cDP-MIL: Robust Multiple Instance Learning via Cascaded Dirichlet Process
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a robust multiple instance learning (MIL) model called cDP-MIL that uses a cascaded Dirichlet process to handle uncertainty in whole slide images.
- Demonstrates improved performance on MIL tasks compared to state-of-the-art methods, especially for noisy or challenging datasets.
- Provides a framework for uncertainty estimation and interpretability in MIL, which is important for real-world applications like digital pathology.
Plain English Explanation
Multiple instance learning (MIL) is a machine learning technique that can be useful for tasks like analyzing medical images. In MIL, the model is trained on "bags" of instances (e.g., small image patches from a whole slide image) rather than individual instances. This can be helpful when the specific relevant regions within an image are not known.
The cDP-MIL model proposed in this paper aims to make MIL more robust and able to handle uncertainty, which is important for real-world applications like digital pathology. It uses a cascaded Dirichlet process, a type of Bayesian nonparametric method, to better model the distribution of instance-level features within each bag.
This allows the model to provide not just a prediction, but also an estimate of the uncertainty in that prediction. The authors show that cDP-MIL outperforms other state-of-the-art MIL methods, especially on noisy or challenging datasets, and provides valuable insights through its uncertainty estimates.
Technical Explanation
The cDP-MIL model uses a cascaded Dirichlet process to model the distribution of instance-level features within each bag in a multiple instance learning task. This allows the model to better handle the uncertainty inherent in MIL problems, where the specific relevant regions within an image are not known.
The model consists of two main components: a feature extractor network that encodes instance-level features, and a cascaded Dirichlet process module that models the distribution of these features within each bag. The Dirichlet process allows the model to adaptively cluster the instances within a bag, which helps capture the diverse global representation [1] and rethink the assumptions about the distribution of instances [2].
The authors evaluate cDP-MIL on several MIL datasets, including applications in digital pathology [3]. They show that cDP-MIL outperforms state-of-the-art MIL methods, particularly on noisy or challenging datasets. The uncertainty estimates provided by the model also offer valuable insights that can be helpful for real-world applications [4].
Critical Analysis
The cDP-MIL model represents an interesting and potentially useful advancement in multiple instance learning. The authors' use of a cascaded Dirichlet process to model the instance-level feature distributions within each bag is a novel and well-motivated approach.
One potential limitation of the work is that the model complexity may make it computationally intensive, especially for large-scale datasets or real-time applications. The authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the model's computational requirements or runtime.
Additionally, while the authors demonstrate improved performance on several MIL datasets, it would be valuable to see how the model generalizes to an even wider range of tasks and application domains. Further research could also explore ways to make the model more efficient or scalable, without sacrificing its strong performance and uncertainty estimation capabilities.
Overall, the cDP-MIL model represents an important step forward in robust and interpretable multiple instance learning, with promising implications for real-world applications like digital pathology.
Conclusion
The cDP-MIL model proposed in this paper offers a novel and effective approach to multiple instance learning, particularly for handling uncertainty and providing interpretable results. By using a cascaded Dirichlet process to model the instance-level feature distributions, the model demonstrates improved performance on a range of MIL tasks, with valuable applications in areas like digital pathology.
While the model complexity may present some practical challenges, the authors have made an important contribution to the field of robust and interpretable machine learning. The ability to not just make predictions, but also estimate the uncertainty in those predictions, is a valuable capability that can help build trust and foster real-world adoption of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
cDP-MIL: Robust Multiple Instance Learning via Cascaded Dirichlet Process
Yihang Chen, Tsai Hor Chan, Guosheng Yin, Yuming Jiang, Lequan Yu
Multiple instance learning (MIL) has been extensively applied to whole slide histopathology image (WSI) analysis. The existing aggregation strategy in MIL, which primarily relies on the first-order distance (e.g., mean difference) between instances, fails to accurately approximate the true feature distribution of each instance, leading to biased slide-level representations. Moreover, the scarcity of WSI observations easily leads to model overfitting, resulting in unstable testing performance and limited generalizability. To tackle these challenges, we propose a new Bayesian nonparametric framework for multiple instance learning, which adopts a cascade of Dirichlet processes (cDP) to incorporate the instance-to-bag characteristic of the WSIs. We perform feature aggregation based on the latent clusters formed by the Dirichlet process, which incorporates the covariances of the patch features and forms more representative clusters. We then perform bag-level prediction with another Dirichlet process model on the bags, which imposes a natural regularization on learning to prevent overfitting and enhance generalizability. Moreover, as a Bayesian nonparametric method, the cDP model can accurately generate posterior uncertainty, which allows for the detection of outlier samples and tumor localization. Extensive experiments on five WSI benchmarks validate the superior performance of our method, as well as its generalizability and ability to estimate uncertainties. Codes are available at https://github.com/HKU-MedAI/cDPMIL.
