Active Learning for Identifying Disaster-Related Tweets: A Comparison with Keyword Filtering and Generic Fine-Tuning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Compares active learning, keyword filtering, and generic fine-tuning for identifying disaster-related tweets
- Demonstrates the effectiveness of active learning in achieving high performance with minimal labeled data
- Evaluates the trade-offs between different approaches in terms of accuracy, efficiency, and generalizability
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers explore different methods for identifying tweets that are related to disasters. Active learning is a technique where the model selects the most informative unlabeled data points for human annotation, allowing it to learn efficiently with a small amount of labeled data. The researchers compare this approach to keyword filtering and generic fine-tuning, which are more commonly used methods for this task.
The key finding is that active learning outperforms the other approaches, achieving high accuracy with significantly less labeled data. This is particularly valuable in disaster scenarios, where time and resources are often limited. The researchers also discuss the trade-offs between the different methods, such as the accuracy, efficiency, and generalizability of each approach.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates three approaches for identifying disaster-related tweets:
- Active Learning: The model selects the most informative unlabeled data points for human annotation, allowing it to learn efficiently with a small amount of labeled data.
- Keyword Filtering: The model uses a predefined set of keywords to identify relevant tweets.
- Generic Fine-Tuning: The model is fine-tuned on a generic disaster-related dataset to improve its performance.
The researchers compare the performance of these approaches on a named entity recognition and topic modeling-based solution for identifying disaster-related tweets. They evaluate the models' accuracy, efficiency, and generalizability on a dataset of tweets related to various disasters.
The results show that active learning outperforms the other approaches, achieving high accuracy with significantly less labeled data. This is particularly important in disaster scenarios, where time and resources are often limited. The researchers also discuss the trade-offs between the different methods, such as the accuracy, efficiency, and generalizability of each approach.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed comparison of active learning, keyword filtering, and generic fine-tuning for identifying disaster-related tweets. The researchers acknowledge the limitations of their study, such as the potential for dataset bias and the need for further evaluation on a wider range of disaster scenarios.
One potential concern is the reliance on human annotation, which can be time-consuming and prone to inconsistencies. The researchers could have explored ways to automate or semi-automate the annotation process, such as using crowdsourcing or pre-existing disaster-related datasets.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific mechanisms or intuitions behind the superior performance of active learning. Further analysis of the model's decision-making process and the types of data it selects could provide valuable insights for improving active learning approaches in the future.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates the effectiveness of active learning for identifying disaster-related tweets, highlighting its ability to achieve high performance with minimal labeled data. The researchers' comprehensive comparison of different approaches provides valuable insights for researchers and practitioners working on disaster response and social media analysis.
The findings of this study have important implications for the development of efficient and scalable systems for real-time monitoring and analysis of disaster-related information on social media platforms. By leveraging active learning, such systems could be deployed more quickly and with fewer resources, ultimately improving the timeliness and effectiveness of disaster response efforts.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Active Learning for Identifying Disaster-Related Tweets: A Comparison with Keyword Filtering and Generic Fine-Tuning
David Hanny, Sebastian Schmidt, Bernd Resch
Information from social media can provide essential information for emergency response during natural disasters in near real-time. However, it is difficult to identify the disaster-related posts among the large amounts of unstructured data available. Previous methods often use keyword filtering, topic modelling or classification-based techniques to identify such posts. Active Learning (AL) presents a promising sub-field of Machine Learning (ML) that has not been used much in the field of text classification of social media content. This study therefore investigates the potential of AL for identifying disaster-related Tweets. We compare a keyword filtering approach, a RoBERTa model fine-tuned with generic data from CrisisLex, a base RoBERTa model trained with AL and a fine-tuned RoBERTa model trained with AL regarding classification performance. For testing, data from CrisisLex and manually labelled data from the 2021 flood in Germany and the 2023 Chile forest fires were considered. The results show that generic fine-tuning combined with 10 rounds of AL outperformed all other approaches. Consequently, a broadly applicable model for the identification of disaster-related Tweets could be trained with very little labelling effort. The model can be applied to use cases beyond this study and provides a useful tool for further research in social media analysis.
