An Auto-tuning Method for Run-time Data Transformation for Sparse Matrix-Vector Multiplication

Overview

• This research paper explores the run-time sparse matrix data transformation from Compressed Row Storage (CRS) to Coordinate (COO) storage and an ELL (ELLPACK/ITPACK) format with OpenMP parallelization for sparse matrix-vector multiplication (SpMV).
• The authors propose an auto-tuning (AT) method using the $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph, which plots the derivation/average for the number of non-zero elements per row ($D_{mat}^i$) and the ratio of SpMV speedups to transformation time from CRS to ELL ($R_{ell}^i$).
• The experimental results show the ELL format is very effective on the Earth Simulator 2, achieving a speedup factor of 151 with the ELL-Row inner-parallelized format, and the transformation overhead is very small, ranging from 0.01 to 1.0 SpMV time with the CRS format.

Plain English Explanation

In this paper, the researchers investigated ways to efficiently multiply sparse matrices (matrices with many zero elements) with vectors. Sparse matrix-vector multiplication is an important operation in many scientific and engineering applications, but it can be computationally expensive.

The researchers focused on transforming the data format of the sparse matrix from Compressed Row Storage (CRS) to Coordinate (COO) storage and an ELLPACK (ELL) format. These different data formats can affect the performance of the sparse matrix-vector multiplication.

To optimize the performance, the researchers developed an automatic tuning (AT) method that uses a special graph, called the $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph. This graph shows the relationship between the number of non-zero elements per row ($D_{mat}^i$) and the speedup of the multiplication compared to the transformation time ($R_{ell}^i$).

The researchers tested their method on the Earth Simulator 2 computer and found that the ELL format was very effective, providing a speedup of up to 151 times compared to the original CRS format. The overhead of transforming the data format was also very small, taking less than 1% of the time for the original sparse matrix-vector multiplication.

The $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph can be used to predict the effectiveness of the data transformation, based on the characteristics of the sparse matrix.

Technical Explanation

The researchers investigated the performance of sparse matrix-vector multiplication (SpMV) using different data formats: Compressed Row Storage (CRS), Coordinate (COO), and ELLPACK (ELL). They parallelized the SpMV operations using OpenMP and proposed an auto-tuning (AT) method to select the optimal data format.

The AT method uses the $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph, which plots the derivation/average for the number of non-zero elements per row ($D_{mat}^i$) and the ratio of SpMV speedups to transformation time from CRS to ELL ($R_{ell}^i$). This graph can be used to model the effectiveness of the data transformation based on the $D_{mat}^i$ value.

The researchers conducted experiments on the Earth Simulator 2 and found that the ELL format was very effective, achieving a speedup factor of 151 with the ELL-Row inner-parallelized format. The transformation overhead was also very small, taking only 0.01 to 1.0 SpMV time with the CRS format.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough analysis of the performance of different sparse matrix data formats and the effectiveness of the proposed auto-tuning method. The researchers have validated their approach on the Earth Simulator 2, which is a powerful supercomputer, but it would be interesting to see how the method performs on more widely available hardware, such as consumer-grade GPUs or CPUs.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss the limitations of the $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph or the potential scenarios where it may not be effective in predicting the optimal data format. Further research could explore the sensitivity of the graph to different types of sparse matrices or the impact of matrix sparsity patterns on the transformation effectiveness.

Overall, the paper presents a promising approach for optimizing sparse matrix-vector multiplication, and the auto-tuning method could be a valuable tool for improving the performance of scientific and engineering applications that rely on this fundamental operation.

Conclusion

This research paper explores the optimization of sparse matrix-vector multiplication (SpMV) through run-time data format transformation and parallelization. The authors propose an auto-tuning method that uses a $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph to model the effectiveness of transforming the sparse matrix data from Compressed Row Storage (CRS) to ELLPACK (ELL) format.

The experimental results on the Earth Simulator 2 demonstrate the effectiveness of the ELL format, achieving a significant speedup of up to 151 times compared to the CRS format, with a relatively small transformation overhead. The $D_{mat}^i$ - $R_{ell}^i$ graph can be a valuable tool for predicting the optimal data format for a given sparse matrix, which could have important implications for improving the performance of a wide range of scientific and engineering applications that rely on sparse matrix computations.