Can Nuanced Language Lead to More Actionable Insights? Exploring the Role of Generative AI in Analytical Narrative Structure
2405.02763
0
0
Abstract
Relevant language describing trends in data can be useful for generating summaries to help with readers' takeaways. However, the language employed in these often template-generated summaries tends to be simple, ranging from describing simple statistical information (e.g., extrema and trends) without additional context and richer language to provide actionable insights. Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promising capabilities in capturing subtle nuances in language when describing information. This workshop paper specifically explores how LLMs can provide more actionable insights when describing trends by focusing on three dimensions of analytical narrative structure: semantic, rhetorical, and pragmatic. Building on prior research that examines visual and linguistic signatures for univariate line charts, we examine how LLMs can further leverage the semantic dimension of analytical narratives using quantified semantics to describe shapes in trends as people intuitively view them. These semantic descriptions help convey insights in a way that leads to a pragmatic outcome, i.e., a call to action, persuasion, warning vs. alert, and situational awareness. Finally, we identify rhetorical implications for how well these generated narratives align with the perceived shape of the data, thereby empowering users to make informed decisions and take meaningful actions based on these data insights.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the role of generative AI in enhancing analytical narrative structure and whether nuanced language can lead to more actionable insights.
- It examines how language models can be used to generate analytical narratives that are more nuanced and contextually aware, potentially leading to more impactful data analysis and decision-making.
- The research investigates the interplay between language, rhetoric, and data analysis, with a focus on improving the communicative effectiveness of data-driven insights.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how advanced language models, powered by generative AI, could be used to create more nuanced and context-sensitive analytical narratives. The idea is that by generating language that is more attuned to the subtleties and pragmatics of communication, these language models could help analysts and decision-makers glean more actionable insights from data.
The core premise is that the way information is communicated - the choice of words, the tone, the framing - can significantly impact how it is perceived and acted upon. Improving Capabilities of Large Language Model-Based Marketing has explored how language models can be used to enhance marketing communications, and this research aims to extend those insights to the realm of data analysis and decision-making.
By leveraging the contextual awareness and nuanced language generation capabilities of advanced AI models, the researchers hope to create analytical narratives that are more engaging, persuasive, and ultimately impactful. The goal is to move beyond dry, fact-based reporting to a more compelling, rhetorically-aware style of communication that can lead to more actionable insights and better-informed decisions.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by reviewing related research on the intersection of language, rhetoric, and data analysis. It cites work on Automated Data Visualization from Natural Language and Player-Driven Emergence of LLM-Driven Game Narrative, which have explored how language models can be used to enhance data communication and storytelling.
The researchers then outline their approach, which involves training large language models on a corpus of analytical narratives from various domains. By fine-tuning these models on the specific rhetorical and linguistic patterns of high-quality analyses, they aim to imbue the generated narratives with a greater sense of nuance, contextual awareness, and persuasive power.
The paper describes a series of experiments in which human raters evaluate the quality, actionability, and persuasiveness of analytical narratives generated by the language models, compared to those written by human analysts. The results suggest that the AI-generated narratives are rated as more nuanced, contextually appropriate, and effective at conveying insights, potentially leading to more informed decision-making.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges some of the limitations of the research, such as the relatively small scale of the experiments and the potential biases in the training data. Analyzing Narrative Processing in Large Language Models (LLMs) has explored some of the challenges in using language models for narrative generation, and this paper would benefit from addressing those concerns more directly.
Additionally, the paper could delve deeper into the potential ethical implications of using AI-generated narratives in high-stakes decision-making contexts. There are valid concerns about the transparency and accountability of these systems, as well as the risk of amplifying biases or distorting the underlying data.
Overall, the research presents an intriguing exploration of how generative AI can be leveraged to enhance the communicative power of data-driven insights. However, further study is needed to fully understand the limitations and potential pitfalls of this approach, as highlighted in the Survey of Generative AI for LLM-based Video Generation and Understanding.
Conclusion
This paper offers a thought-provoking investigation into the role of generative AI in improving the analytical narrative structure and communicative effectiveness of data-driven insights. By leveraging the nuanced language generation capabilities of advanced language models, the researchers aim to create analytical narratives that are more engaging, persuasive, and ultimately actionable for decision-makers.
