Anatomizing Deep Learning Inference in Web Browsers
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the impact of running deep learning models directly in web browsers on the user experience and performance.
- Researchers evaluated the performance and quality of experience for users when deep learning inference is performed on the client-side rather than the server-side.
- The study looked at factors like latency, energy consumption, and end-user perception when using in-browser deep learning.
Plain English Explanation
The paper investigates what happens when deep learning models are run directly inside web browsers, rather than on remote servers. Deep learning is a type of artificial intelligence that can perform advanced tasks like image recognition or language understanding. Traditionally, these models run on powerful servers in the cloud, with the browser just displaying the results.
The researchers wanted to understand how running the deep learning models directly on the user's device (their web browser) impacts the overall experience. They looked at things like:
- Latency - How quickly the model can process the data and return results
- Energy consumption - How much battery power is used by the in-browser model
- User perception - Whether people notice a difference in quality or responsiveness
The goal was to see if bringing deep learning "to the edge" (i.e. the user's device) has benefits in terms of performance and user experience, or if the tradeoffs outweigh the advantages.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing background on the trend towards performing deep learning inference directly on client devices, rather than relying solely on server-side processing. This "edge computing" approach can reduce latency and bandwidth requirements, but introduces new challenges around model size, hardware heterogeneity, and energy efficiency.
To evaluate the impact of in-browser deep learning, the researchers developed a benchmark suite that allows them to run various deep learning tasks directly within a web browser. This includes image classification, object detection, and natural language processing models. They measured metrics like inference time, energy consumption, and user-perceived quality across different hardware configurations and network conditions.
The results show that in-browser deep learning can achieve reasonable performance, with inference times often under 100ms even on mid-range devices. However, energy usage can be high, potentially draining a smartphone's battery quickly. The user experience was generally positive, with participants reporting little difference in quality compared to server-side inference, though some latency issues were noted.
The paper discusses tradeoffs and design considerations for deploying production deep learning models in web browsers. Factors like model compression, hardware acceleration, and adaptive load balancing between client and server are highlighted as important areas for future work.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough, empirical evaluation of the challenges and opportunities around running deep learning models directly in web browsers. The benchmark suite and test scenarios seem well-designed to capture realistic usage conditions.
That said, the study has some limitations. The number and diversity of tested devices and models is relatively constrained, so the findings may not generalize fully to all possible browser-based deep learning use cases. Additionally, the user experience evaluation relied on self-reported feedback, which can be subjective.
Further research is needed to explore more advanced techniques for optimizing in-browser deep learning, such as model partitioning, adaptive offloading, and specialized hardware acceleration. The long-term viability of this approach will also depend on continued improvements in web platform capabilities and device performance.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution by shining a light on an emerging area of AI deployment. The insights gained can help guide developers as they seek to bring the power of deep learning into the browser, balancing performance, efficiency, and user experience.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates that running deep learning models directly in web browsers is a feasible, if not always optimal, approach. While in-browser inference can achieve reasonable performance, there are notable tradeoffs in terms of energy usage and potential latency issues.
The findings suggest that in-browser deep learning may be most suitable for use cases where the benefits of low latency, reduced bandwidth, and enhanced user privacy outweigh the downsides. Continued advancements in areas like model optimization and hardware acceleration could further improve the viability of this approach over time.
