Bridging Data Gaps in Healthcare: A Scoping Review of Transfer Learning in Biomedical Data Analysis
0
📊
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Clinical and biomedical research in low-resource settings faces challenges due to the need for high-quality data with sufficient sample sizes to construct effective models.
- Researchers seek methods to leverage existing knowledge from related studies to support new research efforts.
- Transfer learning (TL), a machine learning technique, offers a solution by utilizing knowledge from pre-trained models to enhance the performance of new models in various healthcare domains.
- Despite its conceptual origins in the 1990s, the application of TL in medical research has remained limited, especially beyond image analysis.
Plain English Explanation
Building effective medical models often requires large, high-quality datasets, which can be difficult to obtain in low-resource settings. Researchers are looking for ways to use knowledge from previous studies to help with their own work. Transfer learning is a machine learning technique that can do this by taking what a model has learned from one dataset and applying it to a new problem. This can help improve the performance of new models in healthcare without needing as much data.
Despite being around since the 1990s, transfer learning hasn't been used much in medical research beyond analyzing medical images like X-rays or MRIs. Researchers want to find ways to use transfer learning with other types of medical data, like patient records or test results, to help address challenges like regional differences in healthcare access, inequality, and privacy concerns.
Technical Explanation
The researchers reviewed 3,515 papers on the use of transfer learning in structured clinical and biomedical data, and found that only 55 met their inclusion criteria. Of those, only 1 (2%) utilized external studies, and 4 (7%) addressed scenarios involving multi-site collaborations with privacy constraints.
To enable effective transfer learning with structured medical data while addressing regional disparities, inequality, and privacy constraints in healthcare research, the researchers recommend:
- Carefully identifying appropriate source data and models for transfer learning.
- Selecting suitable transfer learning frameworks.
- Validating transfer learning models with proper baselines.
Critical Analysis
The paper highlights the limited adoption of transfer learning techniques beyond image analysis in medical research, despite the potential benefits. The researchers rightly identify the need to carefully select source data and models, as well as suitable transfer learning frameworks, to address the unique challenges of clinical and biomedical research in low-resource settings.
However, the study does not delve into the specific barriers or challenges that have hindered the broader application of transfer learning in this domain. Additional research may be needed to understand the technical, regulatory, or cultural factors that have constrained the use of these techniques.
Further, the paper does not provide a detailed evaluation of the performance or effectiveness of the transfer learning approaches used in the reviewed studies. A more comprehensive analysis of the strengths, weaknesses, and tradeoffs of different transfer learning strategies could help guide future research and implementation efforts.
Conclusion
This review highlights the opportunities and limitations of using transfer learning to support clinical and biomedical research in low-resource settings. While the technique has the potential to leverage existing knowledge to enhance the performance of new models, its application has been limited, particularly beyond image analysis.
To realize the full potential of transfer learning in this domain, the researchers emphasize the importance of carefully selecting appropriate source data and models, as well as suitable transfer learning frameworks, while addressing regional disparities, inequality, and privacy constraints. Continued research and innovation in this area could help drive more equitable and impactful healthcare solutions, particularly in underserved communities.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
0
Bridging Data Gaps in Healthcare: A Scoping Review of Transfer Learning in Biomedical Data Analysis
Siqi Li, Xin Li, Kunyu Yu, Di Miao, Mingcheng Zhu, Mengying Yan, Yuhe Ke, Danny D'Agostino, Yilin Ning, Qiming Wu, Ziwen Wang, Yuqing Shang, Molei Liu, Chuan Hong, Nan Liu
Clinical and biomedical research in low-resource settings often faces significant challenges due to the need for high-quality data with sufficient sample sizes to construct effective models. These constraints hinder robust model training and prompt researchers to seek methods for leveraging existing knowledge from related studies to support new research efforts. Transfer learning (TL), a machine learning technique, emerges as a powerful solution by utilizing knowledge from pre-trained models to enhance the performance of new models, offering promise across various healthcare domains. Despite its conceptual origins in the 1990s, the application of TL in medical research has remained limited, especially beyond image analysis. In our review of TL applications in structured clinical and biomedical data, we screened 3,515 papers, with 55 meeting the inclusion criteria. Among these, only 2% (one out of 55) utilized external studies, and 7% (four out of 55) addressed scenarios involving multi-site collaborations with privacy constraints. To achieve actionable TL with structured medical data while addressing regional disparities, inequality, and privacy constraints in healthcare research, we advocate for the careful identification of appropriate source data and models, the selection of suitable TL frameworks, and the validation of TL models with proper baselines.
