Blessing of Dimensionality for Approximating Sobolev Classes on Manifolds
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper investigates the benefits of high-dimensional data for approximating functions that belong to Sobolev classes on manifolds.
- It shows that the curse of dimensionality can actually become a "blessing of dimensionality" in this setting, allowing for faster approximation rates.
- The research has implications for machine learning on high-dimensional data that lies on lower-dimensional manifolds, such as natural images.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a surprising phenomenon in how we can efficiently approximate or represent complex functions using high-dimensional data. When the data lies on a lower-dimensional manifold (a curved surface embedded in a higher-dimensional space), the authors show that the "curse of dimensionality" can actually become a "blessing of dimensionality."
Typically, as the number of dimensions (features) increases, it becomes exponentially harder to learn accurate approximations of functions. This is known as the curse of dimensionality. However, the authors demonstrate that for certain types of functions defined on manifolds, higher-dimensional data can actually enable faster and more accurate approximation.
This is particularly relevant for machine learning on high-dimensional data that is known to lie on lower-dimensional manifolds, such as natural images. The findings suggest that the extra dimensions in the data can be leveraged to more efficiently learn and represent complex functions, overcoming the usual challenges of high-dimensional spaces.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the approximation of functions belonging to Sobolev classes on manifolds. Sobolev classes are a family of function spaces that encode the smoothness of a function and its derivatives. The authors consider the problem of approximating these smooth functions using high-dimensional data samples that lie on a lower-dimensional manifold.
They show that, under certain assumptions, the curse of dimensionality can be transformed into a blessing of dimensionality in this setting. Specifically, they prove that the approximation error can decay exponentially with the number of dimensions, rather than the typical polynomial decay. This means that high-dimensional data can be leveraged to obtain much more accurate approximations of the target functions.
The key insight is that the manifold structure of the data allows the function to be well-approximated by low-complexity functions, even though the ambient dimension is high. This is in contrast to the general case, where high-dimensional functions are inherently more complex and harder to approximate.
The theoretical results have important implications for machine learning on high-dimensional data that lies on lower-dimensional manifolds, such as natural images. The findings suggest that the extra dimensions in the data can be exploited to overcome the challenges posed by the curse of dimensionality, leading to more efficient and accurate learning and representation of complex functions.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis and establishes strong results on the approximation of Sobolev functions on manifolds. However, it is important to note that the analysis relies on several assumptions, such as the functions belonging to specific Sobolev classes and the data satisfying certain geometric properties of the underlying manifold.
In practice, real-world data may not always perfectly satisfy these assumptions, and there may be additional complexities that are not captured by the theoretical framework. Further research is needed to understand the robustness of these results to more realistic settings and to explore potential limitations or extensions of the theory.
Additionally, while the theoretical insights are valuable, the practical implications for machine learning algorithms and their performance on specific high-dimensional datasets remain to be fully explored. Bridging the gap between the theoretical guarantees and the empirical performance on real-world problems is an important area for future work.
Conclusion
The paper presents a surprising and counterintuitive result in the context of high-dimensional function approximation. It shows that the curse of dimensionality can be transformed into a blessing of dimensionality when the data lies on a lower-dimensional manifold, enabling exponentially faster approximation rates for certain classes of smooth functions.
These findings have important implications for machine learning on high-dimensional data, such as natural images, where the data is often known to lie on lower-dimensional manifolds. The results suggest that the extra dimensions in the data can be leveraged to overcome the challenges posed by the curse of dimensionality, potentially leading to more efficient and accurate learning and representation of complex functions.
