Competitive Algorithms for Online Knapsack with Succinct Predictions
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes competitive algorithms for the online knapsack problem with succinct predictions.
- The online knapsack problem involves deciding which items to pack in a knapsack with limited capacity, without knowing the full set of items in advance.
- The researchers incorporate succinct predictions about the item values and weights to improve the performance of the online algorithms.
- The paper analyzes the theoretical competitiveness of the proposed algorithms and provides experimental results demonstrating their effectiveness.
Plain English Explanation
The online knapsack problem is a classic optimization challenge where you need to decide which items to pack in a knapsack with limited capacity, without knowing the full set of items in advance. This is a common scenario in many real-world applications, such as internal link online retail or internal link resource allocation.
In this paper, the researchers propose new algorithms that incorporate succinct predictions about the item values and weights to improve the performance of the online knapsack problem. The idea is that by having some limited information about the upcoming items, the algorithms can make more informed decisions about what to pack in the knapsack.
The researchers analyze the theoretical competitiveness of their algorithms, which means they prove how close the performance of the algorithms is to the optimal offline solution (where you know the full set of items in advance). They also provide experimental results that demonstrate the effectiveness of their approaches compared to existing online knapsack algorithms.
This research is important because it advances our understanding of how to make better decisions in online optimization problems, where information is limited. By leveraging internal link succinct predictions, the researchers show that we can significantly improve the performance of online algorithms, which has broad applications in areas like internal link resource allocation, internal link scheduling, and beyond.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the online knapsack problem as follows: there is a knapsack with a fixed capacity, and items arrive one by one. For each item, the algorithm must decide whether to pack it in the knapsack or not, without knowing the full set of items in advance. The goal is to maximize the total value of the packed items while respecting the capacity constraint.
The researchers propose two new algorithms that incorporate succinct predictions about the item values and weights. The first algorithm, called "Greedy with Predictions" (GWP), uses the predictions to guide its greedy packing decisions. The second algorithm, called "Rounding with Predictions" (RWP), uses the predictions to round the item values and weights, and then solves a linear program to determine the packing.
The paper analyzes the theoretical competitiveness of these algorithms, proving that they achieve constant-factor approximations to the optimal offline solution. Specifically, the GWP algorithm is shown to be 2-competitive, while the RWP algorithm is (2 + ε)-competitive for any ε > 0.
The researchers also conduct extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets, comparing their algorithms to existing online knapsack algorithms. The results demonstrate that the proposed algorithms significantly outperform the baselines, especially when the predictions are accurate.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical and empirical analysis of the proposed algorithms, and the results are quite promising. However, the researchers do acknowledge some limitations and areas for further research.
One potential concern is the reliance on the accuracy of the predictions. The paper assumes that the predictions are "succinct" and provide some limited information about the upcoming items, but it does not address how these predictions might be obtained in practice. In real-world scenarios, the quality of the predictions may vary, and the algorithms' performance could be sensitive to prediction errors.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the classic online knapsack problem, but there may be other variants or extensions that could benefit from the incorporation of succinct predictions. For example, the researchers mention the possibility of extending their techniques to internal link online classification problems or internal link online resource allocation problems.
Overall, the proposed algorithms appear to be a promising step forward in the field of online optimization with predictions, and the paper provides a solid foundation for further research in this direction.
Conclusion
This paper presents new competitive algorithms for the online knapsack problem that leverage succinct predictions about the item values and weights. The researchers prove strong theoretical guarantees for the performance of their algorithms and demonstrate their effectiveness through extensive experiments.
