented a novel and potentially impactful approach for improving power load estimation, which could have significant implications for the efficient and reliable operation of power grid systems. Addressing the identified limitations and exploring further refinements could strengthen the technique and increase its real-world impact.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel method for acquiring better load estimates in power grid time-series measurements by combining anomaly and change-point detection techniques. By integrating these complementary approaches, the researchers aim to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the factors influencing power loads, ultimately leading to more accurate load forecasting models and improved grid management.
The proposed approach has the potential to significantly enhance the efficiency and reliability of power grid systems, reducing the risk of blackouts or other disruptions. While the method shows promise, further research is needed to address potential limitations and optimize its performance for broader real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
A Data Mining-Based Dynamical Anomaly Detection Method for Integrating with an Advance Metering System
Sarit Maitra
0
0
Building operations consume 30% of total power consumption and contribute 26% of global power-related emissions. Therefore, monitoring, and early detection of anomalies at the meter level are essential for residential and commercial buildings. This work investigates both supervised and unsupervised approaches and introduces a dynamic anomaly detection system. The system introduces a supervised Light Gradient Boosting machine and an unsupervised autoencoder with a dynamic threshold. This system is designed to provide real-time detection of anomalies at the meter level. The proposed dynamical system comes with a dynamic threshold based on the Mahalanobis distance and moving averages. This approach allows the system to adapt to changes in the data distribution over time. The effectiveness of the proposed system is evaluated using real-life power consumption data collected from smart metering systems. This empirical testing ensures that the system's performance is validated under real-world conditions. By detecting unusual data movements and providing early warnings, the proposed system contributes significantly to visual analytics and decision science. Early detection of anomalies enables timely troubleshooting, preventing financial losses and potential disasters such as fire incidents.
5/7/2024
Anomaly Detection in Power Grids via Context-Agnostic Learning
SangWoo Park, Amritanshu Pandey
0
0
An important tool grid operators use to safeguard against failures, whether naturally occurring or malicious, involves detecting anomalies in the power system SCADA data. In this paper, we aim to solve a real-time anomaly detection problem. Given time-series measurement values coming from a fixed set of sensors on the grid, can we identify anomalies in the network topology or measurement data? Existing methods, primarily optimization-based, mostly use only a single snapshot of the measurement values and do not scale well with the network size. Recent data-driven ML techniques have shown promise by using a combination of current and historical data for anomaly detection but generally do not consider physical attributes like the impact of topology or load/generation changes on sensor measurements and thus cannot accommodate regular context-variability in the historical data. To address this gap, we propose a novel context-aware anomaly detection algorithm, GridCAL, that considers the effect of regular topology and load/generation changes. This algorithm converts the real-time power flow measurements to context-agnostic values, which allows us to analyze measurement coming from different grid contexts in an aggregate fashion, enabling us to derive a unified statistical model that becomes the basis of anomaly detection. Through numerical simulations on networks up to 2383 nodes, we show that our approach is accurate, outperforming state-of-the-art approaches, and is computationally efficient.
4/12/2024
❗
A Real-time Anomaly Detection Using Convolutional Autoencoder with Dynamic Threshold
Sarit Maitra, Sukanya Kundu, Aishwarya Shankar
0
0
The majority of modern consumer-level energy is generated by real-time smart metering systems. These frequently contain anomalies, which prevent reliable estimates of the series' evolution. This work introduces a hybrid modeling approach combining statistics and a Convolutional Autoencoder with a dynamic threshold. The threshold is determined based on Mahalanobis distance and moving averages. It has been tested using real-life energy consumption data collected from smart metering systems. The solution includes a real-time, meter-level anomaly detection system that connects to an advanced monitoring system. This makes a substantial contribution by detecting unusual data movements and delivering an early warning. Early detection and subsequent troubleshooting can financially benefit organizations and consumers and prevent disasters from occurring.
4/9/2024
Explainable Online Unsupervised Anomaly Detection for Cyber-Physical Systems via Causal Discovery from Time Series
Daniele Meli
0
0
Online unsupervised detection of anomalies is crucial to guarantee the correct operation of cyber-physical systems and the safety of humans interacting with them. State-of-the-art approaches based on deep learning via neural networks achieve outstanding performance at anomaly recognition, evaluating the discrepancy between a normal model of the system (with no anomalies) and the real-time stream of sensor time series. However, large training data and time are typically required, and explainability is still a challenge to identify the root of the anomaly and implement predictive maintainance. In this paper, we use causal discovery to learn a normal causal graph of the system, and we evaluate the persistency of causal links during real-time acquisition of sensor data to promptly detect anomalies. On two benchmark anomaly detection datasets, we show that our method has higher training efficiency, outperforms the accuracy of state-of-the-art neural architectures and correctly identifies the sources of >10 different anomalies. The code is at https://github.com/Isla-lab/causal_anomaly_detection.
6/26/2024