Anatomical basis of human sex differences in ECG identified by automated torso-cardiac three-dimensional reconstruction
0
🌀
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper examines sex differences in electrocardiogram (ECG) biomarkers and their relationship to underlying cardiac anatomy in healthy and post-myocardial infarction (MI) individuals.
- It introduces a novel computational pipeline for reconstructing 3D torso-ventricular anatomies from standard cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
- The research quantifies how sex differences in ECG measures like QRS duration and ST-segment amplitude are associated with differences in ventricular size and cardiac positioning.
Plain English Explanation
The electrocardiogram (ECG) is a common medical test that measures the electrical activity of the heart. Doctors use ECG results to diagnose and assess risk after a heart attack (myocardial infarction or MI). However, interpreting ECG results can be challenging due to natural variations in heart anatomy and differences between men and women.
Women tend to have a higher rate of missed MI diagnoses and poorer outcomes after a heart attack compared to men. This may be related to sex differences in how the heart's electrical signals are measured on an ECG. For example, women often have shorter QRS durations (the time it takes for the ventricles to contract) and lower ST-segment amplitudes (a measure of electrical activity) on their ECGs.
This study used a new computer system to create 3D models of the torso and heart from MRI scans of over 1,400 healthy people and those who had experienced a heart attack. The researchers found that about half the sex difference in QRS duration could be explained by women having smaller ventricles (the heart's pumping chambers) compared to men. Women also tended to have a more elevated and tilted heart position, which was associated with lower ST-segment amplitudes.
After a heart attack, other ECG changes like altered T-wave amplitude and R-axis deviation were more strongly linked to the women's heart positioning rather than electrical differences compared to men. These findings suggest that any tools using ECG data to diagnose or assess heart health should account for these anatomical sex differences to avoid biased or inaccurate results.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a novel, end-to-end automated pipeline to reconstruct 3D models of the torso and ventricular anatomy from standard cardiac MRI scans. They applied this technique to generate personalized anatomical models for 425 post-MI subjects and 1,051 healthy controls from the UK Biobank dataset.
Regression analyses were then used to quantify the relationships between the extracted torso-ventricular parameters and various ECG biomarkers, allowing the team to investigate sex differences. They found that about half the sex difference in QRS duration, both in healthy ([https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/shape-my-heart-cardiac-models-through-learned]shape-my-heart-cardiac-models-through-learned) and post-MI subjects, could be attributed to women having smaller ventricular volumes.
Similarly, the lower baseline ST-segment amplitude observed in women was associated with their relatively smaller ventricles, as well as a more superior and posterior cardiac positioning compared to men. In the post-MI cohort, changes in T-wave amplitude and R-axis deviation were more strongly linked to the women's posterior and horizontal heart orientation rather than electrophysiological differences, as was the case for men.
These findings highlight the importance of accounting for anatomical sex differences when interpreting ECG data, as reliance on population-averaged norms may lead to biased clinical assessments, particularly for women ([https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/using-explainable-ai-to-investigate-electrocardiogram-changes]using-explainable-ai-to-investigate-electrocardiogram-changes, [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/anomaly-detection-electrocardiograms-advancing-clinical-diagnosis-through]anomaly-detection-electrocardiograms-advancing-clinical-diagnosis-through, [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/personalized-heart-disease-detection-via-ecg-digital]personalized-heart-disease-detection-via-ecg-digital).
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the relationship between sex-specific cardiac anatomy and ECG biomarkers, which could have important implications for improving the accuracy and fairness of ECG-based clinical assessments. However, the authors acknowledge that their analysis is limited to a single, predominantly white population from the UK Biobank, and further research is needed to validate the findings in more diverse cohorts.
Additionally, while the automated torso-ventricular reconstruction pipeline represents a significant technical advancement, its clinical feasibility and scalability for widespread adoption remain to be demonstrated. The authors also note that their regression-based approach does not fully capture the complex, nonlinear interactions between anatomy and electrophysiology ([https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/multi-channel-masked-autoencoder-comprehensive-evaluations-reconstructing]multi-channel-masked-autoencoder-comprehensive-evaluations-reconstructing).
Future studies could explore more sophisticated modeling techniques, such as machine learning-based approaches, to better elucidate these relationships and potentially develop personalized ECG interpretation algorithms that account for individual anatomical variations.
