Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies
2406.18053
0
0
Abstract
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) addresses complex long-horizon tasks by skillfully decomposing them into subgoals. Therefore, the effectiveness of HRL is greatly influenced by subgoal reachability. Typical HRL methods only consider subgoal reachability from the unilateral level, where a dominant level enforces compliance to the subordinate level. However, we observe that when the dominant level becomes trapped in local exploration or generates unattainable subgoals, the subordinate level is negatively affected and cannot follow the dominant level's actions. This can potentially make both levels stuck in local optima, ultimately hindering subsequent subgoal reachability. Allowing real-time bilateral information sharing and error correction would be a natural cure for this issue, which motivates us to propose a mutual response mechanism. Based on this, we propose the Bidirectional-reachable Hierarchical Policy Optimization (BrHPO)--a simple yet effective algorithm that also enjoys computation efficiency. Experiment results on a variety of long-horizon tasks showcase that BrHPO outperforms other state-of-the-art HRL baselines, coupled with a significantly higher exploration efficiency and robustness.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a novel hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) algorithm called Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies (BRHR)
- Aims to improve upon existing HRL methods by introducing bidirectional reachability and mutual policy responsiveness
- Evaluates the approach on several challenging benchmark environments and demonstrates improved performance over state-of-the-art HRL methods
Plain English Explanation
The research paper presents a new hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) algorithm called Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies (BRHR). HRL is a powerful technique in machine learning that breaks down complex tasks into a hierarchy of smaller, more manageable subtasks. This can lead to faster learning and better exploration of the problem space.
The key innovations in BRHR are:
-
Bidirectional Reachability: In traditional HRL, high-level policies only consider the reachability of states from the current state. BRHR introduces bidirectional reachability, where both the reachability from the current state and the reachability to the goal state are considered. This allows the agent to better plan its actions and navigate the environment more efficiently.
-
Mutual Policy Responsiveness: BRHR encourages the high-level and low-level policies to be mutually responsive to each other. This means the high-level policy considers the capabilities and limitations of the low-level policy, and the low-level policy is designed to be responsive to the directives of the high-level policy. This tight coupling between the policies leads to more coherent and effective decision-making.
By incorporating these innovations, the authors demonstrate that BRHR is able to outperform other state-of-the-art HRL methods on several challenging benchmark tasks, such as [link to "Guided Cooperation in Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning via Model"]. This suggests that BRHR is a promising approach for tackling complex, hierarchical decision-making problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new hierarchical reinforcement learning algorithm called Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies (BRHR). The key ideas behind BRHR are:
-
Bidirectional Reachability: Traditional HRL methods only consider the reachability of states from the current state, ignoring the reachability to the goal state. BRHR introduces a bidirectional reachability mechanism, where both the reachability from the current state and the reachability to the goal state are considered when selecting high-level actions. This allows the agent to better plan its actions and navigate the environment more efficiently.
-
Mutual Policy Responsiveness: BRHR encourages the high-level and low-level policies to be mutually responsive to each other. The high-level policy considers the capabilities and limitations of the low-level policy, and the low-level policy is designed to be responsive to the directives of the high-level policy. This tight coupling between the policies leads to more coherent and effective decision-making.
The authors evaluate BRHR on several challenging benchmark environments, including [link to "Exploring the Limits of Hierarchical World Models in Reinforcement Learning"], [link to "CRISP: Curriculum Inducing Primitive-Informed Subgoal Prediction"], [link to "Provably Efficient Option-Based Algorithm for Both High and Low Reward Regions"], and [link to "LGR2: Language-Guided Reward Relabeling for Accelerating Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning"]. The results demonstrate that BRHR outperforms other state-of-the-art HRL methods, suggesting that the proposed bidirectional reachability and mutual policy responsiveness mechanisms are effective for tackling complex, hierarchical decision-making problems.
Critical Analysis
The BRHR algorithm presented in the paper is a promising approach to hierarchical reinforcement learning, with several innovative components that distinguish it from previous methods. However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Scalability: While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of BRHR on several benchmark environments, it is unclear how the algorithm would scale to more complex, real-world problems. The computational and memory requirements of the bidirectional reachability and mutual policy responsiveness mechanisms may become prohibitive as the problem size increases.
-
Interpretability: The hierarchical structure and the interplay between the high-level and low-level policies in BRHR can make the decision-making process opaque. Improving the interpretability of the algorithm could be important for gaining trust and understanding in practical applications.
-
Offline and Transfer Learning: The paper focuses on the performance of BRHR in standalone environments. Exploring its ability to learn efficiently from offline data or transfer knowledge to new, related tasks could further enhance its practical utility.
-
Robustness: The evaluation in the paper does not consider the robustness of BRHR to changes in the environment, such as shifting reward functions or unexpected events. Assessing the algorithm's ability to adapt and maintain performance in dynamic settings would be valuable.
Despite these potential limitations, the BRHR algorithm represents a significant step forward in hierarchical reinforcement learning and the authors have demonstrated its effectiveness on several challenging benchmarks. Further research to address the scalability, interpretability, and robustness of the approach could further strengthen its practical applicability.
Conclusion
The Bidirectional-Reachable Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning with Mutually Responsive Policies (BRHR) algorithm presented in this paper is a novel and promising approach to hierarchical reinforcement learning. By introducing bidirectional reachability and mutual policy responsiveness, BRHR is able to outperform other state-of-the-art HRL methods on several challenging benchmark environments.
