Analytical and Empirical Study of Herding Effects in Recommendation Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper provides an analytical and empirical study of herding effects in recommendation systems.
- Herding refers to the tendency of individuals to follow the decisions or opinions of others, even if they contradict their own judgments.
- The researchers investigate how herding can impact the performance of recommendation systems and how it can be mitigated.
Plain English Explanation
Recommendation systems are algorithms that suggest products, content, or services to users based on their preferences and behavior. These systems are widely used by e-commerce sites, streaming platforms, and social media. However, these systems can sometimes be influenced by a phenomenon called "herding".
Herding occurs when people tend to mimic the choices or opinions of others, even if those choices don't align with their own preferences. This can happen when users see what others have chosen or recommended, and then they end up making similar choices, rather than going with their original inclination.
The researchers in this paper wanted to understand how herding can impact the performance of recommendation systems. They conducted both analytical and empirical analyses to study this effect. Their goal was to identify ways to mitigate the influence of herding and improve the accuracy and effectiveness of recommendation systems.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a mathematical model to analyze the impact of herding on recommendation systems. They simulated a scenario where users make choices based on a combination of their own preferences and the recommendations of others.
The model took into account factors like the strength of user preferences, the degree of herding, and the reliability of the recommendation system. The researchers then used this model to explore how different system parameters and user behaviors affect the overall performance of the recommendation system.
In addition to the analytical modeling, the researchers also conducted empirical studies using real-world data from an online platform. They compared the performance of recommendation systems with and without the influence of herding, and explored strategies for mitigating the negative effects of herding.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that herding is a complex phenomenon that can be influenced by various social and psychological factors. While their model provides a valuable theoretical framework for understanding the impact of herding, they recognize that real-world situations may be more nuanced and involve additional factors not accounted for in the model.
Additionally, the empirical analysis was limited to a single platform, so the generalizability of the findings may be constrained. Further research involving diverse platforms and user populations could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the herding effects in recommendation systems.
The researchers also suggest that future work could explore the potential benefits of herding, as it may sometimes lead to positive outcomes, such as the discovery of high-quality content or products that users might not have otherwise encountered.
Conclusion
This study offers an important contribution to the understanding of herding effects in recommendation systems. By combining analytical modeling and empirical analysis, the researchers have demonstrated the significant influence that herding can have on the performance of these systems.
The findings highlight the need for recommendation system designers to consider the potential impact of herding and develop strategies to mitigate its negative effects. This could involve techniques such as diversifying recommendations, providing transparency about the recommendation process, or leveraging user feedback to identify and correct for herding biases.
Overall, this research provides valuable insights that can inform the development of more robust and effective recommendation systems, benefiting both users and the organizations that rely on these tools.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Analytical and Empirical Study of Herding Effects in Recommendation Systems
Hong Xie, Mingze Zhong, Defu Lian, Zhen Wang, Enhong Chen
Online rating systems are often used in numerous web or mobile applications, e.g., Amazon and TripAdvisor, to assess the ground-truth quality of products. Due to herding effects, the aggregation of historical ratings (or historical collective opinion) can significantly influence subsequent ratings, leading to misleading and erroneous assessments. We study how to manage product ratings via rating aggregation rules and shortlisted representative reviews, for the purpose of correcting the assessment error. We first develop a mathematical model to characterize important factors of herding effects in product ratings. We then identify sufficient conditions (via the stochastic approximation theory), under which the historical collective opinion converges to the ground-truth collective opinion of the whole user population. These conditions identify a class of rating aggregation rules and review selection mechanisms that can reveal the ground-truth product quality. We also quantify the speed of convergence (via the martingale theory), which reflects the efficiency of rating aggregation rules and review selection mechanisms. We prove that the herding effects slow down the speed of convergence while an accurate review selection mechanism can speed it up. We also study the speed of convergence numerically and reveal trade-offs in selecting rating aggregation rules and review selection mechanisms. To show the utility of our framework, we design a maximum likelihood algorithm to infer model parameters from ratings, and conduct experiments on rating datasets from Amazon and TripAdvisor. We show that proper recency aware rating aggregation rules can improve the speed of convergence in Amazon and TripAdvisor by 41% and 62% respectively.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Contextual Bandit with Herding Effects: Algorithms and Recommendation Applications
Luyue Xu, Liming Wang, Hong Xie, Mingqiang Zhou
Contextual bandits serve as a fundamental algorithmic framework for optimizing recommendation decisions online. Though extensive attention has been paid to tailoring contextual bandits for recommendation applications, the herding effects in user feedback have been ignored. These herding effects bias user feedback toward historical ratings, breaking down the assumption of unbiased feedback inherent in contextual bandits. This paper develops a novel variant of the contextual bandit that is tailored to address the feedback bias caused by the herding effects. A user feedback model is formulated to capture this feedback bias. We design the TS-Conf (Thompson Sampling under Conformity) algorithm, which employs posterior sampling to balance the exploration and exploitation tradeoff. We prove an upper bound for the regret of the algorithm, revealing the impact of herding effects on learning speed. Extensive experiments on datasets demonstrate that TS-Conf outperforms four benchmark algorithms. Analysis reveals that TS-Conf effectively mitigates the negative impact of herding effects, resulting in faster learning and improved recommendation accuracy.
Read more8/29/2024
0
Preserving Individuality while Following the Crowd: Understanding the Role of User Taste and Crowd Wisdom in Online Product Rating Prediction
Liang Wang, Shubham Jain, Yingtong Dou, Junpeng Wang, Chin-Chia Michael Yeh, Yujie Fan, Prince Aboagye, Yan Zheng, Xin Dai, Zhongfang Zhuang, Uday Singh Saini, Wei Zhang
Numerous algorithms have been developed for online product rating prediction, but the specific influence of user and product information in determining the final prediction score remains largely unexplored. Existing research often relies on narrowly defined data settings, which overlooks real-world challenges such as the cold-start problem, cross-category information utilization, and scalability and deployment issues. To delve deeper into these aspects, and particularly to uncover the roles of individual user taste and collective wisdom, we propose a unique and practical approach that emphasizes historical ratings at both the user and product levels, encapsulated using a continuously updated dynamic tree representation. This representation effectively captures the temporal dynamics of users and products, leverages user information across product categories, and provides a natural solution to the cold-start problem. Furthermore, we have developed an efficient data processing strategy that makes this approach highly scalable and easily deployable. Comprehensive experiments in real industry settings demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. Notably, our findings reveal that individual taste dominates over collective wisdom in online product rating prediction, a perspective that contrasts with the commonly observed wisdom of the crowd phenomenon in other domains. This dominance of individual user taste is consistent across various model types, including the boosting tree model, recurrent neural network (RNN), and transformer-based architectures. This observation holds true across the overall population, within individual product categories, and in cold-start scenarios. Our findings underscore the significance of individual user tastes in the context of online product rating prediction and the robustness of our approach across different model architectures.
Read more9/10/2024
0
Effect of recommending users and opinions on the network connectivity and idea generation process
Sriniwas Pandey, Hiroki Sayama
The growing reliance on online services underscores the crucial role of recommendation systems, especially on social media platforms seeking increased user engagement. This study investigates how recommendation systems influence the impact of personal behavioral traits on social network dynamics. It explores the interplay between homophily, users' openness to novel ideas, and recommendation-driven exposure to new opinions. Additionally, the research examines the impact of recommendation systems on the diversity of newly generated ideas, shedding light on the challenges and opportunities in designing effective systems that balance the exploration of new ideas with the risk of reinforcing biases or filtering valuable, unconventional concepts.
Read more5/24/2024