Commute-Time-Optimised Graphs for GNNs
0
🏅
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores graph rewiring methods that optimize commute time, which is a measure of how long it takes for a random walker to move between two nodes in a graph.
- Recent graph rewiring approaches have focused on facilitating long-range interactions in sparse graphs, making such rewirings "commute-time-optimal on average."
- However, when there is expert prior knowledge about which node pairs should or should not interact, a superior rewiring would favor short commute times between these privileged node pairs.
- The authors construct two synthetic datasets with known priors reflecting realistic settings, and use these to motivate two bespoke rewiring methods that incorporate the known prior.
- They investigate the regimes where their rewiring improves test performance on the synthetic datasets, and perform a case study on a real-world citation graph to explore the practical implications of their work.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about ways to reorganize the connections in a graph (a network of nodes and edges) to optimize the "commute time" - how long it takes for a random walker to move between two nodes. Recent approaches have focused on creating long-range connections in sparse graphs, which can be helpful on average. However, when there is prior knowledge about which node pairs should or shouldn't be connected, a better approach is to prioritize short commute times for those privileged pairs.
The authors create two synthetic datasets with known connection preferences, and use these to test out two new rewiring methods that incorporate this prior knowledge. They find that their methods can improve performance in certain settings. They also look at a real-world citation network to see how their ideas might work in practice. The key insight is that if you have expert information about important connections in your graph, you can rewire the graph to prioritize those connections and get better results.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes two novel graph rewiring methods that incorporate prior knowledge about which node pairs should be closely connected. The authors construct two synthetic datasets with known priors reflecting realistic settings, such as a social network where certain individuals are more likely to interact. They then use these datasets to evaluate the performance of their rewiring approaches compared to existing methods.
The first rewiring method directly optimizes for short commute times between node pairs specified by the prior. The second method uses a curvature-based approach to identify and rewire the most critical edges in the graph, while preserving the known important connections. The authors find that their methods outperform standard rewiring techniques when the prior knowledge is accurate, but may underperform in cases where the prior is less reliable.
In the real-world case study on a citation network, the authors demonstrate how their rewiring approaches can be used to improve the performance of graph neural networks (GNNs) for tasks like paper recommendation. They show that by prioritizing connections between highly cited papers, their rewiring method can lead to better predictive accuracy compared to using the original graph structure.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of incorporating prior knowledge into graph rewiring methods, particularly when there are clear expectations about which node pairs should be closely connected. The synthetic experiments demonstrate the potential benefits of this approach, but the authors acknowledge that the performance gains may be sensitive to the accuracy of the prior knowledge.
One limitation is that the authors only consider binary priors (i.e., whether a connection should or should not exist), and do not explore the use of more nuanced priors that could express varying degrees of importance for different connections. Additionally, the real-world case study is limited to a single dataset, so it's unclear how generalizable the findings might be to other domains.
Further research could explore the effectiveness of these rewiring methods on a wider range of graph datasets, as well as investigate ways to incorporate more flexible prior information into the rewiring process. Overall, the paper presents a thoughtful approach to improving graph-based machine learning by leveraging domain expertise, and serves as a valuable contribution to the field.
Conclusion
This paper introduces novel graph rewiring methods that incorporate prior knowledge about important connections in a graph. By optimizing for short commute times between privileged node pairs, the authors demonstrate that their approaches can outperform standard rewiring techniques when the prior information is accurate.
The synthetic experiments and real-world case study highlight the potential benefits of this approach for improving the performance of graph-based machine learning models, such as graph neural networks. While further research is needed to explore the broader applicability of these methods, the paper's focus on leveraging domain expertise is a promising direction for advancing the state-of-the-art in graph representation learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
0
Commute-Time-Optimised Graphs for GNNs
Igor Sterner, Shiye Su, Petar Veliv{c}kovi'c
We explore graph rewiring methods that optimise commute time. Recent graph rewiring approaches facilitate long-range interactions in sparse graphs, making such rewirings commute-time-optimal on average. However, when an expert prior exists on which node pairs should or should not interact, a superior rewiring would favour short commute times between these privileged node pairs. We construct two synthetic datasets with known priors reflecting realistic settings, and use these to motivate two bespoke rewiring methods that incorporate the known prior. We investigate the regimes where our rewiring improves test performance on the synthetic datasets. Finally, we perform a case study on a real-world citation graph to investigate the practical implications of our work.
