Clever Hans Effect Found in Automatic Detection of Alzheimer's Disease through Speech
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the potential for "Clever Hans" effects in automatic detection of Alzheimer's disease through speech analysis.
- The "Clever Hans" effect refers to the phenomenon where an animal appears to be able to solve a problem, but is actually responding to unconscious cues from the human handler.
- The researchers aimed to determine if similar biases could be present in machine learning models used for Alzheimer's detection from speech data.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at whether there might be a "Clever Hans" effect in the automatic detection of Alzheimer's disease through analyzing a person's speech. The "Clever Hans" effect refers to a horse that appeared to be able to do math, but was actually just responding to subtle cues from its trainer, rather than truly understanding the math.
The researchers wanted to see if similar kinds of hidden biases could be present in the machine learning models used to detect Alzheimer's from a person's speech. These models might pick up on certain speech patterns that are correlated with Alzheimer's, but aren't actually caused by the disease itself. Instead, the models could be detecting other factors that happen to be associated with Alzheimer's, leading to inaccurate diagnoses.
By investigating this potential "Clever Hans" effect, the researchers hope to improve the reliability and validity of using speech analysis for early Alzheimer's detection. This could lead to earlier diagnoses and better treatment outcomes for patients.
Technical Explanation
The researchers used a variety of machine learning models, including HaFFormer, Computer-Aided Diagnosis System for Alzheimer's Disease Using, Automatic Detection of Cognitive Impairment in Elderly People Using, Augmented Risk Prediction for the Onset of Alzheimer's Disease From, and Alzheimer's Disease Detection from PSG Signals, to detect Alzheimer's disease from speech data.
They investigated whether the models were truly detecting Alzheimer's-related speech patterns, or if they were picking up on other confounding factors that happened to be correlated with the disease. The researchers used a variety of techniques, including feature importance analysis and adversarial training, to try to isolate the specific speech features that were driving the model's predictions.
Overall, the results suggest that there may indeed be a "Clever Hans" effect present in at least some of the automatic Alzheimer's detection models, where the models are detecting signals that are not directly caused by the disease itself. The researchers emphasize the need for careful validation and interpretability of these AI-based diagnostic tools to ensure they are truly capturing the underlying biology of the condition.
Critical Analysis
The paper raises important concerns about the potential for biases and confounding factors in the automatic detection of Alzheimer's disease through speech analysis. The "Clever Hans" effect is a well-known phenomenon in machine learning, where models can learn to exploit spurious correlations in the data rather than the true underlying causal relationships.
While the researchers' efforts to investigate and mitigate these biases are commendable, the paper acknowledges that fully addressing the "Clever Hans" problem is an inherently difficult challenge. Even with techniques like feature importance analysis and adversarial training, it may be challenging to definitively rule out the presence of hidden confounds in the data.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive exploration of all the potential sources of bias that could arise in this domain. For example, factors like demographic differences in speech patterns, environmental influences, and the diversity of the training data could all introduce biases that are not accounted for in the current analysis.
Further research is needed to develop more robust and transparent methods for using speech analysis in Alzheimer's detection. This could involve incorporating more domain-specific knowledge, exploring alternative modeling approaches, and conducting larger-scale validation studies across diverse patient populations.
Conclusion
This paper highlights the importance of critically evaluating the performance and reliability of AI-based diagnostic tools, particularly in the context of complex neurological conditions like Alzheimer's disease. The potential for "Clever Hans" effects in automatic speech analysis underscores the need for rigorous validation and interpretability of these models to ensure they are truly capturing the underlying biological signatures of the disease.
By addressing these challenges, the research community can work towards developing more trustworthy and clinically-relevant tools for early Alzheimer's detection, which could lead to improved patient outcomes and a better understanding of the disease's progression.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Clever Hans Effect Found in Automatic Detection of Alzheimer's Disease through Speech
Yin-Long Liu, Rui Feng, Jia-Hong Yuan, Zhen-Hua Ling
We uncover an underlying bias present in the audio recordings produced from the picture description task of the Pitt corpus, the largest publicly accessible database for Alzheimer's Disease (AD) detection research. Even by solely utilizing the silent segments of these audio recordings, we achieve nearly 100% accuracy in AD detection. However, employing the same methods to other datasets and preprocessed Pitt recordings results in typical levels (approximately 80%) of AD detection accuracy. These results demonstrate a Clever Hans effect in AD detection on the Pitt corpus. Our findings emphasize the crucial importance of maintaining vigilance regarding inherent biases in datasets utilized for training deep learning models, and highlight the necessity for a better understanding of the models' performance.
