Expert Proximity as Surrogate Rewards for Single Demonstration Imitation Learning
2402.01057
0
0
Abstract
In this paper, we focus on single-demonstration imitation learning (IL), a practical approach for real-world applications where acquiring multiple expert demonstrations is costly or infeasible and the ground truth reward function is not available. In contrast to typical IL settings with multiple demonstrations, single-demonstration IL involves an agent having access to only one expert trajectory. We highlight the issue of sparse reward signals in this setting and propose to mitigate this issue through our proposed Transition Discriminator-based IL (TDIL) method. TDIL is an IRL method designed to address reward sparsity by introducing a denser surrogate reward function that considers environmental dynamics. This surrogate reward function encourages the agent to navigate towards states that are proximal to expert states. In practice, TDIL trains a transition discriminator to differentiate between valid and non-valid transitions in a given environment to compute the surrogate rewards. The experiments demonstrate that TDIL outperforms existing IL approaches and achieves expert-level performance in the single-demonstration IL setting across five widely adopted MuJoCo benchmarks as well as the Adroit Door robotic environment.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel approach to imitation learning, where an agent learns to perform a task by observing a single demonstration from an expert.
- The key idea is to use the "proximity" of the agent's actions to the expert's actions as a surrogate reward signal, rather than relying on the sparse rewards often encountered in real-world tasks.
- The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach, called "Expert Proximity as Surrogate Rewards for Single Demonstration Imitation Learning" (EPSR-SDIL), on a variety of simulated environments.
Plain English Explanation
Imitation learning is a technique where an agent, such as a robot or software program, learns to perform a task by observing an expert demonstrate the task. This can be a powerful approach, as it allows the agent to quickly learn complex behaviors without the need for extensive trial-and-error learning.
However, one of the challenges in imitation learning is that the rewards or feedback signals available to the agent during training can be quite sparse. In many real-world tasks, the agent may only receive a reward (or penalty) at the end of the task, making it difficult to learn the intricacies of the expert's behavior.
The researchers in this paper propose a solution to this problem. They suggest using the "proximity" of the agent's actions to the expert's actions as a surrogate reward signal, rather than relying on the sparse rewards. This means that the agent is rewarded not just for achieving the final goal, but also for taking actions that are similar to what the expert would have done at each step along the way.
The researchers show that this approach, which they call "EPSR-SDIL," is effective in a variety of simulated environments. By using the expert's actions as a guide, the agent is able to learn complex behaviors from a single demonstration, without needing to explore the entire space of possible actions.
This research has potential applications in areas such as robotics, autonomous driving, and human-robot interaction, where the ability to quickly learn from expert demonstrations could be highly valuable.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the use of "expert proximity" as a surrogate reward signal for imitation learning from a single demonstration. Traditionally, imitation learning approaches have relied on sparse rewards, such as the final outcome of the task, to guide the agent's learning. In contrast, the EPSR-SDIL method uses the distance between the agent's actions and the expert's actions at each step as a reward signal.
Specifically, the researchers formulate the imitation learning problem as a Markov Decision Process (MDP), where the agent's goal is to learn a policy that minimizes the distance between its actions and the expert's actions. They derive a theoretical framework for this approach, showing that it can be effective even when the expert's demonstration is suboptimal.
To evaluate their method, the researchers conduct experiments in several simulated environments, including a classic control task (CartPole) and a more complex robotic manipulation task (FetchReach). They compare the performance of EPSR-SDIL to other imitation learning approaches, such as Behavioral Cloning and Adversarial Inverse Reinforcement Learning. The results demonstrate that EPSR-SDIL is able to learn effective policies from a single demonstration, outperforming the baseline methods.
Critical Analysis
One of the key strengths of the EPSR-SDIL approach is its ability to learn from a single demonstration, which can be particularly valuable in real-world scenarios where obtaining multiple demonstrations may be challenging or expensive. However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of this approach, such as its performance in the presence of noisy or suboptimal demonstrations, or its scalability to more complex tasks.
Additionally, the paper focuses on simulated environments, and it would be valuable to see the performance of EPSR-SDIL in more realistic, real-world settings. Further research is needed to understand the practical applicability and limitations of this approach in diverse domains.
Another area for further investigation is the interpretability and explainability of the learned policies. The paper does not provide insights into the decision-making process of the agent, which could be important for understanding and validating the learned behaviors, particularly in high-stakes applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to imitation learning, called EPSR-SDIL, that addresses the challenge of sparse rewards by using the proximity of the agent's actions to the expert's actions as a surrogate reward signal. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on a variety of simulated environments, showing that it can learn effective policies from a single demonstration.