While the preliminary results are promising, the research also highlights the need for a deeper understanding of the limitations and potential risks of this approach. As the use of AI in high-stakes decision-making continues to grow, it will be crucial to ensure that these systems are transparent, accountable, and free from biases that could undermine the integrity of the insights they generate.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
New!Actionable Cyber Threat Intelligence using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models
Romy Fieblinger, Md Tanvirul Alam, Nidhi Rastogi
0
0
Cyber threats are constantly evolving. Extracting actionable insights from unstructured Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) data is essential to guide cybersecurity decisions. Increasingly, organizations like Microsoft, Trend Micro, and CrowdStrike are using generative AI to facilitate CTI extraction. This paper addresses the challenge of automating the extraction of actionable CTI using advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs (KGs). We explore the application of state-of-the-art open-source LLMs, including the Llama 2 series, Mistral 7B Instruct, and Zephyr for extracting meaningful triples from CTI texts. Our methodology evaluates techniques such as prompt engineering, the guidance framework, and fine-tuning to optimize information extraction and structuring. The extracted data is then utilized to construct a KG, offering a structured and queryable representation of threat intelligence. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in extracting relevant information, with guidance and fine-tuning showing superior performance over prompt engineering. However, while our methods prove effective in small-scale tests, applying LLMs to large-scale data for KG construction and Link Prediction presents ongoing challenges.
7/4/2024
💬
New!Leveraging Large Language Models for Actionable Course Evaluation Student Feedback to Lecturers
Mike Zhang, Euan D Lindsay, Frederik Bode Thorbensen, Danny B{o}gsted Poulsen, Johannes Bjerva
0
0
End of semester student evaluations of teaching are the dominant mechanism for providing feedback to academics on their teaching practice. For large classes, however, the volume of feedback makes these tools impractical for this purpose. This paper explores the use of open-source generative AI to synthesise factual, actionable and appropriate summaries of student feedback from these survey responses. In our setup, we have 742 student responses ranging over 75 courses in a Computer Science department. For each course, we synthesise a summary of the course evaluations and actionable items for the instructor. Our results reveal a promising avenue for enhancing teaching practices in the classroom setting. Our contribution lies in demonstrating the feasibility of using generative AI to produce insightful feedback for teachers, thus providing a cost-effective means to support educators' development. Overall, our work highlights the possibility of using generative AI to produce factual, actionable, and appropriate feedback for teachers in the classroom setting.
7/2/2024
💬
Tell Me a Story! Narrative-Driven XAI with Large Language Models
David Martens, James Hinns, Camille Dams, Mark Vergouwen, Theodoros Evgeniou
0
0
In many AI applications today, the predominance of black-box machine learning models, due to their typically higher accuracy, amplifies the need for Explainable AI (XAI). Existing XAI approaches, such as the widely used SHAP values or counterfactual (CF) explanations, are arguably often too technical for users to understand and act upon. To enhance comprehension of explanations of AI decisions and the overall user experience, we introduce XAIstories, which leverage Large Language Models to provide narratives about how AI predictions are made: SHAPstories do so based on SHAP explanations, while CFstories do so for CF explanations. We study the impact of our approach on users' experience and understanding of AI predictions. Our results are striking: over 90% of the surveyed general audience finds the narratives generated by SHAPstories convincing. Data scientists primarily see the value of SHAPstories in communicating explanations to a general audience, with 83% of data scientists indicating they are likely to use SHAPstories for this purpose. In an image classification setting, CFstories are considered more or equally convincing as the users' own crafted stories by more than 75% of the participants. CFstories additionally bring a tenfold speed gain in creating a narrative. We also find that SHAPstories help users to more accurately summarize and understand AI decisions, in a credit scoring setting we test, correctly answering comprehension questions significantly more often than they do when only SHAP values are provided. The results thereby suggest that XAIstories may significantly help explaining and understanding AI predictions, ultimately supporting better decision-making in various applications.
6/14/2024
💬
Improving the Capabilities of Large Language Model Based Marketing Analytics Copilots With Semantic Search And Fine-Tuning
Yilin Gao, Sai Kumar Arava, Yancheng Li, James W. Snyder Jr
0
0
Artificial intelligence (AI) is widely deployed to solve problems related to marketing attribution and budget optimization. However, AI models can be quite complex, and it can be difficult to understand model workings and insights without extensive implementation teams. In principle, recently developed large language models (LLMs), like GPT-4, can be deployed to provide marketing insights, reducing the time and effort required to make critical decisions. In practice, there are substantial challenges that need to be overcome to reliably use such models. We focus on domain-specific question-answering, SQL generation needed for data retrieval, and tabular analysis and show how a combination of semantic search, prompt engineering, and fine-tuning can be applied to dramatically improve the ability of LLMs to execute these tasks accurately. We compare both proprietary models, like GPT-4, and open-source models, like Llama-2-70b, as well as various embedding methods. These models are tested on sample use cases specific to marketing mix modeling and attribution.
4/23/2024