Ultimately, this paper highlights the importance of holistically evaluating the user experience and system-level implications when deploying AI models, rather than just focusing on raw technical metrics. As the field of AI continues to evolve, such nuanced, empirical studies will be crucial for guiding the development of responsible, effective, and user-friendly applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Anatomizing Deep Learning Inference in Web Browsers
Qipeng Wang, Shiqi Jiang, Zhenpeng Chen, Xu Cao, Yuanchun Li, Aoyu Li, Yun Ma, Ting Cao, Xuanzhe Liu
Web applications have increasingly adopted Deep Learning (DL) through in-browser inference, wherein DL inference performs directly within Web browsers. The actual performance of in-browser inference and its impacts on the quality of experience (QoE) remain unexplored, and urgently require new QoE measurements beyond traditional ones, e.g., mainly focusing on page load time. To bridge this gap, we make the first comprehensive performance measurement of in-browser inference to date. Our approach proposes new metrics to measure in-browser inference: responsiveness, smoothness, and inference accuracy. Our extensive analysis involves 9 representative DL models across Web browsers of 50 popular PC devices and 20 mobile devices. The results reveal that in-browser inference exhibits a substantial latency gap, averaging 16.9 times slower on CPU and 4.9 times slower on GPU compared to native inference on PC devices. The gap on mobile CPU and mobile GPU is 15.8 times and 7.8 times, respectively. Furthermore, we identify contributing factors to such latency gap, including underutilized hardware instruction sets, inherent overhead in the runtime environment, resource contention within the browser, and inefficiencies in software libraries and GPU abstractions. Additionally, in-browser inference imposes significant memory demands, at times exceeding 334.6 times the size of the DL models themselves, partly attributable to suboptimal memory management. We also observe that in-browser inference leads to a significant 67.2% increase in the time it takes for GUI components to render within Web browsers, significantly affecting the overall user QoE of Web applications reliant on this technology
Read more7/26/2024
🤿
0
Empowering In-Browser Deep Learning Inference on Edge Devices with Just-in-Time Kernel Optimizations
Fucheng Jia, Shiqi Jiang, Ting Cao, Wei Cui, Tianrui Xia, Xu Cao, Yuanchun Li, Deyu Zhang, Ju Ren, Yunxin Liu, Lili Qiu, Mao Yang
Web is increasingly becoming the primary platform to deliver AI services onto edge devices, making in-browser deep learning (DL) inference more prominent. Nevertheless, the heterogeneity of edge devices, combined with the underdeveloped state of Web hardware acceleration practices, hinders current in-browser inference from achieving its full performance potential on target devices. To address this issue, this paper presents the pioneering inbrowser inference system, nnJIT, which enables just-in-time (JIT) auto-generation of optimized computing kernels for edge devices. nnJIT is built upon two novel techniques that significantly reduce kernel search and compilation overhead while improving performance firmly: Tensor-Web Compiling Co-Design lowers compiling costs by around 100X through eliminating redundant and ineffective compiling passes; Web-Specific Lite Kernel Optimization Space reduces kernel tuning costs by focusing on Web programming requirements and efficient device resource utilization, pruning the optimization space from millions to only dozens. nnJIT is evaluated for modern models, e.g., BART, T5, and Llama 2, on a range of edge devices including laptops and smartphones using different browsers and hardware from ARM, Intel, AMD and Nvidia. The results show that nnJIT can achieve up to 8.2X faster within 30 seconds compared to the existing baselines.
Read more7/9/2024
🤿
0
Deep Learning Inference on Heterogeneous Mobile Processors: Potentials and Pitfalls
Sicong Liu, Wentao Zhou, Zimu Zhou, Bin Guo, Minfan Wang, Cheng Fang, Zheng Lin, Zhiwen Yu
There is a growing demand to deploy computation-intensive deep learning (DL) models on resource-constrained mobile devices for real-time intelligent applications. Equipped with a variety of processing units such as CPUs, GPUs, and NPUs, the mobile devices hold potential to accelerate DL inference via parallel execution across heterogeneous processors. Various efficient parallel methods have been explored to optimize computation distribution, achieve load balance, and minimize communication cost across processors. Yet their practical effectiveness in the dynamic and diverse real-world mobile environment is less explored. This paper presents a holistic empirical study to assess the capabilities and challenges associated with parallel DL inference on heterogeneous mobile processors. Through carefully designed experiments covering various DL models, mobile software/hardware environments, workload patterns, and resource availability, we identify limitations of existing techniques and highlight opportunities for cross-level optimization.
Read more5/6/2024
0
Hints-In-Browser: Benchmarking Language Models for Programming Feedback Generation
Nachiket Kotalwar, Alkis Gotovos, Adish Singla
Generative AI and large language models hold great promise in enhancing programming education by generating individualized feedback and hints for learners. Recent works have primarily focused on improving the quality of generated feedback to achieve human tutors' quality. While quality is an important performance criterion, it is not the only criterion to optimize for real-world educational deployments. In this paper, we benchmark language models for programming feedback generation across several performance criteria, including quality, cost, time, and data privacy. The key idea is to leverage recent advances in the new paradigm of in-browser inference that allow running these models directly in the browser, thereby providing direct benefits across cost and data privacy. To boost the feedback quality of small models compatible with in-browser inference engines, we develop a fine-tuning pipeline based on GPT-4 generated synthetic data. We showcase the efficacy of fine-tuned Llama3-8B and Phi3-3.8B 4-bit quantized models using WebLLM's in-browser inference engine on three different Python programming datasets. We will release the full implementation along with a web app and datasets to facilitate further research on in-browser language models.
Read more6/10/2024