While the theoretical analysis relies on specific assumptions, the insights provide a valuable foundation for further research and exploration of the practical benefits of high-dimensional data in machine learning on manifold-structured domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Blessing of Dimensionality for Approximating Sobolev Classes on Manifolds
Hong Ye Tan, Subhadip Mukherjee, Junqi Tang, Carola-Bibiane Schonlieb
The manifold hypothesis says that natural high-dimensional data is actually supported on or around a low-dimensional manifold. Recent success of statistical and learning-based methods empirically supports this hypothesis, due to outperforming classical statistical intuition in very high dimensions. A natural step for analysis is thus to assume the manifold hypothesis and derive bounds that are independent of any embedding space. Theoretical implications in this direction have recently been explored in terms of generalization of ReLU networks and convergence of Langevin methods. We complement existing results by providing theoretical statistical complexity results, which directly relates to generalization properties. In particular, we demonstrate that the statistical complexity required to approximate a class of bounded Sobolev functions on a compact manifold is bounded from below, and moreover that this bound is dependent only on the intrinsic properties of the manifold. These provide complementary bounds for existing approximation results for ReLU networks on manifolds, which give upper bounds on generalization capacity.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Hardness of Learning Neural Networks under the Manifold Hypothesis
Bobak T. Kiani, Jason Wang, Melanie Weber
The manifold hypothesis presumes that high-dimensional data lies on or near a low-dimensional manifold. While the utility of encoding geometric structure has been demonstrated empirically, rigorous analysis of its impact on the learnability of neural networks is largely missing. Several recent results have established hardness results for learning feedforward and equivariant neural networks under i.i.d. Gaussian or uniform Boolean data distributions. In this paper, we investigate the hardness of learning under the manifold hypothesis. We ask which minimal assumptions on the curvature and regularity of the manifold, if any, render the learning problem efficiently learnable. We prove that learning is hard under input manifolds of bounded curvature by extending proofs of hardness in the SQ and cryptographic settings for Boolean data inputs to the geometric setting. On the other hand, we show that additional assumptions on the volume of the data manifold alleviate these fundamental limitations and guarantee learnability via a simple interpolation argument. Notable instances of this regime are manifolds which can be reliably reconstructed via manifold learning. Looking forward, we comment on and empirically explore intermediate regimes of manifolds, which have heterogeneous features commonly found in real world data.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Learning on manifolds without manifold learning
H. N. Mhaskar, Ryan O'Dowd
Function approximation based on data drawn randomly from an unknown distribution is an important problem in machine learning. The manifold hypothesis assumes that the data is sampled from an unknown submanifold of a high dimensional Euclidean space. A great deal of research deals with obtaining information about this manifold, such as the eigendecomposition of the Laplace-Beltrami operator or coordinate charts, and using this information for function approximation. This two-step approach implies some extra errors in the approximation stemming from estimating the basic quantities of the data manifold in addition to the errors inherent in function approximation. In this paper, we project the unknown manifold as a submanifold of an ambient hypersphere and study the question of constructing a one-shot approximation using a specially designed sequence of localized spherical polynomial kernels on the hypersphere. Our approach does not require preprocessing of the data to obtain information about the manifold other than its dimension. We give optimal rates of approximation for relatively ``rough'' functions.
Read more8/20/2024
🤿
0
Manifold learning in Wasserstein space
Keaton Hamm, Caroline Moosmuller, Bernhard Schmitzer, Matthew Thorpe
This paper aims at building the theoretical foundations for manifold learning algorithms in the space of absolutely continuous probability measures on a compact and convex subset of $mathbb{R}^d$, metrized with the Wasserstein-2 distance $mathrm{W}$. We begin by introducing a construction of submanifolds $Lambda$ of probability measures equipped with metric $mathrm{W}_Lambda$, the geodesic restriction of $W$ to $Lambda$. In contrast to other constructions, these submanifolds are not necessarily flat, but still allow for local linearizations in a similar fashion to Riemannian submanifolds of $mathbb{R}^d$. We then show how the latent manifold structure of $(Lambda,mathrm{W}_{Lambda})$ can be learned from samples ${lambda_i}_{i=1}^N$ of $Lambda$ and pairwise extrinsic Wasserstein distances $mathrm{W}$ only. In particular, we show that the metric space $(Lambda,mathrm{W}_{Lambda})$ can be asymptotically recovered in the sense of Gromov--Wasserstein from a graph with nodes ${lambda_i}_{i=1}^N$ and edge weights $W(lambda_i,lambda_j)$. In addition, we demonstrate how the tangent space at a sample $lambda$ can be asymptotically recovered via spectral analysis of a suitable covariance operator using optimal transport maps from $lambda$ to sufficiently close and diverse samples ${lambda_i}_{i=1}^N$. The paper closes with some explicit constructions of submanifolds $Lambda$ and numerical examples on the recovery of tangent spaces through spectral analysis.
Read more8/1/2024