Asynchronous Approximate Agreement with Quadratic Communication

Overview

• This paper presents optimally resilient asynchronous approximate agreement protocols that require less communication than previous approaches.
• The protocols achieve various types of agreement, including barycentric agreement and edge agreement, while tolerating up to a third of Byzantine parties.
• The protocols use efficient communication patterns that improve on the state-of-the-art in terms of message complexity and round complexity.

Plain English Explanation

In a distributed system, parties (or nodes) need to reach an approximate agreement on some value, even if up to a third of the parties are Byzantine (behaving maliciously). The seminal protocol of Abraham, Amit and Dolev achieves this, but requires a large number of messages to be sent.

This paper presents new protocols that achieve the same level of resilience (tolerating up to a third of Byzantine parties) but with much lower communication requirements. The key ideas are:

• Barycentric agreement: Parties reach agreement on a point in the "center" of their inputs, without needing to reliably broadcast their full inputs.
• Edge agreement: Parties agree on the endpoints of an interval, rather than a single point, again with less communication.
• Efficient protocols: The protocols use clever communication patterns to reduce the number of messages and bits that need to be exchanged.

These improvements make the protocols much more efficient and practical for real-world distributed systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper considers an asynchronous network of n parties, up to t of which can be Byzantine. The goal is to achieve approximate agreement, where the parties obtain approximately equal outputs in the convex hull of their inputs.

The authors first present a protocol for omega-dimensional barycentric agreement, which allows parties to agree on a point in the "center" of their inputs, using O(omega * n^2) small messages.

Next, they introduce a protocol for edge agreement in a tree of diameter D. This is done by running ceil(log_2 D) iterations of a multivalued graded consensus variant, resulting in a O(log(1/epsilon))-round protocol for epsilon-agreement in [0, 1] with O(n^2 * log(1/epsilon)) messages and O(n^2 * log(1/epsilon) * log log(1/epsilon)) bits of communication.

Finally, the authors extend the edge agreement protocol to achieve edge agreement in mathbb{Z}, and thus epsilon-agreement in mathbb{R} with quadratic communication, in O(log(M/epsilon)) rounds, where M is the maximum honest input magnitude.

These protocols improve on the state-of-the-art, which matches the complexity only when the inputs are all either 0 or 1.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a significant advancement in the field of asynchronous approximate agreement, with protocols that are both highly resilient (tolerating up to a third of Byzantine parties) and highly efficient in terms of communication complexity.

One potential limitation is that the protocols assume the network topology is known in advance, which may not always be the case in real-world distributed systems. Additionally, the protocols are designed for numerical inputs, and it's not clear how they would extend to more complex data types.

Further research could explore ways to relax the assumptions about network topology, or to develop protocols that can handle a wider range of input types. Additionally, it would be interesting to see how these protocols perform in practical implementations and real-world scenarios.

Conclusion

This paper presents a significant advance in the field of asynchronous approximate agreement, with protocols that achieve optimal resilience while dramatically reducing the communication complexity compared to previous approaches. The key innovations are the use of barycentric and edge agreement, along with efficient communication patterns.

These protocols have the potential to enable more practical and scalable distributed systems, especially in scenarios where communication bandwidth is limited or Byzantine behavior needs to be tolerated. The paper provides a strong foundation for further research and development in this important area of distributed computing.