A Canonical Data Transformation for Achieving Inter- and Within-group Fairness

Overview

• As machine learning algorithms are increasingly used for applications involving sensitive data, the issue of fairness in these algorithms has become a growing concern.
• While previous work has focused on achieving fairness between different demographic groups, this can sometimes lead to unfair treatment of individuals within the same group.
• This paper introduces a formal definition of "within-group fairness" and proposes a pre-processing framework to address both inter-group and within-group fairness with minimal impact on accuracy.

Plain English Explanation

Machine learning algorithms are being used more and more for important decisions that affect people's lives, such as loan applications, criminal risk assessments, and university admissions. This has raised concerns about whether these algorithms are treating different demographic groups (e.g., race, gender, age) fairly.

Previous research has looked at ways to make algorithms "fair" between groups - for example, ensuring that people of different races have an equal chance of being approved for a loan. However, the authors of this paper point out that algorithms aiming for this type of "group fairness" can sometimes end up treating individuals within the same group unfairly.

To address this, the researchers propose a new way to define and achieve "within-group fairness." Their approach ensures that individuals from the same demographic group are treated fairly relative to each other, not just that different groups are treated equally on average.

The key idea is to transform the input data in a way that preserves the relative rankings of individuals within each group, while also ensuring fairness between groups. This is done through a pre-processing step before the data is fed into the machine learning model.

The researchers test their framework on two real-world datasets and show that it can achieve both inter-group and within-group fairness with only a small decrease in overall accuracy compared to other fairness techniques.

Technical Explanation

The authors introduce a formal definition of "within-group fairness" that captures the idea of fairness among individuals within the same demographic group, in addition to fairness between groups. They propose a pre-processing framework to meet both inter-group and within-group fairness criteria without significantly compromising model accuracy.

The framework works by first mapping the input feature vectors of individuals from different groups to an "inter-group-fair canonical domain." This mapping is designed to preserve the relative ranking of individuals within each group, while also ensuring fairness between groups. The transformed feature vectors are then fed into a scoring function to make predictions.

The researchers evaluate their framework on the COMPAS risk assessment and Law School datasets. They compare its performance in achieving inter-group and within-group fairness to two existing regularization-based fairness methods. The results show that their approach can successfully satisfy both fairness criteria with only a small drop in overall accuracy compared to the other techniques.

Critical Analysis

A key strength of this work is the formal definition of within-group fairness, which addresses an important limitation of previous group fairness approaches. By preserving the relative ranking of individuals within each group, the proposed framework helps ensure that everyone is treated fairly compared to their peers, not just that different groups have equal average outcomes.

However, the paper does not explore how the choice of mapping function might impact the trade-off between fairness and accuracy. There may be more sophisticated techniques for constructing this mapping that could further improve the overall performance.

Additionally, the experiments are limited to two specific datasets. More research is needed to understand how well the framework generalizes to a wider range of applications and data types. There may also be other important fairness criteria, beyond inter-group and within-group fairness, that should be considered.

Overall, this work makes an important contribution by highlighting the need to consider fairness at the individual level, not just the group level. The proposed pre-processing approach provides a promising direction for achieving a more comprehensive notion of fairness in machine learning systems.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel framework for achieving both inter-group and within-group fairness in machine learning models with minimal impact on overall accuracy. By mapping input features to a canonical domain that preserves relative rankings within groups, the approach ensures that individuals are treated fairly not just compared to other demographic groups, but also within their own group.

The experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this framework on real-world datasets, suggesting it could be a valuable tool for developing fair and equitable machine learning systems. As the use of these algorithms continues to grow, addressing fairness concerns at both the group and individual level will be crucial for building trust and ensuring these technologies have a positive impact on society.