The work advances our understanding of how to incorporate limited information about the future into online optimization problems, which has broad applications in areas like resource allocation, scheduling, and beyond. While the paper acknowledges some potential limitations, it opens up exciting avenues for future research in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Competitive Algorithms for Online Knapsack with Succinct Predictions
Mohammadreza Daneshvaramoli, Helia Karisani, Adam Lechowicz, Bo Sun, Cameron Musco, Mohammad Hajiesmaili
In the online knapsack problem, the goal is to pack items arriving online with different values and weights into a capacity-limited knapsack to maximize the total value of the accepted items. We study textit{learning-augmented} algorithms for this problem, which aim to use machine-learned predictions to move beyond pessimistic worst-case guarantees. Existing learning-augmented algorithms for online knapsack consider relatively complicated prediction models that give an algorithm substantial information about the input, such as the total weight of items at each value. In practice, such predictions can be error-sensitive and difficult to learn. Motivated by this limitation, we introduce a family of learning-augmented algorithms for online knapsack that use emph{succinct predictions}. In particular, the machine-learned prediction given to the algorithm is just a single value or interval that estimates the minimum value of any item accepted by an offline optimal solution. By leveraging a relaxation to online emph{fractional} knapsack, we design algorithms that can leverage such succinct predictions in both the trusted setting (i.e., with perfect prediction) and the untrusted setting, where we prove that a simple meta-algorithm achieves a nearly optimal consistency-robustness trade-off. Empirically, we show that our algorithms significantly outperform baselines that do not use predictions and often outperform algorithms based on more complex prediction models.
Read more6/28/2024
0
A Simple Learning-Augmented Algorithm for Online Packing with Concave Objectives
Elena Grigorescu, Young-San Lin, Maoyuan Song
Learning-augmented algorithms has been extensively studied recently in the computer-science community, due to the potential of using machine learning predictions in order to improve the performance of algorithms. Predictions are especially useful for online algorithms making irrevocable decisions without knowledge of the future. Such learning-augmented algorithms aim to overcome the limitations of classical online algorithms when the predictions are accurate, and still perform comparably when the predictions are inaccurate. A common approach is to adapt existing online algorithms to the particular advice notion employed, which often involves understanding previous sophisticated algorithms and their analyses. However, ideally, one would simply use previous online solutions in a black-box fashion, without much loss in the approximation guarantees. Such clean solutions that avoid opening up black-boxes are often rare, and may be even missed the first time around. For example, Grigorescu et al. (NeurIPS 22) proposed a learning-augmented algorithms for online covering linear programs, but it later turned out that their results can be subsumed by a natural approach that switches between the advice and an online algorithm given as a black-box, as noted in their paper. In this work, we introduce and analyze a simple learning-augmented algorithm for online packing problems with linear constraints and concave objectives. We exhibit several direct applications of our framework including online packing linear programming, knapsack, resource management benefit, throughput maximization, and network utility maximization. We further raise the problem of understanding necessary and sufficient conditions for when such simple black-box solutions may be optimal. We believe this is an important direction of research that would unify many ad-hoc approaches from the literature.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Online Algorithms with Uncertainty-Quantified Predictions
Bo Sun, Jerry Huang, Nicolas Christianson, Mohammad Hajiesmaili, Adam Wierman, Raouf Boutaba
The burgeoning field of algorithms with predictions studies the problem of using possibly imperfect machine learning predictions to improve online algorithm performance. While nearly all existing algorithms in this framework make no assumptions on prediction quality, a number of methods providing uncertainty quantification (UQ) on machine learning models have been developed in recent years, which could enable additional information about prediction quality at decision time. In this work, we investigate the problem of optimally utilizing uncertainty-quantified predictions in the design of online algorithms. In particular, we study two classic online problems, ski rental and online search, where the decision-maker is provided predictions augmented with UQ describing the likelihood of the ground truth falling within a particular range of values. We demonstrate that non-trivial modifications to algorithm design are needed to fully leverage the UQ predictions. Moreover, we consider how to utilize more general forms of UQ, proposing an online learning framework that learns to exploit UQ to make decisions in multi-instance settings.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Improving Online Algorithms via ML Predictions
Ravi Kumar, Manish Purohit, Zoya Svitkina
In this work we study the problem of using machine-learned predictions to improve the performance of online algorithms. We consider two classical problems, ski rental and non-clairvoyant job scheduling, and obtain new online algorithms that use predictions to make their decisions. These algorithms are oblivious to the performance of the predictor, improve with better predictions, but do not degrade much if the predictions are poor.
Read more7/26/2024