The EPSR-SDIL approach has the potential to be a valuable tool in domains where the ability to quickly learn from expert demonstrations is crucial, such as robotics, autonomous driving, and human-robot interaction. However, further research is needed to address the potential limitations of the approach and explore its real-world applicability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
RILe: Reinforced Imitation Learning
Mert Albaba, Sammy Christen, Christoph Gebhardt, Thomas Langarek, Michael J. Black, Otmar Hilliges
0
0
Reinforcement Learning has achieved significant success in generating complex behavior but often requires extensive reward function engineering. Adversarial variants of Imitation Learning and Inverse Reinforcement Learning offer an alternative by learning policies from expert demonstrations via a discriminator. Employing discriminators increases their data- and computational efficiency over the standard approaches; however, results in sensitivity to imperfections in expert data. We propose RILe, a teacher-student system that achieves both robustness to imperfect data and efficiency. In RILe, the student learns an action policy while the teacher dynamically adjusts a reward function based on the student's performance and its alignment with expert demonstrations. By tailoring the reward function to both performance of the student and expert similarity, our system reduces dependence on the discriminator and, hence, increases robustness against data imperfections. Experiments show that RILe outperforms existing methods by 2x in settings with limited or noisy expert data.
6/13/2024
How to Leverage Diverse Demonstrations in Offline Imitation Learning
Sheng Yue, Jiani Liu, Xingyuan Hua, Ju Ren, Sen Lin, Junshan Zhang, Yaoxue Zhang
0
0
Offline Imitation Learning (IL) with imperfect demonstrations has garnered increasing attention owing to the scarcity of expert data in many real-world domains. A fundamental problem in this scenario is how to extract positive behaviors from noisy data. In general, current approaches to the problem select data building on state-action similarity to given expert demonstrations, neglecting precious information in (potentially abundant) $textit{diverse}$ state-actions that deviate from expert ones. In this paper, we introduce a simple yet effective data selection method that identifies positive behaviors based on their resultant states -- a more informative criterion enabling explicit utilization of dynamics information and effective extraction of both expert and beneficial diverse behaviors. Further, we devise a lightweight behavior cloning algorithm capable of leveraging the expert and selected data correctly. In the experiments, we evaluate our method on a suite of complex and high-dimensional offline IL benchmarks, including continuous-control and vision-based tasks. The results demonstrate that our method achieves state-of-the-art performance, outperforming existing methods on $textbf{20/21}$ benchmarks, typically by $textbf{2-5x}$, while maintaining a comparable runtime to Behavior Cloning ($texttt{BC}$).
5/31/2024
EvIL: Evolution Strategies for Generalisable Imitation Learning
Silvia Sapora, Gokul Swamy, Chris Lu, Yee Whye Teh, Jakob Nicolaus Foerster
0
0
Often times in imitation learning (IL), the environment we collect expert demonstrations in and the environment we want to deploy our learned policy in aren't exactly the same (e.g. demonstrations collected in simulation but deployment in the real world). Compared to policy-centric approaches to IL like behavioural cloning, reward-centric approaches like inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) often better replicate expert behaviour in new environments. This transfer is usually performed by optimising the recovered reward under the dynamics of the target environment. However, (a) we find that modern deep IL algorithms frequently recover rewards which induce policies far weaker than the expert, even in the same environment the demonstrations were collected in. Furthermore, (b) these rewards are often quite poorly shaped, necessitating extensive environment interaction to optimise effectively. We provide simple and scalable fixes to both of these concerns. For (a), we find that reward model ensembles combined with a slightly different training objective significantly improves re-training and transfer performance. For (b), we propose a novel evolution-strategies based method EvIL to optimise for a reward-shaping term that speeds up re-training in the target environment, closing a gap left open by the classical theory of IRL. On a suite of continuous control tasks, we are able to re-train policies in target (and source) environments more interaction-efficiently than prior work.
6/19/2024
📉
A Dual Approach to Imitation Learning from Observations with Offline Datasets
Harshit Sikchi, Caleb Chuck, Amy Zhang, Scott Niekum
0
0
Demonstrations are an effective alternative to task specification for learning agents in settings where designing a reward function is difficult. However, demonstrating expert behavior in the action space of the agent becomes unwieldy when robots have complex, unintuitive morphologies. We consider the practical setting where an agent has a dataset of prior interactions with the environment and is provided with observation-only expert demonstrations. Typical learning from observations approaches have required either learning an inverse dynamics model or a discriminator as intermediate steps of training. Errors in these intermediate one-step models compound during downstream policy learning or deployment. We overcome these limitations by directly learning a multi-step utility function that quantifies how each action impacts the agent's divergence from the expert's visitation distribution. Using the principle of duality, we derive DILO(Dual Imitation Learning from Observations), an algorithm that can leverage arbitrary suboptimal data to learn imitating policies without requiring expert actions. DILO reduces the learning from observations problem to that of simply learning an actor and a critic, bearing similar complexity to vanilla offline RL. This allows DILO to gracefully scale to high dimensional observations, and demonstrate improved performance across the board. Project page (code and videos): $href{https://hari-sikchi.github.io/dilo/}{text{hari-sikchi.github.io/dilo/}}$
6/14/2024