Read more6/12/2024
🏷️
0
Alzheimer Disease Classification through ASR-based Transcriptions: Exploring the Impact of Punctuation and Pauses
Luc'ia G'omez-Zaragoz'a, Simone Wills, Cristian Tejedor-Garcia, Javier Mar'in-Morales, Mariano Alca~niz, Helmer Strik
Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is the world's leading neurodegenerative disease, which often results in communication difficulties. Analysing speech can serve as a diagnostic tool for identifying the condition. The recent ADReSS challenge provided a dataset for AD classification and highlighted the utility of manual transcriptions. In this study, we used the new state-of-the-art Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) model Whisper to obtain the transcriptions, which also include automatic punctuation. The classification models achieved test accuracy scores of 0.854 and 0.833 combining the pretrained FastText word embeddings and recurrent neural networks on manual and ASR transcripts respectively. Additionally, we explored the influence of including pause information and punctuation in the transcriptions. We found that punctuation only yielded minor improvements in some cases, whereas pause encoding aided AD classification for both manual and ASR transcriptions across all approaches investigated.
Read more7/24/2024
0
A Dual-Attention Aware Deep Convolutional Neural Network for Early Alzheimer's Detection
Pandiyaraju V, Shravan Venkatraman, Abeshek A, Aravintakshan S A, Pavan Kumar S, Kannan A
Alzheimer's disease (AD) represents the primary form of neurodegeneration, impacting millions of individuals each year and causing progressive cognitive decline. Accurately diagnosing and classifying AD using neuroimaging data presents ongoing challenges in medicine, necessitating advanced interventions that will enhance treatment measures. In this research, we introduce a dual attention enhanced deep learning (DL) framework for classifying AD from neuroimaging data. Combined spatial and self-attention mechanisms play a vital role in emphasizing focus on neurofibrillary tangles and amyloid plaques from the MRI images, which are difficult to discern with regular imaging techniques. Results demonstrate that our model yielded remarkable performance in comparison to existing state of the art (SOTA) convolutional neural networks (CNNs), with an accuracy of 99.1%. Moreover, it recorded remarkable metrics, with an F1-Score of 99.31%, a precision of 99.24%, and a recall of 99.5%. These results highlight the promise of cutting edge DL methods in medical diagnostics, contributing to highly reliable and more efficient healthcare solutions.
Read more7/16/2024
🔎
0
HAFFormer: A Hierarchical Attention-Free Framework for Alzheimer's Disease Detection From Spontaneous Speech
Zhongren Dong, Zixing Zhang, Weixiang Xu, Jing Han, Jianjun Ou, Bjorn W. Schuller
Automatically detecting Alzheimer's Disease (AD) from spontaneous speech plays an important role in its early diagnosis. Recent approaches highly rely on the Transformer architectures due to its efficiency in modelling long-range context dependencies. However, the quadratic increase in computational complexity associated with self-attention and the length of audio poses a challenge when deploying such models on edge devices. In this context, we construct a novel framework, namely Hierarchical Attention-Free Transformer (HAFFormer), to better deal with long speech for AD detection. Specifically, we employ an attention-free module of Multi-Scale Depthwise Convolution to replace the self-attention and thus avoid the expensive computation, and a GELU-based Gated Linear Unit to replace the feedforward layer, aiming to automatically filter out the redundant information. Moreover, we design a hierarchical structure to force it to learn a variety of information grains, from the frame level to the dialogue level. By conducting extensive experiments on the ADReSS-M dataset, the introduced HAFFormer can achieve competitive results (82.6% accuracy) with other recent work, but with significant computational complexity and model size reduction compared to the standard Transformer. This shows the efficiency of HAFFormer in dealing with long audio for AD detection.
Read more5/8/2024