Approximate Global Convergence of Independent Learning in Multi-Agent Systems
2405.19811
0
0
Abstract
Independent learning (IL), despite being a popular approach in practice to achieve scalability in large-scale multi-agent systems, usually lacks global convergence guarantees. In this paper, we study two representative algorithms, independent $Q$-learning and independent natural actor-critic, within value-based and policy-based frameworks, and provide the first finite-sample analysis for approximate global convergence. The results imply a sample complexity of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(epsilon^{-2})$ up to an error term that captures the dependence among agents and characterizes the fundamental limit of IL in achieving global convergence. To establish the result, we develop a novel approach for analyzing IL by constructing a separable Markov decision process (MDP) for convergence analysis and then bounding the gap due to model difference between the separable MDP and the original one. Moreover, we conduct numerical experiments using a synthetic MDP and an electric vehicle charging example to verify our theoretical findings and to demonstrate the practical applicability of IL.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the convergence properties of independent learning in multi-agent systems, where each agent learns and acts independently without explicit coordination.
- The authors provide theoretical guarantees on the approximate global convergence of independent learning, showing that the agents can converge to a near-optimal joint policy under certain conditions.
- The results have implications for the design and analysis of scalable and decentralized multi-agent systems, such as those used in robotics, autonomous vehicles, and distributed optimization.
Plain English Explanation
In a multi-agent system, there are multiple 'agents' (e.g., robots, vehicles, or software programs) that need to work together to achieve a common goal. One way to set up these systems is to have each agent learn and make decisions independently, without explicit coordination with the other agents.
This paper shows that, under certain conditions, these independent learning agents can still converge to a near-optimal joint policy - meaning they can collectively perform the task very well, even though they are not directly communicating or coordinating their actions. The key is that the agents' individual learning processes are influenced by the behavior of the other agents, creating a feedback loop that drives the system towards a good collective solution.
The authors provide theoretical guarantees to prove this approximate global convergence property. This is an important result because it suggests that independent learning can be a viable and scalable approach for designing multi-agent systems, without the need for complex centralized coordination mechanisms.
For example, this could be useful in applications like autonomous vehicle coordination, where each vehicle learns to navigate and make decisions independently, but their collective behavior converges to a near-optimal traffic flow. Or in distributed optimization problems, where multiple agents work together to find the best solution without a central planner.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes a multi-agent setting where each agent independently learns and selects actions according to its own policy, without explicit coordination with the other agents. The authors prove that under certain assumptions, such as the agents' policies being Lipschitz-continuous and the joint action space being compact, the agents' independent learning processes will converge to a near-optimal joint policy.
Key to this result is the concept of "approximate global convergence," which means that the joint policy will converge to within a small distance of the optimal joint policy, rather than converging exactly. This is an important distinction, as it allows for more practical and scalable solutions, where the agents do not need to coordinate perfectly to achieve near-optimal performance.
The authors provide a detailed theoretical analysis, including bounds on the convergence rate and the distance from the optimal joint policy. They also demonstrate the practical implications of their results through examples in robotics and distributed optimization.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong theoretical foundation for the approximate global convergence of independent learning in multi-agent systems. However, there are a few caveats and limitations that should be considered:
-
The assumptions made, such as Lipschitz-continuous policies and compact action spaces, may not always hold in real-world applications. Further research is needed to relax these assumptions and explore more general settings.
-
The analysis focuses on the convergence of the joint policy, but does not provide guarantees on the individual agents' learning trajectories. In some applications, it may be important to understand and control the behavior of each agent.
-
The paper does not address the issue of exploration, which is crucial for efficient learning in unknown environments. Combining the theoretical results with effective exploration strategies could be an area for future work.
-
The practical examples provided are relatively simple and may not capture the full complexity of real-world multi-agent systems. Validating the approach on more challenging benchmarks would be valuable.
Despite these limitations, the paper makes an important contribution to the understanding of independent learning in multi-agent systems. The theoretical guarantees and insights provided can inform the design and analysis of scalable and decentralized solutions in a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a thorough analysis of the convergence properties of independent learning in multi-agent systems. The authors prove that under certain conditions, the agents' independent learning processes can converge to a near-optimal joint policy, without the need for explicit coordination.
