Bridging the Gap Between Approximation and Learning via Optimal Approximation by ReLU MLPs of Maximal Regularity

Overview

• The paper explores the tension between the two main perspectives in deep learning: approximation and learning theory.
• Approximation favors large, expressive models that may not generalize well, while learning theory prefers smaller, more constrained models.
• The paper aims to identify a class of neural networks that is both highly expressive and statistically well-behaved.

Plain English Explanation

The foundations of deep learning are supported by two seemingly opposing views: approximation and learning theory. Approximation advocates for large, highly expressive models that may not generalize well, while learning theory favors smaller, more constrained models that can generalize better.

However, real-world deep learning implementations often require both expressiveness and statistical reliability. The paper asks: Is there a class of neural networks that is large enough to be a universal approximator but structured enough to generalize well?

The paper provides a positive answer to this question by identifying a highly structured class of ReLU multilayer perceptrons (MLPs) that are both optimal function approximators and statistically well-behaved. This class of MLPs can approximate any Lipschitz function to a small uniform error, while maintaining a bounded Rademacher complexity and near-optimal sample complexity.

The key to this achievement is a new construction method that avoids the standard approach, which relies on small spikes that sacrifice regularity. Instead, the paper introduces a method that fits linear pieces together using Kuhn triangulations, avoiding these small spikes and maintaining the desired properties.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a class of ReLU multilayer perceptrons (MLPs) that are both highly expressive and statistically well-behaved. Specifically, the paper shows that any L-Lipschitz function from the unit hypercube [0,1]^d to the interval [-n,n] can be approximated to a uniform error of Ld/(2n) on the unit hypercube using a sparse, Lipschitz ReLU MLP.

This MLP has the following properties:

• Width: O(dn^d)
• Depth: O(log(d))
• Number of non-zero parameters: O(dn^d)
• Weights and biases are in {0, ±1/2} except for the first and last layers, which have magnitude at most n

Unlike previously known large classes of universal ReLU MLPs, the Rademacher complexity of this class remains bounded even when the depth and width become arbitrarily large. Additionally, this class of MLPs achieves a near-optimal sample complexity of O(log(N)/sqrt(N)) when given N i.i.d. normalized sub-Gaussian training samples.

The key to this construction is the use of Kuhn triangulations to fit linear pieces together, avoiding the small spikes that are typically used to achieve universal approximation. This new approach maintains the desired properties of expressiveness and statistical reliability.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to constructing a class of neural networks that are both highly expressive and statistically well-behaved. The authors acknowledge that their construction method may be more complex than the standard approaches, and they discuss potential limitations, such as the difficulty of implementing the Kuhn triangulation in practice.

Additionally, while the paper provides theoretical guarantees on the approximation error, Rademacher complexity, and sample complexity of the proposed class of MLPs, it does not include any empirical evaluations or comparisons to other neural network architectures. It would be interesting to see how this class of MLPs performs in real-world deep learning tasks compared to other models.

Furthermore, the paper focuses on the specific case of approximating Lipschitz functions, which may limit the applicability of the results to a broader range of functions. It would be valuable to explore whether this construction can be extended to other function classes or to more general deep learning settings.

Conclusion

The paper presents a significant contribution to the field of deep learning by identifying a class of neural networks that are both highly expressive and statistically well-behaved. This work helps to bridge the gap between the two seemingly opposing perspectives of approximation and learning theory, providing a practical solution for deep learning implementations that require both expressiveness and reliability.

The key innovation is a new construction method that avoids the small spikes typically used in universal approximation, instead fitting linear pieces together using Kuhn triangulations. This approach allows the proposed class of MLPs to maintain strong theoretical guarantees on approximation error, Rademacher complexity, and sample complexity.

While the paper raises some practical implementation challenges and opportunities for further research, it represents an important step towards developing deep learning models that can be both powerful and well-behaved, with potential implications for a wide range of applications.