Conclusion
This research highlights the importance of considering sex-based differences in cardiac anatomy when interpreting ECG data, as reliance on population-averaged norms may lead to biased clinical assessments, particularly for women. The novel computational pipeline introduced in this study represents a significant advancement in our ability to quantify the relationships between ECG biomarkers and underlying torso-ventricular structure. These findings have the potential to inform the development of more personalized and equitable ECG-based diagnostic and risk stratification tools, ultimately leading to improved outcomes for all patients.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌀
0
Anatomical basis of human sex differences in ECG identified by automated torso-cardiac three-dimensional reconstruction
Hannah J. Smith, Blanca Rodriguez, Yuling Sang, Marcel Beetz, Robin Choudhury, Vicente Grau, Abhirup Banerjee
Background and Aims: The electrocardiogram (ECG) is routinely used for diagnosis and risk stratification following myocardial infarction (MI), though its interpretation is confounded by anatomical variability and sex differences. Women have a higher incidence of missed MI diagnosis and poorer outcomes following infarction. Sex differences in ECG biomarkers and torso-ventricular anatomy have not been well characterised, largely due to the absence of high-throughput torso reconstruction methods. Methods: This work presents quantification of sex differences in ECG versus anatomical biomarkers in healthy and post-MI subjects, enabled by a novel, end-to-end automated pipeline for torso-ventricular anatomical reconstruction from clinically standard cardiac magnetic resonance imaging. Personalised 3D torso-ventricular reconstructions were generated for 425 post-MI subjects and 1051 healthy controls from the UK Biobank. Regression models were created relating the extracted torso-ventricular and ECG parameters. Results: Half the sex difference in QRS durations is explained by smaller ventricles in women both in healthy ($3.4 pm 1.3$ms of $6.0 pm 1.5$ms) and post-MI ($4.5 pm 1.4$ms of $8.3 pm 2.5$ms) subjects. Lower baseline STj amplitude in women is also associated with smaller ventricles, and more superior and posterior cardiac position. Post-MI T wave amplitude and R axis deviations are more strongly associated with a more posterior and horizontal cardiac position in women rather than electrophysiology as in men. Conclusion: A novel computational pipeline enables the three-dimensional reconstruction of 1476 torso-cardiac geometries of healthy and post-myocardial infarction subjects, quantification of sex and BMI-related differences and association with ECG biomarkers. Any ECG-based tool should be reviewed considering anatomical sex differences to avoid sex-biased outcomes.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Personalized Topology-Informed 12-Lead ECG Electrode Localization from Incomplete Cardiac MRIs for Efficient Cardiac Digital Twins
Lei Li, Hannah Smith, Yilin Lyu, Julia Camps, Blanca Rodriguez, Abhirup Banerjee, Vicente Grau
Cardiac digital twins (CDTs) offer personalized textit{in-silico} cardiac representations for the inference of multi-scale properties tied to cardiac mechanisms. The creation of CDTs requires precise information about the electrode position on the torso, especially for the personalized electrocardiogram (ECG) calibration. However, current studies commonly rely on additional acquisition of torso imaging and manual/semi-automatic methods for ECG electrode localization. In this study, we propose a novel and efficient topology-informed model to fully automatically extract personalized ECG electrode locations from 2D clinically standard cardiac MRIs. Specifically, we obtain the sparse torso contours from the cardiac MRIs and then localize the electrodes from the contours. Cardiac MRIs aim at imaging of the heart instead of the torso, leading to incomplete torso geometry within the imaging. To tackle the missing topology, we incorporate the electrodes as a subset of the keypoints, which can be explicitly aligned with the 3D torso topology. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed model outperforms the time-consuming conventional method in terms of accuracy (Euclidean distance: $1.24 pm 0.293$ cm vs. $1.48 pm 0.362$ cm) and efficiency ($2$~s vs. $30$-$35$~min). We further demonstrate the effectiveness of using the detected electrodes for textit{in-silico} ECG simulation, highlighting their potential for creating accurate and efficient CDT models. The code will be released publicly after the manuscript is accepted for publication.
Read more8/27/2024
📶
0
Shape of my heart: Cardiac models through learned signed distance functions
Jan Verhulsdonk, Thomas Grandits, Francisco Sahli Costabal, Thomas Pinetz, Rolf Krause, Angelo Auricchio, Gundolf Haase, Simone Pezzuto, Alexander Effland
The efficient construction of anatomical models is one of the major challenges of patient-specific in-silico models of the human heart. Current methods frequently rely on linear statistical models, allowing no advanced topological changes, or requiring medical image segmentation followed by a meshing pipeline, which strongly depends on image resolution, quality, and modality. These approaches are therefore limited in their transferability to other imaging domains. In this work, the cardiac shape is reconstructed by means of three-dimensional deep signed distance functions with Lipschitz regularity. For this purpose, the shapes of cardiac MRI reconstructions are learned to model the spatial relation of multiple chambers. We demonstrate that this approach is also capable of reconstructing anatomical models from partial data, such as point clouds from a single ventricle, or modalities different from the trained MRI, such as the electroanatomical mapping (EAM).
Read more5/24/2024
🤖
0
Using explainable AI to investigate electrocardiogram changes during healthy aging -- from expert features to raw signals
Gabriel Ott, Yannik Schaubelt, Juan Miguel Lopez Alcaraz, Wilhelm Haverkamp, Nils Strodthoff
Cardiovascular diseases remain the leading global cause of mortality. Age is an important covariate whose effect is most easily investigated in a healthy cohort to properly distinguish the former from disease-related changes. Traditionally, most of such insights have been drawn from the analysis of electrocardiogram (ECG) feature changes in individuals as they age. However, these features, while informative, may potentially obscure underlying data relationships. In this paper we present the following contributions: (1) We employ a deep-learning model and a tree-based model to analyze ECG data from a robust dataset of healthy individuals across varying ages in both raw signals and ECG feature format. (2) We use explainable AI methods to identify the most discriminative ECG features across age groups.(3) Our analysis with tree-based classifiers reveals age-related declines in inferred breathing rates and identifies notably high SDANN values as indicative of elderly individuals, distinguishing them from younger adults. (4) Furthermore, the deep-learning model underscores the pivotal role of the P-wave in age predictions across all age groups, suggesting potential changes in the distribution of different P-wave types with age. These findings shed new light on age-related ECG changes, offering insights that transcend traditional feature-based approaches.
Read more4/23/2024