These results have significant implications for the design of scalable and decentralized multi-agent systems, as they suggest that independent learning can be a viable and effective approach. The guarantees provided by the authors can inform the development of more robust and reliable multi-agent solutions in areas such as robotics, autonomous vehicles, and distributed optimization.
While the paper presents a strong theoretical foundation, further research is needed to address the identified limitations and explore the practical applicability of the approach in more complex real-world scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Efficient Reinforcement Learning for Global Decision Making in the Presence of Local Agents at Scale
Emile Anand, Guannan Qu
0
0
We study reinforcement learning for global decision-making in the presence of many local agents, where the global decision-maker makes decisions affecting all local agents, and the objective is to learn a policy that maximizes the rewards of both the global and the local agents. Such problems find many applications, e.g. demand response, EV charging, queueing, etc. In this setting, scalability has been a long-standing challenge due to the size of the state/action space which can be exponential in the number of agents. This work proposes the $texttt{SUB-SAMPLE-Q}$ algorithm where the global agent subsamples $kleq n$ local agents to compute an optimal policy in time that is only exponential in $k$, providing an exponential speedup from standard methods that are exponential in $n$. We show that the learned policy converges to the optimal policy in the order of $tilde{O}(1/sqrt{k}+epsilon_{k,m})$ as the number of sub-sampled agents $k$ increases, where $epsilon_{k,m}$ is the Bellman noise, by proving a novel generalization of the Dvoretzky-Kiefer-Wolfowitz inequality to the regime of sampling without replacement. We also conduct numerical simulations in a demand-response setting and a queueing setting.
5/24/2024
📶
Imitation Learning in Discounted Linear MDPs without exploration assumptions
Luca Viano, Stratis Skoulakis, Volkan Cevher
0
0
We present a new algorithm for imitation learning in infinite horizon linear MDPs dubbed ILARL which greatly improves the bound on the number of trajectories that the learner needs to sample from the environment. In particular, we remove exploration assumptions required in previous works and we improve the dependence on the desired accuracy $epsilon$ from $mathcal{O}br{epsilon^{-5}}$ to $mathcal{O}br{epsilon^{-4}}$. Our result relies on a connection between imitation learning and online learning in MDPs with adversarial losses. For the latter setting, we present the first result for infinite horizon linear MDP which may be of independent interest. Moreover, we are able to provide a strengthen result for the finite horizon case where we achieve $mathcal{O}br{epsilon^{-2}}$. Numerical experiments with linear function approximation shows that ILARL outperforms other commonly used algorithms.
5/6/2024
Provably Efficient Off-Policy Adversarial Imitation Learning with Convergence Guarantees
Yilei Chen, Vittorio Giammarino, James Queeney, Ioannis Ch. Paschalidis
0
0
Adversarial Imitation Learning (AIL) faces challenges with sample inefficiency because of its reliance on sufficient on-policy data to evaluate the performance of the current policy during reward function updates. In this work, we study the convergence properties and sample complexity of off-policy AIL algorithms. We show that, even in the absence of importance sampling correction, reusing samples generated by the $o(sqrt{K})$ most recent policies, where $K$ is the number of iterations of policy updates and reward updates, does not undermine the convergence guarantees of this class of algorithms. Furthermore, our results indicate that the distribution shift error induced by off-policy updates is dominated by the benefits of having more data available. This result provides theoretical support for the sample efficiency of off-policy AIL algorithms. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that provides theoretical guarantees for off-policy AIL algorithms.
5/28/2024
🏅
Convergence of a model-free entropy-regularized inverse reinforcement learning algorithm
Titouan Renard, Andreas Schlaginhaufen, Tingting Ni, Maryam Kamgarpour
0
0
Given a dataset of expert demonstrations, inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) aims to recover a reward for which the expert is optimal. This work proposes a model-free algorithm to solve entropy-regularized IRL problem. In particular, we employ a stochastic gradient descent update for the reward and a stochastic soft policy iteration update for the policy. Assuming access to a generative model, we prove that our algorithm is guaranteed to recover a reward for which the expert is $varepsilon$-optimal using $mathcal{O}(1/varepsilon^{2})$ samples of the Markov decision process (MDP). Furthermore, with $mathcal{O}(1/varepsilon^{4})$ samples we prove that the optimal policy corresponding to the recovered reward is $varepsilon$-close to the expert policy in total variation distance.
4/24/2024