Read more8/20/2024
0
A Named Entity Recognition and Topic Modeling-based Solution for Locating and Better Assessment of Natural Disasters in Social Media
Ayaz Mehmood, Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
Over the last decade, similar to other application domains, social media content has been proven very effective in disaster informatics. However, due to the unstructured nature of the data, several challenges are associated with disaster analysis in social media content. To fully explore the potential of social media content in disaster informatics, access to relevant content and the correct geo-location information is very critical. In this paper, we propose a three-step solution to tackling these challenges. Firstly, the proposed solution aims to classify social media posts into relevant and irrelevant posts followed by the automatic extraction of location information from the posts' text through Named Entity Recognition (NER) analysis. Finally, to quickly analyze the topics covered in large volumes of social media posts, we perform topic modeling resulting in a list of top keywords, that highlight the issues discussed in the tweet. For the Relevant Classification of Twitter Posts (RCTP), we proposed a merit-based fusion framework combining the capabilities of four different models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERT, and ALBERT obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.933 on a benchmark dataset. For the Location Extraction from Twitter Text (LETT), we evaluated four models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERTA, and Electra in an NER framework obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.960. For topic modeling, we used the BERTopic library to discover the hidden topic patterns in the relevant tweets. The experimental results of all the components of the proposed end-to-end solution are very encouraging and hint at the potential of social media content and NLP in disaster management.
Read more5/3/2024
💬
0
CrisisSense-LLM: Instruction Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Multi-label Social Media Text Classification in Disaster Informatics
Kai Yin, Chengkai Liu, Ali Mostafavi, Xia Hu
In the field of crisis/disaster informatics, social media is increasingly being used for improving situational awareness to inform response and relief efforts. Efficient and accurate text classification tools have been a focal area of investigation in crisis informatics. However, current methods mostly rely on single-label text classification models, which fails to capture different insights embedded in dynamic and multifaceted disaster-related social media data. This study introduces a novel approach to disaster text classification by enhancing a pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) through instruction fine-tuning targeted for multi-label classification of disaster-related tweets. Our methodology involves creating a comprehensive instruction dataset from disaster-related tweets, which is then used to fine-tune an open-source LLM, thereby embedding it with disaster-specific knowledge. This fine-tuned model can classify multiple aspects of disaster-related information simultaneously, such as the type of event, informativeness, and involvement of human aid, significantly improving the utility of social media data for situational awareness in disasters. The results demonstrate that this approach enhances the categorization of critical information from social media posts, thereby facilitating a more effective deployment for situational awareness during emergencies. This research paves the way for more advanced, adaptable, and robust disaster management tools, leveraging the capabilities of LLMs to improve real-time situational awareness and response strategies in disaster scenarios.
Read more6/26/2024
🏷️
0
QuakeBERT: Accurate Classification of Social Media Texts for Rapid Earthquake Impact Assessment
Jin Han, Zhe Zheng, Xin-Zheng Lu, Ke-Yin Chen, Jia-Rui Lin
Social media aids disaster response but suffers from noise, hindering accurate impact assessment and decision making for resilient cities, which few studies considered. To address the problem, this study proposes the first domain-specific LLM model and an integrated method for rapid earthquake impact assessment. First, a few categories are introduced to classify and filter microblogs considering their relationship to the physical and social impacts of earthquakes, and a dataset comprising 7282 earthquake-related microblogs from twenty earthquakes in different locations is developed as well. Then, with a systematic analysis of various influential factors, QuakeBERT, a domain-specific large language model (LLM), is developed and fine-tuned for accurate classification and filtering of microblogs. Meanwhile, an integrated method integrating public opinion trend analysis, sentiment analysis, and keyword-based physical impact quantification is introduced to assess both the physical and social impacts of earthquakes based on social media texts. Experiments show that data diversity and data volume dominate the performance of QuakeBERT and increase the macro average F1 score by 27%, while the best classification model QuakeBERT outperforms the CNN- or RNN-based models by improving the macro average F1 score from 60.87% to 84.33%. Finally, the proposed approach is applied to assess two earthquakes with the same magnitude and focal depth. Results show that the proposed approach can effectively enhance the impact assessment process by accurate detection of noisy microblogs, which enables effective post-disaster emergency responses to create more resilient cities.
Read more5/14/2024