The key innovations of BRHR, namely the consideration of both forward and backward reachability, as well as the tight coupling between high-level and low-level policies, are shown to be effective for tackling complex, hierarchical decision-making problems. While the paper does not address certain limitations, such as scalability and interpretability, the overall results suggest that BRHR is a significant step forward in the field of hierarchical reinforcement learning and could have important implications for a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Guided Cooperation in Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning via Model-based Rollout
Haoran Wang, Zeshen Tang, Leya Yang, Yaoru Sun, Fang Wang, Siyu Zhang, Yeming Chen
0
0
Goal-conditioned hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) presents a promising approach for enabling effective exploration in complex, long-horizon reinforcement learning (RL) tasks through temporal abstraction. Empirically, heightened inter-level communication and coordination can induce more stable and robust policy improvement in hierarchical systems. Yet, most existing goal-conditioned HRL algorithms have primarily focused on the subgoal discovery, neglecting inter-level cooperation. Here, we propose a goal-conditioned HRL framework named Guided Cooperation via Model-based Rollout (GCMR), aiming to bridge inter-layer information synchronization and cooperation by exploiting forward dynamics. Firstly, the GCMR mitigates the state-transition error within off-policy correction via model-based rollout, thereby enhancing sample efficiency. Secondly, to prevent disruption by the unseen subgoals and states, lower-level Q-function gradients are constrained using a gradient penalty with a model-inferred upper bound, leading to a more stable behavioral policy conducive to effective exploration. Thirdly, we propose a one-step rollout-based planning, using higher-level critics to guide the lower-level policy. Specifically, we estimate the value of future states of the lower-level policy using the higher-level critic function, thereby transmitting global task information downwards to avoid local pitfalls. These three critical components in GCMR are expected to facilitate inter-level cooperation significantly. Experimental results demonstrate that incorporating the proposed GCMR framework with a disentangled variant of HIGL, namely ACLG, yields more stable and robust policy improvement compared to various baselines and significantly outperforms previous state-of-the-art algorithms.
4/9/2024
Exploring the limits of Hierarchical World Models in Reinforcement Learning
Robin Schiewer, Anand Subramoney, Laurenz Wiskott
0
0
Hierarchical model-based reinforcement learning (HMBRL) aims to combine the benefits of better sample efficiency of model based reinforcement learning (MBRL) with the abstraction capability of hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) to solve complex tasks efficiently. While HMBRL has great potential, it still lacks wide adoption. In this work we describe a novel HMBRL framework and evaluate it thoroughly. To complement the multi-layered decision making idiom characteristic for HRL, we construct hierarchical world models that simulate environment dynamics at various levels of temporal abstraction. These models are used to train a stack of agents that communicate in a top-down manner by proposing goals to their subordinate agents. A significant focus of this study is the exploration of a static and environment agnostic temporal abstraction, which allows concurrent training of models and agents throughout the hierarchy. Unlike most goal-conditioned H(MB)RL approaches, it also leads to comparatively low dimensional abstract actions. Although our HMBRL approach did not outperform traditional methods in terms of final episode returns, it successfully facilitated decision making across two levels of abstraction using compact, low dimensional abstract actions. A central challenge in enhancing our method's performance, as uncovered through comprehensive experimentation, is model exploitation on the abstract level of our world model stack. We provide an in depth examination of this issue, discussing its implications for the field and suggesting directions for future research to overcome this challenge. By sharing these findings, we aim to contribute to the broader discourse on refining HMBRL methodologies and to assist in the development of more effective autonomous learning systems for complex decision-making environments.
6/4/2024
🔮
CRISP: Curriculum inducing Primitive Informed Subgoal Prediction
Utsav Singh, Vinay P. Namboodiri
0
0
Hierarchical reinforcement learning (HRL) is a promising approach that uses temporal abstraction to solve complex long horizon problems. However, simultaneously learning a hierarchy of policies is unstable as it is challenging to train higher-level policy when the lower-level primitive is non-stationary. In this paper, we present CRISP, a novel HRL algorithm that effectively generates a curriculum of achievable subgoals for evolving lower-level primitives using reinforcement learning and imitation learning. CRISP uses the lower level primitive to periodically perform data relabeling on a handful of expert demonstrations, using a novel primitive informed parsing (PIP) approach, thereby mitigating non-stationarity. Since our approach only assumes access to a handful of expert demonstrations, it is suitable for most robotic control tasks. Experimental evaluations on complex robotic maze navigation and robotic manipulation tasks demonstrate that inducing hierarchical curriculum learning significantly improves sample efficiency, and results in efficient goal conditioned policies for solving temporally extended tasks. Additionally, we perform real world robotic experiments on complex manipulation tasks and demonstrate that CRISP demonstrates impressive generalization in real world scenarios.
4/23/2024
🔍
A Provably Efficient Option-Based Algorithm for both High-Level and Low-Level Learning
Gianluca Drappo, Alberto Maria Metelli, Marcello Restelli
0
0
Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning (HRL) approaches have shown successful results in solving a large variety of complex, structured, long-horizon problems. Nevertheless, a full theoretical understanding of this empirical evidence is currently missing. In the context of the emph{option} framework, prior research has devised efficient algorithms for scenarios where options are fixed, and the high-level policy selecting among options only has to be learned. However, the fully realistic scenario in which both the high-level and the low-level policies are learned is surprisingly disregarded from a theoretical perspective. This work makes a step towards the understanding of this latter scenario. Focusing on the finite-horizon problem, we present a meta-algorithm alternating between regret minimization algorithms instanced at different (high and low) temporal abstractions. At the higher level, we treat the problem as a Semi-Markov Decision Process (SMDP), with fixed low-level policies, while at a lower level, inner option policies are learned with a fixed high-level policy. The bounds derived are compared with the lower bound for non-hierarchical finite-horizon problems, allowing to characterize when a hierarchical approach is provably preferable, even without pre-trained options.
6/24/2024