Read more7/17/2024
🔄
0
A Recent Survey of Heterogeneous Transfer Learning
Runxue Bao, Yiming Sun, Yuhe Gao, Jindong Wang, Qiang Yang, Zhi-Hong Mao, Ye Ye
The application of transfer learning, leveraging knowledge from source domains to enhance model performance in a target domain, has significantly grown, supporting diverse real-world applications. Its success often relies on shared knowledge between domains, typically required in these methodologies. Commonly, methods assume identical feature and label spaces in both domains, known as homogeneous transfer learning. However, this is often impractical as source and target domains usually differ in these spaces, making precise data matching challenging and costly. Consequently, heterogeneous transfer learning (HTL), which addresses these disparities, has become a vital strategy in various tasks. In this paper, we offer an extensive review of over 60 HTL methods, covering both data-based and model-based approaches. We describe the key assumptions and algorithms of these methods and systematically categorize them into instance-based, feature representation-based, parameter regularization, and parameter tuning techniques. Additionally, we explore applications in natural language processing, computer vision, multimodal learning, and biomedicine, aiming to deepen understanding and stimulate further research in these areas. Our paper includes recent advancements in HTL, such as the introduction of transformer-based models and multimodal learning techniques, ensuring the review captures the latest developments in the field. We identify key limitations in current HTL studies and offer systematic guidance for future research, highlighting areas needing further exploration and suggesting potential directions for advancing the field.
Read more7/19/2024
0
Deep Transfer Learning for Kidney Cancer Diagnosis
Yassine Habchi, Hamza Kheddar, Yassine Himeur, Abdelkrim Boukabou, Shadi Atalla, Wathiq Mansoor, Hussain Al-Ahmad
Many incurable diseases prevalent across global societies stem from various influences, including lifestyle choices, economic conditions, social factors, and genetics. Research predominantly focuses on these diseases due to their widespread nature, aiming to decrease mortality, enhance treatment options, and improve healthcare standards. Among these, kidney disease stands out as a particularly severe condition affecting men and women worldwide. Nonetheless, there is a pressing need for continued research into innovative, early diagnostic methods to develop more effective treatments for such diseases. Recently, automatic diagnosis of Kidney Cancer has become an important challenge especially when using deep learning (DL) due to the importance of training medical datasets, which in most cases are difficult and expensive to obtain. Furthermore, in most cases, algorithms require data from the same domain and a powerful computer with efficient storage capacity. To overcome this issue, a new type of learning known as transfer learning (TL) has been proposed that can produce impressive results based on other different pre-trained data. This paper presents, to the best of the authors' knowledge, the first comprehensive survey of DL-based TL frameworks for kidney cancer diagnosis. This is a strong contribution to help researchers understand the current challenges and perspectives of this topic. Hence, the main limitations and advantages of each framework are identified and detailed critical analyses are provided. Looking ahead, the article identifies promising directions for future research. Moving on, the discussion is concluded by reflecting on the pivotal role of TL in the development of precision medicine and its effects on clinical practice and research in oncology.
Read more8/9/2024
0
A Survey of Few-Shot Learning for Biomedical Time Series
Chenqi Li, Timothy Denison, Tingting Zhu
Advancements in wearable sensor technologies and the digitization of medical records have contributed to the unprecedented ubiquity of biomedical time series data. Data-driven models have tremendous potential to assist clinical diagnosis and improve patient care by improving long-term monitoring capabilities, facilitating early disease detection and intervention, as well as promoting personalized healthcare delivery. However, accessing extensively labeled datasets to train data-hungry deep learning models encounters many barriers, such as long-tail distribution of rare diseases, cost of annotation, privacy and security concerns, data-sharing regulations, and ethical considerations. An emerging approach to overcome the scarcity of labeled data is to augment AI methods with human-like capabilities to leverage past experiences to learn new tasks with limited examples, called few-shot learning. This survey provides a comprehensive review and comparison of few-shot learning methods for biomedical time series applications. The clinical benefits and limitations of such methods are discussed in relation to traditional data-driven approaches. This paper aims to provide insights into the current landscape of few-shot learning for biomedical time series and its implications for future research and applications.
Read more5/7/2024