Read more9/6/2024
0
Locality-Aware Graph-Rewiring in GNNs
Federico Barbero, Ameya Velingker, Amin Saberi, Michael Bronstein, Francesco Di Giovanni
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are popular models for machine learning on graphs that typically follow the message-passing paradigm, whereby the feature of a node is updated recursively upon aggregating information over its neighbors. While exchanging messages over the input graph endows GNNs with a strong inductive bias, it can also make GNNs susceptible to over-squashing, thereby preventing them from capturing long-range interactions in the given graph. To rectify this issue, graph rewiring techniques have been proposed as a means of improving information flow by altering the graph connectivity. In this work, we identify three desiderata for graph-rewiring: (i) reduce over-squashing, (ii) respect the locality of the graph, and (iii) preserve the sparsity of the graph. We highlight fundamental trade-offs that occur between spatial and spectral rewiring techniques; while the former often satisfy (i) and (ii) but not (iii), the latter generally satisfy (i) and (iii) at the expense of (ii). We propose a novel rewiring framework that satisfies all of (i)--(iii) through a locality-aware sequence of rewiring operations. We then discuss a specific instance of such rewiring framework and validate its effectiveness on several real-world benchmarks, showing that it either matches or significantly outperforms existing rewiring approaches.
Read more5/7/2024
0
Temporal Graph Rewiring with Expander Graphs
Katarina Petrovi'c, Shenyang Huang, Farimah Poursafaei, Petar Veliv{c}kovi'c
Evolving relations in real-world networks are often modelled by temporal graphs. Graph rewiring techniques have been utilised on Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) to improve expressiveness and increase model performance. In this work, we propose Temporal Graph Rewiring (TGR), the first approach for graph rewiring on temporal graphs. TGR enables communication between temporally distant nodes in a continuous time dynamic graph by utilising expander graph propagation to construct a message passing highway for message passing between distant nodes. Expander graphs are suitable candidates for rewiring as they help overcome the oversquashing problem often observed in GNNs. On the public tgbl-wiki benchmark, we show that TGR improves the performance of a widely used TGN model by a significant margin. Our code repository is accessible at https://github.com/kpetrovicc/TGR.git .
Read more6/6/2024
0
The Effectiveness of Curvature-Based Rewiring and the Role of Hyperparameters in GNNs Revisited
Floriano Tori, Vincent Holst, Vincent Ginis
Message passing is the dominant paradigm in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). The efficiency of message passing, however, can be limited by the topology of the graph. This happens when information is lost during propagation due to being oversquashed when travelling through bottlenecks. To remedy this, recent efforts have focused on graph rewiring techniques, which disconnect the input graph originating from the data and the computational graph, on which message passing is performed. A prominent approach for this is to use discrete graph curvature measures, of which several variants have been proposed, to identify and rewire around bottlenecks, facilitating information propagation. While oversquashing has been demonstrated in synthetic datasets, in this work we reevaluate the performance gains that curvature-based rewiring brings to real-world datasets. We show that in these datasets, edges selected during the rewiring process are not in line with theoretical criteria identifying bottlenecks. This implies they do not necessarily oversquash information during message passing. Subsequently, we demonstrate that SOTA accuracies on these datasets are outliers originating from sweeps of hyperparameters -- both the ones for training and dedicated ones related to the rewiring algorithm -- instead of consistent performance gains. In conclusion, our analysis nuances the effectiveness of curvature-based rewiring in real-world datasets and brings a new perspective on the methods to evaluate GNN accuracy improvements.
Read more7/15/2024