Read more7/22/2024
🖼️
0
Establishing Truly Causal Relationship Between Whole Slide Image Predictions and Diagnostic Evidence Subregions in Deep Learning
Tianhang Nan, Yong Ding, Hao Quan, Deliang Li, Mingchen Zou, Xiaoyu Cui
In the field of deep learning-driven Whole Slide Image (WSI) classification, Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) has gained significant attention due to its ability to be trained using only slide-level diagnostic labels. Previous MIL researches have primarily focused on enhancing feature aggregators for globally analyzing WSIs, but overlook a causal relationship in diagnosis: model's prediction should ideally stem solely from regions of the image that contain diagnostic evidence (such as tumor cells), which usually occupy relatively small areas. To address this limitation and establish the truly causal relationship between model predictions and diagnostic evidence regions, we propose Causal Inference Multiple Instance Learning (CI-MIL). CI-MIL integrates feature distillation with a novel patch decorrelation mechanism, employing a two-stage causal inference approach to distill and process patches with high diagnostic value. Initially, CI-MIL leverages feature distillation to identify patches likely containing tumor cells and extracts their corresponding feature representations. These features are then mapped to random Fourier feature space, where a learnable weighting scheme is employed to minimize inter-feature correlations, effectively reducing redundancy from homogenous patches and mitigating data bias. These processes strengthen the causal relationship between model predictions and diagnostically relevant regions, making the prediction more direct and reliable. Experimental results demonstrate that CI-MIL outperforms state-of-the-art methods. Additionally, CI-MIL exhibits superior interpretability, as its selected regions demonstrate high consistency with ground truth annotations, promising more reliable diagnostic assistance for pathologists.
Read more7/25/2024
🤿
0
Multi-head Attention-based Deep Multiple Instance Learning
Hassan Keshvarikhojasteh, Josien Pluim, Mitko Veta
This paper introduces MAD-MIL, a Multi-head Attention-based Deep Multiple Instance Learning model, designed for weakly supervised Whole Slide Images (WSIs) classification in digital pathology. Inspired by the multi-head attention mechanism of the Transformer, MAD-MIL simplifies model complexity while achieving competitive results against advanced models like CLAM and DS-MIL. Evaluated on the MNIST-BAGS and public datasets, including TUPAC16, TCGA BRCA, TCGA LUNG, and TCGA KIDNEY, MAD-MIL consistently outperforms ABMIL. This demonstrates enhanced information diversity, interpretability, and efficiency in slide representation. The model's effectiveness, coupled with fewer trainable parameters and lower computational complexity makes it a promising solution for automated pathology workflows. Our code is available at https://github.com/tueimage/MAD-MIL.
Read more4/9/2024
0
DGR-MIL: Exploring Diverse Global Representation in Multiple Instance Learning for Whole Slide Image Classification
Wenhui Zhu, Xiwen Chen, Peijie Qiu, Aristeidis Sotiras, Abolfazl Razi, Yalin Wang
Multiple instance learning (MIL) stands as a powerful approach in weakly supervised learning, regularly employed in histological whole slide image (WSI) classification for detecting tumorous lesions. However, existing mainstream MIL methods focus on modeling correlation between instances while overlooking the inherent diversity among instances. However, few MIL methods have aimed at diversity modeling, which empirically show inferior performance but with a high computational cost. To bridge this gap, we propose a novel MIL aggregation method based on diverse global representation (DGR-MIL), by modeling diversity among instances through a set of global vectors that serve as a summary of all instances. First, we turn the instance correlation into the similarity between instance embeddings and the predefined global vectors through a cross-attention mechanism. This stems from the fact that similar instance embeddings typically would result in a higher correlation with a certain global vector. Second, we propose two mechanisms to enforce the diversity among the global vectors to be more descriptive of the entire bag: (i) positive instance alignment and (ii) a novel, efficient, and theoretically guaranteed diversification learning paradigm. Specifically, the positive instance alignment module encourages the global vectors to align with the center of positive instances (e.g., instances containing tumors in WSI). To further diversify the global representations, we propose a novel diversification learning paradigm leveraging the determinantal point process. The proposed model outperforms the state-of-the-art MIL aggregation models by a substantial margin on the CAMELYON-16 and the TCGA-lung cancer datasets. The code is available at url{https://github.com/ChongQingNoSubway/DGR-MIL}.
Read more7/8/2024